Call Of Duty: Modern Warfare Review - 6 Ups & 5 Downs
A return to form... with some issues.

Infinity Ward's quasi-reboot of the Call of Duty: Modern Warfare franchise is out now, and though the game was subject to a level of pre-release controversy now typical for the AAA shooter series, the end result has been warmly received by most critics so far.
Is Modern Warfare a great game? No. Is it one of the best entries into the Call of Duty franchise? Probably not.
But it does serve as a welcome palette cleanser after last year's disappointingly cynical and piecemeal Black Ops IIII, which lacked a campaign mode entirely while training its focus on Battle Royale shenanigans.
Modern Warfare is a more traditional Call of Duty game and all the better for it, touting a tight campaign and dynamic multiplayer, even if Infinity Ward has also made a number of baffling creative and design decisions which undeniably hold the game back.
It'll be interesting to see if the developer can whip the game into shape over the coming months, though many of these issues are so thoroughly baked into the end-product that, sadly, there's little hope.
Even with the Call of Duty fanbase being famously tough to please, Modern Warfare is sure to be one of the series' more divisive recent offerings, despite its clear effort to strip back the silliness and deliver a more "classic" experience...
Downs...
5. The Infuriatingly Low Time-To-Kill

Though this year's multiplayer suite is a solid improvement upon last year's offering for the most part, there's one aspect where the game proves monumentally frustrating - its absurdly low time-to-kill.
TTK is a vital component of any online shooter, and its implementation has varied wildly across the Call of Duty franchise, with fans firmly divided on whether twitchy, frantic shootouts or more prolonged engagements are the way to go.
Unfortunately, even those who enjoy a low TTK may be left irritated by the brevity of combat scenarios in this game: often before you even have time to register an enemy, you're dead.
This doesn't make for the most satisfying style of play in a game that's already ditched the franchise's conventional three-lane map layout for a more free-flowing and unpredictable design.
It was plainly clear from the beta that Infinity Ward needed to raise the TTK, because the prospect of skilled players being able to turn the tide of a longer shootout is so much more appealing than "he who shoots first wins."
Some modes are certainly better-tuned to accommodate the game's twitchy combat style, but combined with Modern Warfare's other eccentric design decisions, the low TTK can make deaths feel cheap and "undeserved." Speaking of which...
4. Spawns Are Frustrating

Spawns were one of the beta's most complained-about aspects, and sadly they don't seem to be much improved in the final game.
Whether you're playing the epic, jam-packed Ground War or even a less-busy 10v10 mode, it's not uncommon to find yourself spawning in ridiculously close proximity to enemies, who are then able to pick you off with a comical ease - or the other way around.
It's therefore extremely easy for players to "spawn trap" the opposing team, resulting in players racking up countless consecutive deaths in a row before they've had time to react or, you know, move.
Also, due to the large size of the maps, you may often find yourself spawning a huge distance from objectives, which combined with the low TTK, can make pressing forward for the win a slightly demoralising experience.
Granted, with Modern Warfare's more ambitious player load in Ground War, there were always going to be teething problems, but given that it affects even modes with smaller player counts, it's clear that the spawns are desperately in need of a tweak.
3. It's Full Of Bizarre Design Decisions

Despite the many things Modern Warfare gets right, it's also full of strange design decisions which often seem nonsensical and downright antithetical to the experience that most players want.
For starters, PC players will be irked to learn that their version of the game is online-only, and even if you're playing the single-player campaign, you need to be connected to the game's servers.
That these servers crashed on release day, and millions of players were locked out of the campaign for several hours, is proof perfect of why DRM restrictions such as this are pathetic and unacceptable. Bizarrely, though, the restriction wasn't implemented on consoles.
But in terms of actual gameplay, there are so many missing and needlessly altered features: the typical map vote system is gone, the minimap no longer displays gunfire sounds, sprint movement has been slowed compared to the beta, matchmaking resets after every match, and double XP tokens continue to count down even while you're in menus.
Perhaps the biggest overall design flaw is how actively the game promotes camping: between the low TTK, lack of gunfire indicators on the map, loud footsteps and unconventional map layout, most maps reward camping while punishing a run-and-gun style, which feels rather unfair.
While some of these issues could be remedied in a patch, others are so inherently part of the game's design that they can't much be altered, and so players will either have to try and acclimate themselves or simply move on.
2. Spec-Ops Is Dull & Unbalanced

Outside of the campaign and main online multiplayer mode, Modern Warfare features a co-op Spec Ops mode, which continues the campaign's story through a series of four-player online skirmishes.
It's basically Modern Warfare's answer to the absent Zombies mode, but between its tedious, repetitive mission objectives - collecting an endless string of trinkets or killing various terrorist commanders - and the mode's shockingly high difficulty, it's not much fun to play.
Even mere minutes into a Spec Ops match, you're likely find yourself overrun with a fleet of generic A.I. foes, creating an unbalanced feel that's genuinely more annoying than it is entertaining.
Some may appreciate the challenge, but for most players it's more likely to serve as a brief time waster mode they try out and then never return to. Compared to Zombies, this feels incredibly low-effort.
1. All The Missing Multiplayer Modes

