FIFA 19: 11 Players Who Will Be Overrated

These 11 players will undeservedly boss the game.

Suarez Fifa 19
EA Sports

FIFA 19 is almost upon us and it's high-time we get into the weeds of predictions. Player ratings is one of the most exciting aspects of each years game, and helps us understand who EA deem as the world's finest players, and those they aren't so high on.

Unless you are a fan of Real Madrid, Barcelona, or Paris Saint-Germain, you'll be familiar with ratings disappointment. Each year you'll be disappointed that your favourite player on your team isn't rated anywhere near what you think he should be.

The pendulum also swings the other way though; some of the highest-rated players in the game are only there due to reputation. You see this with the likes of Kylian Mbappé, whose rating rose 12 points from FIFA 17 to 18 - largely due to his major money transfer to PSG.

So, it's fair to say that Electronic Arts is prone to favouring some high-profile players over others. The game is filled with bizarre ratings but we've narrowed it down to the inevitable all-star overrated 11! Get your pitchforks ready!

11. Mesut Özil

Arsenal's Mesut Ozil
Nigel French/EMPICS Sport

Mesut Özil has been a staple of world football since bursting onto the scene at the 2010 World Cup. In almost cringe-worthy fashion, Real Madrid bought him following those breakout performances at the age of 21.

Some may forget but Özil's first two seasons at Madrid were downright incredible; he bagged 25 assists his first season and was on the Ballon d'Or shortlist the next. It was rather predictable, then, that Madrid decided to replace him with Luka Modrić - in hindsight, this was a good choice but at the time reeked of Madrid unnecessarily splurging.

The German playmaker has been a focal point of Arsenal's attack for five years now... but that's not exactly a compliment. In FIFA 18 Özil was rated 88, then Arsenal had the clubs worst ever Premier League season. Özil was a big part of an unmotivated and unimpressive Arsenal team that finally led to Arsene Wenger's resignation.

As if that weren't enough, Özil also started for the Germany team that crashed out of the 2018 World Cup in spectacular fashion. Özil is a far cry from the player he was in 2010, and should be nowhere near a 90 rating.


10. Jesse Lingard

Jesse Lingard Man Utd
Barrington Coombs/EMPICS Sport

Jesse Lingard is more popular than he is talented. That's not to say he isn't a good football player, he is, but as an attacking player who has only managed eight goals and five assists in 33 appearances for Manchester United, Lingard is definitely more flash than substance.

Credit where it is due, Lingard rose up through the ranks in United to finally force himself into Jose Mourinho's first team. He's an exciting, technical player who can create goals, score some crackers, and made fans love him with his Fortnite-inspired dances. Lingard's future is obviously very bright but as of now, he's more reminiscent of Raheem Sterling than Dele Alli.

Lingard has good dribbling and speed but his end product leaves a lot to be desired and he makes dumb decisions. His output for United has never been good enough to warrant his high rating, and his World Cup was completely lacklustre to boot.

Lingard has heaps of potential but he has yet to hit the mark of a mid 80 rated player.


9. Álvaro Morata

Álvaro Morata
By Кирилл Венедиктов [CC BY-SA 3.0GFDL, CC BY-SA 3.0 (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0) or GFDL (http://www.gnu.org/copyleft/fdl.html)], via Wikimedia Commons

To say Álvaro Morata had a mediocre first season at Chelsea is an understatement. The Spaniard scored 15 goals in 42 appearances, which doesn't quite justify his huge price tag.

Purchased as a replacement for Diego Costa, Morata failed to live up to that standard. Chelsea has always thrived with a physical, scrappy striker at the forefront of the attack. These are traits Morata does not possess and he has struggled at Chelsea as a result.

However, to say these are new issues for Morata would be untrue. The Spaniard started his career at Real Madrid, where he made 37 appearances and scored only ten goals. Following his disappointing return over four seasons, he was shipped to Juventus where he made 63 appearances, scoring only 15.

Surprisingly, Madrid opted to invoke the buy-back clause and bring Morata back to the Bernabéu. That only last one season but his return was greatly increased; as he managed 15 goals in 26 appearances. Those stats were apparently enough for Chelsea to fork out so much. His inaugural season at Stamford Bridge was so underwhelming he wasn't picked for Spain's World Cup squad.

Nothing about Morata justifies his FIFA 18 rating of 84, let alone anything higher.


