FIFA 18: 10 Changes EA Sports Must Make

Fifa 17 was good but there's still a lot that needs to be improved.

EA SPORTS FIFA 2017
EA Sports

Let’s not lie to ourselves, Fifa 17 is the best football game on the market right now. We’ve all got that one ‘purest’ friend who still plays Pro Evo because “ah man, fifa players run like they’re on rails”, but they’re lying to themselves. Fifa 17 was a huge leap forward for the franchise and the genre in general.

The physics are the best they have ever been and so are the graphics (remember 09 when Aguero looked about 30 stone but ran like a gazelle?). But that does not make it perfect.

So since Fifa 18 is a mere ten months away at best, we’re taking a look at what EA should definitely change and/or ditch all together.

Come with us on a journey to the promised land...

10. Free Kicks

FIFA 17 free kick
EA Sports

This is not going to be a crowd pleaser but if we’re honest with ourselves, the new free kick should show itself out.

It’s not pandering to the ill-skilled masses, but the effort that scoring free kicks takes isn’t worth the ONE goal you get when you manage to pull it off. The new penalty system is a vast improvement mainly because you can pick where you put the ball. I’m told there’s a similar feature on free kicks but it’s just so temperamental. There’s no mid-ground between picking the head off a fly at 40 yards and shanking it over the crossbar from just outside the box.

It’s time Fifa realised that they were never going to get a free kick system purer than that ball in the bottom left hand corner that let you control exactly where you hit it.


9. Crowds

Eden Hazard, FIFA 17
EA Sports

It’s a niggle but it’s a niggle that needs to get fixed. Every year I hear someone from EA say they’ve fixed how the crowds look and every year I imagine that same EA someone being rushed to the burns ward for a case of pants on fire syndrome.

The crowds still look so copy/pasted that you can see about ten people wearing the same clothes moving the same way in any given close up. I’m not saying that we suddenly want pitch invasions on legendary mode, but variety is the spice of life and I bet EA has more than ten people templates knocking around.

Oh and fix the chants. Never should I hear ‘oh when the saints…’ when playing Man United as Wolves.


8. Elements Of The Journey Brought Into Virtual Pro

The journey FIfa 17
EA Sports

For so many reasons The Journey is an inspired move. Tapping into the usually dead by Year 8 dream of being a pro footballer, to the point where, when Aguero/Costa/Giroud goes down in the preseason friendly one is inspired to give a solemn nod of the head and admit ‘my time is now’.

But that ability to craft your own single player journey has existed for many years in the Virtual Pro mode. So, now we know that it works, why not bring some of the features from the journey into VP?

I’m not saying replace it. The Journey has you play as a young black man from the inner city who works hard and ends up in the big leagues. That is an excellent narrative that shouldn’t have taken until 2016/17 to come to fruition.

What would be nice is a few of the flourishes that made The Journey so playable. The training sessions to fight your way into the team. The press coverage. The post match interviews. Little touches that bring the campaign to life.


7. Team Talks

Mourinho Fm2020
Mike Egerton/EMPICS Sport/Sports Interactive

Sometimes you just have a bad day and find yourself sisyphus to a third round league cup tie to Rotherham at home. The team isn’t moving the ball quickly enough, the wingers aren’t making runs and suddenly it’s half time.

Now, you’ve given this team talk a million times in your head so what about being able to give it to your team. The Journey proved that Fifa can do the alternate choice speech thing so why not take it to its natural conclusion? Do what Mourinho seems allergic to and actually tell his team how he wants them to play.

You can already set your players to make certain runs in the team selection menu but why not make it a hundred times more enjoyable? How rewarding would it be, at half time, to tell your CAM’s to make delayed runs into the box AND THEN ACTUALLY HAVE THEM WIN THE GAME BY DOING THAT IN THE SECOND HALF?


6. WSL

Women's Football FIFA 16
EA Sports

It’s 2016 and we’re still asking for this? I’m a football globalist but even I think it’s a bit weird we got the J-League before we got the Women’s Super League.

