NBA Live 18 Review: 3 Ups & 3 Downs
Don't call it a comeback.
After a one year hiatus, EA Sports is back with its version of NBA basketball. The sole fact that they refuse to give up is applaudable, especially when taking into account who they're up against. Comparing NBA Live and NBA 2K would be simply unfair, at least for now, so this review will approach NBA Live 18 as a singular, standalone game.
This approach does the game more justice, since the release is not a comeback per se, but an attempt at one.
Once we reasonably lower our expectations it's easy to see why EA Sports wants to continue releasing basketball video games - they know how to make them, even though they target a certain audience.
NBA Live 18 is a game for sports fans in general and not basketball fans specifically. It's a perfect product for what's been referred to by sports scholars as the "highlight generation," for fans who prefer to watch solely the highlights and not whole sporting events. That's why this EA Sports title is simple, quick and filled with athletic plays - it's easy to master and even easier to enjoy, hence appealing to a large audience.
Ups...
3. (Some Aspects Of) The Presentation
Signing the deal with ESPN was a great move by EA Sports. Thanks to it, The One, as well as in-game menus, look really professional.
The ESPN logo sometimes jams for a second, but that's fine, the sole presence of "The Worldwide Leader" and the instantly recognizable music are a nice touch of authenticity. During the game this mostly concerns starting lineup presentation, which looks like taken directly from an actual NBA game.
Commentary is also on point, and Jeff Van Gundy really takes his role seriously, bursting with excitement after highlight-worthy plays. The same goes for Steven A. Smith and Max Kellerman, who discuss your player, nicknamed The Comeback Kid, during their television program First Take.
Other commentator Mike Breen and expert/NBA legend Jalen Rose are also in the game and they're quite okay, although not as good as the previously-mentioned pundits.
2. It's Immediately Playable, Entertaining & Flows Well
NBA Live basketball is rather arcade basketball played by ridiculously athletic players and while true basketball fans may see it as it's main vice, others may see it as a virtue. The Defensive Assist button is really helpful when you're trying to slow down your opponent, while a very clear Shot Meter makes improving your offensive game quick and easy.
It's also not like NBA Live ignores general rules of basketball and physics and focuses solely on entertainment. At times NBA Live looks very real - even though it's mostly during plays showcasing the player's superhuman jumping abilities.
For example, the above play looks incredible, it's very natural and fluent. If a game of basketball only consisted of dunks and blocks, NBA Live 18 would be the best basketball video game out now.
1. WNBA
Political correctness aside, WNBA is really the most fun aspect of this game. This should suggest the direction that the creators should pursue in the future, as playing with female basketball players is more fun than expected. WNBA teams are only available in quick game mode in this edition, but hopefully they can appear in The Franchise next year as well.
While the player models are too mobile and "light" for men's basketball, female players actually look a lot better when performing similar plays as men. The females somehow seem more in place, more natural, as their play involves less strength and more finesse.
Seeing a 6'10" man almost 'float' on the court is discouraging, but seeing a 5'10" female do the same feels - and looks - just right.
Inclusion of WNBA teams is also a nice nod to female gamers and basketball players alike, who can finally play as their idols.
Downs...
3. Lack Of Balance
One of the main problems regarding NBA Live 18 is lack of consequence. For example, driving into the lane is rather easy, while shooting next to an opponent that's not doing much, just standing next to you, can be extra hard. Big men are quick and agile, and don't have have a problem bringing the ball up the court and attempting reverse dunks or lay-ups. Generally, the way to succeed is through individual, not team plays.
In regards to presentation, it fails to adjust to important moments. When you win a championship the commentators don't seem to understand this profound moment. The championship celebration is also more "meh" than anything.
The One is the best game mode of NBA Live 18, but even it can get frustrating, as your teammates too often prefer to stand behind the three point line and wait for your move than actually participate in the game.
2. It Tends To Get... Strange
The game needs to switch to the Frostbite engine as soon as possible, because graphically it's simply not impressive.
Player models need to be updated, because the players look more like superheroes than actual people. The differences between different players and their frames aren't stressed enough, which results in too many players looking very similar despite substantial differences regarding their height and/or weight.
There's also a strange aura around them from time to time, but this is due to bad lighting, which makes the court look unnatural; simply too bright. The baskets themselves and crowd look realistic, however these positives get lost when looking at the floor and what's happening on it.
"Strange" is also the nicest way to describe how the players can still score from mid-range or three, despite gameplay sliders being set at zero. Similarly, a slider set at one hundred doesn't guarantee any shot will actually go in. While this might be fine since ridiculous shots won't count anyway, an open shot should guarantee easy points. Here, it doesn't.
1. 'The Franchise' Mode
The Franchise mode is simply awful. Before starting it's better to turn off cap space, because it'll lead to nothing but frustration - if a team is over the cap space (and almost every team in the NBA has that problem), the game automatically prevents you from making a trade. For example, if your team is $20M over the cap, you need to first get rid of that $20M in contracts but also make sure that the other team isn't over the cap after the trade as well.
Also, once your trades are rejected you don't get any counter offers, nor get a real understanding of how team preferences really work - even though it's indicated that a team has a high interest in your player, your offer may be rejected precisely because it has no interest in him.
Apart from the ridiculous trade system, you can't change player positions or scout rookies. Also, during simulation CPU sometimes changes up your roster, which can be really annoying. The process of re-signing players is oversimplified and so is the process of team management. Granted, your starters look nice standing next to each other in the Franchise menu, but that's where the positives end.
The fact that you can automate all tasks regarding team management is all you need to know about the realism of this mode.