FIFA 19: 10 Criminally Underrated Players
FIFA 19 is here and the latest instalment proves EA still can't get some players right!
FIFA 19 is here and, as always, we've had more than enough time to appreciate all of the good and the bad the game has to offer.
From the divisive new shooting mechanics to the fun new Kick-Off modes, poorly ageing Career Mode to the mediocre finale of The Journey; FIFA 19 has proven to be a middling entry in the series. Beyond the gameplay and features, one area we can always expect to be quite maddening, is player ratings!
All fans want their teams players to be higher rated than they actually are. In many instances though, that in fact should be the case. FIFA 19 is no different than its predecessors, in that it favours big name players like Ronaldo, Neymar, Messi, and Pogba, over equally quality players from smaller clubs.
The ten players on this list represent Electronic Arts Canada's misguided judgements in regards to top-class players from all over the world. Some of these players would have to bribe someone to get the rating they deserve, or at least start styling their hair like they're an extra in Fury Road.
10. Andrew Robertson - 81
1342399The Liverpool left-back is arguably first or second in the Premier League in his position, yet he holds a mere 81 in FIFA 19. The other best left back in the league, Man City's Benjamin Mendy, also holds an 81, so perhaps EA just don't care for left-backs.
Alberto Moreno had failed to impress over the course of three seasons at Anfield, so much so that Jurgen Klopp turned to midfielder James Milner to plug the hole in the defence. Then Robertson joined Liverpool from Hull City in 2017 and almost immediately established himself as the left-back solution the Reds had been searching for.
Since then, Robertson has created seven assists and one goal for Liverpool, and endeared himself to the fans with his tireless work rate, humble attitude, and defensive abilities. He's undeniably one of the Premier League's best left-back's and an 81 in FIFA 19 is no representative of that.
9. Ederson - 86
For several years now, David De Gea has been the Premier League's best goalkeeper, with his only real competition being Thibaut Courtois and Hugo Lloris. That changed last season when Manchester City purchased Brazilian stopper, Ederson. According to EA Sports however, he isn't even close to their level.
Beyond his inhuman goal kicks, Ederson made 58 saves, including two penalties, and kept 16 clean sheets for Manchester City in the 2017/18 season. He was a large part of City's unprecedented, record-breaking season, and established himself as the only true competitor to De Gea.
Ederson is in the top two or three in the world right now, yet his 86 rating puts him well below De Gea, Neuer, Courtois, and even Navas. Even his potential of 89 puts him below De Gea's starting rating, which is just ludicrous.
8. Harry Kane - 89
When a player is ranked 89, complaining is a little like splitting hairs. However, what on Earth does Kane have to do to score a 90 rating? If he played for Barcelona, Real Madrid, or Juventus, he'd probably be rated 95.
Since his debut season with Tottenham Hotspur, Kane hasn't failed to score at least 20 goals. The last two seasons he's managed 29 and 30 goals in the league alone, then went to the World Cup in Russia and won the Golden Boot!
Kane's stats are almost identical to Robert Lewandowksi, who is rated 90. Kane's stats are substantially better than any season Neymar has ever had, but the Brazilian is preposterously rated 92. It's undeniable that Harry Kane has been shafted for FIFA 19, but maybe that will change if he leaves Spurs.
7. Benjamin Pavard - 80
Benjamin Pavard was one of France's best performers at the World Cup in Russia, and yet he's rated a flat 80 in FIFA 19.
Of course, it's easy to get over-hyped on a player following a World Cup, especially a player who scored one of the best goals in the entire tournament. However, there is no hyperbole when it comes to Benjamin Pavard.
The 22 year old is a first-team player for Stuttgart in Bundesliga, and cemented himself as one of the most promising right-backs in the world. He might not be the finished article yet, but he will continue to grow and prove himself - which is where his apt FIFA potential of 86 comes in. However rating him 81 in the interim is a smidge low, as he will continue to prove in the German League.
6. Domagoj Vida - 80
Vida was a large reason why Croatia made it to the World Cup final and, while he might not be a top ten defender in the world, he's certainly better than his 80 rating would have you believe.
Vida had been a stalwart of Dynamo Kiev's defence since 2014, before he joined Besiktas following his World Cup performances. Prior to Kiev, Vida had stints at Dinamo Zagreb and Bayern Leverkusen, where he failed to impress. The Croatian then found his feet in the Ukranian League with Kiev and made 55 appearances and scored nine goals.
The centre back pairing of Vida and Dejan Lovren were as formidable as they were compelling at the World Cup in Russia, and he has proven himself at the club level in various European teams. The 29 year old doesn't have much room for improvement at his point, but a rating of 82 would seem far more fitting.
