Metal Gear Solid V: Phantom Pain - 9 Big Questions It Should've Answered (But Didn't)

The "missing link" in the MGS saga? Yeah right.

For as much as Metal Gear Solid V was touted to be the "missing link" of the entire saga, bridging timelines and stories to solidify the entire series, the final game actually ended up raising more questions than it answered. Even ones that seemed to be certain bets, promised in the pre-release material or brought up in Ground Zeroes, remain unanswered by the end of The Phantom Pain's sixty hour-plus running time. While fans have since theorised why Kojima's final chapter left so many lingering threads unanswered, it's clear that something went wrong during the production of the fifth instalment. From cut episodes rounding out the arcs of key characters in the main game being nowhere to be found in the final release and modders unearthing a mysterious "Chapter 3" that was seemingly planned at some stage, it's obvious that there was originally far more to The Phantom Pain's story. Unfortunately, that means fans and players alike have been left to ponder what could have been, coming up with their own interpretations of the remaining questions raised. With new details being unearthed in the game every single day, there's a good chance that some of these could end up being answered in the coming weeks. However, until that happens, these are the most infuriating series-spanning questions that The Phantom Pain failed to answer. If there are any answers we're missing, please leave them down in the comments below - otherwise, sharpen that head-scratching finger. We're going in.


9. What Code Talker Meant By Keeping An Eye On Kaz

In a late-game cut-scene upon returning to Mother Base, Big Boss stumbles across Code Talker seemingly lost in a trance, spying on members of the Diamond Dogs. While most of what he says is kind of amusing and throwaway - Ocelot's aim is off, a few soldiers are meeting next to some containers - Code Talker also cryptically tells Snake to keep an eye on Kaz. It's a strange scene because it doesn't really amount to anything in-game. There's supposedly a spy in the midst, which explains everyone's hesitation and caution at this point in the story, however this moment sets up Kaz as an untrustworthy figure even though the rest of the title points to him being one of Big Boss' most loyal comrades. The mystery around Kaz is also alluded to early on while Huey's being interrogated by Ocelot, who also cryptically mentions that Kaz might have had something to do with the destruction of Mother Base 9 years ago. Unfortunately there's no in-game explanation for what these scenes might mean, and there's even less clues for fans to piece it together for themselves.

8. Where€™s Roy Campbell During All This?

Roy Campbell has had a rather weird run when it comes to the pre-Solid Snake Metal Gear games. First introduced in spin-off Portable Ops, Campbell was set-up to be Big Boss' right hand man, a trusted soldier with whom Naked Snake formed the Foxhound unit with. However, the uneasy state of Portable Ops as canon in the main series means the story of that game is entirely up in the air, and many were expecting The Phantom Pain to set the record straight once and for all. As it stands currently though, Campbell could either be tied to Big Boss in a direct way or could only be relevant to the story once the latter returns to Foxhound some time before the beginning of the first Metal Gear. With MGS V choosing to leave this portion of Big Boss' life unanswered, Campbell's role in the prequels is still as vague as ever.

7. The Meaning Of The Vol. 2 Tape In Ground Zeroes

One of the biggest mysteries of Ground Zeroes that fans are still speculating over to this day is the unusual tape that can be uncovered while exploring Camp Omega. Titled "Vol. 2" the tape was nothing other than a series of hidden frequencies mimicking the same noises of the MSX operating system. Unfortunately for would-be detectives though, the data included on the disc wasn't entirely comprised of MSX code, and therefore fans hit a wall in trying to decode the tape's hidden messages. Going into The Phantom Pain everyone thought that the answer to the tape, or at the very least a "Vol. 1" explaining the significance of the messages, would be found at some point. The cassette in Ground Zeroes was supposed to contain some sort of vital information that would tie in with the two games, however with no explanation to be found so far in The Phantom Pain, it's looking like fans are going to be in the dark about this particular Kojima oddity for a while. Even worse, the end of MGS V shows Big Boss playing a tape from "The Man Who Sold The World", and the B-side of that cassette also plays out in MSX frequencies similar to the original Ground Zeroes tape. Unfortunately, the scene only served to shroud this unanswered mystery in even more confusion and uncertainty.

6. Everything About Gray Fox

The omission of Gray Fox entirely in The Phantom Pain is almost inexcusable when you think about how easy it would have been to introduce the character in this instalment. Even if you exclude Portable Ops, which already established and set up the Big Boss and Gray Fox dynamic, the inclusion of the character in V would have been the perfect opportunity to establish one of the series' longest lingering threads. The franchise has already established that Gray Fox and Naomi Hunter were operating in Africa in the 80s, and as a result, fans quite rightly expected to bump into the characters in some form during the course of the new game's story. With the locations and the decade matching up so perfectly, it seemed obvious that either Gray Fox or Naomi would play into MGS V's narrative at some point. Of course, it wasn't to be, and both fan-favourites were nowhere to be found.

