Final Fantasy 7 Remake: 8 Things NOBODY Wants To Admit

Whisper it.

Final Fantasy 7 remake
Square Enix

By now, many of us have finished the first five hours of Final Fantasy VII, in its 2020 guise as a AAA action-RPG/rhythm action dance-a-thon.

And, contrary to perfectly understandable fears given Final Fantasy's track record over the past two decades or so of being complete arse, it's actually good! Very good in fact.

You could even call it the best Final Fantasy since Final Fantasy X (which admittedly, is like calling herpes the best VD since syphilis. And no, that's not a Final Fantasy character, though she could be.)

But is it the glittering masterpiece so many games critics and fans have suggested? Or have they all been temporarily benighted by the relief of a six-year process to reimagine a universally beloved classic not resulting in something as catastrophic as that massage sequence in Final Fantasy X-2?

Well, they have and they haven't.

At it's best, Final Fantasy VII Remake is "a triumph" (according to our own Scott Tailford), but unfortunately, a wonderful 10 hour game is hidden within a much less fun 30 hour one.

Bathing in nostalgia has caused a Mako like affliction called 'denial', and there are some hard truths to be had.

--

Note: Full spoilers within.

8. It Looks Amazing... But Only Sometimes

FFVII Remake Midgar overhead
Square-Enix

At its very best, Final Fantasy VII Remake's visuals shine as brightly as a thousand midday suns upon exiting a movie theatre. At their worst, it's as though you're viewing them through a window smudged by a kid's grubby hands.

The aesthetic inconsistency is another consequence of a patched-together project, with Square-Enix seemingly devoting oodles of attention and resources to eye-catching set-pieces, whilst auto-filling the bits in between.

The low-res texture issues are well noted, and they are particularly prominent in those periods of laborious downtime between the game's marquee moments. Though it's an exaggeration to say they look like something from a PS2 game, the blurry background details are definitely not something you'd expect from a multi-million dollar AAA title at the end of the PS4's lifespan.

How much the graphical inconsistencies detract from the experience is situational. Badly lip-synched NPCs tripping over each other in squint-o-vision almost seems apt during the lazily implemented side-quest scenarios. Having a standout vista of Midgar ruined by a flat cardboard cutout of the city below does not.

It's sort of like when, at school, you'd draw a fantastic picture only for the teacher to tell you to 'fill the page', resulting in a rushed, scribbled mess everywhere else. This is a theme that runs throughout Final Fantasy VII Remake.


7. A Lot Of It Is... Really Boring

FFVII Remake Drum
Square-Enix

Padding is all well and good when it is wrapped around a delicate ornament shipped several thousand miles from the opposite side of the world, on the presumption that you're not expected to display said padding on your mantelpiece once you've opened the box. This metaphor largely describes the FFVII Remake experience - an excellent, occasionally outstanding game - swaddled in so much colourless material.

The argument is that, between the main story beats imported from the original, Square-Enix needed to flesh the game out. Which is fine, except it doesn't hold up unless we also accept they needed to flesh it out with some exceptionally dull, repetitive diversions.

Not all the new material falls foul of this: the trip to the Shinra depot and the expansion of Wall Market are welcome additions, which enhance, not hinder the story. Splodging through the sewers a second time - and fighting the same boss! - or playing the world's worst third-person shooter in Shinra's underground research facility do not.

And as for Hojo's Drum, why, I simply wanted to die during that floor. What a way to crush the pace of one of FFVII's finest segments.

Then there's the inane side-quests - we'll cover those in detail - and the long, forced walking sections (even if they are designed to mask background loading). Why do we have to hold down triangle to activate a button? Is it because other games have done it, and Square-Enix didn't understand it's a trick to disambiguate player mistakes? Or is it just another way to minutely spool out the process?


6. The Dialogue Is Cringeworthy

FFVII Remake Flower
Square-Enix

"But it's just a JRPG, what do you expect?" or "Well, the dialogue in the original was bad!" are not good excuses for writing that can be fairly described as utter bobbins.

In 2020, after Firewatch, Witcher 3, God of War, Her Story and countless other games with maturely present characters all having a degree of humanity, we've come to expect a lot more than FFVIIR's cliché-riddled, overblown anime nonsense.

