Fallout 76 Hands-On: 8 Reasons You Should Be Worried
It's not looking good.
Fallout 76 is... not having an easy go.
First announced to a cacophony of "... what?!", the online-only spin-off is going down the furtive narrative route of showing what the first group of Vault-Tec survivors were up to... in an MMO framework. That means no NPCs as all quests are doled out through mission boards and found items in the world, a progression that factors in microtransactions, and an emphasis on squad-based gameplay. Even the main portions of what are usually Fallout-themed story sequences are pushed to the back of the experience.
Now, there are some notable positives. Exploring the wasteland with your friends is a neat way to fulfil the escapism of literally being the first humans to do so in the lore, and Bethesda have peppered the landscape with tons of beasts to seek out and take down.
At time of writing, a variety of outlets have gone hands-on with code only a month out from release, and sadly, it's pretty clear Fallout 76 is struggling to make ends meet; ticking boxes in a variety of camps, but not coalescing into something worth a premium price.
Here's to Bethesda turning everything around, because right now? Eeesh...
8. Frame-Rate Is Noticeably Bad
Bethesda have been quick to stress that the build given to press isn't representative of what we'll be playing at launch, but this begs the question in regards to frame rates at such a late stage: Why is the game STILL juddering along at a snail's pace?
Rumours abound that because Bethesda are STILL using the Creation Engine (their custom-built tech first used in Skyrim seven years ago), it's taken years to get anything off the ground whatsoever. This contrasts Elder Scrolls Online, which being developed by ZeniMax Online, launched in HeroEngine, before upending everything post-launch to ensure gameplay was as smooth as possible.
Naturally that didn't stay the case as any MMO is susceptible to connection problems, but across all the recent hands-on clips, Fallout 76 appears to drop into single digit frame rates at times, especially when other players posse up or the action kicks off.
So close to launch, it's a markedly bad look.
7. V.A.T.S. Is Completely Different
Simply because a constantly online game means no pausing, V.A.T.S has had to be completely reworked.
Where the "Vault-Assisted Targeting System" previously let you pause time, target limbs and plan your next move, now it just throws a percentage hit on an enemy in real time. Tap the button again and you take the shot - something that certainly does the trick inasmuch as reducing down the core of what V.A.T.S. is as a stat-crunching helper-system, but this makes everything markedly less satisfying or useful.
Obviously if you're not embroiled in combat, you can makeshift the new system to act like the old by slowly manoeuvring the cursor over various body parts and seeing the numbers change, but on a fundamental level, V.A.T.S. is now more like auto-aim than anything more tactical.
6. The Same Tired Inventory System
A complaint that was first made a decade ago, Fallout's Pip-Boy inventory might be a signature element of play, but boy if it isn't cumbersome.
Sadly, as Fallout 76 introduces arbitrary survival mechanics like hunger and thirst to keep track of, you now have food items, medicine etc. as part of the never-ending, all-in-one alphabetised list we've grown to hate.
As IGN noted in their playthrough, the fact there's also no pausing means you're trying to frantically navigate a list of collectibles, essential items and anything in between, sometimes all while under fire.
The whole thing is just strange, because there's an all-new, far more detailed map to use... and yet the inventory has remained on the Pip-Boy, in the exact same fashion as before.
5. Hunger & Thirst "Survival Elements"
Like the "You are over-encumbered" message we all despise across both Fallout and Elder Scrolls, it appears Bethesda like putting caps on certain parts of the experience under the guise of "realism", where the majority of the experience is utter wish fulfilment.
In 76, yes you're free to hunt mutated sloths and score headshots from across the map... but you'll have to eat and drink at regular intervals, to keep some Hunger and Thirst meters topped up.
To some degree, yes, any survival game needs such meters to fulfil its contractual need to the genre, but just who is this for? From where I'm looking, is it really good gameplay to put a group quest on hold while you fry up some bloatfly meat?
At their very best, meter-based survival mechanics are a mild annoyance. At their worst, they get in the way of literally everything else.
4. Divisive Settlements Are A Big Part Of Gameplay
That one part of Fallout 4 you never asked for and barely interacted with?
It's back, and now forms a core part of the game.
Yes, building settlements could be fun, and as a visual reward for hundreds of gathered/crafted components they were fine as a distraction, but now? You'll have to get stuck into building homesteads on the regular, as the "plot" is essentially rebuilding America.
Though at time of writing we have no idea as to how big these settlements can get, there isn't a faction system in the game whatsoever, so it's not like you're building a makeshift Brotherhood of Steel, or making your mark on the world as a city.
Annoyingly, The Verge's hands-on time pointed out that "construction is still slightly clunky, as it was in Fallout 4, and it can be difficult to place things exactly where you want them". This, after one of the most standout complaints from Fallout 4 was the awkward settlement integration, and that was with a demonstrably smaller array of components to build from.
If nothing has changed since 2015, that's one hell of a black mark.
3. No NPCs... But Instances Are Only "A Dozen" Players
At time of writing, Bethesda won't confirm just how many people are in any given "instance" of the game world, leaving the press to discern it's something close to a dozen.
The problem with such a small number when it comes to a gargantuan map size, is that leaves a LOT of walking from point to point. IGN pointed out that coming across another player does feel momentous and worthwhile, but that the ratio of map size to player density seems a little off.
It's worth remembering that Fallout 76 doesn't have any NPCs, either. Personally I think this is so Bethesda can seed the world with Ghouls or other "firsts" as the timeline unfolds, but it means the very notion of a "group Fallout experience" can be somewhat obscured, because there just aren't people to interact with.
2. No Real Objective
Yes, your main prerogative is "Go reclaim America!", but that's an overarching, never-ending MMO "main quest" if I ever heard one. 76's story is more routed in the relationships you'll have with other players, or "that one time you teamed up to defeat Mothman".
It must be said that every time a developer falls back on the "our game's story is told by the players" shtick, it never goes well. Although VICE's Motherboard site houses a great piece on how environmental detail can create a riveting playspace to explore, it's nothing on the "find your father", "avenge your failed execution", "find your infant son" setups of Fallout 3, New Vegas or 4.
Clearly, this completely non-linear setup is geared towards longevity, and possibly tiding us over until The Elder Scrolls VI drops. That said, a Fallout game entirely based on "Just go find things... there'll be something out there... somewhere!" is going to divide a lot of people.
1. We Need To Talk About The Graphics
Bethesda's Fallout wing has never had the best art direction - or rather, they've never had the most colourful or 4K fan-pleasing graphics. Still, the series has a definable identity, and fans most certainly didn't fall in love with the Wasteland over aesthetics.
That said, Fallout 76 is not a looker... to the point of coming across like it's on past hardware.
The current jaw-dropping clip doing the rounds is one of the nuclear explosions that comes as part of regular gameplay. After a nuke has been set off, a set period of the map will be designated as the blast zone, then you have the above to watch: A flat-looking, almost pizza-textured "nuclear cloud" that looks about as threatening as a melted Nuka Cola can.
Obviously this is just one small part of the experience, but coupled with a look that almost appears to be a step back from Fallout 4, it only combines to leave a sour taste.
Remember too, this is releasing just weeks after Red Dead Redemption 2. There's a chance the whole thing could become a laughing stock.