8. James Rodríguez

Colombia James Rodriguez WC Kit
Adidas Football

James Rodríguez has had an interesting career. The Colombian made a name for himself at the 2014 World Cup and, once again, Real Madrid paid top-dollar for a young star based on a handful of performances.

Granted, Rodríguez had just moved from Porto, where he had an impressive return of 25 goals from 65 appearances for a midfielder, to Monaco. His run at Monaco, however, left a lot to be desired but Madrid wanted the good-looking 23-year-old who scored a worldie at the World Cup. After a few seasons of struggling to get play-time at Madrid, he requested a loan under Zinedine Zidane, and was shipped to Bayern Munich.

Rodríguez had a middling season on loan at Bayern Munich and it seems he will be heading back to Madrid to compete with the likes of Isco, Asensio and Casemiro for a spot, and he pales in comparison to them.

Undoubtedly Colombia's most important player at the 2018 World Cup, Rodríguez was forced to miss out on the final few games due to injury, bringing to an end his rather miserable year. James' star is fading and his FIFA rating should reflect that.


7. Ousmane Dembélé

VfL Wolfsburg v Borussia Dortmund - Bundesliga Osamane Dembélé
2016 Getty Images

For years, Real Madrid were accused of shelling out millions to buy La Liga titles, meanwhile, Barcelona did it by growing talented players within the system. In recent years that moniker has changed for Barcelona, as the Catalan club have started throwing money in every direction, sometimes to little effect.

Barcelona's spending reached new heights in 2017 following the sale of Neymar to Paris Saint Germaine. Suddenly flush with cash and panicking to replace the Brazilian, Barcelona went out and purchased eight players in the summer transfer window. The highlight of those signings was 20-year old Ousmane Dembélé from Borussia Dortmund

Dembélé cost Barcelona a whopping amount, and since then has made 23 appearances, playing over 1000 minutes, scoring 4 goals and making 6 assists. Hardly the kind of return that the price tag warrants.

You can't blame Dembélé however, as he was put under incredible pressure and then was put on the bench when Barcelona got their true target: Phillippe Coutinho. The youngster still has immense potential but a disappointing season, coupled with him barely featuring for France at the World Cup, and it's clear his market value and rating has surely suffered.


6. Thomas Müller

Thomas Muller Bayern Munich
Martin Rickett/PA Archive/Press Association Images

For lack of a better comparison, Thomas Müller is evocative of Nicklas Bendtner. Of course, Müller is a significantly better player than Bendtner but similarly to the Dane, Müller feels like he has tricked everyone into thinking he's world class.

Having spent his entire career at Bayern Munich, Müller has a decent record of 104 goals in 286 games. For comparison sake, German legend Miroslav Klose played 446 games in his career and scored 175 goals - meaning Müller's record is pretty damn good. That said, the best return he has ever had in a Bundesliga season is 20 goals, and that's a lot better than his norm.

In the last two seasons for Munich, Müller has scored 13 goals in 58 games. Those are some awful stats that equal Fernando Torres' output for Atlético Madrid - a player we all recognise as well past his prime. Müller is only 28 years old but his numbers are diminishing as though he'd cracked 30. He only scored 8 goals last season and was last seen boarding a plane to Russia. His rating should be low 80's at best.


5. Luis Suárez

Barcelona's Luis Suarez
Petros Karadjias/AP

Luis Suárez is a living legend. Rarely can I recall a footballer with the amount of headlines surrounding them as Suárez. Granted, those headlines were not always positive, but Suárez's football career has been a fascinating whirlwind. Whether it was his first biting incident - yes first - 2014 World Cup handball, astounding run with Liverpool in the Premier League, second biting incident, or his transfer to Barcelona, Suárez is as interesting as it gets.

Suárez played 110 games for both Ajax and Liverpool, scoring 81 and 69 goals respectively. That's an unreal turnaround. Since moving to Barcelona, the Uruguayan has played 130 games and scored 110 goals. Those stats are truly other-worldly. Since 2015/2016 though, his goal return has been slowly decreasing and the 2018 World Cup showed that his legs aren't quite what they used to be.

Luis Suárez still has the goal-scoring instinct and he's probably going to have another 20+ goal season for Barcelona this year, but it's clear he's slowing down. It's sad but inevitable. He was overshadowed by Cavani at the World Cup and failed to really impact matches. He's still aces but Suárez should be rated three or four points below his FIFA 18 rating of 92.