Again, it's not a uniform issue.

Some of the interactions between Barrett and Cloud on missions, for example, whilst a symptom of a modern sensibility called "nobody ever shuts the f*ck up", feel genuine in a way FFXV's Backstreet Boys did. The entire scene with Elmyra describing her adoption of Aerith - largely lifted verbatim from the original - is legitimately emotive. The writing has its moments.

But mostly, it's cringey lines like something out of your old LiveJournal fanfic, interspersed by anime groans. And nothing is ever, ever left unsaid. When Aerith hands Cloud a flower, taken aback, he exclaims, "a flower?!" On the PS1, this line made sense, with visuals mostly abstractions of the events unfolding. When we can see said flower in super high-definition (albeit blurry textured) form? It makes you make one of those daft noises they all do.


5. Combat Has MAJOR Flaws

FFVII Remake Combat
Square-Enix

When it works, FF7R's action/turn-based hybrid is a sparkling cornucopia of colourful chaos, allowing for some seriously breathtaking set-pieces.

But it so frequently falls down the metaphorical stairs.

Sometimes the camera goes absolutely haywire, particularly when combat becomes cluttered. Swap characters and it channels Cecil B. DeMille, lining up the fresh combatant for a beauty shot. That's lovely and all, except it usually heralds being blindsided by an evil dog/robot/whatever.

The camera can be somewhat tamed with adjustments to the questionable default settings, but what can't be, are some bizarre design choices.

The game actively encourages a rhythm of regularly switching characters; not doing so will result in them standing there, doing absolutely f*ck all. This can sometimes lead to a cycle of despair, where you have to go on the offensive in a pinch just to build ATB to heal. The end becomes inevitable.

And then there are the interrupts.

Need to cure desperately? Built up your Limit Break and preparing to unleash a finishing blow? Tough luck, pal, you've been bonked from behind. Not only do you lose the attack animation, but the ATB or entire limit break goes with it.

It's needlessly frustrating - particularly when items use up ATB as well.

Also, the FFXIII-style stagger system - whilst demanding strategy - turns some bosses into slogs.

For long periods, it feels as though you're lightly tapping them with a pool cue, before a five second stagger window to unleash some real damage. This is obviously the point, but it makes the player feel weak - and worst of all, can result in some very tedious re-runs if a death spiral occurs.


4. The Side-Quests Are Banal And Tedious

FFVII Remake Dancing Man
Square-Enix

Plundering a crashed aircraft thousands of leagues under the sea. Convincing a sneaky materia thief to join your band, before helping her win the approval of her father. Breeding a champion race-chocobo that lets you travel to a secluded islet containing the world's most powerful summon materia.

These are the sort of side-quests which infuse the world with mystery, making it seem more expansive than it really is. They stoke the imagination, and ask the player to engage with the world, or otherwise have them saying, "Wow! I didn't know about that!"

In Final Fantasy VII Remake's side-quests, you round up some cats.

OK, so there is more to them than that, but the degree of banality rarely rises above an episode of BBC's The One Show.

Instead of being incredible secrets you discover under your own steam, all of the Remake's side-quests are prescribed to the player; a set of chores to tick off a list.

Go to point A, kill enemy B, return, all with some fluffy inane dialogue in between. Though the material rewards might be handy, the quests themselves so blatantly exist to extend the life of the game, with all the content in an upfront catalogue lest anyone miss out on the tedium.

There's never a true sense of exploring Midgar - it's not like any of it can be interacted with outside these quest NPCs, and in some cases, whole areas only become relevant once your journal dictates.

It's symptomatic of the laundry-list approach to modern AAA game design, which copies and pastes content to fill space.

It is very, very uninspiring.


3. The Male Power Fantasy Issue

FFVII Remake Cloud Tifa Aerith
Square-Enix

One of the expanded characters most Final Fantasy VII Remake players seem to enjoy the most is Jessie.

In the original, the AVALANCHE bombardier hit a few switches, had a chat about scanners on a train, and then, by and large, popped her proverbials on the side of a scaffold. We barely got to know her, let alone care.

