Mass Effect 5: 10 Perfect Ways Bioware Can Save The Franchise
And we thought the pressure was on after Mass Effect 3.
It's safe to say at this point that as a franchise, Mass Effect is on life support. Its third instalment had one of the most roundly-despised endings in the history of gaming, and even though we gave Bioware the benefit of the doubt when 'resurrecting' the canon for Mass Effect Andromeda, scores of bugs, bad storylines and boring questlines quickly put that to bed.
Still, the question of, "Does the public want more Mass Effect?" was answered with a resounding "Actually, yes", as ME:A still sold very well, topping various platform and gaming charts for weeks post-launch. Naturally, these statistics don't take into account the amount of copies then traded back in after the reality of Andromeda's naff-ness settled in, but it's safe to say that the love we all feel for the trilogy can still be mined for profit.
To that end, what would be known as 'Mass Effect 5' could go either way. Andromeda is a totally self-contained story - save for a post-credits scene tagging on another powerful figure above the main villain - though considering the literal point-and-laugh reception the game received, it might be another five years before another instalment drops.
If/when it does, Bioware need - even more than they did post-ME 3 - to nail every aspect of ME5's creation from top to bottom, starting with...
10. Demonstrate Strong Marketing And Faith In The Product
Even if you weren't aware that various key members of Bioware departed in the wake of ME3's diabolic conclusion, the way EA drip-fed Andromeda's existence to the public was straight-up weird. Considering the story potential of what 'another Mass Effect' could be, fans actually got their first look during the unveiling of the PS4 Pro, where Andromeda was thrown in to sell some fancy 'dynamic lighting' effects for Sony's new system.
Then... nothing.
Nothing except multiplayer trailers and low-key "Welcome to the Andromeda Initiative" tidbits anyway, and nothing that even attempted to convince the masses that Bioware knew what they were doing. The assumption was that EA had granted another use of the license for nothing more than cashing in on its namesake, and naturally, come launch, solid shooting mechanics couldn't disguise the fact that Mass Effect Andromeda was about as essential to the canon as Han Solo shooting second was to Star Wars.
When EA finally get round to doing Mass Effect 5, they need to address the complaints head-on. Activision are currently apologising profusely for the state of Infinite Warfare as they attempt to showcase Call of Duty: WWII, and although apologies aren't necessary here, it's not hard to get Mass Effect fans excited, so get to it.
9. Lose The 'Dragon Age Inquisition In Space' Approach
Take my hand, Bioware, and say it with me: "I cannot make an open-world game".
Good, good.
We all know you tried, and we all see which parts of the competition you're trying to ape, but hundreds of fetch quests, completing basic, badly-rendered puzzles and following glowing objects around doesn't constitute entertainment, fun or poignance, okay?
Bioware seem to have looked at the likes of Bethesda, Ubisoft or perhaps Rockstar and thought to themselves, "So that's all you do? More of everything?", only the end result in their case is a complete mishmash of time-wasting goals that don't feed into any sense of progression. Mass Effect Andromeda's planets felt more like giant square landmasses peppered with game design straight out of an early 2000s MMO (one that isn't Warcraft).
Now, it can be satisfying to just gorge on 'Mission Complete!'-style pop-ups like continuing to graze through a large popcorn bucket halfway into a movie, but this approach nearly always turns to sheer boredom for the vast majority of players. We need narrative thrust, a reason to care, and set of locations that don't just look like you gave up halfway through and said, "That'll do."
We need planets and play-spaces as hyper-detailed as the franchise's lore codex. Nothing less will suffice.
8. Multiple Playable Alien Races
For the longest time, the assumption behind playing as a customisable human was to ground all real-world colours and creeds behind the notion of defending humanity as one; proving humans as a species could hang with the other intergalactic heavyweights in the Alliance.
However, four games on, an even stronger message of solidarity would surely be letting us become embroiled in various other alien cultures, drawing comparisons and creating talking points that mirror life on Earth. Showing the whole galaxy's races all go through similar squabbles? That would be one hell of a message, and Bioware already handled this expertly with their portrayal of Quarian citizenship mimicking various secluded religious views, but it's only the tip of the iceberg.
