Mass Effect 3: 5 Other Broken Endings We'd Fix

Five other endings in games that we weren't happy with and how we might go about fixing them if we had an all powerful New Ending DLC Machine.

With Bioware this week releasing DLC to change the ending of Mass Effect 3 because the fans were not satisfied with what was available on the disk, we thought today would be a good time to loom at five other endings in games that we weren't happy with and how we might go about fixing them if we had an all powerful New Ending DLC Machine. In no particular order, here are our picks (Warning, spoilers ahead).

1. Eternal Sonata

Here is an example of an ending that could have been great, but didn't stick to its guns and chickened out. What should have been a great ending where Polka dies and the world ends when Chopin passes is completely undermined when they bring Polka back because she was in love and reveal that it wasn't just in Chopin's head after all. This ending had a lot of potential, but was just too scared of leaving players with an ending where two of the were dead. Kill them both off when the time is right and you would have left players with a sombre but memorable and touching ending.

2. Final Fantasy X

On the topic of games that feel like they didn't want to commit to their endings it's time to talk about Final Fantasy X. The game built up this emotional story about the relationship between Tidus and Yuna before having Tidus just Disappear in a way that strongly hinted that he might not be gone, blatantly trying to leave room for its direct sequel. Also, they could have added a lot of weight to the ending by committing to Yuna dying during the final summoning. This game suffered at the hands of the developers knowing that they wanted to develop X-2. Without that story in the back of their minds, they could have created an ending that was up there with the likes of Chrono Trigger and some of the other JRPG's known for the strength of their stories.

3. Beyond Good and Evil

This was a brilliant game with a brilliant ending. You defeat the final boss, the story wraps up and all the loose ends are dealt with leaving you with a fulfilling conclusion. The credits roll, leaving you with a sense that this self contained experience is over and done with and everything is over. But wait, what's this I see at the end of the credits, it's another cutscene. It was short, but left us on such an unbelievable cliffhanger ending that fans were desperate for a sequel. Nine years and one teaser trailer later, and that sequel is still seemingly no closer. If Ubisoft had left out that teaser the game wouldn't have been any worse, but adding it in completely undid the wonderfully self contained ending you had created.

4. Alan Wake

So after a gruelling journey past untold terrors and plot twists to finally rescue your wife, things start to get a little weird and nonsensical. You defeat a weird tornado of evil, dive into a lake where a mysterious author in a diving suit tells you about your never before mentioned evil twin Mr. Scratch who will be living your life while you stay trapped forever in the cabin in an attempt to free your wife from the lake. For a game with a great story, the ending felt hugely rushed, lacking in answers, and incomplete unless you play through the DLC, which provides some of but not all of the answers. Some extra explanation, closure and sense would have gone a long way.

5. Batman: Arkham Asylum

Batman: Arkham Asylum is heralded by many to be one of the greatest examples of a franchise Tie-in game done right. What was done wrong however was the ending. During the whole experience The Joker is portrayed as someone who revels in subtlety, enjoying intellectual struggle and psychological warfare based methods of torturing the hero. With this in mind, I hate that they chose to throw that all out the window in favour of having The Joker bulk up on drugs and challenge Batman to a fist fight at the games peak. It is so unbelievably out of character that it just completely broke the experience for me. An ending that showed The Joker battling in a more characteristicly Cooperant way would have felt much more natural. So there we have it. What do you think of this list? Would you leave these endings as they are? Do you agree that these could have been ended better? Is there a game we missed that you would like to see fixed? Let us know your thoughts on the comments below.

Contributor
Contributor

Long time JRPG and Nintendo SuperFan, Laura is a passionate gamer who comes to WhatCulture to share her nerdy ramblings with the world.