Kingsglaive - Final Fantasy XV Review: 4 Ups & 6 Downs
Gorgeous but shallow.

Final Fantasy XV's highly-anticipated animated spin-off movie, Kingsglaive, is available now on VOD platforms, and it's fair to say that critics haven't taken too kindly to it so far.
It is, of course, worth bearing in mind that the critical panning in part comes from film critics who won't be playing the video game equivalent when it arrives on November 29, so may be less-tolerant of the film's various indulgences.
That said, the consensus doesn't lie: it's hard to call Kingsglaive an outright good film, and much like prior FF movies The Spirits Within and Advent Children, is laudable more for its presentation than its approach to characters and plot.
Fans will lap it up regardless, though they're best-advised to keep their expectations in check with what is nothing if not an extremely middling animated adventure.
Here are 4 ups and 6 downs from Kingsglaive: Final Fantasy XV...
Ups4. The Animation Is Incredible

If there's one thing about Kingsglaive that's absolutely beyond reproach, it's the largely terrific quality of the animation.
From the gorgeous vistas of Eos through to the character models and frantic action, it all looks beautiful, and is surely one of the best-looking animated films on the market right now. Final Fantasy has always been ahead of the curve when it comes to lifelike, cinematic animation, and this film is no exception, no matter its myriad flaws.
It may sound like a cliche, but switching your brain off and just soaking in the marvellous visuals is a perfectly valid way to enjoy this movie.
3. The Epic Musical Score

While John R. Graham may not be a name composer and has clearly been hired on the cheap in order to keep costs down, but he still does an absolutely rock solid job helping create an epic atmosphere that feels consistent enough (if naturally not as majestic) as Nobuo Uematsu's beloved work on the franchise.
It helps that Final Fantasy XV's composer Yoko Shimomura collaborated with Graham on much of the soundtrack, and while the arrangements here may not be sure-fire classics of the series, they still prove there's no need fretting at the lack of Uematsu.
2. Strong Action Sequences

If you're watching Kingsglaive largely for the barmy set-pieces, then you probably won't be disappointed. Yes, there's sometimes a bit of a wait for the action to ramp up, but once it does, it's both prolonged and electric, especially a mid-film rescue sequence that throws everything at the screen but still remains surprisingly coherent.
One can certainly argue that the film threatens to overdo it with some Transformers-esque, Michael Bay-inspired overkill in its final reel, but it seems unlikely that fans of the franchise will find the action to take things too far.
As a pyrotechnics display, it's sharply directed and absolutely gorgeous to behold. Bravo.
1. It Will Make You Want To Play Final Fantasy XV

Kingsglaive's primary goal is to make you hyped up to play Final Fantasy XV, and in that regard, it is an undeniable success.
The negatives here don't really seem to reflect on the game itself (though it remains to be seen if the writing is up to scratch or not), and in terms of world-building and aesthetic appeal, as well as a cheeky post-credits stinger, it more than does its job effectively.
It'll be up to fans to decide whether or not the film does enough good to paper over its eminent issues, but it certainly doesn't harm the upcoming game in any particular way, while helping flesh out the wider universe.
But what are those negatives? Let's find out.
Downs:6. The Plot Is Total Nonsense

It won't be too surprising to anyone who's ever played a Final Fantasy game or watched a Final Fantasy movie that Kingsglaive's plot is, well, a complete mess.
Sure, it starts off simple with the easily-understood war between the kingdom of Lucis and the Niflheim empire, but it quickly snowballs with an ever-increasing level of contrivance such that it becomes harder to care about what's going on the more muddled it becomes.
Character motivations on both sides are frequently questionable at best, and as such it quickly becomes a "switch your brain off and enjoy the light show" kind of outing. Again, not a shocker, but the creative minds behind the FF franchise could do with learning that less is sometimes more.
5. It Wastes A Talented Voice Cast

Arguably the movie's biggest crime is the ridiculous waste of a terrifically talented trio of actors. Firstly, there's Breaking Bad's Aaron Paul, who plays protagonist Nyx Ulric, a generic-looking, hopelessly bland Kingsglaive guard, and without much of interest to work with, Paul is forced to sleepwalk his way through the part.
Next up is Game of Thrones' Lena Headey, who is hilariously miscast as Lady Lunafreya Nox Fleuret, a character clearly far younger than Headey and so the voice doesn't match the look of the character at all. It honestly just feels like a desperate step to appeal to the nerd contingent by casting a popular actress from the biggest fantasy property on TV right now.
Sean Bean arguably fares the best as the noble King of Lucis, Regis Lucis Caelum CXIII, but even he isn't utilised to his full potential.
It's easy to see why these three actors were cast (brand recognition) and why they agreed to do it (easy money for a weekend in a sound booth), but given the potential here, it ends up feeling rather cynical and lazy.
4. Blatant Product Placement

Final Fantasy and real-world product placements don't mesh together well at all, as evidenced by the distracting abundance of them in Kingsglaive.
The most egregious bout of advertising comes with the presence of the Audi R8 as the heroes' transport of choice, while the likes of Beats, Japan Air Lines, Uniqlo, Volkswagen, and Samsung all get their prized screen time also.
Some might argue that it makes the world of Eos seem more realistic, but remember that this isn't Earth, only an "Earth-like" world, so it is incredibly bizarre whatever way you may want to justify it. It doesn't sink the film, but it does feel rather icky and immensely jarring given the fantastical setting.
3. Poor Pacing

Pacing is a real issue here: Kingsglaive clocks in at a meaty 115 minutes, and at times that length will effortlessly fly by, while often it will just feel like a tiresome slog.
After an exhilarating opening action sequence, be prepared to settle in for an unreasonable number of scenes loaded with overstuffed dialogues, many of which simply repeat the same thing or tell characters something the audience has already seen.
Those who suffer through this talkiness will be rewarded with an almost exhausting amount of action mid-film, pretty much wall-to-wall with minimal interruptions throughout, but the movie overall may have been better-served by having its action doled out amid all the chatting, to make it a less torturous experience.
And finally, it all arrives at a jarringly abrupt finale, cementing the fact that this film is in serious need of a more competent editor.
2. Inconsistent Lip Sync

As fantastically lifelike as the movie's characters indeed look, the lip sync work is all over the place. Sometimes characters' voices match up perfectly with their lip movements, and at other times it's incredibly sloppy-looking.
That such a technically precise film could drop the ball so blatantly in one of its most basic areas is truly baffling. It contributes towards creating an uncanny valley effect throughout which is unfortunate given how near-faultless many of the rendered characters actually look.
Some may see this as a nitpick, yet all but the least-observant audiences will probably notice it at one point or another.
1. Awful Dialogue

Crisp, concise, naturalistic dialogue has never been Final Fantasy's forte, but even so, there are plenty of groan-worthy moments throughout the movie.
First of all, there's exposition all over the place and the film just can't massage it into the script naturally, as well as some incredibly on-the-nose dialogues about Nyx being an "immigrant", possibly in a misguided attempt to have some social relevance.
That's just the beginning, though. There are tons of lame, "witty" comebacks shouted out as our heroes take down enemies, and plenty of howlingly cliched lines ripped straight out of the action movie/video game handbook, such as a villain telling Nyx, "You're out of time" to which he wryly retorts, "I'll make some".
Faux-bada** rubbish like this just makes Kingsglaive feel like an anime trying so, so hard to be a real movie and not quite succeeding.
What did you think of Kingsglaive: Final Fantasy XV? Shout it out in the comments!