FIFA 15: 15 Ratings EA Sports Have Got Completely Wrong

The top 50-rated players in FIFA 15 are out, and EA have missed a sitter.

Last Sunday, one of the most eagerly-anticipated days in the run-up to the release of FIFA 15 passed as EA Sports finished their countdown of the top 50-rated players in the upcoming football simulation title. Since Wednesday 3rd, the publishers have been teasing out player ratings 10 at-a-time, and yesterday finished with their top ten. Throughout the course of this reveal, EA threw up many surprises. Players who many expected to be further up in the standings were instead released early and with an inferior score while some on this list haven't budged an inch from last year's game in spite of putting in some excellent personal performances over the last 365 days. Ratings in '15 are based on players' performances over the course of the last 12 months, and are intended to reflect on how their virtual counterparts stack up in EA's digital football world. Yet there are a series of stars who have played better than these ratings suggest during that period and it's not hard to find gripes with FIFA'S top 50. Whether it's a completely harsh downgrade, an inexplicable upgrade or a static rating, we've rounded up 15 Ratings EA Sports Have Got Completely Wrong in FIFA 15 - and we also have a bone to pick with the No.1 rated player, too. To find out why, and so much more besides, click 'next' to get started.

15. Thibaut Courtois (86)

There have been very few goalkeepers better than Thibaut Courtois over the last year, with the on-loan Chelsea star putting in a series of excellent performances during his temporary stay at Atletico Madrid in 2013-14. Courtois conceded just 24 La Liga goals last season - the lowest "goals-to-games" ratio in Spain's top division. It was because of this - and a stringent back line - that allowed Atletico to win their first league title since 1996 while Courtois himself was rewarded for his excellent displays between the stick with a recall from his loan and a place in Chelsea's first-team squad this term. But he hasn't been rewarded by EA. In spite of his aforementioned exploits, the keeper has risen only two points from last year's 84, and is considered just one point better than Petr Cech - the man he has just displaced at Stamford Bridge. For us, there has to be more of a differentiation between the two goalies, for one is clearly a lot better than the other. The highest-rated keeper on the game in Manuel Neuer at 90, and we feel as though Courtois deserves to be a lot closer to the Germany international.

14. Angel Di Maria (86)

In spite of his excellent performances for Real Madrid recently, Angel Di Maria has inexplicably retained last year's rating of 86, with EA apparently deciding he's just as good as he was 12 months ago. Instead, the stats show Di Maria has gotten a lot better, though this hasn't been reflected by the publisher's latest grades. No player in Spain provided more assists than Di Maria's 17 last season, with the winger setting up more goals than the likes of Madrid teammate Gareth Bale and the so-called 'assists king' Cesc Fabregas. The Argentinian also popped up with 11 goals in all competitions - the most he's ever scored in a single campaign for Real - yet still his rating has not moved. You have to wonder what more Manchester United's new signing could have done to warrant an increase. Not only did he excel at club level but he also shone on the international stage and was a driving force behind his country's run to the World Cup final at this summer's tournament in Brazil. A rating of 88 would surely therefore have been more appropriate.

13. Juan Mata (85)

That age-old footballing cliché "it's a game of two halves" was practically created for Juan Mata. The midfielder endured and enjoyed two vastly different experiences last season - spending half of the campaign on Chelsea's bench and the other half scoring goals for Manchester United. Signed by United in the January transfer window and rescued from the fringes of Stamford Bridge, Mata's rating could so easily have gone up or down in FIFA 15 given his topsy-turvy term. In the end it was the latter, with the Spain star's score dropping two points from last year's 87, which we feel is harsh. Mata started only two full games for Chelsea during the first half of the 2013-14 season and was deemed surplus to requirements by manager Jose Mourinho. But upon moving to United in the winter transfer window, he scored six goals from 15 appearances and showed he is very much a world class player. And so we feel his rating should have remained as it was because, when you weigh everything up, he has neither excelled nor waned over the course of the last 12 months.

12. Xabi Alonso (84)

Sometimes a player rating can appear inconspicuous until compared to that of a peer, and that is certainly true of Xabi Alonso. The former Real Madrid star has been awarded an apparently-generous score of 84 in FIFA 15, despite the fact neither he, Real or Spain enjoyed a particularly good 12 months. Alonso struggled to get in the team at the Bernabeu at times in 2013-14, making only 26 league appearances, of which he played 18 full games. Real meanwhile finished third in La Liga while Spain were unceremoniously knocked out of the World Cup at the group stages after just three games, losing two. And you have to ask yourself, is Alonso really the 48th best player in the world today? His score of 84 sends him into EA's top 50-rated players' category and makes him just as good as Italy legend Andrea Pirlo, apparently, which really does put things into perspective. Frankly, we can't understand EA's reasoning behind this rating.

