FIFA 14: 10 EPL Players Who Will Definitely Be Over-Rated

The simple fact of the matter is, that every year, there are a number of players who are simply too good €“ they don't truthfully reflect their stats in real life, whether because the EA Sports scouts are clearly fallible, or because of some other unspoken agenda to protect certain players (or so the conspiracy theorists out there might suggest.) Whatever the motivation, it's very obvious that there are some players who enjoy inflated ratings no matter how they actually perform on the pitch. There are of course also those who are hugely underrated, but they don't do as much damage in game as those who are ridiculously over-powered - because frankly, noone wants to be left in the dust by the speed-demon that is Gabi Obertan, do they? So, without further ado, we're looking at the players who will inevitably be unjustly granted preferential ratings treatment when EA Sports' latest addition to the biggest football franchise hits shelves soon.

Honourable Mention

Wayne Rooney
Rooney, former darling of the Premier League and England team has spent the summer making eyes at Chelsea, and flirting not so coyly with Arsenal, in the hope that someone will rescue him from the unpaid Hell he endures year after year, picking up millions of pounds and annual trophies. You have to really feel for him. And while he probably won't be over-rated, per-se in Fifa 14, there's no way the game will do justice to the attitude problems that invariably threaten to turn Wazza from world-beater to entitled, and disinterested passenger. So, he'll be great, but he won't be enough of a problem.

10. Stewart Downing

Team: West Ham Sam Allardyce might believe he's got a bargain, having signed the former Middlesbrough and Aston Villa winger for a small slither of what big-spending, not-really-valuing-properly Liverpool shelled out for him, but going on last season's form, they've arguably paid too much for the sometimes England midfielder. To his credit, Allardyce is aware that the player has failed to live up to his early promise in recent years, and openly confessed on signing him that he was hoping he'd signed the Aston Villa Downing, rather than the Liverpool version. It makes sense: after tall, Stoke City clearly signed the Liverpool Michael Owen, rather than the bench-dwelling self-apologist, and Newcastle United famously signed the Liverpool Ian Rush, as opposed to the old man with a moustache who scored an impressive one goal for them. Anyway, given Downing's form in his first season at Anfield, EA Sports clearly valued the Aston Villa Downing, since he was improbably good last time out, and there's very little chance that will change, with him back playing first team football. He was a 79 last season - roughly 25 points higher than he should have been in real terms, and if he's anywhere above the 70 mark, which he probably will be, the ratings team are being too generous again.

9. Kolo Toure

Team: Liverpool The lesser-talented Toure brother might be enjoying something of a resurgence in Red this season, having left Manchester City to head for Anfield earlier in the summer, but that doesn't mean he should enjoy an upturn in rating. And that's not necessarily to say he doesn't deserve it in real terms - last season he was a bit part player, never able to string together many performances and build up match fitness or sharpness, and this year he has already shown himself worthy of a place in Liverpool's starting line-up - it's just that an increase in rating would be ridiculous from last year. Somewhat unthinkably, Ultimate Team last year ranked Toure at 81, and 83 as a defender, including an eye-water 85 for shooting. Quite who they were looking at when they came up with that rating is anyone's guess, but it can't have been the City defender who did very little to warrant anything above a 70 last year. Now that his resurgence is being talked up, as well as his inevitable importance to Liverpool, there is zero chance EA Sports are going to drop his rating to an acceptable level. They might go below the 80 mark, which would be more than right, but the chances of him getting the high 60s rating he currently deserves are probably slim to none, and thus he's another for the inevitably over-rated pile.

8. Hugo Lloris

Team: Tottenham Hotspur Hugo Lloris is a great 'keeper, there's no denying that. But what he is not, is a 90 plus rated 'keeper. Overall, FIFA 13 gave the French custodian a very high 87 rating, with plus 90 on key attributes like Diving and Reflexes, and yet anyone who has watched the 'keeper in real life will probably quite happily admit that those figures are vastly over-powered. There is no way Lloris should have been rated a full 10 plus points over Tim Krul for the same attributes, or 7 more than Simon Mignolet, or even 8 more than Michel Vorm, all of whom proved themselves better 'keepers than Lloris last term (even in comparatively struggling teams, especially in the cases of Newcastle and Sunderland.) In real life, Brad Friedel kept the Frenchman out of the starting line-up, and for good reason, despite being a massive 15 points lower for Diving, and 12 lower for reflexes. Lloris was unfairly over-powered, and you have to suspect that he will command similar stats this year out as well, especially with presumably more projected pitch time, and a season of Premier League football under his belt.