Easily the most disappointing aspect of Modern Warfare's online suite is how many classic modes are missing on launch, even if Infinity Ward has promised that more will be added in the near-future.
Fan favourite mode Kill Confirmed is surely the most bothersome omission, while the absence of Demolition, Hardpoint, Capture the Flag and many more is also a massive shame for launch weekend, especially with no timeline for them being added.
On the eve of the game's release, Infinity Ward also pulled the enjoyable night maps from rotation, and though the developer stated they'd be re-added at a "later date," that's no good for those who enjoyed playing the night-vision mode in the beta.
Of course, the online suite was always going to be a malleable product that's shaped over time, but even so, that these modes are apparently ready yet haven't been deployed day one, is totally baffling.
Modern Warfare's issues aside, though, it gets a lot right that future entries could certainly learn from...
Ups...
6. The Campaign Is The Series' Best In Years

If Call of Duty's campaigns have been either generic, silly or even non-existent for quite some time now, Modern Warfare's story mode is a breath of fresh air, delivering a more dynamic and memorable sortie closer in quality to the series' earlier outings.
Though clocking in at only around five hours in length, the campaign is uncommonly serious, thoughtful and well-acted for the franchise, juggling its various ethical quandaries with a greater sense of perspective and ambiguity.
The usual self-consciously shocking moments are there, for sure, but the character of rebel leader Farah Karim lends a human face to the usual flippant carnage on offer, and the new game engine ensures it looks more slickly cinematic than ever before.
Much like the original Modern Warfare's campaign, there's a welcome focus on variety and dynamic gameplay: across the story mode, you'll have night-vision shootouts, fly RC planes and even take part in a terrifyingly tense, Resident Evil 7-esque stalker segment.
While hardly a game-changer for the series, Modern Warfare's campaign is a major return to form after years either experimenting or resting on its laurels, with just enough fan service to reward loyal fans.
5. Ground War Is (Mostly) Awesome

The big new multiplayer innovation this year is the inclusion of a huge-scale, 64-player Ground War mode, and though it undeniably feels like an inferior spin on the epic Battlefield formula, it's still a ludicrously entertaining shake-up of the core formula.
There are many issues with it, as already mentioned, but when you get into the rhythm of it, it can be so much fun.
It is, simply, absolute chaos, and while many will find it exhaustingly over-crowded, it's great to see the franchise finally embracing larger player loads as fans have been requesting for many years now.
With the sheer wealth of combat and traversal options available to the player, Ground War is as creative and hilariously over-the-top as Modern Warfare gets.
You'll probably want to cleanse your palette with some of the game's more pared-down modes after a while, but given the ambition of implementing such a mode, it's far more of a success than not.
4. Realism & Gunfight Modes Are Snappy Additions

There are two more modest modes included in the game's current playlist that are well worth trying out: Realism and Gunfight.
Realism strips away the HUD elements and makes headshots a one-hit kill, creating a more urgent and intense experience than the more arcade-y core style.
This also requires players to listen out for enemy footsteps and try to keep track of their ammo without any on-screen indicators, removing various visual elements players take for granted and flipping the game on its head in the process.
Then there's Gunfight, a 2v2 mode where players are given a random loadout each round, and a round is won by simply eliminating the other team.
This often means that you'll last a whole 10 seconds before dying, but rounds are typically over so fast that it's tough to get frustrated.
The single-life mechanic also makes rounds decidedly more tense and captivating, and it's easy to imagine how Gunfight's bite-sized presentation will become a fave among streamers in particular.
3. Combat Is Slick & Responsive

No matter the many justified complaints fans will have about this year's multiplayer, there's little arguing with Call of Duty's uniformly excellent core gunplay.
Shooting still feels as great as it ever has: aiming is responsive and has a visceral weight to it that so many FPS games simply don't, aided by fluid traversal that feels just right.
Far away from the OTT gimmicks which have accompanied some recent CoD games, Modern Warfare strips the core combat back to basics, while not forgetting the beefy impact which has made the series' gunplay best-of-class ever since the original Modern Warfare.
Would it feel even better if Infinity Ward fixed some of the aforementioned design issues? Sure, but as it stands, it's still an absolute blast to play in its best moments.
2. Domination Steals The Show
Despite the inherent appeal of Ground War's epic canvas of mayhem, Modern Warfare's show-stealing mode is actually a classic fan fave: Domination.
Domination has been one of CoD's perennial bread-and-butter modes, but what makes it so distinctly great in this game is that it provides something of a solution to the game's frustratingly low TTK.
By funnelling players to a series of three distinct objectives, there's far less likelihood that you'll be picked off by a shooter hiding in a dark corner.
It also means that players don't need to exhaustively scan every area of the frame looking for enemies, as more often than not they're heading to the same area you are.
10v10 Domination serves as a major breath of fresh air compared to the game's more frustration-inciting modes, because it feels more stripped-down and back-to-basics while still benefiting from the improved engine.
For those who find themselves constantly dying in Ground War, Domination is the safe haven you've been looking for.
1. The Stunning Sound Design

In the ultra-competitive world of AAA online FPS games, sound design is hugely important, and while the Battlefield franchise has typically bettered Call of Duty in this department, this year Modern Warfare takes a huge leap forward.
Find yourself a great pair of headphones and this is perhaps the most sonically immersive game in the series yet: gunfire sounds absolutely thunderous and responds appropriately according to the environment, while explosions are deafening.
Though already proving controversial with many fans, footsteps have been given a massive boost in the sound mix this year, ensuring that those wearing surround sound headphones have a distinct advantage when it comes to tracking down the enemy - even if this arguably encourages camping.
While it'll be up for debate how Modern Warfare's aural suite compares to Battlefield, it's brilliantly crafted on its own merits and compliments the sharp visuals exceptionally well.