FIFA 15: Celtic Player Rating Predictions

How the Bhoys should shape up in this year's FIFA release.

Fifa 15 Celtic The release date for FIFA 15 is creeping ever closer, and as EA Sports typically hold off on dumping all of the relevant new information on us, various leaks and piecemeal official announcements have painted a very broad picture of the upcoming game. It's going to be good-looking, it's going to be immersive, and it's going to sell as huge a number as it always does - these things are not up for debate. Whether EA Sports will have ironed out all of the kinks and glitches that blighted last year's game - and addressed the frustrating issue of handicapping in a more intelligent manner - is still up for debate, and so too is how well the developers will do in rating the players in-game. Notoriously, each annual release comes with the almighty compromise that some ratings will be glaringly, horribly wrong, and others will be a tiny bit wrong: inevitably it is those mistakes that are noticed more than how right they were in giving Daniel Sturridge 88 for finishing. As is traditional, the leaks of supposed FIFA team ratings have already began to appear, with the top sides in the Premier League in focus, but it's important also to look to the other European powers in the game. Will Real Madrid get 100s across the board for their ridiculous squad? Will Luis Suarez's mental stats be as colourful as his rap sheet? And most importantly of all, how will Scottish champions Celtic shape up after another SPL win, but an even start to this campaign? With that in mind, we're rating the 12 key players in the Bhoys squad ahead of FIFA 15's official unveiling...

12. Scott Brown - 73

FIFA 14 Rating: 73 The dynamic box-to-box midfielder, as he was once dubbed, didn't have as prolific a season last year as he had in 2012/13, but he played a lot more first-team games for the Bhoys. He arguably didn't quite meet the heights he had scaled in the season previous either in terms of his performances, but remained a key member of the squad. This year the player should get the same rating as he had in FIFA 14, and though he was injured in pre-season and is yet to play a part in Celtic's games so far, he should continue his importance in midfield, as long as his fitness returns and he can avoid getting sent off in as illustrious company as he did last season (after kicking out at Neymar of all people). He remains quick on the ball, is powerful and capable of some incisive runs, even if his passing accuracy could be better, and his shooting considerably so. For players looking to team his pace with Kris Commons in a more advanced role in midfield, it's unlikely his pace will drop from last year's 87, which will likely be his most useful characteristic for players taking on Celtic in FIFA 15.

11. Anthony Stokes - 76

FIFA 14 Rating: 72 Regardless of any criticisms of the quality of the SPL, scoring 20 goals in any league campaign is very much worthy of acclaim, and that is precisely what Anthony Stokes managed last season, despite a poor start. With the arrival of Leigh Griffiths, the former Hibs striker found his shooting boots and ended on the nice round number in the 5-2 win over Aberdeen, and showed in the second half of the season more promise than he has for some seasons. FIFA 14 already recognised his best attributes, giving impressive ratings for Shoot Power, speed and Agility, but for a striker, his shooting rating was far from eye-catching to the point that it always felt smarter to go out and bring someone else in with greater composure. But on the back of his 20 goal haul last year, Stokes might well enjoy an improvement in that key department, which would also account for the general improvement in his overall rating. He should at least be closer to 80 for his finishing than the 73 he was rated at last year.

10. Craig Gordon - 73

FIFA 14 Rating: N/A The former Sunderland stopper might well be a major gamble for Celtic, considering his appalling injury record in the past few years, but there is no doubting that he is an able custodian and one who should fill the considerable gloves of Fraser Forster, provided he can stay out of the treatment room long enough to put together a run in the Hoops net. That's a fairly big question, given that the former Scotland international managed just 16 appearances for Sunderland since 2010, but having trained with Rangers last season and spent some time coaching, Gordon has declared himself free of injuries. If that's true, Celtic have a bargain on their hands, whose ability once earned him the accolade of the greatest ever save in the Premier League. That he was agile, composed and an excellent shot-stopper are not to be doubted, and if Gordon remains injury free he is undoubtedly worth his 73 rating. He was last rated at 78 in FIFA 12, and it's a reasonable assumption that he'll see a downgrade from then: but Celtic seem to have made it clear they have the confidence in Gordon as Forster's replacement, and that might well boost him in EA Sports' eyes back towards former glories.

