Mass Effect 4 Wishlist: 11 Things Fans Demand

An order so tall, the galaxy's finest need to be called in.

They say go big or go home, and when you're looking at the smouldering pile of wreckage and broken dreams left behind in the wake of Mass Effect 3, it's going to take a considerable amount of communal faith healing to get the Mass Effect ship back on course. For the most part people don't - and never did - actively want to hate the series, but hell hath no fury like a nerd scorned. As evident in something as recent as the new lightsaber design catching hell from fans of a franchise that peaked over three decades ago, it proves once you've built a fanbase dedicated to exploring your fiction for hours upon hours, that love will always manifest in the most passionate ways possible. Back to Mass Effect 4 though, and in the years since its confirmation there have been a number of staff members leave Bioware, including project lead Casey Hudson - who also doubles as the guy who said ME 3 "wouldn't end with you picking an A, B or C" resolution. So maybe it's a good thing, maybe it's not, but either way the team heading up part four aren't the exact same as the first three, and that opens up the possibilities for how things are going to go considerably. Do you want another Mass Effect after everything that went so spectacularly wrong? Check out our potential wishlist and compile your own in the comments below.


11. A (Hopefully Playable) Demo In 2015

So let's start with the most improbable thing going; an in-game E3 demo that also ends up as something in consumer's hands before the year's end. Needless to say, a proof of concept is desperately required to quell many fan's fears, as so far the only thing shown has been a tech reel of sorts last year, although all that consisted of was a shot of the world in-progress, a Krogan-looking alien and plenty of voiceover about how there'd be an entire galaxy of possibilities. Obviously it was early days and they wanted to test the waters, but that was then and this is now - if the team have been hard at work putting something together it means they've at least got the concept for the game's direction nailed down. So why not show off what they have? E3 is the place for big things to arrive and blow people away, and all eyes are on this year especially to deliver something monument for everyone to get stuck into.

10. Original Trilogy Cameos

Depending on who you talk to, some people are clamouring for ME 3 to not be the final resting place for their favourite respective characters - whilst others think a clean break is what's needed instead. Regardless, thanks to having such diverse racial traits both aesthetically and culturally, there's a very good chance that certain established character/racial traits would carry over anyway, like any Krogan's tribal roots, a Quarian's spiritual eastern traits, human's position as the 'newcomers' to the galaxy etc. This essentially opens up the possibility for a new squad to have a variety of things in common with the original crew either through action or dialogue, but in the end it might be better or more assuring to simply drop in actual crew members depending on where 4 takes place in the timeline.

9. No DLC

Downloadable content does have its place in the modern gaming landscape, but all the same, wouldn't it be so refreshing and ultimately rewarding to fans if a developer behind one of the biggest franchises out there actually released their game without the need to parse out content afterwards? Mass Effect has a closer relationship with this business practice than most, as it was what completely crippled part three's appeal when people found out some essential characters or beats of the story were locked behind a paywall...
Going forward, sadly it looks like DLC is here to stay as it helps suitably gargantuan budgets the likes of what Mass Effect 4 will already have get recouped post-launch. However, we can but dream.

8. A Dedicated Main Character Model

A glaringly huge error with the original trilogy was in the modelling of your Commander Shepard, in that even if you opted to take as long as you wanted framing every cheek bone and pockmark, your Shep would never look as 'real' as the box art version - purely down to the fact he was the only one scanned in from a real actor. The person in question is one Mark Vanderloo, brought in assumedly for the PR campaigns as it's a bit hard to sell a game without a face. However, as Mass Effect 3 started telling a more linear story character-wise with regards to Shepard's inner torment, alongside the fact plenty people gave up on their custom Sheps and chose the 'official' model anyway at the start of ME 2, either the overall rendering tech needs to be perfected regardless of your options, or we just need a dedicated render model that'll let our actions define the character instead.

7. Truthful Marketing

Between Destiny, Alien: Colonial Marines, Assassin's Creed: Unity, Watch Dogs and more, there's been quite the handful of bubbles burst come the time when consumers finally get their hands on a retail product, and it'd be a disturbing trend in desperate need of addressing if it was any more frequent. Still, hopefully Bioware have learnt their lesson when it comes to what happened through the lead-up and release of Mass Effect 3, and can instead get back to the otherwise harmonious sense of love between creator and fan they had throughout both the first game release and post-launch periods. It's not much to ask, but please don't sell your game as something it's not. If we're going to be going down a more linear route albeit within a galaxy we love then fine. Don't hide the turret sequences and don't try and say it's 'our' experience when it's only going to end one of three ways - if you have a dedicated vision you think is best then stick to it. The worst thing that gamers are increasingly becoming sick of is being lied to.

