Nintendo Switch Reviews: 12 Critical Reactions You Need To Know
Mixed notices for Nintendo's work-in-progress console.
After an uncommonly brief hype period for a new console, the Nintendo Switch is here, and the gaming press at large have had a few weeks to tinker around with the new device Nintendo hopes will erase all those bad memories of their largely abandoned Wii U.
It's clear from the rather mixed response to the console so far that it's going to be a marathon rather than a sprint back into the general public's good graces, though it remains to be seen whether the switch gimmick itself is going to make a sufficient impact with the casual gaming crowd.
The Switch's promise is clear, even in spite of some glaring issues Nintendo stubbornly refused to remedy before launch, so it just depends on how eagerly they will capitalise on their shiny new device, or simply end up condemning it to become another commercial disappointment. Just announce another damn Metroid Prime game already, OK?
Here are 12 critical reactions you need to know about the Nintendo Switch...
12. Switching Between Handheld & TV Is Mostly Seamless
"It definitely works as advertised: within a couple of seconds of dropping the tablet onto the dock, the picture transfers right over to the TV, and after detaching the Joy-Con (or using a separately purchased Pro Controller) you’re ready to play. The transition back to handheld mode is just as seamless, which is definitely impressive." - IGN
"The Nintendo Switch completely blurs that line between home and portable gaming. Now I can take Zelda with me wherever I go — not some limited version, mind you, but the full console Zelda experience. I can play on my TV, pick up the tablet from its dock, and continue the game without skipping a beat or compromising the experience." - The Verge
A common thread running through the reviews is that though some outlets aren't entirely sold on the console's longevity or mass appeal, it does execute its central gimmick well, in creating a home console-handheld hybrid that allows gamers to have fully-fledged AAA gaming experiences both at home and on the move.
If this wasn't so seamless, the console could've ended up DOA, but that's thankfully not the case.
11. It Is A Clear Product Of Compromise
"The Switch is a beguiling, flawed piece of hardware that isn’t like any other gaming system I’ve owned. It executes its main idea well enough that its shortcomings are alternately forgivable and all the more frustrating... I predict the Switch will make a great many people happy, and a great many people angry. It is a Nintendo product, after all." - Kotaku
"The Switch is a console sandwiched between a bar of success lowered by the disaster of the Wii U and the considerable ground Nintendo must make up." - Polygon
The one single word that appeared in more reviews than anything else was "compromise". Many critics feel that the console isn't merely a compromise between the design philosophies of the home and handheld markets, but also in terms of controls, technical capabilities, and an evident, desperate desire to keep the price down while offering experiences that can compete with what Sony and Microsoft have to offer.
The prevailing verdict is that these compromises are often frustrating from a consumer point of view, even though on a pure tech level the Switch is mostly agreed to be an impressive and innovative piece of kit, all the more so once the price drops a little.
10. Handheld Mode Is Awesome
"For Breath of the Wild, the Switch renders in 720p in handheld mode instead of TV mode’s 900p, so framerates were more consistent...The compressed textures and lack of anti-aliasing were also far less impactful on the smaller screen, and combined with the lack of Joy-Con syncing problems, this made handheld mode my go-to when I wanted the best possible overall experience." - IGN
"If I pop the console out of the dock and start playing in tablet mode, everything immediately runs more smoothly. The frame rate is solid in the same places (with a few exceptions), and the overall image is crisper. The disparity is likely because the Switch runs at 720p resolution in handheld mode and bumps up to a more demanding higher resolution (1080p in general, 900p in the case of Zelda) when plugged into the TV." - Kotaku
Despite the fairly mixed reception to the Switch overall, there was near-universal praise for playing the game in handheld tablet mode, where many of the unit's core issues aren't at all apparent.
Performance-wise, games look fantastic on the small screen, and critics also commended the screen's brightness settings, which will allow for easy playing outside in the sun over the coming months.
The handheld mode being called "the best possible experience" despite touting a lower resolution has to be a bit embarrassing for Nintendo, though.
9. Battery Life Is Disappointing (But Not Unexpected)
"Expect just over three hours of use with while playing intensive titles, on either low or 50 per cent brightness, with volume set halfway, and WiFi enabled...It's not an impressive number, and at maximum brightness it gets worse still, at two hours and 37 minutes. In fairness, [Zelda] is one of the most demanding Switch games available. Nintendo claims battery life can stretch to six hours given less taxing software, but it sets the bar for what to expect in major 3D games." - Eurogamer
"If you’re planning on taking the Switch on a train or plane, you'll definitely want to bring the charging cable with you...While this isn’t the worst-performing handheld battery life, it certainly isn’t the kind of marathon performance you might hope for from a daily companion." - Polygon
To their credit, Nintendo made it clear a while ago that the Switch's battery life would last from 2.5-6 hours, and predictions seem to be bang on the money that intensive 3D games such as The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild can't even make it to the three-hour mark without the player turning brightness and other factors down.
Considering that most reviewers have been playing Zelda above all else, it's pretty much still unknown if the battery can make it to six hours while playing any game. The main take-away here is that you need to have a charger cable and power outlet nearby if traveling for extended periods.