4. Raheem Sterling

Raheem Sterling
PETER POWELL/epa/Corbis

Raheem Sterling just had his best ever season with Manchester City, so how could his rating possibly be too high? Well, because he still isn't all that great a player.

Sterling has all the potential in the world... but that has been the case for five years now. Since being thrust into the spotlight at Liverpool during the 2013/14 season, Sterling caught the eye of everyone with his incredible speed potential to be the next big English star. Since then, Sterling moved to Manchester City seeking trophies and more dollar dollar bills, has been hounded by the media, and improved little by little.

Sterling is certainly a better player now than he was at Liverpool, however, he's not on the level of other Premier League wingers like Wilfried Zaha, Eden Hazard, Sadio Mane, or his teammate Leroy Sane. He's added some goals to his game but he's still greedy and still makes terrible decisions.

His run with England at the World Cup was admirable but he cost his team as many potential goals as he created. He's still got room to grow but Raheem Sterling should stay around his 85 rating from FIFA 18, definitely no higher.


3. Paul Pogba

1335580

The Manchester United star just played a huge role in helping France to win the 2018 World Cup but he's still certain to be overrated in FIFA 19. Chances are, Pogba will increase his previous 88 rating to a 90, perhaps even 91, but his real rating should be closet to 85.

Pogba is reminiscent of Mario Balotelli; he's a loud, abrasive personality and, on his day, can be one of the best players in the world, however, those days are few and far between. Pogba doesn't always show-up, he can be completely ineffective in many games as we saw this season with Manchester United. He's a prime example of the problem with modern footballers: more concerned with money, dancing and Instagram, than they are with being the best player possible.

Pogba is a good player, sometimes phenomenal, but he pales in comparison to his centre midfield peers Kevin De Bruyne, Luka Modrić, N'Golo Kanté, and Christian Eriksen. Pogba has all the attributes to be as good as those chaps but doesn't showcase it on a consistent basis.


2. Manuel Neuer

Germany's keeper Manuel Neuer looks against the sun during a training session in Essen, Germany, Monday, Oct. 13, 2014. Germany will play a Euro 2016 group D qualifying soccer match against Ireland on Tuesday in Gelsenkirchen. (AP Photo/Martin Meissner)
Martin Meissner/AP

Manuel Neuer has been hailed as the best goalkeeper in the world for five years, has started making mistakes for Bayern Munich and the German national team, diminishing his status.

To be fair to Neuer, he was injured for the majority of the 2017/2018 season, so we can rule that one out as a non-factor. However he started every game for Germany at the 2018 World Cup and was far from impressive in their three games and two losses. He's also prone to making the odd Loris Karius-style mistake and is 32 years old - not old for a goalie but certainly peaked.

All of this is to say that Neuer's star is quickly fading while the likes of David De Gea, Alisson Becker, Ederson, and Hugo Lloris are clawing at the number one spot. Neuer is no longer the world's best goalkeeper and his FIFA 19 rating should reflect that.


1. Lionel Messi

Messi Vs Nigeria1
By Кирилл Венедиктов (https://www.soccer.ru/galery/1055457/photo/733486) [CC BY-SA 3.0GFDL, CC BY-SA 3.0 (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0), GFDL (http://www.gnu.org/copyleft/fdl.html) or CC BY-SA 3.0 (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by

Yep, it's finally happening, Lionel Messi's star is fading.

Messi had a great campaign with Barcelona; playing 36 games and scoring 34 goals. That's an incredible record, no doubt about it, and only three goals less than the year before. However the Argentinian legend is 31 years old and, as we saw with Cristiano Ronaldo's transfer to Juventus, all good things must come to an end.

Messi has always performed mind-meltingly good for Barcelona but conversely always disappointed for Argentina. None more recent than Messi's 2018 World Cup run, which was forgettable at best.

Messi has never proven himself in another league and his international disappointments lead to theories that he wouldn't be successful at another club. Factor in more impressive current players like Mohammed Salah and Kylian Mbappe, and Messi's status as the world's greatest player is surely dimming.

For as long as I can recall, Messi has been rated over 90 in FIFA. In 2019's instalment, his rating should still be around 89/90 but definitely no higher.


In this post: 
FIFA 19
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Curtis is from Ireland and lives in Canada now.