5. Kylian Mbappe - 87
Kylian Mbappe might just be the brightest young star the football world has ever laid eyes on. Which has us puzzled as to why he's rated 5 points lower than his PSG counterpart, Neymar?!
Mbappe became a household name when he was purchased by Paris Saint Germaine for a earth-shattering fee of around £154,000,000 (including add-ons). It seemed a truly preposterous fee to pay for an 18 year old. In fact, PSG paid the fee largely based off of one successful season, in which Mbappe scored 15 goals in 29 appearances for Monaco.
Since then, Mbappe has proved for both club and country that he was worth every penny and then some. So far this season, he has six appearance in all competitions and six goals. While Neymar has games where everyone questions where all his hype comes from, Mbappe has games where we stare in bewilderment at how good he could become.
He's only 19 but he surely ranks amongst the world's top players already, so we can only wonder in awe and fear at where his glass ceiling is. Unless of course, you work for EA, in which case you think he's just alright.
4. Justin Kluivert - 75
Justin Kluivert is 19 years old. He scored 10 goals and made 5 assists for Ajax last season... from the right wing. Since then, he earned himself a move to Italian giants Roma and scored his first goal in the Champion's League. He's an incredible young talent but he's a mere 75 in FIFA 19.
As the son of legendary footballer, Patrick Kluivert, expectations were always high for the Dutch youngster. He's shown glimpses, but last season he began to really show what he was capable of. With his Champion's League goal for Roma, Kluivert became the club's youngest player to ever score in the competition. And, while he's a long-term replacement for Mohammed Salah, Kluivert has all the potential in the world to become a superstar!
This makes his FIFA 19 rating of 75 quite baffling. He's well below his peers Ousmane Dembélé, Christian Pulisic, and Adnan Januzaj. Kluivert has proven that he is a pacey winger who can score goals and create plenty of chances, everything one could ask for in a right midfielder, and he's not even 20! His potential is extremely high but he's already good enough to warrant a higeher rating that 75.
3. Virgil Van Dijk - 85
What do you get if you combine a footballer and a brick wall? Virgil Van Dijk.
The Dutchman has single-handedly transformed Liverpool's defence from a nervous wreck, into one of the Premier League's most formidable. You can legit see a massive difference in Liverpool's defense pre-and-post Van Dijk. In the few months prior to Van Dijk arriving at Anfield, the Reds were the second worst team in the league in terms of defensive errors. In the 10 months since, they have conceded far less goals on average, and gone undefeated at home in the league!
Van Dijk is still the world's most expensive defender but no-one even talks about that anymore. He is amongst the very best defenders in world football, and yet his rating is only 85! That puts him a long way behind FIFA's highest rated centre-back, Sergio Ramos at 91. We'd go as far as to call that one a crime.
2. Luke Shaw - 78
Now, let's get one thing clear, Shaw has spent more time on the sidelines at Man Utd than he has on the pitch. And, up until this current season, his FIFA 19 rating would seem perfectly fitting.
However his form in the 2018/19 season shows that 23 year old has plenty left to give, which makes his 78 rating look misjudged on the part of EA. Shaw is one of the very few players under the current Jose Mourinho regime at Manchester United that seems to be thriving. He made 11 appearances for United in the previous two seasons, but he's already made six this year, as well as scored and made an assist.
Shaw moved to United from Southampton in 2014, with high expectations. For four years it seemed he would never live up to the hype, with the player even coming under intense criticism for being "fat". It seemed he would never turn things around but here we are. Shaw is quickly regaining his esteem and meeting the expectations fans and pundits had for him in 2014. With that in mind, a 78 rating could prove foolish.
1. Mohammed Salah - 88
1331704Mohammed Salah is currently in a poor run of form, having played nine games for Liverpool in all competitions and only managed three goals and one assist. While his shooting boots of last season may be missing as of writing, Salah is still a tremendously dangerous player who constantly finds himself in goal-scoring opportunities. It's only a matter of time before he starts putting them away with regularity and his FIFA 19 rating of 88 will seem ridiculous.
The Liverpool winger was the top scorer in all of Europe last season and set the Premier League alight. He scored 43 goals, which puts him ahead of Cristiano Ronaldo, Lionel Messi, Neymar, Sergio Aguero, Lewandowski, Harry Kane, and Edinson Cavani. Yet he's below all of them in ratings; he's not even in the top 20 players in the game!
His performances last season more than earned a 90 rating, which would still put him below several of the names listed, but at least it would be more in line with his stats and abilities.