6. Combat Needs To Not Be Gears Of War

Bungie took a weird turn in ME 3, whereby they doubled down on the whole 'Gears in space' feel of ME 2, but ended up throwing in some really naff level designs and missions whereby you were either bolted to a turret for a few minutes, or were retrieving items from a time-limited arena. Assumedly it was their take on Gears' Horde mode, but it flat-out sucked, making long-time fans feel like they weren't playing something designed by people that had sat down and wrote about the philosophical quandaries surrounding the Quarian/Geth organic/synthetic debate, and more like a mod made for the Call of Duty crowd. Mass Effect 2 had it pretty much spot on, giving you access to a range of Biotic powers alongside plenty of firearms, some special weapons with lower ammo counts, and the ability to deploy special attacks as you manoeuvred around the field. The only thing worth carrying over from 3 are the contextual kills where you could grab a guy over or around cover - all else either needs to be streamlined into its own take on the genre, or trimmed back to allow for greater strategy against any combination of enemies.

5. Reasons To Mix Up Your Squad In The Field

Building on the combat refinement options, there needs to be more opportunities within the deployment of your squad. Say you have Tali/an established tech specialist with you, maybe they could open a door that otherwise wouldn't be hack-able if you had a brute force-focussed team. Essentially in the past games you only chose your partners based on either wanting to hear their dialogue or because they had one particular attack you liked having quick-access too (like a life-saving Concussive Shot) - or you thought bringing along someone like Miranda would help your chances at romance somewhere down the line. However, the idea of varying up who you're playing with to gain access to other items, routes or NPC-specific dialogue is a must for the sake of replayability alongside just the fun of hearing all of Bioware's consistently-brilliant writing.

4. Multiple Ways To Solve Any Conflict

Some of the best moments in the other games came from a specific situation showing you could choose from some extended options dependant on what your reputation or standing was at the time. It's something that made you feel like you had a real impact on your surroundings, and should be used far more frequently. The ability to talk to the squad with a dialogue tree whenever you like would be perfect instead of the one-button, one-line stuff seen before. Essentially they can be treated like Metal Gear does its Codec; available whenever you want a mission pointer or some chatter about something else - albeit with additional options to steer the conversation. Coming out the other end of a battle or cutscene only to take five and check in with your squad to discuss your options both in the field, politically and/or on-world would easily solidify 'the new Mass Effect experience' as something not possible on previous hardware.

3. Multiple Playable Races

As we delved into over here, opening up the possibilities for race-relations yourself would be an incredibly immediate way to change the perspective given on the galaxy at any one time. The Elder Scrolls games have executed on this idea flawlessly multiple times, and although on older hardware you're always going to be limited in the amount of overarching variations the game will provide depending on who or what you are, it's a great way to expand upon any given mythology in a meaningful way. Imagine being able to get into the metallic hide of a Geth, forever bound to the hivemind's doing, but wanting to explore the galaxy first-hand. The same goes for a Quarian and their Migrant Fleet, or the Asari and the potential to become a devout Justicar instead. It's obviously a lot of work to bring a story to life for just one hero, but if there's any developer that can realise an even greater, more varied vision whilst factoring in all the possibilities, it's Bioware.

2. To Not Feel Like A Cash-In

This almost goes without saying, but you'd be surprised how many people think "they're only doing another Mass Effect because they have to". Perhaps it's a valid point; the franchise is easily the studio's most successful effort both financially and culturally despite everything, it's a household name - and in the end we all know a few things about it from the iconic designs of the Asari to the Normandy's shape and Commander Shepard's recognisable face. On the other hand that means whatever Bioware want to do next probably HAS to be tied into this universe somehow for the sake of rebuilding their mainstream reputation outside of Dragon Age. With new IP Shadow Realms now cancelled and the rumours of ME 4 centring around it having nothing in common with the original trilogy, it means whatever design doc they've got worked up could be moulded into a Mass Effect title anyway. Let's just hope it's Mass Effect in more than just name.

1. No Multiplayer

Chances are there's not a soul left on this earth who's playing Mass Effect 3's multiplayer anywhere nearly as furiously as Bioware would need to justify its development as time well spent. Instead, despite ME 3's multiplayer being serviceable enough, almost every Mass Effect fan would much rather they devoted all their resources to bolstering the main game. Either through art assets, character dialogue refinements, story inconsistences etc. fans want full steam ahead locomotion on Mass Effect 4 being the ultimate single player RPG experience like it was always born to be, without any needless distractions like XP only available online or the barest mention of the word 'deathmatch'. Tacked on multiplayer modes are the bane of otherwise spectacular solo experiences; they feel like cheap grabs at extending replayability any way you look at them, and there are always a million and one things better suited to an experience such as Mass Effect that'll keep people poking around the galaxy for longer than crowbarred-in matchmaking. Maybe not too much planetary probing though. What's on your personal wishlist for Mass Effect 4? Let us know in the comments!

Gaming Editor
Gaming Editor

WhatCulture's Head of Gaming.