9. Derk Boerrigter - 72

FIFA 14 Rating: 71 He might have caught some unwanted attention for Celtic by diving against St Johnstone to illegally win a penalty, but the former Ajax player is a solid talent, and one who should enjoy a slight uplift from last year's rating. Yes, he only managed 16 appearances for the Bhoys last year, but his pace and acceleration, and his shot power make him exactly the type of attacking player that FIFA players tend to love. Combining his pace with Stokes and Brown will prove fruitful for Celtic players particularly, and while his finishing and heading make him far from a goal-scoring machine in the game, he's likely to be a more than useful winger. Meanwhile, Aleksandar Tonev is likely to come in at around 68, making him the likely stand in for Boerrigter. It's difficult to see how the Aston Villa midfielder will gain anything like a big increase on his FIFA 14 rating considering he made 17 appearances in the Premier League last year and seems mostly unfancied this year by Paul Lambert. But Tonev is still reasonably well-rated, and he should have potential around the 70-72 range.

8. Mikael Lustig - 77

FIFA 14 Rating: 73 To their credit, EA Sports did get Lustig's potential right last year, with a 77 rating possible, but his starting point of 73 was just too low for the impressive Swede, even if he is 28 and thus beyond the usual age that the game thinks players can still be any good. This year, the defender deserves to be increased to the top of his former potential, and have a new potential closer to 80. The game also needs to change his ridiculous Very Bad international profile, considering he's a starting defender for his country. He's unlikely to be the best attacking defender in the game, though his form in real life at times last season proves FIFA's low ratings of his attacking prowess were a little under-weight. The real problem for Lustig last year in FIFA was that his technical skills just weren't there: ball control of 64 for a defender is just ridiculous, and balance of 56 was clearly wrong for anyone who has actually seen him play. Both of those attributes need upgrading, and he needs an overall lift to somewhere like 77 for the sake of realism.

7. Teemu Pukki - 74

FIFA 14 Rating: 72 Like Lustig, Pukki started last year's game with a base rating some way off his potential growth (a comparatively impressive 78), which was mostly reflective of his apparent inability to do anything other than be a striker in EA Sports' eyes. In FIFA 14, he was quick, agile and possessed good striking skills, but he couldn't pass, tackle, or cross and his vision was woeful (a little ridiculously, considering he's a striker, and it's basically a key part of his job), an while his attacking stats were about right, it's a little unfair how much the rest were downgraded. In real life the former Sevilla and Schalke man has hardly been prolific, but 7 goals in 16 starts is hardly disastrous. The Finn has admitted that his debut season after moving from Germany was disappointing, but he proved with some deft attacking displays that there is probably a lot more to come from him (as EA basically confirmed with that potential rating last year). Though his first full season wasn't exactly great, Pukki is motivated and confident, as he's told the press and he has already scored twice in Europe, so perhaps a slight increase would be fair.

6. Efe Ambrose - 70

FIFA 14 Rating: 68 In FIFA 14, the Nigerian was strong, powerful and good in the air, and there was always the potential to grow his rating up to his potential of 74, and while he looks in danger of occasionally sabotaging his own career - either through poor discipline or comically bad performances like his jaded role in Celtic's defeat to Juventus last year, he's still a strong squad member. Some of his defensive qualities in last year's game left a lot to be desired, and were occasionally a little harsh, which accounts for the increase of 2 rating points this year. He should arguably have started out as that rating last year in the first place, so it's not really reflective of an improvement in the player (even though at times he did warrant individual praise), but more a redressing of a slight error in rating. The centre-back is hardly going to be pulling up too many trees, but he's a good presence to have if only for aerial duels, and his power should be key for dealing with more fleet-footed, lighter attackers.

5. Jason Denayer - 73

FIFA 14 Rating: N/A Man City's Belgian teenager is destined for great things - it might not with the Champions, but it will happen somewhere. The centre-back is strong, quick and powerful and has a great eye for a pass, much like compatriot Vincent Kompany, and he's tough in the tackle and built a little like Micah Richards, which is always a good thing for a centre-half. He's already made a big impact since his season long loan switch, scoring his new side's first goal and picking up the Man Of The Match award in the 6-1 demolition of Dundee Utd, and if he can continue that early form into the season it's likely he'll force Efe Ambrose out of the first team for an extended period. Man City are very much aware of his ability, and moving him out to Celtic should do a lot for his progress, and while there is inevitably an element of guesswork in establishing his likely rating, it's far from an unreasonable assessment. And if the starting rating of 73 doesn't excite you enough, it's likely he'll be rated at significantly closer to 80 for potential.

