FIFA 16: 10 Overrated Players Who Need Downgrading

Who hasn't lived up to EA's pre-season predictions?

When fans compare their in-game superstars to real-life, it's easy to see spot the players who haven't lived up to EA's pre-season rating predictions. Though the Match Day features have been used effectively this time around, the base ratings for certain players in the game are still hard to fathom. It has now become routine for FIFA gamers everywhere to rip open the box of their new game, hurriedly shove the disc into their chosen console, then proceed to analyse every team's stats; sizing up the opposition, rather than diving straight into a game. There's obviously no major tournament this summer either, meaning that players will be based pre-dominantly on their club form, as opposed to a rating surge simply for scoring a goal on the world stage. EA are constantly finding ways to increase the realism throughout every aspect of the game, so with FIFA 16 on the horizon and enough game time to judge players across the season, it's time to look at which players need to be downgraded to keep the game consistent with the real world. Here are the 10 prime candidates, although there will no doubt be plenty more changes made on FIFA 16...

10. Shinji Kagawa - 81

Shinji Kagawa was a tremendous talent for Dortmund the first time around, and was a key figure in winning back-to-back Bundesliga titles, notching up 21 goals in 49 league games. But following a nightmare at Manchester United, he returned to Dortmund where his beloved side propped up the table after some serious relegation form. Kagawa has only found the net twice in 22 league appearances this time around after ending a 1,830 Bundesliga goal-drought, and though that's not his main duty in the side, he has only picked up 3 assists. Did the Japanese international peak too early?

9. Angel Di Maria - 86

Angel Di Maria might seem like an easy target at the minute, but he has to be included in this list after a tough year adjusting to the Premier League. The flying winger has rapid pace, and mazy dribbling skills, but his final product has been sorely lacking at times, despite racking up 3 goals and 9 assists for Manchester United this season. Those numbers aren't too bad, but do they merit an 86 rating? No. His standard Ultimate Team also comes with a 71 physical rating, higher than many players of his style, when the reality is, a light breeze would be enough to send Di Maria drifting into the stands at Old Trafford.

8. David Luiz - 82

When it comes to downgrading David Luiz, it's not necessarily his overall rating that's the problem, it's all of the extras that combine to make him arguably the best defender in the game, when he certainly isn't in the real world. His defensive stats are very decent, and when you combine that with the rest of his attributes, he becomes a monster, with only three below 65. He's quick for a defender, strong, and good at passing, long shots and freekicks. He doesn't come across as a seriously flawed player due to the lack of many mental stats, and following his inclusion in the World Team of the Year, he looks set to rise, when some of his stats should probably be heading in the opposite direction,

7. Sami Khedira - 84

Sami Khedira is like a forgotten man following a history with troublesome injuries that have seen him fall out of the Real Madrid first team. There's no shame in dropping out of such a top quality side, but has Khedira really done enough to justify being one of the top central midfielders in the game? He has been a solid team player before, but lacks the X-Factor required to be classed as part of the European elite. His 84 rating is on par with Andrea Pirlo, easily one of the classiest midfielders of his generation, with the knack of popping some show-stopping passes. Khedira needs to be downgraded by a point or two, and a transfer away from the Bernabeu pronto.

6. Rio Ferdinand - 79

Rio Ferdinand's move to QPR has achieved two things: 1. Added a few million more into his retirement fund. 2. Confirmed that he is no longer good enough for the Premier League. The 36-year-old should have left Manchester United transferred to his sofa, but he adamantly ploughed on with his career for one last big pay day. He's too slow, and looks like he just doesn't really care all that much about QPR's miserable campaign that will more than likely end in relegation. At 79, he's overrated, and if he continues to play next season, he can expect to be downgraded.

5. Mesut –zil - 86

Mesut Ozil is slowly growing into the Arsenal setup after a largely lukewarm start to life in London, but does he warrant a place among the game's elite? To be an 86 in the game, the player should be a superstar, and while Ozil is clearly still a very talented player, he's not a key cog in the Arsenal team, and has had very little impact on the world stage since he masterminded that famous victory over England in the 2010 World Cup. Ozil warrants an 83 or at a push an 84 level, but to put him level with the likes of Neymar and Marco Reus (both 86) is laughable.

4. Robert Lewandowski - 87

Part-time Dortmund bandwagon fans around the world flooded Twitter with fake outrage following Robert Lewandowski's controversial free transfer from Dortmund to Bayern Munich. The Polish striker was lethal for Jurgen Klopp's side, racking up 73 goals in 121 games, but while his 13 in 24 record for Bayern is reasonably impressive, it shouldn't be enough for Lewandowski to keep his ridiculous 87 rating on FIFA 16. His current rating puts him ahead of almost every other striker in the world including Sergio Aguero, Diego Costa and even Harry Kane. He's a very good player, but he should be closer to 84 or 85 rather than jostling around in the chasing pack looking up at Messi, Ronaldo and Ibrahimovic.

3. Robin Van Persie - 88

Similarly to Lewandowski, there was maybe a time when Robin Van Persie deserved such a high rating, but this season looked like the beginning of the end for the Dutch master. The 31-year-old made a brave switch from Arsenal to Manchester United, and it has proved to be a very good deal, but he isn't the same lethal force he once was. His goal haul this season stands at 13 for club and country, with 9 of those goals coming while his team has scored at least 3 in a game. He's a classy footballer, and a solid bit-part player, but he's nowhere near justifying an 88 rating.

2. Andres Iniesta - 89

This entry is painful to write. Andres Iniesta is one of the most underrated players of his generation, and alongside Xavi, provided the launchpad for Lionel Messi to fire his way to stardom. He's lifted an unbelievable 25 trophies throughout his career with and boasts another 32 individual honours to his name, but the Barcelona man has failed to record a single goal or assist for Barcelona in an entire year. It's a staggering loss of form for an largely unsung great who has looked a shadow of his former self since Spain's miserable World Cup campaign. It's tough to say, but Iniesta needs to be downgraded just a couple notches from his incredible 89 rating.

1. Radamel Falcao - 88

The tale of Falcao is one of the most disappointing Premier League stories in recent years, following his shock loan switch from Monaco to Manchester United. His deadline day move was greeted by a real sense of excitement across the country as the nation looked to set to get a glimpse of one of Europe's hottest attacking talents at the peak of his career. Unfortunately, the Columbian has failed to reproduce any of his deadly form that earned him a fearsome reputation at Porto and Atletico Madrid, and has only netted 4 goals in 23 games for the Red Devils. His performances have been abject, and Louis Van Gaal simply can't trust him to even come off the bench at times to impact a game. He was 88 level, but surely that won't last.

In this post: 
FIFA FIFA 16
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

What Culture contributor. NCTJ accredited Sports Journalist. Regret-filled Sunderland AFC season ticket holder. Optimism-filled NFL fan. Lover of all things Game Of Thrones, Breaking Bad, Walking Dead & more.