9 Most Shocking Betrayals In Gaming History

Not only do you have to fight to remove the knife from your back, but when's done right you'll be picking your jaw back up too.

In the context of a gaming narrative, the betrayal is something that is a delicate concept to execute. If it's done well it will be remembered by many for its affect on each individual player. If it isn't though, your twist may be seen as lacking motivation or credibility. But when you can pull it off, when you can make the turn of your favourite supporting hero into a treacherous villain believable, you'll get something special that players will remember. Betrayal isn't something to handle lightly. It effectively takes a good guy and turns them into a bad one. It's a moment that can turn a good character into a great character, as their moment of villainous reveal can be fondly remembered as a turning point. So however you choose to turn your once beloved hero into an agent of evil, be sure it's done with care. The following ten shocking betrayals are some of the most famous in the history of the industry, and stand out as stark examples of how to pull it off. Some of them are driven by pure evil, others by circumstance. But no matter how you slice it, these betrayals were shocking, and made a lasting impression on the games they were a part of.

9. Lance Vance Sells Out Tommy Vercetti

It was easy to be fooled by Lance Vance. He was charming and charismatic, but even so there was something mysterious about him. You wanted to know more about him, and on the few missions where he accompanied you in your acts of criminal activity, there was a bond that slowly formed between Tommy Vercetti and Lance. They were brothers, brought together by fate. This was reinforced by the fact that, together, the two of them became the reigning criminal kingpins of Vice City. They were living large, holding the drug trade under their thumb. But like any great crime drama, their friendship was not long for this world, as the impending arrival of Sonny Forelli, Tommy's former friend, put a sore spot on their blossoming partnership. As their friendship grew as well as their stranglehold on the 1980's drug empire scene, so did Lance's resentment of Tommy. And in his final act of cowardice, Lance decided he would sell you (as Tommy) and your organisation out to Sonny. It was a betrayal built on the lust for power, and Lance was ultimately revealed to just be a conniving, backstabbing grunt. It was truly a pleasure to snuff him out.

8. Urdnot Wrex Goes Against Shepard's Orders

Wrex was one of the most popular characters spawned out of the first Mass Effect game; his gruff, no-nonsense attitude was fun to see unfold against your choices, and his top-notch voice performance gave him a worthy place alongside Commander Shepard. But as a member of the infamous Krogan species, his character was mired in conflict. The genophage had severely crippled his people, forcing them into a state of upheaval and distress. It was no surprise, then, that Wrex would do whatever it took to make sure the Krogans rose to supremacy in the galaxy once more. But when Shepard and his team arrived on Virmire, a cure for the genophage was in sight. The only problem was that the base holding all of the attempts to find the cure was going to be destroyed. This put Wrex into an awkward position, forcing him to go against his commanding officer. Wrex's betrayal is one of tragedy, as his turn is not purely villainous, instead it's driven by the desire to save his people. In this way Wrex saw himself as a hero, making your resultant choice of whether to kill him or not all the more difficult.

7. The Boss Defects

There's a quiet, chilling moment when this is happening to you for the first time. As you slowly begin to realise that this strong, seemingly patriotic female warrior is actually turning right in front of you - it starts to slowly break your heart into a million little pieces. And her betrayal is a lingering, ongoing feeling as she breaks Snake's arm and hurls him off a bridge to his doom. As Snake watches the helicopter holding his former mentor fly away, and as the opening credits of Metal Gear Solid 3: Snake Eater begin you begin to realise that this is no ordinary game. The betrayal of the Boss leaves a sorrowful tone over the story, and puts the player on a collision course with her. As you battle through the army she has in front of her and come to know the true nature of her betrayal, it is something that sits with you forever. You could sense - even in that moment - the reflection of the Boss. It granted her a spectacular performance, driven home to perfection by the lovely Lori Alan. She created a truly three-dimensional character, sparked by a believable set of motivations. The Boss' defection in MGS3 is a prime example of how to accurately write a truly shocking betrayal.

6. Albert Wesker Turns Double Agent On S.T.A.R.S.

The original Resident Evil was a landmark title in survival horror. By placing you inside the confined walls of an enormous mansion and filling it to the brim with flesh-eating zombies, it put you in a very real state of fear. Your ammunition was limited and if you found yourself overwhelmed, it became very easy to see that unpleasant game over screen. But there was perhaps nothing more shocking in the original Resident Evil than the revelation that Albert Wesker, the captain of STARS, was a double agent working for the evil Umbrella Corporation. Having lured the members of the team directly into a trap, built to use the unknowing agents as canon fodder for their mutilated creatures no less, Wesker became the true villain of the series. His betrayal was a sharp one, as he showcased his penchant for cruelty by manipulating STARS member Barry Burton into doing his dirty work. Wesker's betrayal was enough to catapult him into becoming the most hated man in the Resident Evil universe, as well as the most popular. His turn was a successful and timeless one and it created a memorable villain that will not soon be forgotten.

