Madden 15: 10 Over-Rated Players That Need Downgrading
These players deserve a serious reality check from EA Sports.
EA SportsMadden 15 is due for release at the end of August just in time for the new Gridiron season. Although the promise of new and improved gameplay, graphics and online content are eagerly awaited by the masses, it is the roster update which always keeps me and countless others in line with money in hand. Did my team or any of its players have a good season last year- will it be fairly reflected in this years game? Full details will only be revealed in August so here is a list of players who need serious downsizing due to sub-par performances, crippling injuries and ageing limbs. In some cases I still believe these are good if not great NFL players. Over the years Madden has been extremely generous giving near perfect scores of 99/100 to players year in, year out. Other EA franchises such as Fifa gave Cristiano Ronaldo and Lionel Messi lowly scores of 92 and 94 in comparison. These 10 players, often rated higher than said footballing Gods, do not come close to sharing their ability and thus deserve a serious reality check.
10. Clay Matthews - 96
wikiClay Matthews is a fine football player. He owns a Superbowl ring, has been to the Pro Bowl 4 times and is a two time All Pro. He has also been plagued by injuries the last couple of years and has been part of one of the worst defences in the NFL. Now I know a teams deficiencies should not reflect that of the individual but there are simply two many negative factors weighing against Matthews' huge 96 rating. When on the field he is certainly a factor but a broken thumb last year and constant double teams limited Matthews to only 7.5 sacks. Premier QB rushers like JJ Watt and Robert Mathis receive just as much attention as Matthews yet get the job done on a far more regular basis. No.10 on my list and by no means deserving a huge ratings decrease, it is Matthews outrageously high rating from last season which largely sees him in this category. I hope and expect Matthews to be given a low 90's overall rating in this year's Madden edition. His bubbly personality and shocking blonde hair may work for him, it looks as though his blonde locks are everywhere on the field, but will this sustain his reputation on the field and in the game? We'll see in August.
9. Sean Lee
Tim Sharp/AP/Press Association ImagesMiddle Linebackers are extremely underrated in Madden games. This given their importance to a teams defence both as captains and tackle makers. It seems almost unfair to put Sean Lee on this list due to the injury he recently sustained but either way he is likely to take a ratings hit. Lee played only 11 games and recorded 0 sacks. He still made a relatively high number of tackles (99) and interceptions (4) but constant injury sees him make this list and Madden are also sure to take this into consideration. It doesn't help that Dallas had probably the worst defence in the league last year. Lee was at the helm for the majority of these matches. With a rating of 90 and Madden already ruthless on MLB numbers he is bound to show a decrease should he make the field.
8. Matt Ryan
wikiA good but not great QB, the Atlanta Falcon playmaker deserves to take a step back. A big part of his teams horrible 4-10 season, Ryan failed to deliver on a potentially great franchise. The Falcons after all were mere yards away in 2012 from representing the NFC at the Superbowl. Matty Ice can have few excuses. In Roddy White and the sure hands of Tony Gonzalez he had 2 high grade receivers to throw to (2 more than Mr Newton). Julio Jones was also active for 5 games and is another outstanding player. He should be reaching his best years as a 7th year veteran so last years distinctly average numbers were particularly harmful to his teams chances of going one step further. With 26 TD's but 17 INT's, Matty Ice does not deserve a 94. It wouldn't be a surprise to see Ryan drop out of the 90's altogether. With such a talented group of receivers at his disposal the opportunity to mask certain flaws and propel his rating sees him enter this list at this early stage.
7. Jason Witten
Tim Sharp/AP/Press Association ImagesWitten also didn't have a terrible season but is included on this list for his extremely high rating in Madden 25. At 32 his best footballing years are most probably behind him and the number of great tight ends around the NFL at the moment sees Witten put into context. Given the choice, I'd rather have Graham, Gronkowski, Davis, Thomas and Bennett on my roster than Witten. Last years 96 overall will surely decrease as a result of these other tight ends. In Madden, it's unlikely the 5th, 6th or 7th best player in a position will keep such a lofty rating. Tony Romo had a fine year statistically (31 TD's 10 INT's) so for Witten to have fewer yards than the soon to be OAP Tony Gonzalez is worrying. A rating in the high 80s low 90s seems most likely for the man from Tennessee.
