Batman: Arkham Knight - 8 Big Worries From The "Officer Down" Trailer

Looks like we might have another Dark Knight Rises on our hands...

Now, before we get stuck into this, it's worth noting some positives about the latest trailer that showed a sizeable continuous chunk of gameplay. First up the graphics are absolutely phenomenal, like really - every raindrop looked perfectly rendered and Batman himself has a character model that appears to be walking a solid line between Tony Stark-esque high-tech gadgetry and gritty militaristic functionality in-game. The city of Gotham looks impeccable too, with every neon-soaked alleyway and backstreet being suitably gorgeous - in a dilapidated, hellhole-on-earth sort of way anyway - but it easily makes for some city streets you can't wait to glide through and clean up. However, and here comes the rub - aside from the Batmobile's introductory sequence (brought on by a hilarious button prompt to 'Even the odds'), the rest of what's here doesn't look like it's going to be doing anything particularly revolutionary. In fact, when you scratch beneath that stunning exterior, what's left underneath leaves quite a lot to be desired. Considering the game has once again been delayed and there are still a litany of issues present even within this newest footage, it sadly points to the final version not being the all-singing, all Batarang-throwing excursion of fun people need it to be. First though, check out the trailer below and see what you think: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=s2ieOuO1Lbk


8. The Voice Acting

The first thing that'll send your okay-compass into the red is the voice acting - it's just a bit too hammy for its own good. Now obviously some people are going to want their Batman hokey'd up to the max, dictating to razor-throated Jim Gordon that whatever negativity is going down, he "Won't let it happen!" said in the most saturday morning cartoon way possible - but the fact is that even the legendary Kevin Conroy doesn't seem to be delivering his lines with the right level of weight here. The Batman of Arkham City was a bit off when it came to staying within the parameters of being Gotham's protector, and later in this demo when we see him interrogating a soldier, again doesn't sound like he's trying to get information out the guy for the sake of fulfilling his duties as someone who thrives on protecting the weak; instead it all reads too much like another day at the office.

7. The Glitches

Assumedly this is something they just didn't catch before making the trailer live, but if you look past the tree in the above clip - or check out the segment just after Bats blows the holy hell out of a perp's car in the full trailer - you'll catch someone spinning in place as they attempt to flee the scene. Obviously in a world this size you're not going to be able to catch everything - and embracing 'the crazy' like Skyrim just helped boost that game's appeal - but as the Arkham titles have been very good when it comes to programming in the past, it'd be a shame to go down a more unpolished route now. Fans will be more than aware the entire game was delayed from last year, receiving another push back just this week (March 23rd) to the end of June - and all of this must be playing into Rocksteady ironing over the creases. Still, when a major chunk of your game shows the AI getting stuck and Bats' cape going randomly rigid mid-animation (when he rescues the cop at the start around 3:20) alongside a bunch of fight sound effects that don't land on cue, it's not capitalising on the vision people have built up from being so long in development.

6. Everything About The Batmobile Combat

So we finally got to see some extended Batmobile combat, and for the naysayers it's everything they need to prepare for the worst. Basically if you took a chunk of the gameplay mid-chase where Bats is launching missiles at the enemy car and barricading his way through concrete slabs to take them down - it doesn't even remotely look like a Batman game. Due to the sheer amount of variation between versions of the Batman character there's been across guys like Frank Miller, Scott Snyder, Chris Nolan, Grant Morrison etc. doing their own spin, there's always going to be a load of different expectations for what Batman 'should' be like - but in none of them will you find a tank-happy version blasting goons with missiles and assuming they make it out the resulting wreckage alive. It seems like you'll be using the Batmobile constantly to get around too, as the only alternative appears to be a certain other obtuse mechanic that doesn't appear to have changed much...

5. The Grapple-Glide System Still Looks Very Awkward

Did you ever wonder how Batman got around, zipping from place to place and out the site of peoples' last lines in any given conversation? Turns out it's all through the use of his grapple gun; something that yes is a regular fixture of the old utility belt - yet just feels a bit awkward when used to chain together propulsive glides across the city. Plenty fans didn't have a problem with this at all once they got used to it, but for the rest the very idea of Batman not being able to glide gracefully through the city, instead constantly climbing and falling his way to the next goal is a bit lacking. It's all about the momentum of it too, as in the new footage once you've got a grapple point and have reeled in and past it, Batman takes off at a great pace - but that initial connection still just doesn't flow into his animation very well, making the overall traversal have the same duck n' dive nature from City and Origins.