Mainly - like in the Elder Scrolls games - we just want to play as other races, see how NPCs react, see which abilities we're granted and ultimately, flesh out that notion of escapism through video games even more. Quarians, Turians, Krogan - even a newly-minted Geth discovering what life even is and 'feels' like - all of these would be phenomenal additions to the canon, providing a unique way to approach Mass Effect going forward.
7. Separate Multiplayer & Single-Player Into Standalone Releases
Let's just be honest: Gamers invested in Mass Effect as a story couldn't give two hoots about the multiplayer. Yes, they'll play it for a handful of matches, but it's not the driving force, whatsoever. Conversely, those who really adore the multiplayer - and they do exist, hence Mass Effect 3's player base staying strong to this day - aren't replaying the stories over and over, either.
So, please everybody. Separate the two chunks of the game into completely different releases.
Let the multiplayer portion of Bioware (the guys that took over the project in Andromeda's case) have their own standalone release, and flesh that portion of the game's mechanics out in a way that benefits online competition. You can even make it free-to-play, falling back on microtransactions to sustain, for the sake of satisfying those single-player gamers who would complain a mode was being removed entirely.
Said narrative-lovers though? They would get a dedicated single-player Mass Effect with no distractions.
No bolted on 'Galactic Readiness', no arbitrary 'companion apps' or 'Strike Team missions' to appease. I dare say nobody on the story side of things would really care if Bioware announced multiplayer was being siphoned off, as it can only strengthen two sides to Mass Effect that right now, feel leagues apart.
6. Redesign The Conversation System
I'm gonna go out on a limb and say the Paragon/Renegade system wasn't all that flawed. Yes, there were obvious binary outcomes to many in-game events, but that allowed Bioware to track said events across multiple games. After all, "Is X still alive?" is a much easier question to answer than "Were you kind, angry, dismissive or sarcastic, and how did that make them feel?"
To that end, Andromeda's 'overhauled' conversation system was supposed to give the player a more 'emotion-based' set of responses to characters and scenarios, the assumption being that those branching narrative pathways would then be more plentiful. Ultimately, it resulted in five variations on the exact same sentiment, unless you explicitly declined to do something - and even then, depending on what it was, you'd still get a prompt in your quest log.
Basically, this is a "If it ain't broke..." scenario. Fans weren't actively complaining about Paragon/Renegade, and even if Bioware do want to add more nuance and personality to our responses, the amount of hidden meters and checkboxes Mass Effect is then keeping track of, has to amount to something.
Look to the likes of The Witcher 3, where the ultimate ending you're given is predicated on a number of specific interactions you had with Ciri over the whole game. THAT was how to do an ending that encapsulated a number of 'human' dialogue options, resulting in something all who finished will always remember.
5. No More "You're The Chosen One" Narrative
Empowerment and escapism don't always go hand-in-hand, but they do in Bioware's games. From Dragon Age to Andromeda, Bioware have fallen back on giving your character some sort of 'activation' power that - especially in Andromeda - helps the protagonist make up for 1000s of years of progress in seconds.
Whether it's a magical incantation or a super-intelligent A.I. implant, the story of Andromeda far too often fell back onto "X monolith wasn't working until you came along!", and this translates into the wider structure of the world itself. You can tell Bioware are fans of this style of "You're the literal centre of the universe" narratives, but with so many games in, it would be a welcome change of pace to focus on somebody else entirely.
As a comparison, the entire point behind making the player embody Raiden in Metal Gear Solid 2 was to show Solid Snake from a completely different light. There is a TON of plot potential in analysing the aftermath of any given 'hero's actions (as the Marvel Cinematic Universe is finding), yet in a Bioware RPG, you save the galaxy, activate every console, solve every racial dispute etc., just by standing there.
We need a change. Simple as.
4. Don't Outsource The Facial Animations
Want a reason why Andromeda's launch day facial animations looked so hilariously terrible? It came down to EA literally and actively telling Bioware's coders that facial animation was not a priority. You can check out the full report from Bioware staffers discussing the issue here, but sufficed to say, the big takeaway is that EA Bucharest were given the job of sorting the faces out, rather than keeping it in-house.
