Mass Effect 4: 10 Reasons BioWare Must Start A New Saga

possible-mass-effect-4-story-hints-in-me3

Launched in the fall of 2007, Bioware€™s Mass Effect franchise filled the western space opera vacuum left by the cancellations and finales of Star Trek, Stargate, and Battlestar Galactica. Spanning three games, its overarching storyline revolved around Commander Shepard and his/her struggles against the Reapers, a race of machines that culled all life in the galaxy every 50,000 years. Despite an ending that is controversial, to say the least, Mass Effect has managed to expand out into the multimedia universe, with comics, novels, mobile games, and even an animated movie. But just about everything has been part of or tied into Shepard€™s saga €“ and that has to change when the next Mass Effect game is released. Here are the 10 reasons Bioware needs a whole new plot for the next Mass Effect game. Warning: spoilers for Mass Effect 3 will be largely present.

10. They Already Said They Would

Casey Hudson, producer of Mass Effect The first reason on this list is a bit of an odd one: it€™s a promise a company has already made. During Mass Effect 3€™s pre-launch hype tour, a number of Bioware employees and then-CEO Dr. Ray Mazuka touted that ME3 was the end of Shepard€™s story. And they were very, very clear about that:
Similarly, producer Michael Gamble said, "After this, Commander Shepard's story is complete." When pressed, "Even if there are more games in the Mass Effect universe, he/she definitely won't be in them?" He laconically replied, "Correct."
While Bioware hasn€™t had the most sterling record of decision making when it comes to the franchise, this is probably the best move they could make. It€™s better to move on to new things and let the players keep their fond memories of Shepard and company than ruin them with a sequel that doesn€™t satisfy anyone.

9. A Fresh Start For Gameplay

XCOM: Enemy Unknown combat UI Mass Effect 1-3 were all shooter RPGs, with different ratios of shooter to RPG. While it was nice to see Bioware find the sweet spot between the two in ME3, after five years, it was starting to get a little old. Starting up a new saga in ME4 means that Bioware can experiment with new gameplay ideas without worrying about backlash from the fans. After the critical and financial success of XCOM: Enemy Unknown, it might be a good idea for the next Mass Effect to be a turn based strategy (TBS) game. TBS, a once thriving genre in the early days of PC gaming, is pretty much dead outside of a few new western games and Japanese strategy RPGs. If Bioware ever decided to go with another combat heavy game, a TBS can easily give players control of squads of soldiers with the vast array of tech, biotic, and weapon abilities without worrying about combat pacing or limited hot keys.

8. More Exploration

ME galaxy map Mass Effect has always had a strong exploration bent, allowing players to fly all over the galaxy and check out planets. While the actual execution of the exploration in the games is debatable (I, for one, hate the Mako, while others swear by it, and let€™s not get into planet scanning), it€™s safe to say that there€™s plenty more to see in the Mass Effect universe. In fact, the codex says that only about 1% of the galaxy is explored by the time Shepard€™s story arc ends. A new saga benefits exploration in two ways: 1) We can see stuff that the original saga missed and 2) It gives Bioware an opportunity to flesh out some of the locations we only caught glimpses of. The first is pretty obvious €“ we haven€™t seen a lot of developed planets in the first three games. It doesn€™t help that in ME3, most of them were being blown up, and that we were constantly teased by Cerberus Daily News stories about wars and disasters on planets we never saw. The second is something you need to think about €“ we really didn€™t see all that much of the worlds Shepard and company set foot on. Even with DLC expanding some of them, like Illium and Omega, there€™s plenty left untouched for new games to use.

7. A Chance To Redeem The EU

Mass Effect novels Like any franchise that has made a lot of money, Mass Effect has an Expanded Universe of novels, comics, and audio/visual media (plus some mobile games). Some of these stories are written by or with the actual writers of the games, while others have not. But they are all mediocre at best and horrifically terrible at worst, telling stories that no one cares about and barely exploring the incredible sandbox that is the Mass Effect universe. ME4 would be a fresh start for the whole franchise, including the EU. The current EU is mostly fluff pieces that set up things for the games (The Illusive Man, the Collectors, Kahlee Sanders, and Cerberus taking over Omega were all introduced in the EU) and depend on the games€™ reputations to draw in readers. A new, better EU would be one that stands apart from the story of the ME4 saga and manages to draw in readers by exploring the parts of the ME universe the games can€™t. It should make you want to read the books and comics, instead of just reading their plot summaries off of a Wiki.

6. Other Characters Deserve The Spotlight

Mass Effect 2 cast portrait One of the main draws of Mass Effect was the characters, especially the members of Shepard€™s squad. As we talked to them, we often got teased with bits of backstory that were never explored (aside from things that led into side quests/loyalty missions). Garrus, Wrex, Kasumi, Thane, and Mordin in particular have long backstories with plenty of adventures, making them great choices for the leads of a new saga if Bioware is feeling conservative. Things get even more fun if we look at some of the more memorable side characters seen throughout the franchise. Major Kirrahe, Captain Bailey, and Primarch Victus are just a few of the characters that could easily have a whole story or set of stories revolve around them. But Bioware, if you€™re reading this, please don€™t ever make a game where we play as Conrad Verner.