11. Carlos Tevez (85)

Another rating that falls down to credulity when compared to that of a peer is Carlos Tevez's. There can't be many out there who expected to see the forgotten Juventus striker make EA's top 50 in the player ratings yet with an overall score of 85, the former Manchester City and United forward comes in as the 39th best player in the game. Which is just a little daft, really. At the grand old age of 30, Tevez's career is starting to wind down and he didn't even play for Argentina at this summer's World Cup. Since leaving City the South American has dropped off the radar a little and while he scored 19 Serie A goals last season, the Italian league is hardly competitive, with Juve sauntering to the title by 17 points. But the one thing that really makes this score fall down in the face of credulity is the fact his rating of 85 makes Tevez just as good as Diego Costa. Really? Both are rated at 85 and it goes without saying that the latter is the far better player. Again, there simply has to be more of a differentiation between the two, and EA's failure to recognise that Costa is obviously superior is quite unforgivable. Do they even watch football?

10. Arturo Vidal (85)

One of the most reckless ratings to come from EA's reveal of their top 50 is Arturo Vidal€™s, with the Juventus midfielder being DOWNGRADED from 86 in last year€™s game to 85, which is ever so slightly perplexing. Vidal was a beast for Juve last season, scoring 11 goals from 32 appearances, and if anything, surely his score should have headed in the opposite direction. The tenacious midfielder put in a series of dominating performances from the middle of the park in 2013-14, living up to his nickname of Il Guerriero (€œThe Warrior€). His determination and iron will were further underlined by the fact he was still one of the best players at the World Cup, despite the Chilean suffering a knee injury in the months preceding the finals in Brazil. And that perhaps is the reasoning behind EA€™s decision to slash his score. The 27-year-old had an operation to repair his meniscus before the World Cup and hasn€™t played 90 minutes of football since. But if that€™s the only rationale behind his demotion, that€™s disappointing because Vidal remains one of the best midfielders in world football, and EA's ratings tragically don't reflect that as he comes in as just the 35th best player on the game.

9. Mesut Ozil (86)

Up until now this list has dealt mostly with player ratings that we feel are too low, but there were occasions during EA's unveiling of their top 50-rated players list that certain stars received a generous score. Take Mesut Ozil for example. He's down one point from 87 last year but that's still not enough of a decrease for our liking. Ozil joined Arsenal for £42.5 million last summer, with his move from Real Madrid shattering the London club's transfer record. But he has yet to live up to his price tag. The Germany international only scored five goals in 2013-14 and seemed to struggle while adapting to the English game, looking off the pace at the best of times. He made just 26 Premier League appearances and started only 14 of those games, being subbed off in 42.3% of his matches, according to Squawka stats. The physicality of the English game clearly took its toll on the player, who is used to taking winter breaks and looked exhausted due to the lack of one. And it's because of these problems that we feel he deserves a lower score, for we do not deem him worthy of his position as the 28th best player in the game in light of his performances over the last 12 months.

8. Neymar (86)

While EA have been generous with Ozii, they have completely overlooked Neymar. The Barcelona forward has just enjoyed a tremendously-successful 12 months for club and country yet has risen by just one point from last year's rating of 85. Signed from Santos last summer, the forward excelled during his debut campaign in Spain, scoring 15 goals in all competitions. He also shone for Brazil. With the weight of a whole nation riding on his shoulders, Neymar could so easily have buckled under the pressure as his home country hosted the World Cup, yet he stepped up to the plate and scored four goals and provided an assist to fire the Seleção to the semi-finals. Neymar missed the semis due to an injury sustained in the quarter-final victory over Colombia and had he been fit and able to play, he would surely have added more goals to his tally and may even have won the Golden Boot. He certainly deserves to be higher than 30 on EA's top 50, for that simply does not recognise his status as one of the best players in the world today - at the age of just 22, lest we forget.

7. Robin van Persie (88)

Robin van Persie's downgrade in the FIFA franchise was inevitable following last season's events but many expected to see the Manchester United striker's rating fall further than it has done. van Persie's score has only been slashed by a point from last year's 89, and in our eyes that is not enough of a decrease. The Dutchman struggled for both form and fitness in 2013-14 and as such was limited to just 10 full games in the Premier League, meaning he was unable to replicate the goal-scoring heroics of two seasons ago that saw him net 26 goals in the league and win the Golden Boot award. And following a disappointing campaign that saw him fall short of those achievements on the second time around, you cannot seriously argue he is the 11th best player in the world today, as his rating in FIFA 15 would have us believe. The likes of Diego Costa and Sergio Aguero were in far better form last term, and yet they somehow have lower ratings than RVP.

6. Sergio Aguero (86)

Sergio Aguero scored 17 goals to Robin van Persie's 12 last season and yet the Manchester City striker has been downgraded by TWO POINTS from last year. With a score of 86, Aguero has been left in the dust by the Dutchman and is bizarrely rated as only the 24th best player in FIFA 15. It almost goes without saying that this rating is incorrect, based on the Argentinian's performances over the last 12 months at least. Aguero may well have been injured for large swathes of the 2013-14 campaign, making only 23 Premier League appearances, but he still averaged almost a goal-a-game when he played. His 28 goals from 34 total appearances makes a mockery of his rating and we're still trying to fathom just why EA decided to savagely slash his score from last year's game. It could be that he endured a disappointing World Cup with Argentina having missed most of it through injury, but when fit, there are few better strikers in the world than the 26-year-old, who has been hard done by here.