This practice apparently wasn't due to money, it was simply a case of EA telling those involved that things such as gunplay, vehicles etc. were more important than how characters conversed with one another. Liam Robertson (from the linked clip) mentions that Bioware staff “actively went out of their way to offer their services to do additional work on the human character assets, and were turned away."
Going forward the solution is simple: Develop your technology in-house, with a dedicated team that understand your engine from top to bottom. Bioware's engines have been shaky when it comes to conversations at the best of times, but Mass Effect 5 is going to need to have L.A. Noire-levels of realistic facial movements, just to leave all those Andromeda gifs in the dust.
3. Give Us A Compelling Villain And/Or Narrative Setup
Saren and The Illusive Man, both brilliantly duplicitous, interesting villains with depth, nuance and above all, memorability. Saren's hidden good side ultimately being able to be drawn out in that final battle was a masterstroke, and although TIM stays firmly on the side of evil, the notion of an all-seeing, all-controlling entity that boils down to one individual is always compelling from a fictional standpoint.
In Andromeda we got the Archon, a cookie-cutter, Marvel or modern Star Trek-style villain. One note, one M.O. (kill everything) and nothing to write home about after the fact, the Archon exists only as a slightly more verbose target; one to be shut up and put down as soon as possible.
For Mass Effect 5, we need a scenario that immediately sparks player interest. That came from these mysterious and driven villains in games past, yet in Andromeda, the entire driving force to proceed was "You want to explore? This evil being is in your way".
What about navigating a scenario similar to the First Contact Wars, or something that mimics another Genophage and the considerations that go into it? As we're seeing in the real world, mutually assured destruction and nuclear power are nightly news topics, so why not take those concepts and use sci-fi to truly break them down?
2. Return To The Milky Way
As I noted in my "How Bioware Should Have Made Mass Effect Andromeda" piece, the only way to move forward from a catastrophic event like the close of Mass Effect 3 is to have the confidence to tackle it head on. I posited that we'd get multiple characters that knew of Shepard's actions who could discuss them accordingly, allowing for the player to have this quasi fourth wall-breaking discussion with the writers, where your squadmates would chime in with their opinion on the 'rumours' of the synthetic ending or meeting the space child.
This of course means picking an ending from the three and running with it, but this could be accomplished through a menu option or a series of recap videos for newcomers - either way, the aftermath of those decisions is interesting enough to make up for any lack of knowledge on the part of the player.
Point being, travelling to the Andromeda galaxy didn't actually achieve anything, or provide a worthwhile purpose other than to mentally 'distance' players from the events of Shepard. Every major action in the plot could've happened back home, and it's here where the franchise should belong - especially considering the contrived way Bioware wrote the reason why all the Milky Way races were still around.
Speaking of aliens...
1. Tons Upon Tons Of New Aliens, Plantlife, Environments Etc.
Bioware essentially wrote themselves a 'get out' clause when it came to expanding the variety of aliens and races within Mass Effect - the labelling of Council and non-Council races. The latter introduced us to the Batarians in ME1, and the Vorcha in ME2. Ostensibly, it's a way to play into the more 'hostile' or less cooperative aliens that don't want to take part in trans-galactic diplomacy.
To that end, it's an easy sell that there are entire colonies, tribes and ways of life continuing outside the 'governmental ring' that we've interacted with before. The first trilogy's Galaxy Map showed but a fraction of the Milky Way itself in detail, letting us skip over scores of planets on our way to completing specific main and side missions. Bioware even wrote miniature biographies for each one of these potential homesteads, it's just a case of fleshing them out into additional, worthwhile stories.
Because when you're touting any sort of space-based adventure, literally only having floating rocks as your 'jaw-dropping moment' is pathetic.
Outside of setting Mass Effect 5 in the same basic timeline as the trilogy, there's also the possibility of upending that entirely, having a character piece together "What happened" some hundreds of years in the future, thereby allowing Bioware to pick and choose which remnants of the canon they'd like continued.
Anything that lets us return to that sensation of genuine discovery from the original would be welcomed with open arms.
--
What do you want Bioware to do with Mass Effect? Let us know in the comments!