7. Emmanuel Mayuka

Emmanuel MayukaTeam: Southampton Aside from his recent goal-scoring exploits in the Capital One Cup for the south coasters, you could be forgiven for forgetting that the Zambian is even still at Southampton. He has had very little impact at all in the past year, seeing his time on the pitch restricted to just one start and a handful of substitute appearances for the Saints, and he's hardly become a big name on the English scene, despite performing well for his country. But if you're a FIFA player, you'll probably think differently about Mayuka, who was handed an improbable rating last year that clearly ignored all sense of logic and the reality of the Premier League. Because Mayuka, the 22 year old striker with very little Premier League experience, is one of the most prodigiously talented forwards on the entire game. His Acceleration is a fleet-footed 91, while his Sprint Speed tops out at 90, and adding to that Agility of 90 and Balance of 85, and you have one of the finest, quickest strikers in the world, rotting away on Southampton's bench, when he should presumably be demolishing defences and embarrassing anyone foolish enough to get into a one-on-one with him. Oh, and he has a five-star weak foot, making him dangerous on either side. Even if EA Sports listen to sense and drop his stats by 20%, he will still be over-rated, judging by his fleeting forays onto the pitch at St Marys, and you have to assume that they'd be unwilling to drop them even further to save face.

6. Joe Hart

Team: Manchester City When Joe Hart isn't writhing around on the floor selling Head & Shoulders to people who clearly believe dandruff is a debilitating disease, he often keeps goal for Manchester City and England. Trouble is, he doesn't do it as well as FIFA 13 suggested, nor, inevitably as well as FIFA 14 will, no doubt. Last season, Hart was a bit of a weak link (everything is relative) and he wasn't as imperious as one might expect from a Championship-contending team's 'keeper to be, but that didn't stop EA Sports from putting him on the cover of the game, and making him as infallible as a goal-tending Zeus. He was over-powered quite markedly, saving some ludicrous efforts, and though there is absolutely no doubting his ability, or indeed his suitability to play in goal for both City and England, it would appear that the lack of competition has dulled his skills a little, and while pre-season might have ironed them out, his costly clanger against Cardiff City in his team's second game of the new term hardly inspires confidence that he is as infallible as some might suggest. Chances are, EA Sports will continue the Hart love in, ignoring any of the stumbles from last season, and making him as close to God as humanly possible in goalkeeping terms at least.

5.Theo Walcott

Team: Arsenal The bias towards speedy players on FIFA is something that some fans without a tight grip on how to defend will no doubt openly hate. Even comparatively unskilled players like Gabriel Obertan - a disaster for most of his time in the black and white of Newcastle - can set the game alight because they are immensely fast, and can control the ball even slightly. Theo Walcott doesn't quite fall into the same bracket as Obertan, since he actually scores goals and can have an impact on how his team plays, but he has been over-powered on FIFA since his earliest days at Arsenal. Because of the game's bias towards speed, Walcott tends to be a darling in-game: he is blisteringly fast, and though in real life that only leads to anything dangerous around 20% of the time (he's surprisingly frustrating to watch for someone so "exciting") in the game he is an attacking behemoth. Because of that speed, it's unlikely that Walcott's rating will drop at all, even if his dribbling skills leave a lot to be desired in real life, and his balance is not quite as line-precise as suggested in previous games. His brilliance is a crushing inevitability, because of how he plays, and there's no getting around that.