5. Yaya Toure (86)

Considering he was Manchester City's top goalscorer in the Premier League last season with 20 goals, we find it outrageous that Yaya Toure's rating of 86 has stayed where it was from FIFA 14. Coming in at number 22 on EA's top 50, Toure's score has neither decreased nor increased from last year. Which is ridiculous considering the Ivorian was quite easily the best midfielder in England's topflight in 2013-14 with his goal haul of 20 strikes representing his most prolific campaign in front of goal since his career began in 2001. His lung-busting, rampaging runs through the middle of midfield made him a nightmare to defend against and very few defenders were able to stand in his way. It was Toure's form that was part of the reason why City won their second league title in three years and while he was named in the PFA Premier League Team of the Year, his performances went largely unnoticed and unappreciated - particularly, as it seems, by EA, who have failed to recognise his status as one of Europe's best midfielders today.

4. Radamel Falcao (88)

You really do have to wonder just how much European football the so-called experts over at EA HQ have been watching over the last 12 months because if they'd seen any French football at all, they would know that handing Monaco striker Radamel Falcao a rating of 88 is totally ludicrous. Falcao has only gone down one point from last year's rating of 89 despite missing half of last season and the World Cup due to the knee injury he suffered back in January. The Colombian spent six months on the sidelines and only managed nine Ligue 1 goals as a result. So why then has his rating not been slashed further? Considered the 12th best player in the world today based off EA's top 50, Falcao has done little over the last 12 months to suggest he deserves a rating anywhere near as lofty. He's only five points worse off than the best player in '15 - Lionel Messi - which really puts things into perspective. Admittedly a world class player when fit, the ratings are designed to reflect performances over the last 365 days and Falcao simply didn't play enough - or score enough - during that period to deserve this score.

3. Diego Costa (85)

What does 27 league goals in 35 games get you? An increase of a paltry one point in FIFA 15, according to EA, who have shackled Diego Costa with a truly dismal score. Chelsea's new signing has only gone up one point from last year's rating of 84 despite the fact only Lionel Messi and Cristiano Ronaldo outscored him in La Liga in 2013-14. Costa was the third-highest goalscorer in Spain last term and was prolific both domestically and in European competition, banging in eight goals in nine Champions League appearances to equal the record held by Vavá since 1959 for most in a season by an Atletico player. His prodigious goalscoring may have earned him a move to Chelsea this summer, but his rating in '15 hasn't moved much. Bizarrely considered only the 37th best player in the game according to EA's top 50, Costa has the same score as Carlos Tevez, despite scoring 16 more goals than him, and is three points behind Robin van Persie, despite hitting 15 more than the Dutchman. With these numbers in mind, how on earth did EA arrive at their decision to give the Spain international such an insulting rating?

2. Cesc Fabregas (84)

EA got quite a few ratings completely wrong in FIFA 15, with the publishers making a number of howlers this year. But arguably one of the worst ratings handed down was that given to Chelsea's Cesc Fabregas, who has astonishingly seen his score slashed by TWO POINTS from last year's game. Down from 86, the midfielder must be wondering what on earth he's done to deserve such a paltry score and someone over at EA HQ must harbour a SERIOUS grudge against the Spaniard to have arrived at this unfathomable decision that, quite frankly, flies in the face of his performances over the last 12 months. The former Barcelona star scored 13 goals in all competitions for the Catalans last season and also conjured up 16 assists, coming joint-second in the assists table alongside Koke with only Angel Di Maria setting up more goals in Spain over the last 12 months. But it appears as though he is being singled out from a Barcelona campaign that saw the club finish trophy-less, for that is the only reason we can come up with to explain EA's lamentable decision to rate him as only the 46th best player in the game.

1. Lionel Messi (93)

Somewhere in Spain, Cristiano Ronaldo must be seething. For most of his career he has fought an almost-personal battle with arch nemesis Lionel Messi for the right to be called the best player in world football, and this year it appeared as though he had finally achieved that mantle following his Ballon d'Or win. Voted as the world's best player only eight months ago, EA must have missed THAT particular memo because they've only gone and made Messi the highest-rated player on FIFA 15. There's a degree of controversy surrounding this decision - The Argentinean is after all the game's cover star and you can't help but wonder if that factored into the decision making. After all, EA certainly couldn't have arrived at this decision based off the duo's respective performances in 2013-14, for Ronaldo scored 35 La Liga goals to Messi's 28, and if I were CR7, I'd feel somewhat miffed that I'd been done over in the ratings by someone I just outscored. EA have a lot to answer for in regards to their player ratings, but we don't envisage we'll be getting any answers any time soon. What ratings do you think EA got wrong on FIFA 15? Let us know in the comments thread, below.

Contributor
Contributor

Joseph is an accredited football journalist and has interviewed nearly all of the current 20 Barclay's Premier League managers. He is also a correspondent for Bleacher Report and has written for Caught Offside and Give Me Football.