Assassin's Creed: Victory Wishlist - 10 Things Fans Demand

Why ask for feedback after every mission if they're not going to take it on board?

This is the year that's going to make or break Assassin's Creed for the masses. Once the championed next-generation (of the time) console-selling franchise that was just effortlessly drenched in cool vibes - the very idea of being a hooded uber-assassin trained in the ways of old to dispatch targets without breaking a sweat was a concept for the ages. In fact, it's such a spectacularly engaging and enjoyable idea that Ubisoft have since trotted out eight main games in total, a slew of spin-offs, some movies and even a string of comics, the main titles themselves settling into an annual-release schedule that many would say following AC: Unity has become a major cause for concern. There's only so many times you can dish out the secret sauce before everyone takes it for granted - or worse, ram it down everyone's collective throats until they balk it back up again - and so following Unity's glitch-packed release, Ubi's once-phenomenal franchise is on some pretty rock ground in 2015. Some fans have reconciled to just buying the yearly instalments regardless, whilst others are sick to death of the barest incremental advance the dev team fails to put into the core gameplay - but regardless of which side of the fence you're on, everyone's got their wishlist of what would make AC a downright fantastic experience once again.


10. No Chase Missions

Hey, it's a wishlist right? So dream big. The AC chase missions have been a bane on the franchise since the first one, and although they showed off pretty positively back at the very first title's unveil, since then they've turned from the high-octane thrill of chaining jumps to catch your target into just holding forward and the right trigger whilst occasionally getting snagged on buildings or objects in the environment instead. Put simply, these missions have far outstayed their welcome, and unless Victory's refinements to the core gameplay engine are such that you feel as in control of your character as Shadow of Mordor's did Talion (which is very unlikely) they'd better fall by the wayside altogether.

9. A Great Character Story Arc

For the most part, aside from the arbitrary deaths of main characters that come alongside an AC campaign, every hero since Altair and Ezio have essentially emerged at the close of their respective games the same as when they went in. Edward Kenway seemingly took on the abilities of the assassin whose clothes he stole just for the sake of it, and whilst AC III let you play as Connor from child to adult, the earlier sections were over way too soon - not to mention misjudged pacing-wise thanks to a lengthy stint as Templar Haytham Kenway - conveniently putting him into the standard assassin mould and never wavering for the duration. The problem with multiple Assassin's Creeds releasing so close to each other is the general pace of gameplay is very much engrained in the cultural psyche - which is to say people want to pick up from where they left off, without having to do all the training and preamble beforehand. However, that's completely anathema to the idea of telling a new story with a new protagonist each and every time, as you need the appropriate time dedicated to build people and events up for both the character and player. Something has to give, and until they can really dedicate the time to each character's training, stumbles and the overcoming of each struggle in real time, there's always going to be a big clash of story versus action.

8. A Better Mission Structure

Here's a mind-blowing question; does Assassin's Creed need to be open-world? The stealth games of old like Tenchu and Splinter Cell barely knew what open worlds even were - yet they were all the better for it. Splinter Cell: Blacklist's approach to missions back in 2013 was to give you a massive overarching map of the world, letting you pick missions with a certain degree of variation or importance depending on their relation to the main story. Assassin's Creed would benefit wholeheartedly from letting their art department focus on far more tightly-packed individual areas, rather than fleshing out alleyways and alcoves of gigantic cities that no one is 1. Going to see and 2. Even appreciate. You can still do all the leaping, jumping and swinging through levels as before - it would just be in dedicated walled-off chunks of the environment rather than an entire city - hell, the Animus simulation aspect perfectly fits this approach to a tee. If you're not totally in agreement or you're about to rage out in the comments - just ask yourself what does AC being open-world actually benefit the player, and would a Hitman/Splinter Cell approach suit it far better?

7. A Reason To Fight

Y'know which AC hero has one of the most interesting drive to their story? Adewale. Who? Exactly. Star of AC: Black Flag's standalone pack Freedom Cry, Ubisoft dove into the slave trade of the 18th Century, tasking you with freeing the oppressed whilst delivering sweet, steely justice to those behind the whips and chains. Aside from possibly Ezio's motivation to get started in AC II, this provided a very simple "Go kill the people who deserve it" narrative beat that was otherwise missing from Black Flag's (admittedly fun) 'evil pirate' shtick, and was all the better for it. Unity had Arno seemingly becoming an assassin overnight thanks to sharing a cell with one, and it's something indicative of the previous point too - AC needs their heroes to be up to speed on the latest hidden blade-dealing tactics out there from where the last game left off, and so far Ubisoft have ended up taking the convenience route over some much needed innovation.

6. An Interesting Protagonist

Who was the last AC protagonist you actually enjoyed playing as? It certainly wasn't Connor, Arno or even Edward Kenway after his introductory sequence. When the series launched you were put in the shoes of Desmond, and with him being the main thread that held all the other ancestor stories together, in theory everything he experienced in the Animus should've remained secondary until the abilities of his forefathers bled through to himself - whereby we'd all of gotten that fancy AC: New York trilogy-capper everyone was expecting. Instead we've been thrown into the shoes of everyone from Italian rapscallions to plundering pirates and French nobles - all of them having the 'Star Wars prequel problem' of not having a decent entry point for you, the non-rooftop-hopping human. Ezio came closest but even his transition to the ways of the Order were a little convenient upon reflection - was it not a little strange that him and his brother just happen to be super-athletes who already treat their city as a playground? Regardless of the events of the story itself, the person we're embodying should reflect some of the inquisitions and first-foot mistakes of the player - that way regardless of how crazy and sci-fi tinged they want to take the story, it can all be filtered through a character who's reacting to everything like we are.