There's a superb expanded sequence in the remake that takes us to Jessie's privileged childhood home plate-side, as we learn her motivations for joining AVALANCHE. Her greatly expanded role is mostly to provide some necessary emotional impact when she gets a bit shot to death (what with Part 1 obviously shorn of that scene).

However... much this memorability manifests from her absolute thirst for Cloud.

Within five minutes of knowing him, Jessie is dripping off the sulky anti-hero as though he's wearing Lynx Africa or something. It's hardly surprising that a subset of the audience seem to have warmed to her this time around, then.

The 'female characters as male power fantasy' theme continues with primary protagonists Tifa and Aerith.

Without dwelling on her preposterously proportioned chest, Tifa's interactions with Aerith - Cloud's new gal, she reckons - are laced with jealousy. It's a way for the target audience to vicariously 'enjoy' two idealised women fighting for their affection, even if Cloud's personality doesn't demand it.

Then there's Madame M, who implicitly makes SOLDIER boy spaff his parachute pants, for a price. This all goes, ahem, hand-in-hand with the Remake's female cast being almost entirely in service of the men.


2. It DOES Need To Exist, Compared To The Original

FFVII Remake Aerith
Square-Enix

Perhaps one of the saddest consequences of the Final Fantasy VII Remake is that it'll encourage a whole new generation of players to revisit the original, only to discover that - and as an enormous fan of the series, it absolutely pains me to write this - it's aged drastically.

Like, forgotten potato in a cupboard drastically.

Veterans will overlook what have since became 'flaws'. Newcomers will not. The lack of analogue control. The constant random battles. The agonising pace of said battles. And the grind. Oh boy, the grind.

Final Fantasy VII Remake, as much as us old-school fans wanted it, couldn't just be 1997's game dragged into the 2020s. That's hard for us to admit, which is sort of the point of this piece.

Is the new battle system perfect? Not at all, and the suggestion turn-based is old hat is something of a canard. But can it be sold to modern gamers in the previous guise? Not hardly.

Though I lament the demise of pre-rendered backdrops and the fixed camera, it almost seems a waste to recreate these historic environments with a billion polygons only to then restrict them to a bird's eye view. It's arguably less atmospheric - a static shot of a slum felt that much more oppressive - but it's certainly more marvellous. A free view lets the player stop and take in these glorious sights - so long as they aren't made out of paper, anyway.

Changes are a necessary evil, then, and for the most part, they're in service of a fresh take here. But what about changes to the story? Well...


1. THAT Ending

final fantasy 7 cloud
Square Enix

Without question the biggest talking point for those who've finished Final Fantasy VII Remake is just what in God's name was going on with that ending?

In brief: Throughout the game, Cloud and crew are haunted by spectres, who are seemingly trying to ensure the course of history flows correctly. Any deviation from fate's intention - in other words, the plot of the original game - sees these chronology wonks spring into action. Barrett takes one for the team in Shinra HQ, but he shouldn't have.

The ghouls - Whispers, as it happens - step in to save him.

This all culminates with a battle against Kingdom Hearts' Chernabog in a dimensional rift, as Cloud and friends fight the very concept of destiny itself. Oh, and then there's a battle with Sephiroth, just because. Had to get One Winged Angel in there somewhere.

Oh my, it's all so very subversive, and basically Tetsuya Nomura's way of saying, "stop telling me to remake FFVII" ... whilst also remaking FFVII.

And like everything, it isn't exactly subtle; the Whispers are phantoms, which coincidentally, sounds a lot like fandom. It's definitely interesting, and has certainly sparked more discussion than a 1:1 retelling of the original five hours ever could.

But is it good, or as, as some quarters have called it, "genius"?

Or is it subversion for subversion's sake, and an excuse for Square-Enix to do whatever the f*ck they want with the series going forwards, whilst selling it on the cache of its nostalgic appeal?

That's up to you to decide.

But yes, it's that.


Editorial Team
Editorial Team

Benjamin was born in 1987, and is still not dead. He variously enjoys classical music, old-school adventure games (they're not dead), and walks on the beach (albeit short - asthma, you know). He's currently trying to compile a comprehensive history of video game music, yet denies accusations that he purposefully targets niche audiences. He's often wrong about these things.