How Sony Almost Killed God Of War

Between a radical redesign and Sony testers HATING it... GOTY 2018 fought to survive.

God Of War 2018
Sony

You'd like to think that the almighty God of War 2018 was conceptualised under a moonlit sky, given animation and a physics engine by some unseen angelic force, only to strut fully-formed out the door and into our arms. But that was not even remotely the case.

That reaction from Creative Director Corey Barlog when he finally looked upon critics' scores and realised he'd made one of the best games of all time? It came from five years of struggle and hard work; of pitching a "radical reimagining" of one of gaming's most recognisable heroes... and suffering everything from complete overhauls to straight-up insulting feedback in return.

To dissect just how much of an achievement God of War is - and why it should be genuinely treasured - you need to know the inner workings of its production, just as much as the satisfying slam of splitting a Draugr's skull in two with a well-placed axe swing.

First up, the original pitch: Kratos goes to Egypt.

Revealed in an official capacity at Devcom 2018, Barlog highlighted a number of earlier concept art pieces where Ancient Egypt was the setting. Interestingly, this was doubled by a handful of leaks and rumours, though until now, they'd never bore meaningful fruit.

Cont'd...


God Of War Egypt
Sony/Gearnuke

Either way, if "God of War 4" had gone full Egypt (like Assassin's Creed Origins' and its accompanying boss battles), the version we got would've been demonstrably different - not to mention the signature Leviathan Axe would've been notably changed.

At this stage in development, the team became split down the middle as to whether they should continue with Egypt, or shift into Scandinavia and Norse mythology. After taking a vote that resulted in a tie, it was Corey Barlog vouching the for the latter that tipped the balance.

Yes, it all came down to one person's vote - and in this case, that person was the project lead.

All this, and the most retrospectively obtrusive element hadn't entered the fray: Sony.

As was told by Barlog in this impressively frank developer presentation, everything from external testing teams to Sony Worldwide President Shuhei Yoshida appeared to strongly dislike what he and his Santa Monica team were putting together.

Basically, because all the different parts of the game - engine, art design, combat etc. - were being developed in tandem, it was nigh-on impossible to produce a playable "vertical slice" of God of War, to show off. This resulted in all pre-launch builds being less than ideal, and it only caused internal negativity to snowball.

Cont'd...


At every turn, God of War appeared to barely run with a stable frame rate. The combat loop and core feel wasn't there, and faith in pulling off such an experimental endeavour was waning. The project had an air of "Trust us, we can do this... probably", as only after enough time had been invested, would the entire thing come together.

Obviously this didn't sit well with testing groups or studio heads, and Barlog had some seething feedback:

"What are you doing to Kratos? You're ruining Kratos. He's picking flowers! He's picking flowers?! This is ridiculous!" came one tester's thoughts, who apparently wanted to leave the play session because "he was so angry that Kratos was picking flowers."

Said Corey, "People were very protective of the franchise, and if they thought something was wrong they did not hesitate to tell me how much I suck."

Sadly, even Shuhei Yoshida couldn't hold in his disbelief at the state of the game only six months before launch, playing a build and leaving without saying a word. Barlog would later find out through a friend that Yoshida was "horrified" by what he saw, but this immensely counterproductive atmosphere actually spurred the team to get everything finished.

Pressure makes diamonds, after all.

"Everyone had to rally together; not just the combat team, but the engine team, the rendering team [...] The lesson I had to keep learning was to put the difficult thing in front of us, and not get comfortable. We need to force ourselves sometimes to be very uncomfortable."

It is precisely because of this series of events that Corey Barlog and his immensely talented team cemented themselves as some of the best creatives in the industry. It went right to the finish line, and Corey in particular had to shoulder an immense amount of pressure, channeling it into what we can now comfortably say was worth such a hectic development.

Props to the team. God of War is easily one of the best games of 2018, of the decade, and all time.


Watch Next


In this post: 
God of War
 
Posted On: 
Gaming Editor
Gaming Editor

WhatCulture's Head of Gaming.