5. It€™s Time To See History

Mass Effect Codex Entry One of the best and worst things about Mass Effect is the extensive background info on the setting. While there€™s tons of historical stuff in the planet descriptions and Codex entries, most of it doesn€™t matter to the average fan. Most people aren€™t going to think of the story or fan art potential of the €œbeings of light€ seen on Klencory or the Rachni War because of that old adage: Show, don€™t tell. Shepard€™s saga matters to players and fans because they€™ve seen and played it, while the 50,000 years that come before it are barely a blip on fans€™ radar. A new saga would have a chance to fix all that. Why? Because odds are that a new story would be set before ME3, to avoid having to deal with the divergent endings. Why not go further back, to any of the numerous wars that happened on the Citadel Council€™s watch? Bioware has the writers to make an all alien cast work and the Codex provides the basic facts for any number of stories. If Bioware really wants to prove Mass Effect is a viable intellectual property in the long term, there are worse ways to do it.

4. New Cast, New Stories

Silhouttes For Bioware, making ME4 a fresh start in terms of story and character might be the best thing to do. After all, Mass Effect fans have spent five years with Shepard and company, trying to beat the Reapers before they wiped out all life in the galaxy. We€™ve barely skimmed the surface of the ME universe, its inhabitants, and the amount of stories that can be told €“ why not make a new story that expands on some aspect of the universe that the games barely touched on? Not only that, but it€™s time for Bioware to break out of its writing rut and a new ME game is the best way to make it happen. It€™s been common knowledge for a while that Bioware uses the same basic plot and character templates so they can work faster. But doing the €œancient evil awakens€ plot twice in a row isn€™t going to help win over newcomers or people disappointed by how Shepard€™s saga ended. It€™s time for Bioware to step up to challenge and show that their writing prowess isn€™t just the result of a formula €“ make something new, with a new cast players can care about, and prove that Mass Effect isn€™t just a flash in the pan.

3. The Reapers Were Never Interesting

Reaper Fleet Villains or antagonists are a major cornerstone and litmus test of a story. If they€™re interesting and three dimensional characters, they€™re a major benefit to the story. If they€™re not, then they sap out a lot of the energy and tension, forcing everything else to carry the story. And sadly, the villains of the Shepard Saga are the least interesting part of the entire Mass Effect trilogy. Why? The Reapers are basically mecha space Cthulhu€™s that want to kill/harvest all life in the galaxy for reasons. Everything about them is generic and taken from some other work of fiction. Their appearance? H.P. Lovecraft. Their €œharvest all life in the galaxy€ schtick? Taken from Revelation Space. Their booming voices? Generic villain trait. There€™s nothing really interesting about them as characters or antagonists €“ especially not after the conversation with Sovereign on Virimire. After spilling the entire Reaper plan to Shepard, Sovereign doesn€™t answer the one question that can make or break a villain: why? In that moment, the Reapers were revealed as the plot devices they were. The Reapers don€™t exist as characters, just as backstory for the galaxy at large and motivation for the events of the games. That€™s why Mass Effect 2, the least Reaper focused game in the trilogy, is the best game: the Reapers are barely in it and serve their function. They cause the story to happen, but it€™s the characters and their adventures that are the focus and what people actually care about.

2. Shepard & The Reapers Dominate Too Much

Shepard and Reapers The Reapers and Shepard are the Alpha and Omega of Mass Effect. ME 1-3 all focus on them (to varying degrees), leading to the sense that the Shepard saga is all that matters about the ME universe. Everything in the expanded universe somehow ties into Shepard and/or the Reapers. Instead of feeling like an ocean teeming with possibilities, Mass Effect feels like a small pond with two giant yachts on it. If you€™re not Shepard or Reapers, you don€™t matter €“ and it shows in the fan community. How much fan art and fiction is there that doesn€™t involve Shepard and/or the Reapers? Not a lot. The lack of scope in Mass Effect is something that has to be addressed by ME4. Like Star Trek in the 1980s, Mass Effect is associated with a set of characters more than a universe, which is never a good thing for a franchise. Getting away from the Reapers and Shepard is a great way to remind everyone that this is a universe worth telling stories in, especially ones that aren€™t related to the original trilogy. In a galaxy teeming with untold numbers of heroes and villains, it€™s hard to see why Bioware can€™t come up with an equally compelling cast with better adversaries.

1. It€™ll End The Mass Effect 3 Ending Debate

Mass Effect 3 Ending Demotivator If you€™re a Mass Effect fan like me, you were letdown by the endings to Mass Effect 3. Even with the Extended Cut, they€™re nothing spectacular and at times ridiculous (hello, Synthesis ending). But the worst thing about the ME3 endings is how practically every Mass Effect conversation will wind up hitting that subject. Part of it is due to the fact that this is the last major ME title for a while, but I find that rehashing the same arguments over and over again leaves me less and less inclined to care about anything new from Mass Effect. So please Bioware, give us something new, so we can stop beating the rotten corpse of a dead horse and get back to wanting Mass Effect. I think everyone, even the haters, would appreciate it. Like this post? Think I€™m crazy or off the mark when it comes to Mass Effect? Leave a comment below or talk to me on Twitter.

 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Living in Florida, enjoying the weather when its good, writing for a living. TV, Film, Animation, and Games are my life blood. Follow me on Twitter @xbsaint. Just try not to get too mad when I live tweet during Toonami.