4. David Luiz

David LuizTeam: Chelsea This may come as something of a revelation to Barcelona fans who seem to be perpetually linked with a move for the Sideshow Bob-haired Brazilian centre-half, or indeed the Chelsea fans who sit and watch him every week, but David Luiz is not the player some think he is. Luiz was remarkably undervalued by FIFA 13, particularly in Ultimate Team, where his improbably high stats were offset by an equally improbable low cost, and he became an essential purchase for that very reason. But counter to those stats, and indeed to what appears to be established "logic" that values him at around the Rio Ferdinand mark, he is not a superhuman defender. He still frequently finds himself out of position, dragged by his typically Brazilian gung-ho attitude up the pitch, and he runs back towards his own goal without the ball far too much for a world class defender. Add to that the fact that he gives the ball away, and he's a poor man's Fabricio Coloccini. Yes, the past year has seen an upturn in his skills, which has pushed him to a starting spot in the Brazil squad, but you have to remember, these things are relative, and the Brazilian defence isn't quite as alluring as the Brazilian attack. Or as hard to get into. Regardless, his stats are likely to see a massive uplift, because he was undervalued last year, and because public opinion seems to have turned towards him after his first poor season at Chelsea was swept away by fresher, less poor memories.

3. Yohan Cabaye

Team: Newcastle United This summer has seen any number of transfer sagas, sending Jim White's head into a comical, Exorcist-style spin, and none can have been as frustrating as the saga of No Transfers at Newcastle United. Famously frugal, the owner so far has made one loan signing, and shipped out a fair number of so-called "fringe" players, to make an already thin squad "stronger" for the coming season. That hasn't gone down too well with fans, who clearly play a lot of Football Manager, and prefer when managers can stand for pre-season promo photo shoots flanked by at least 10 new players (despite the obvious effect that had on QPR last year) and what has made those grumbles louder is the relatively "new" Yohan Cabaye saga. He's probably off to pastures new - whether that's in England or not - and Alan Pardew has said he'll only go for the going rate for "world class players" - i.e. world class money. Sadly for Pardew, Mike Ashley and Cabaye, his performances last year were some way away from world class: in the grand scheme of things, Shola Ameobi probably pushed the term closer for qualification. He was disinterested, uncommitted and frequently injured, and though his range of passing, and his ability to hit freekicks onto a postage stamp are great, his performances last year warrant neither the hyperbole from fans and manager, or the inevitably inflated rating he will get on FIFA 14.

2. Fernando Torres

Team: Chelsea Despite Chelsea's inability to sign a new striker (so far) and their preference for signing ALL of the midfielders in the world, Jose Mourinho cannot be unaware that in Fernando Torres, he has a bit of a lame duck of a striker. Hamstrung terribly by that giant price tag that took him from Liverpool to the South, Torres has looked a shadow of his former glorious self, and would probably do well to justify a tenth of what Chelsea over-paid for him a few years back. But despite this, FIFA 14 will probably still give him a great rating. There's precedence after all: last year he had better finishing than Robert Lewandowski, and he hasn't suffered anything like the catastrophic drop in rating that his equally catastrophic drop in form should have earned him so far. Some say it's because of shirt sales, but there surely can't be that many people still buying shirts for the centre-forward whose national team consciously invented a system where they wouldn't have to play with strikers in order to compensate for how rubbish he is. Can there?

1. Gareth Bale

Team: Tottenham Hotspur For now, the Welsh "wizard" remains at Spurs, despite an even more obscene public flirtation with other teams than Yohan Cabaye's apparent come and get me plea to anyone listening, and wherever he plays this year, it's unlikely he will be anything but the best British player in the game. Based on the good half of his season last term, Bale was a one-man wrecking machine, dragging Spurs by the scruff of their necks into winning positions, and destroying teams with ease, thanks to impeccable forward drive, and an infuriatingly convincing ability to throw himself on the ground in goal-scoring positions. But there were two halves to last season, and there's no forgetting that the player who underwhelmed in that other half wasn't so far away from the Spurs door not too long ago. Here's a note to all the hyperbole writing media out there - Gareth Bale is not the best player in the world. He might be one of the best left-sided attackers in Europe, but he's far from the king of the entire sport, but the inevitability of his massively overpowered stats on FIFA 14 is lurching towards us mercilessly like a freight train on a highway to Obvious Town. Did we miss any players you think will definitely be over-rated when FIFA 14 comes out? Share your picks below.

Contributor
Contributor

WhatCulture's former COO, veteran writer and editor.