Detroit: Become Human Review: 6 Ups & 2 Downs
Quantic Dream's formula perfected? Almost.
The latest game from Quantic Dream is finally here after years of waiting, and it aims to deliver the best take on the company's choose-your-own-adventure gameplay.
It's no secret that both Heavy Rain and Beyond: Two Souls were divisive games that were really an acquired taste. Not unlike David Cage himself, the director of all three games.
Detroit follows the same gameplay and narrative path as its predecessors, but tries to make it more suited to a wider demographic. It's safe to say that if you hated Heavy Rain and Beyond, you probably won't like Detroit either, but it's definitely the most accessible game the company has made so far.
Even with all of the changes that Quantic Dream has made, Detroit really lives or dies by the theme of choice and how far it is taken. If it falls at that hurdle, it doesn't really have a leg to stand on.
With that in mind, let's take a look at everything that Detroit does right and wrong. Let's start with the bad news first.
Downs...
2. Movement Is Extremely Clunky
One of the biggest problems from past Quantic Dreams games is unfortunately still a pretty big issue for Detroit.
Controlling any of the three main characters is often like trying to move a tank down a hallway. Movements are very imprecise and sudden, which means that trying to get in front of something specific in order to interact with it is almost always a pain.
It doesn't help that camera movement is tied to the right stick, which is also what you use to interact with pretty much everything in the game world. This means that the game will often confuse movements, resulting in some pretty frustrating game moments.
Detroit does try its best to alleviate these problems by making the areas as tight as possible, but unfortunately it doesn't really work all that well.
Having a really tense story moment ruined by your character spinning around in circles and failing a button prompt can ruin the moment pretty fast.
1. Choices Aren't Always Made Clear
For a game all about making decisions, this is a pretty big problem to have.
At many key points in Detroit, the choices the player is given aren't always perfectly clear about their results. Most of the time it can be as simple as a dialogue option going a different way than intended, but sometimes it can actually cause some pretty big consequences.
Part of the fun of Detroit is seeing where the story will go and crafting it all for yourself, but that effect is ruined when it feels like the game isn't really explaining what all of your actions will do.
This is a similar complaint to the one many had with Fallout 4, where the dialogue tree simply didn't give enough information about what was being said, although here the issue is much worse due to the time restraint on choices and focus on the story.
Now, enough griping, it's time to look at what makes Detroit so great.
Ups...
6. It's Absolutely Gorgeous
Everything in Detroit is absolutely jaw-dropping, and it's easily one of the best looking games of this generation.
One of the most important things in Detroit is the characters, so it's a pretty good thing that all of them are highly detailed and look amazingly lifelike. The main three in particular look photorealistic, which is one of the benefits of Quantic Dream's acting process.
It's not just the character models that look great though, as the environments are also lush. Each area is like a set-piece, and it's clear that they've all had extensive work put into making them look as good as possible. It's one of the benefits of being a linear experience.
Best of all has to be the weather effects, with both the snow and the rain coating the characters and environments. It has to be some of the best implementation of weather in game to date.
Simply put, Detroit is one of those games you pop in to make your friends jealous.
5. Connor Could Carry His Own Game

Of all of the characters in Detroit, Connor is easily the standout.
That's not to say that Kara and Markus aren't great characters too, but more that Connor's arc and story choices are a lot more interesting.
Seeing him slowly slip into becoming more human or robotic is extremely interesting on both ends of the scale, especially considering he easily has the most emotional range of all of the characters. Bryan Dechart's performance of the character is truly impressive, and he's easily going to be remembered as the game's most interesting protagonist.
It helps that Connor also comes attached to Hank, who is another of the games' greatest characters. The relationship between the two may be a little bit predictable, but it's still satisfying nonetheless, especially when this sort of 'bromance' hasn't really appeared in a Quantic Dream game yet.
With the success of Detroit, Quantic Dream should really look into giving Connor his own game, as it's pretty clear he can handle one.
4. The Story Is Overall Satisfying

Getting the story of Detroit right is a pretty important thing when you consider it's the main focus of the game, and luckily Quantic Dream managed to pull it off.
Although a lot of things can be changed by the player's decisions, the general story direction of Detroit is mostly kept the same. Where it ends up and the choices it gives you are all pretty satisfying and interesting, and it's definitely the best narrative Quantic Dream have delivered so far.
All three of the characters have interesting stories, motives and twists that make playing through their scenarios over and over again such a joy. Detroit does have a bit of an issue of beating you over the head with some obvious themes, but it's never bad enough to detract from the overall experience.
It's nothing revolutionary, but Detroit manages to deliver an interesting story that is made all the better by the fact that it really is your story.
3. Set-Pieces Are Actually Fun To Play

For the first time in Quantic Dream history, the set-pieces and gameplay sections are actually fun to play.
Both Heavy Rain and Beyond: Two Souls had a problem with mundane tasks and generally boring gameplay that made it hard to want to keep going, but Detroit actually fixes that by having some cool mechanics and set-pieces.
The new scanning mechanic for both Connor and Markus workd pretty well to highlight things to interact with and to break up the monotony of just constantly walking around. Connor's in particular acts like an advanced detective mode and makes his chapters the most fun in the game.
One of the best moments in the game features Connor chasing a deviant across a rooftop, which adds a sense of pace that was desperately missing beforehand. It's surprisingly responsive too, which makes the rest of the game's clumsiness seem really odd.
2. The Soundtrack And Sound Design Are Fantastic

Detroit makes the brave choice to have three different composers work on the game, which gives it a flavour all its own. The sound design is fantastic to boot.
All three of the stories have completely different sounds to them, which is important because of how different they are. Although Connor's theme is probably the best track in the game, the rest of all add to the emotions its trying to project.
In fact, the sound design in general is fantastic. Everything from dull thumps in the attic to overhead helicopters is excellently realised.
1. The Promise Of Choice Is Realised

This is easily the most important part of any choice-based narrative game. Do the choices you make actually have an impact on the story?
Detroit: Become Human does this in a way that no other game like it has in a long while. Every single scene has a mind-boggling amount of choice in it, from little changes in dialogue to whether or not certain characters live to see the end of the story.
The use of a flowchart really encapsulates exactly how much choice you have in the game. In certain big scenes, it stretches and weaves across the screen and even has to be contained within several screens.
It's this amount and depth of choice that really propels Detroit beyond anything else Quantic Dream has ever done. The characters are a big reason too, but the fact that you can really create a story tailored for you is pretty impressive.
This is the best game Quantic Dream have ever released, and it's going to be pretty hard to top.
--
What did you think of Detroit? Do you agree? Let us know in the comments!