5. Why Big Boss Returns To Foxhound

Another major plot point The Phantom Pain chose to ignore was why Big Boss, a man notorious for having no allegiance to any nation after the events of MGS3, goes back to lead the USA-developed Foxhound. Considering the ambiguous ending of The Phantom Pain and Foxhound's critical role in the original Metal Gear, MGSV gave nothing concrete to explain why Big Boss would get himself involved with the organisation all over again. Sure, he was one of the main figures who helped create it in the first place, but why would he leave in the first place, help facilitate Diamond Dogs, and then suddenly decide to take back up his old position? It's a mystery The Phantom Pain never even remotely touches on.

4. How Diamond Dogs Turned Into Outer Heaven

It's mentioned in The Phantom Pain that the soldiers Snake recruits always abandon Mother Base once their leader is lost, because essentially, when it boils down to it, outfits like the Diamond Dogs or the MSF only survive because Big Boss is around to keep them all in order. So with this in mind, it's difficult to understand just how the relatively friendly Mother Base turns into the international threat of Outer Heaven. It's clear that Snake's coma at the start of V marks the end of the MSF, and his awakening is the start of the Diamond Dogs, yet the missing link as to how Mother Base became Outer Heaven is suspiciously absent from the final game. While this would be fine if there was another release to fill in the gap, as it stands The Phantom Pain is Kojima's final entry into the series, and thus the mystery behind the most important transition in the history of Big Boss' private military company will most likely never be answered.

3. Where Are Solidus And Solid Snake?

While MGSV made a great effort to clear up the timeline of the Les Enfants Terrible project and the shady background behind it, the game still didn't really flesh out what happened to both Solidus and Solid Snake once the clones were separated. Although Kojima made a great effort to explain what was going on with Eli aka Liquid Snake, the other two clones were left suspiciously absent. While we can probably guess what happens with David (Solid Snake) between the events of The Phantom Pain and Metal Gear, the absence of Solidus only makes the character even more difficult to place in the series' timeline. Supposedly the perfect clone, The Phantom Pain doesn't give any indication of what's going on with the future president of the United States, or why his cloning project worked so well. Hell, we still have no idea why Solidus is so old compared to Solid and Liquid during the events of the second Metal Gear Solid.

2. How Big Boss Became The Villain Of Metal Gear

Perhaps the biggest mystery and the biggest plot arc that was teased in the trailers, the reveal of why Big Boss transforms into the monster of the original Metal Gear, is never actually explained in Kojima's latest release. Hell, the character goes out of his way at points to show the audience just how much of good guy he is. From saving the child soldiers to giving the fallen Diamond Dogs the send-off they deserved, Big Boss on many occasions during the course of the game is shown to do the right thing even when succumbing to a dark side that would have made more sense for the narrative the title had been teasing. Look, Big Boss' warmongering, kidnapping and murderous ways doesn't make him the most innocent of protagonists, but nothing in this final game even hinted at how the character could go from how he is in V to the moustache-twirling villain of the original Metal Gear.

1. What Happened To Camp Omega?

One of the biggest mysteries left lingering after The Phantom Pain isn't actually from something brought up in that game, but the title's prequel, Ground Zeroes. Although a lot of the questions players had about the prison were answered in the prequel's cassette tapes, there were still a few purposefully unanswered threads that teased how the location would significantly play into MGS V proper. The relationship between Phantom Pain and Ground Zeroes was given even more significance in the run up to V's release, as Kojima promised a return to Camp Omega in the new title, all the while boasting about an innovative feature involved that could only be accomplished in video games. Unfortunately, it seems that whatever idea Kojima had for incorporating the camp was scrapped at the last minute, as the location isn't re-visitable, nor is it even mentioned. Whether the content was cut or whether Kojima was simply lying to players is unclear at this point, but one thing's for sure, the final mysteries around Camp Omega and the supposed 'game-changing' feature that would tie the location to The Phantom Pain is something fans will unfortunately never be able to experience. What were your biggest questions heading in, that were never answered? Let us know in the comments!

Contributor

Josh has over 11 years of experience as a published writer, having worked nine of those years as a full-time content producer at WhatCulture. In that period he has created hundreds of articles, videos and podcast episodes for multiple WhatCulture channels, specialising in gaming, horror and film & TV. He now primarily works as a senior content producer and presenter on WhatCulture Gaming where he co-hosts the WhatCulture Gaming Podcast, a top 3 UK most listened to gaming podcast that he co-created in 2018. Over the years he has reviewed several high-profile gaming releases, covered industry events with on-site reporting, opined on breaking news, and even kicked off his interviewing career by chatting to childhood hero, Tommy Wiseau.