FIFA 19: 10 Players Who Deserve A Rating Downgrade
Attention EA: Stop pretending Mesut Özil is world class in 2018.

A few things are certain when FIFA 19 lands later this month.
Ultimate Team will take precedence over Career Mode, some of EA's hyped-up features will prove themselves to be background noise and cover man Cristiano Ronaldo will be one of the highest-rated players in the game. Is this fair? Well, yes. CR7 is legitimately a world great, and his rating should reflect that.
Then, there's Neymar, another man who has been used as a promotional tool in the lead up to release. PSG's 'whizz kid' no longer fits that nickname. He's 26 years old. The Brazilian is also the most expensive player in the business, and that's probably why he'll be there and thereabouts as one of FIFA 19's best.
Those guys deserve their lofty status. Others don't, and their ratings must be lowered.
EA's ratings system can be a bit unpredictable at times. Whilst top-tier players like Ronaldo, Neymar and Lionel Messi warrant scores in the mid-90s, others skirt dangerously close to them despite being in the twilight of their careers or having poor seasons. It's time to put that right before the top three or four drift ominously closer to the middle of the pack rather than standing out on their own...
10. Arjen Robben

Last Year's Rating: 88
Don't get the wrong end of the stick here. Dutch maestro Arjen Robben still has good enough pace to throw shade on any suggestions the 34-year old Bayern man is finished. He's also an effective weapon the Munich side continue to use in season 2018-19.
That's testament to how well he's looked after his body.
Father Time is catching up though. Robben, who ranked #24 in EA's own Top 100 list for FIFA 18, no longer deserves to be rated higher than players like Man City's David Silva (43) or Spurs' Danish main man Christian Eriksen (40). His 88 overall rating is just a little high, so it should be reduced a point or two come FIFA 19.
EA don't need to punish Robben too hard. It's not his fault age is beginning to catch up with him, and a score of 85 or 86 would seem fair.
9. Zlatan Ibrahimović

Last Year's Rating: 88
The same goes for current LA Galaxy striker (and all-round polarising figure) Zlatan Ibrahimović.
Ibra has 16 goals in 21 appearances since joining the MLS side in March. Those who don't watch the American league shouldn't be tricked into thinking those stats mean nothing; MLS is a much better division than most give it credit for, and it's never a given that Europe's best will prosper there towards the end of their careers.
Aged 36, the big Swede is still banging them in, so why should his FIFA 19 rating drop? Two words: Edinson Cavani. The PSG forward ranked a full seven places lower than Ibrahimović in last year's game, and that's something EA need to change. After all, Cavani remains at the peak of his powers.
Ibrahimović, talented though he is, could be doing with having a point or two knocked off his score. If EA are smart, they'll gift that to the Uruguayan hitman and restore some realism.
8. Yaya Touré

Last Year's Rating: 83
Watch out, Olympiakos. Yaya Touré's 36th birthday will go down on 13 May 2019, and the Greek giants would do well to ensure he has a birthday cake waiting on him. They don't want a repeat of the childish antics of Yaya and his agent back in 2014.
In all seriousness, and speaking strictly about matters on the park, Touré isn't quite the strolling midfield powerhouse of old, and the 83 rating handed to him in FIFA 18 is a bit much. Considering his age, where he's plying his trade, and the fact Man City boss Pep Guardiola decided against keeping Yaya, his rating needs to be closer to 80.
There's even an argument to be made for dropping it further. Touré doesn't have the deceptive pace he once had, and he's unlikely to roam as far forward in the final few years of his career as he used to. Maybe 79 would be the best rating for him in 19.
7. Gary Cahill

Last Year's Rating: 84
In August, Gary Cahill informed England gaffer Gareth Southgate that he no longer wanted to be considered a full-time member of the national set up. Barring an injury crisis of epic proportions, English fans won't be seeing Gaz pull on the Three Lions. His decision to retire slightly masks the reality: he had been replaced anyway.
Harry Maguire and John Stones were the preferred back two during the summer's World Cup in Russia, and that speaks volumes about where Cahill is at right now. New Chelsea manager Maurizio Sarri has yet to include the club captain in any of his starting teams so far this season.
In FIFA 18, Cahill's score was 84. That's high, and it made him one of the most reliable centre backs in the game. Due to his ongoing struggles to break into Sarri's plans and his international semi-retirement, the big defender no longer deserves that towering rating when FIFA 19 hits store shelves.
6. Leighton Baines