5. Catalina Betrays Claude

Grand Theft Auto is one of the biggest franchises in the history of gaming. As a whole, it's sold over 100 million copies worldwide. The true boom for the series happened with GTA III - released in 2001 on the PlayStation 2. A game that has since sold over 13 million units. Would you believe that the catalyst for GTA III was a betrayal? In the opening cinematic of the game, the silent protagonist known as Claude was shot by his criminal girlfriend Catalina. This jumpstarts the game as his story of revenge is centred on this one moment. He's sold out by his gang and sent to prison where he's soon busted out and starts a bloody path to get his much deserved vengeance. He works his way up, betraying a few men and women of his own along the way, to get the 411 on the Colombian Cartel and take out Catalina for good. Catalina leads the anti-hero of GTA III into a deadly chase in the final moments of the game, and in true super-villain fashion threatens the life of his love interest in the process. As Catalina ascends into the sky via a helicopter, believing herself to have been completely successful, she at last gets her comeuppance via a rocket placed straight into the cockpit. She was a vile woman, and was taken care of accordingly. But no one can doubt that Catalina's betrayal may have been the first step in making GTA the powerhouse it is today.

4. The Player Turns To The Dark Side

It's difficult to imagine a more apropos entry than this. In the Knights of the Old Republic games, you are granted the opportunity to wield the incredible power of the Jedi. Whether you use those powers for the light side or the dark side, it was a unique idea at the time of the original KOTOR's release. Fans of the Star Wars universe could finally feel what it was like to know the power of the dark side. It was fresh, exciting and one of the most compelling pieces of Star Wars fiction to come out in years. Towards the end of the game, after the stunning revelation that you are actually a Sith Lord known as Darth Revan, you are given a dramatic choice by the recently turned Bastila Shan. She gives you one final chance to turn to the dark side, cementing your path through the game from here on out. It was an iconic moment, becoming one of the more famous scenes from the series. If you choose to join Bastila, and reclaim your grand Sith empire from the hands of Darth Malak, you were then expected to kill your Jedi team mates Jolee Bindo and Juhani. This was one of the most shocking moments in the whole game, and created an interesting dynamic. You weren't being betrayed, rather you were the one committing such a thing. It was almost subversive, creating a sense of finite reality to the game. If you did this and chose to become the ultimate Sith Lord you had to slaughter your friends. It was justifiably shocking, and you only had yourself to blame.

3. Absolute Power Corrupts Wheatley

In Portal 2, the player meets Wheatley nearly as soon as the game begins. The somewhat surreal opening, full of staring at art and listening to relaxing music is interrupted by the introduction of his character; a nervous, happy-go-lucky robot that is saddled with the task of getting you to safety. The two of you are thrown together, an unlikely pair who must escape the wrath of the returning GLaDOS AI system, who is none-too-pleased about you killing her in the first game. Gulp. Good thing you've got your new best buddy Wheatley with you. Except for the part where upon giving Wheatley the power to achieve victory, the rush of such a thing he's been deprived of goes straight to his head. In a game that is often cited for its clever humor and witty script, the turn of Wheatley from ineffectual drone to a homicidal, killer machine is truly frightening. As you begin to realise that Wheatley now has complete control over the facility, your life expectancy goes down drastically. Being forced to team up with your old villain is a classic trope, but it works well here. Together, you and GLaDOS must combine forces in order to defeat the little robot gone mad. While it's difficult to say you find peace with your former foe, it's fair to say that the two of you will happily enjoy shutting Wheatley's big mouth together once and for all.

2. Atlas Turns Your World Upside Down

Atlas' betrayal begins before you even realise it. In fact, the first words that come out of his mouth are part of his calculated plan to screw you over. As you progress through the underwater dystopia of Rapture, you truly begin to believe that this guy is on your side. And why wouldn't you? He seemingly helps you get out of jams, tells you the right places to go, and he's even got an innocent wife and child. It's not hard to walk through Rapture your first time and think, "Man, that Atlas is a swell guy." But you'd be very wrong, as your arrival was preordained. Once you reach the office of Andrew Ryan, you discover that Atlas' nice guy routine, and even the catchphrase you didn't even know he had, were all part of his plan. "Would you kindly" was just a post-hypnotic phrase he used to manipulate you into doing his bidding. At the time, it was one of the most talked-about video game reveals, and remains to this day a powerful moment for anyone who has been lucky enough to avoid reading the truth (until now of course - Ed.). Like most of the villains on this list, Atlas gets just what he deserves for his treachery in the end.

1. Liquid Snake Reveals Himself As Master Miller

After you first meet Master Miller via a Codec conversation in Metal Gear Solid, he soon becomes one of your most trusted allies in the quest to stop Liquid Snake from his nefarious plans. He's a survival expert, and if you're looking for tips on how to survive and thrive, he's your man. And despite how suspect it was that Master Miller would not answer his Codec during oddly convenient times, it was hard to imagine it as anything other than a coincidence. Master Miller was your former mentor, and a man Snake trusted with his life. But as the countdown to doomsday began - inadvertently started by Snake himself - the man we believed to be Master Miller pulled back the curtain on the most shocking video game betrayal of all time. The real Master Miller was dead, murdered in his home before the mission even began. This entire time, Snake was being used as a pawn by his villainous twin brother Liquid Snake. It was truly shocking, and stands as one of the most memorable moments in franchise history. It created a sense of raw power and aura to Liquid. His uncanny ability to impersonate Master Miller enough to convince Snake, a man who knew him exceptionally well, was an incredible notion. Liquid was cunning, and a masterful manipulator. He took Snake's past and used it against him, creating a moment that will live forever. There's sure to be more betrayals that I didn't mention. These are just a few of the moments when the gamer was lured into a trap, and stabbed in the back. Sound off and let me know what your most shocking gaming betrayals are.

Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Writer, game developer, intersectional feminist.