Surely it’s a no brainer if you’re EA. We want more people to play the game, maybe more would come if we embraced an entirely new type of football which women’s football is, let noone tell you different.

At this point it’s hard not to admit that, in England at least, the women’s national efforts far outstrip those of the me.Let’s get Fran Kirby on the cover and embrace a whole new type of football. Who know’s? The legions of Fifa players world wide might actually get hooked on women’s football and finally give it the recognition it deserves.


5. Commentary That Adapts To Your Game

Apologies for giving Alan and Martin both barrels on this one but the commentary needs a serious overhaul. Namely, it needs to react to your own game in career mode.

Example, you decide to challenge yourself and start a career with say, Aston Villa. A thankless task. But a few shrewd transfers later and you’ve brought tiki taka to the West Midlands. You quickly burn through the championship and find yourself back in the top flight. Does anyone comment on how quickly this new manager has brought Villa back up in a season? Nope. Say you finish top four or even win the Prem, will anyone ever mention it again? Double nope.

If Fifa 18 is to carry on the franchises’ good work it needs to start making the commentary fit your experience and not the other way around.


4. The Youth System

fifa 17 youth
EA Sports

Other than that number that moves up and down almost at random, is there any point to the youth system? Beyond existing as a means to keep the game going ten seasons into a campaign mode. But for the usual four-seasons-then-bored crowd, what threat can your board mount? Yeah you won the triple in your first season but you didn’t bring fresh talent Darren ‘potato face’ Moore into the first team, so we’re letting you go. Please.

You can invest millions, hire the best scouts around and send them to three corners of the globe for years at a time. But you can be sure that all they’re coming back with is a handful of youngsters that look like the cast of Police Academy IV and there won’t be a 60+ rated player among them.

I get that it takes time. But throw us a bone, Fifa. Give us a wunderkind from the favelas who’s a 75 at age 16. Or how about a reliable Milner figure who will never get above 78 but has a stupidly high stamina and strength.


3. Stadiums

Juv Stadium
EA Sports

A simple one which has been overlooked outside the top flight. Sometimes I think Fifa forgets that there are people out there who follow the EFL Championship.

Having every Prem stadium but only five Championship grounds is not cool. I know a good amount of Wolves fans who would pay through the nose to replace Ivy Lane with the Molineux. It’s not just English fans that have felt short changed by EA’s unwillingness to map out more stadiums.

Just think about all the famous international stadiums that aren’t featured. Come on Fifa, at this point you have more money than God. Just buy the rights, already.


2. Better Transfers

Fifa Transfers
EA Sports

There’s only three things certain in life; Death, Taxes and the knowledge that David Alaba WILL sign for Juventus in your first season of Fifa 17. The year before it was Dzeko to Arsenal. Safe to say, transfers have always been a bit weird in the world of Fifa.

Granted, when you start the campaign mode over so many times you are going to see patterns but let’s shake it up. How about a shock horror rivalry switch where Kane signs for Arsenal or Lukaku goes to Liverpool? It’s rare but it does happen. Come on Fifa, live a little.


1. A Transfer Market That Makes Sense

Hull City v Leicester City - Premier League - KCOM Stadium Jamie Vardy
Jon Buckle/EMPICS Sport

It’s a niggle that you only really find after playing the campaign mode through a few seasons but it’s one that really shakes up the desired immersion of the game. You’ll notice that after a while only big players go to big clubs. Small players stay at small clubs.

What’s more, say you managed to turn a youth team player into a semi functional member of the squad (good luck). Then say that, due to them being up front, they manage to bang in a few important goals a la Jamie Vardy. Does that mean that another club will swoop with a silly big campaign changing offer? Don’t bet on it.

Say you choose to start with a lesser Prem team and manage to do a Leicester. Will clubs be lining up to steal away your best players the next season? Double don’t bet on it which, in that situation, kind of ruins the challenge. Sure you could just say no to any offers but it’d be nice to be asked right?


In this post: 
FIFA 18
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

80% David Brent / 20% Def Jam. Does whatever a spider can.