Last Year's Rating: 82
In fairness to Cahill, he merits an 84 way more than Everton stalwart Leighton Baines deserves his 82. This is a prime example of EA's annoying need to make Premier League players look like the best around. That's fine for a handful of deserving stars, but not Leighton bloody Baines.
No offence intended to the man here, mind, just an observation.
Baines is not an 82-rated player in 2018. The 33-year old defender should be closer to a 76 or 77 at this stage in his career. Instead, he was knocking on the doors of the Top 100 in FIFA 18, and that's not very realistic. Baines, though solid, isn't one of the world's best wing backs.
One suggestion would be dropping some of his pace stats but keeping in the physicals. That way, Baines would become less of a box-to-box superstar (like he was last year) and more of an ageing pro who represents a decent buy for mid-table sides.
5. Wayne Rooney

Last Year's Rating: 81
As his career winds down, the position Wayne Rooney takes on the pitch continues to drop deeper. At new club DC United in MLS, he's sitting in the old Andrea Pirlo midfield role, and his job is to both spring attacks with defence-destroying passes and marshall the defensive back line just behind him.
That's a role Rooney is well-suited to. The ex-Man Utd and Everton man has always been a bit of an on-the-field general, and that's true even when losing some speed or agility. Unfortunately for 'Fat Boy' (José Mourinho's words, not ours), EA were being a little too generous when they handed him an 81 rating in FIFA 18.
Come FIFA 19, that should change.
Granted, it won't be by much. Rooney is still deserving of an 80, for example, but his journey from the heights of Premier League football to North America must be taken into consideration.
4. David Luiz

Last Year's Rating: 86
Eighty six. Eek!
Everyone's favourite Sideshow Bob-lookalike David Luiz ranked 60th overall in EA's Top 100 last year. That's respectable, and he ranked above everyone from Bayern Munich's David Alaba (67) and Barcelona's Jordi Alba (74) to Spurs CB Jan Vertonghen (80) and club mate César Azpilicueta (76).
To put that into ratings terms, Luiz, at 86, was considered one point better than Alba, Vertonghen and Azpilicueta. Alaba had the same overall score, yes, and yet his defending and physical stats were slightly slower than the Chelsea man's. Hmm, we're not sure about that.
Luiz has attributes, nobody can deny that. 86 is high however, and EA need to stop getting carried away just because he's in the Prem playing for a top team. Dropping his score by two full points so guys such as Alaba and Vertonghen (in particular) are better would be smart.
3. Gonzalo Higuaín

Last Year's Rating: 90
New AC Milan striker Gonzalo Higuaín had a dismal time of it in Russia during the 2018 World Cup.
His three group stage appearances yielded no goals, and he lost his starting place for the Round Of 16 loss to France after that. This followed just one goal in nine qualifying showings. Higuaín, like many of his Argentine teammates, couldn't replicate searing club form at international level.
He's not off to the best of starts at the San Siro following his move from Juventus in the summer either. Gonzalo hasn't scored in Milan's first two Serie A matches, and that 90 rating he received in FIFA 18 is starting to look a bit excessive.
Now in his 30s, Higuaín isn't the hot young prospect he was when trading Real Madrid for Napoli in 2013. Proven goalscorer in Italy or not, 90 is over-the-top from EA, and Higuaín's rating should realistically fall this year to between 85-88.
2. Marco Reus

Last Year's Rating: 86
Borussia Dortmund's Marco Reus must be considered one of the strangest cover star choices from EA over the past decade. His name doesn't quite fit with upper-echelon stars like Cristiano Ronaldo or Lionel Messi, and he hasn't exactly shone since gracing FIFA 17's box two years ago.
It's important to point out that ligament damage has hindered him. Even so, the German has failed to haul Dortmund to any level of consistency since his return, and after netting against Leipzig the previous week, he was rather woeful in BVB's drab 0-0 draw with Hannover last weekend.
86 isn't the correct score for Marco at the moment. His real-life form can't live up to how good he is in FIFA, and that's something the statisticians have to address. Giving Reus the same overall as Real Madrid's Isco or Harry Kane, both of whom had 86 themselves last time, feels off.
1. Mesut Özil

Last Year's Rating: 88
Alas, we come to one of the most frustrating players in the entire Premier League.
Despite being armed with bags of talent, Arsenal's Mesut Özil p*sses it all away by turning in enigmatic performances that make it seem like he's hiding when he should be one of Unai Emery's main men. This inconsistent style has plagued the German since joining the Gunners five years ago.
His 88 rating in FIFA is almost embarrassing to report. Özil is talented, though flawed, borderline anonymous when it counts in bigger games for Arsenal, and he's hardly on par with match winners such as Juve's Paulo Dybala or Atlético Madrid's brilliant Frenchman Antoine Griezmann.
By comparison to those players, Özil is overrated in FIFA. Early reports say his overall rating has slid in the new game. If that turns out to be the case on-disc when the game is released, and in Ultimate Team when EA tweak with weekly updates, then it'll be fully deserved.
-
What other players do you feel deserve a downgrade in FIFA 19? Let us know your thoughts down in the comments section below!