4. The Combat Is Almost Exactly The Same

If it ain't brok- ah, you know the rest. However, regardless of how much fun it is to mash someone's face in in time with certain button prompts, this is Rocksteady's big finish for the series - their final trilogy-capper of an entry that should be going all-out to flesh out Bats' moveset considerably, avoiding the Origins-style sense of series fatigue many people had in 2013. Maybe you literally do just want some more of the same delicious ribcage-popping same? Rocksteady are intent on delivering it, but so far you can count the new combat moves on two fingers - a slow-motion Fear Takedown that lets you dispatch a group of guys in slow-motion, and a few more contextual attacks like ramming a dude's head into an electric box. Chances are with this many things being exactly the same and most of the innovation being tied to the Batmobile itself, you're not going to have to change your gameplan on-mission whatsoever, and outside of drinking in the new visuals while you do so - that's a big worry.

3. Where's The Arkham Knight's Development?

What do you know about the Arkham Knight - the most interesting villain there's been in a Batman canon since the Court of Owls' assassin in Scott Snyder's reboot? He's a guy, with some soldiers... who answers to Scarecrow and hasn't spoken - threatening eh? In the preluding comics he's written as someone who essentially monologues to himself, all "I'm gonna get you Batman!"-like, which really, really isn't what's needed when the tone for this is already so self-serious and gritty. The last major trailer elected to rebalance the villain hierarchy completely from the Knight-fronted screens beforehand, showing that although we're all working overtime to figure out who's under the mask, it's Scarecrow who's the main 'big bad' in the game. So far unless you've been keeping up with the comics, you don't know anything more about the Knight than you did after the main announcement last year, but showing or mentioning him for even a second to tide those over who are actively enjoying playing the guessing game is a big missed opportunity. Instead, it makes you realise his role in this might be secondary to the rest, with a "You're the only Arkham Knight in Gotham, Batman"-style reveal coming at the close of the game.

2. Driving Looks Claustrophobic

There's a reason you don't see racing games with levels based around dark, right angle turn-filled city streets - they're just no fun. The thing is, in taking the Gotham from Arkham City as a template - i.e. a very closed-off, dilapidated and evacuated city of scum and melee-arenas separated by buildings and signage - it doesn't make for the best place to start bombing about in a high-powered car. Their answer to this seems to be that buildings don't matter and you can just careen through whatever you like - something that okay, works for the sake of letting you stay on someone's tail - but has been the one major flaw in the game's design that hardly anyone seems okay with. Now that the footage is out and both the driving and car combat consists of constantly banking sharp turns while firing rockets after a series of cooldown timers expire - it's really not looking good. In fact, as this is the vast majority of the game...

1. It Just Doesn€™t Feel Like Batman

A carryover from Arkham City, as that version of the Dark Knight had him going after Talia for a quick romp in the Lazarus Pit rather than focussing on saving Gotham itself, and that's without mentioning how little respect he appears to have for his supporting team. Obviously as mentioned earlier you're always going to come across varying notions of what people think Batman should be or act, but now that we've seen some considerable chunks of gameplay and it's focussed primarily in him hopping in a tank to dole 'justice' to those on the other side of his Bat-cannons, it all feels very off. Most of Batman's greatest tales have been pitting him against foes with nothing but his wits to save him, and sure in the Under The Red Hood storyline in particular that did mean calling on the Batmobile to fire in out the blue and skewer a guy into the harbour, Injustice-style. But, as one of the biggest gripes with Nolan's Dark Knight Rises were the later scenes where Batman's blasting all and sundry with the cannons mounted to his aerial Bat(plane), avoiding a gun-happy Bat who seems to be up for shooting manned vehicles altogether would've been a better call. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=s2ieOuO1Lbk How have you found the new trailer? Let us know in the comments and join the Facebook for more!

Gaming Editor
Gaming Editor

WhatCulture's Head of Gaming.