6. Arian Foster
wikiLimited in his production due to injury, Foster still had a fairly average year in the NFL's worst team. Starting 8 games and scoring only 1 TD, Foster's 95 rating will surely plummet. In a league dominated by the passing game, stand out running backs are becoming harder to find. Whilst the Adrian Petersons' of this world still receive praise despite the course the game is taking, Foster looks set to miss out on fanfare. He does however benefit from the Texans current QB issues though and could easily prove me wrong come game time. Foster could likely be an early sleeper in that he starts off in the high 80's and ends up with a similar rating to last year with re-evaluation throughout the season.
5. Joe Flacco
Patrick Semansky/AP/Press Association ImagesFlacco is another Superbowl winner and as quarterback, rightly deserved his rating of 93 in last years outing. He remains one of the highest paid players in Football and was part of a team suffering from a Superbowl hangover. Despite this, Flacco deserves to be downgraded. The numbers don't lie. Throwing 22 interceptions in a season is ugly. Yes he boasts a powerful arm and threw for a decent amount of yards (3,912) but playing for the current champions these figures aren't good enough. With a virtual bullseye on their jerseys due to last season's success, the Ravens needed their signal caller to stand up. Instead, he was extremely effective in getting his offensive chums to sit on the bench after conceding turnover after turnover. Flacco has never been a stand out quarterback in the NFL and as Superbowl MVP deserved his 93 rating last year. Expect things to return to normal and see Flacco as a mid to high 80's entry in Madden 15.
4. Maurice Jones-Drew
Michael Conroy/AP/Press Association Images I'm a big fan of Jones-Drew. I feel sorry for him for sticking with the awful Jaguars team. With his talent, putting the team on his back in front of 500 odd fans seems unfair. His move to the Raiders could be a God send as he partners Darren McFadden but don't expect his 91 rating to remain. Mojo had a horrible season. Yes everyone knew he was most likely to have the ball but the same can be said for Peterson, Charles and McCoy. To average 3.4 yards in 15 games and score only 5 TD's is certainly not putting the team on one's back. As stated, we are used to seeing Mojo give his team a chance which simply wasn't the case last year. Moreover, his 95 agility rating is also set to decline as he reaches 30. Sharing snaps with McFadden, Jones-Drew is a player who is unlikely to regain his lofty rating from previous Madden editions.
3. Champ Bailey
Julio Cortez/AP/Press Association ImagesThis guy's prime seems many moons ago yet his legacy keeps him in Maddens' good books. Charles Woodson has already been given the Madden chop regarding a ratings downgrade and Madden 15 should see Bailey mirror his counterpart. The Saints CB hasn't amassed more than 3 interceptions since 2006. His lack of game time saw his release from Denver and at 35 it's highly unlikely he will see too many snaps in New Orleans. A future hall of famer, Bailey has had a terrific career but with a 93 rating next to his name, don't be surprised if he drops close to 10 points in Madden 15.
2. Steve Smith
Chuck Burton/AP/Press Association ImagesSteve Smith is a 90. How? If he remains anywhere close to this number in Madden 15 someone needs to have a serious look in the mirror. I could write a 15,000 word thesis as to why this man needs to be put down but will instead limit this rant to only 100 words. Foremost, Smith was the only stand out receiver on an extremely limited receiving corps. His quarterback wasn't Christian Ponder but 2013 Pro Bowler Cam Newton. His team finished as 2 seeds in an extremely competitive NFC, yet the guy only amassed 745 receiving yards and 4 touchdowns in 15 starts?! Carolina saw fit to give Smith the boot after 13 seasons and one can only hope Madden give him a suitable decrease too. His speed (92), agility (93) and awareness (94) should all take a hit. I enjoy Smith's speed and toughness but his age is also a factor and I can't help but think this ratings request will be granted by the powers that be.
1. Tom Brady
Joe Mahoney/AP/Press Association ImagesCalm down. I'm a huge fan of Tom Brady. I thoroughly enjoyed his cameo in Entourage and the fact he made a mockery of the NFL draft system. I'm aware the Patriots made the AFC championship game but this was not one of Brady's best seasons and his whopping 97 rating should be reevaluated. He's said in the same breath as the all time best NFL QB's (and rightly so) but hear me out. First off Brady has always had a good offensive line in front of him which gets overshadowed by his apparent lack of receivers. With Gronkowski, Edelman and Amendola to throw to, we aren't exactly looking at Jacksonville, Buffalo or Tennessees' options. His 25 TDs and 11 INT's are respectable but this is Tom Brady we are talking about. Manning, Brees, Rodgers and even Philip Rivers outplayed him last year. It is because we expect so much from him that he stands at no.1 on this list. Should the number 4 or 5 QB in the league be given a repeat 97? If you believe so then I can only apologise but at 36 it is up to Tom to prove me and Madden 15 wrong.