4. Stefan Johansen - 75

FIFA 14 Rating: 73 Perhaps because of the lack of Old Firm games and the close rivalry at the top of the league that traditionally pushes Celtic to play to their best strengths, a lot of the better Hoops players in last year's game started out with relatively conservative ratings in comparison to their potential. Stefan Johansen - who only joined the club in January - was one such player, given a starting base of 73, but a potential rating of around 80, and while it is Scott Brown and Kris Commons who are the beating heart of the Celtic midfield, the Norwegian is just as key. In 2013, the highly-rated centre-midfielder won the Danish midfielder of the year award, and he has already announced himself to Celtic with some good displays in the second half of the season. In FIFA 14, his progress to 80 and above tended to be impressively quick, and he gained a reputation as something of a goal-scoring machine despite his pace and speed not matching up to Brown's. Again, it seems likely that his starting rating will be lower than his potential - which should be pushed as high as 82 or so - and he will undoubtedly be one of the more valuable Celtic players in the game.

3. Emilio Izaguirre - 74

FIFA 14 Rating: 72 As ever, the Honduran full-back attracted attention from the Premier League throughout the summer (and don't rule out a move from below the border before the end of August), and that is testament to how good a player he has proved for Celtic already. He was unfairly down-graded after FIFA 13 from 74, and proved himself one of Celtic's most impressive players once again last season despite that, so his return to a better rating should be assured. Yes, EA Sports will continue to attract accusations that they favour more "popular" players in the ratings system, but Izaguirre surely cannot be any lower than the 74 he was initially graded in FIFA 13. He was voted the Player of the Year in 2011 for good reason, and though he has had to overcome major injury since then, his value to the team is untold, particularly in his ability to get forward and put crosses into the box. Perhaps a 74 rating is a little generous in some FIFA players' eyes, but there is no way the Honduran is a worse player than he was two years ago, and if EA Sports do downgrade him again, it will be fundamentally wrong of them.

2. Virgil Van Dyk - 76

FIFA 14 Rating: 72 There's a good reason why Fraser Forster has just earned himself a £10m move to the Premier League, and it's not his shot-stopping skills. The giant Geordie was a solid goal-keeper as he proved on more than one occasion last year, but the fact is he was protected by an occasionally monumental defence that went 1,215 minutes without conceding a goal, breaking the 43-year-old record previously set by Aberdeen. Teams simply did not get much of a chance to score against the Bhoys, and a lot of the responsibility for that success fell on Virgil Van Dijk's considerable shoulders. For his efforts, the Dutchman won the Celtic Players' Player of The Year award, and has been linked with a move away from the club - most recently to Newcastle United. Van Dijk is the real deal, and if he chooses not to stay at Celtic, he will slot into most Premier League defences with ease, at a fraction of the cost of the likes of Mangala, and if he does stay, he will continue to be the keystone to the Scottish side's defence. Thanks to his imperious season last year, he deserves an uplift from his 72 rating in FIFA 14, to something more reflective of the potential rating EA Sports gave him (of 78).

1. Kris Commons - 80

FIFA 14 Rating: 74 Ratings of 80 shouldn't be handed out without understanding exactly what that sort of assessment means, but 27 goals from 34 games for a midfielder in any league is an astounding return, and Commons deserves the accolades of a boosted rating this year based on that alone. If Van Dijk was the most important player from Celtic's foundation last year, Commons was undoubtedly the supremely important presence in attack, and while he's now 30, his retirement from international football should be a boost for Celtic. if he can score even 20 goals this season, he will have more than justified his new improved rating. Last year, EA Sports were all-too conservative with the Englishman, giving him only 71 for finishing, when he should be into the 80s and generally skimming a few points off his rating unfairly. The old adage goes that class is permanent and form only temporary, but it's very obvious that Commons importance to Celtic's cause should see him pushed beyond the ceiling of the 70s. How do you think Celtic should shape up this year? Did we get any of the ratings wrong? Share your thoughts below in the comments thread.

Contributor
Contributor

WhatCulture's former COO, veteran writer and editor.