5. Multiple Approaches To Assassination Missions

This is one of the only things Unity got right; assassination missions that allowed for a multitude of entry points, alongside scouting the surrounding area for things like NPCs with extra information, world events you could trigger and so on. It's totally ripped from the Hitman series, but it absolutely works here thanks to AC's movement allowing you to get up and around many of the buildings you're infiltrating. The very first AC gave you a target and asked you to infiltrate however you like to take him out - something that led to you feeling a great sense of achievement after filtering through crowds or diving off the rafters for the kill all of your own volition. Unity's were a bit all over the place thanks to not being able to keep track of what affected what or how, opening up the idea of replayability tenfold - yet crippling it by having the options open to you be utterly unsatisfying. At the most you'd activate a steam vent which would move a group of guards somewhere else, and when you've been told there's the option for a 'Unique Kill' yet have no way of finding out what it is unless you stumble upon it by accident - it's just bad design.

4. Make The Best Use Of The New Swing Mechanic

So far the only thing shown that resembles a new mechanic so far is the above shot of whoever the new character is swinging around what looks like a train station - something that's either going to shake up the foundations of AC considerably by opening up your horizontal movement speed - or be as forgettable as Revelations' hook-blade. The key is to not be context-sensitive, as having certain outcrops or points in the map where you can deploy your sick new gadget only serves to hamper its use overall - or the feeling that you can tackle any given scenario in a unique new way to the series. The aforementioned hook-blade didn't really do anything other than let you leap onto some ziplines or clamber ledges slightly faster - and thus it's integral that whatever this new swing mechanic is be used to let you essentially become something of a Spider-Man/Assassin-hybrid.

3. No Micro-Transactions, DLC Or Companion Apps

Okay let's clarify a little - 'no DLC' means no essential DLC for the full experience, so nothing that's announced even before release where even before they've put their hard-earned cash down, fans know what they're buying isn't the full version. Another case in point is the companion app that launched alongside Unity, containing a key game mode from the previous titles in the managing of your mini assassin army - yet didn't receive anything of a meaningful wink or a nod in the main game. Whether you were sick of sending your troops across the world or not, relegating key content to an optional app - or having said app trigger chests to unlock in your game - is just plain stupid. Aside from Freedom Cry, AC's DLC has been relatively pointless too - Unity's Dead Kings had nothing to write home about aside from a cool-looking Guillotine Gun (something that should've been in the main game), and so instead of dedicating resources or leaving things out the campaign with the intent to pack it in later down the line, how about giving fans a full game for once? That goes quadruple for micro-transactions. Even if you're sitting firmly in the 'well if you don't like them, then don't buy them' camp, the very idea that Ubi are happily promoting the idea of paying your way through the progression of their game does a disservice to the team that developed it and video games overall as anything close to an artistic medium.
You wouldn't pay extra to unfold the bottom half of a painting, and if a movie had a second PR campaign centred around one more scene shown in theatres for a ridiculous price after the credits rolled there'd be hell on - so why should it be accepted in video games?

2. Drop The Multiplayer

Let's be honest, all the fake celebrity voiceover adverts that preceded the launch of AC felt like the most un-Assassin's Creed thing ever. Stealth is not something undertaken by a group of people - Tenchu Z's failed online mode could've told you that - and even if you can overcome the A.I. problems where enemy guards are reacting to a variety of alert states all co-dependant in individual players' states of visibility, it'll still fall apart spectacularly thanks to only 5% of the online population taking these missions seriously. The only reason solo titles go multiplayer is to increase longevity and the time a buyer will hold onto something before trading it in - or to ensure through multiplayer add-ons that the developer can recoup their development costs. Now obviously AC is one of the most expensive franchises to develop for, but somewhere along the line they have to balance their gameplay goals with how that's going to be perceived by fans of the franchise. AC does not need multiplayer, and it never did. The series can be all about the solo experience through and through, something that would be a breath of fresh air more than ever in today's multiplayer-focussed landscape.

1. A Female Protagonist

Proving that Ubisoft do their most creative and meaningful work away from their core triple-A titles, yes, AC Liberation had Aveline de Grandpré - an 18th Century African-French assassin who had many of the abilities of AC III's Connor back in 2012 - sadly it was barely covered by the press in any meaningful way; nor was it particularly great either. The fact remains that outside of creating a slew of semi-interesting male protagonists, there's been scarce little done to flesh out different gendered approaches to the Assassin's Order overall. We rarely see females that in their respective time periods would have far more to rally against or to say than the fellas, which is a shame as like in Freedom Cry it provides an engaging viewpoint on the times right away. It's worth pointing out that with feminism in 2015 being less about equality and more about extremist reactions to anything male-centric - alongside the fact Ubisoft got the brunt of the latter mindset last year when it was 'revealed' they didn't want a female hero in Arno's place - if they did allow for a female protagonist so soon it might seem like something of an apology. Still, you can't deny that depending on the time period - in this case Victorian England - being an aristocratic Lady by day and death-dealing assassin by night would be one hell of a Peggy Carter-style story to tell. What's on your wishlist for AC: Victory? Let us know in the comments, and join the Facebook for more!

Gaming Editor
Gaming Editor

WhatCulture's Head of Gaming.