8. The Joy-Con Controls Could Be Better
"The Joy-Con are a nifty idea, though they don’t always work as well as I would’ve hoped. For starters, I simply haven’t found them very comfortable. I find that the buttons are oddly placed and the thumbsticks feel small and overly flippy...I spent several days playing Zelda with the Joy-Con combined onto the controller grip and while it was serviceable, I never got fully comfortable...For games you’d play on your TV, they’re a lackluster substitute for a full-sized, standard game controller." - Kotaku
"This Voltron-esque configuration won’t be beating Sony’s Dual Shock 4 any time soon, but it’s far more comfortable and functional than I imagined it would be from just looking at it. The smallish face buttons are sufficiently clicky and easy to hit, but the lack of a traditional D-pad or full-sized analog triggers will put it at a disadvantage for certain types of games...It’s easy enough to adjust to these tiny quirks, but even once I did, the Joy-Con never felt quite like home the way a great controller should." - IGN
"The Joy-Cons, when connected to the Switch, are...fine...They’re not quite what you would demand of a dedicated console controller, but they’re mostly close enough." - Polygon
The Joy-Con controllers have received a fairly mixed response so far, with many admitting that they found them more comfortable than they expected, but that they're still a poor substitute for a more uniform controller, especially during prolonged gaming sessions.
Thankfully, Nintendo does have a solution to this problem, but it comes at a cost...
7. The Pro Controller Is Definitely Worth Buying
"For a full-fledged, traditional gaming controller, the Switch's Pro pad really is the way to go. Sadly, it is another expensive Switch accessory, but you do get a proper d-pad this time and a larger battery rated for 40 hours while the analogue sticks are larger and more accurate...In short, this is the real deal. If you're planning on using the Switch as a docked home console, and if you can take the price, the Pro controller comes highly recommended." - Eurogamer
"I also highly recommend getting a Switch Pro Controller, which costs $70...The Pro Controller...makes it much easier to use the Switch to 'switch' seamlessly. You pop the console into its dock, pick up the controller, and play. If you want to take it on the go, pop it out and you’re ready to rock. Without a Pro Controller, you have to disassemble and reattach the controllers each time you go from TV to mobile, as well as anytime you want to charge the Joy-Con. It significantly slows down an otherwise pleasingly snappy process." - Kotaku
You're going to pay through the nose for it, but can you really put a price on comfort when you're going to be pouring hopefully hundreds of hours into your Nintendo Switch?
The Pro Controller plays like a dream according to just about every outlet that was lucky enough to receive one, and that's hardly surprising considering how much more ergonomic it looks, free of the design challenges associated with the Joy-Cons.
6. The Hard Drive Is Too Small
"With 32GB of pre-installed flash NAND memory, out of which only 25.9GB is usable, you will need to ration your space carefully with digital purchases. For small indie games this shouldn't be an issue, but it's easy to see major releases chewing through this quickly." - Eurogamer
"There’s no way you’ll be able to go digital with your library unless you buy a hefty SD card (Nintendo says cards up to 2TB will be supported, but that functionality is not yet enabled). Given that Dragon Quest Heroes is the same size as the Switch’s entire internal storage, it’s surprising that Nintendo didn’t at least offer an option for a system with a more respectable storage capacity." - IGN
This was basically clear from the moment the specs were announced, but it's always nice to have confirmation: the Switch's 32GB internal hard drive is hilariously small and, honestly, pretty embarrassing.
Yes, it'll be easy enough for players to add more space themselves, but this just feels like a desperation move to keep the console's price low, rather than launching it with an adequate amount of space considering that the PS4 and Xbox One launched with 500GB hard drives each over three years ago.
5. Joy-Con De-Sync Is A Major Issue
"Apparently, the left Joy-Con is an area where Nintendo could’ve spent a little more. I’m not the only person experiencing de-syncs with it relatively often when playing with the Joy-Con detached or in the Joy-Con Grip, leaving inputs temporarily unread until it reconnects a few seconds later. I’ve seen it happen occasionally with The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild – Link died more than a few senseless deaths this way – but more often when playing 1-2-Switch, which has several mini-games that require you to cover most of the Joy-Con with you hand, potentially interfering with its signal." - IGN
"The left half of the Joy-Con controller simply won’t stay synced to the console. Either it’s connected but severely laggy, so button presses either register late or not at all, or it simply drops the connection. It’s a total showstopper. I cannot play Switch on the television—not unless I buy an optional “Pro Controller” for $70, that is." - Wired
"It's important to be mindful that there are some reports of the Joy-Con de-syncing when the system is docked, but I have never had this happen, even once, in my over 60 hours of testing." - Destructoid
Word about the left Joy-Con's sync issues actually found its way online several days before the Switch's hardware embargo lifted, and left many fans anxious about what it might mean for the launch.
Nintendo are reportedly looking into the issue but have yet to offer any real word on it, though the consensus seems to be that a firmware patch altering the Joy-Con's Bluetooth frequency should fix the issue.
Still, it's a pretty embarrassing gaffe right out of the box, especially considering how many journalists it's affecting, and how this surely couldn't have slipped through hardware testing.
4. Zelda Is A Day-1 Killer App
"Most new video game consoles arrive alongside a couple of big budget launch games. Rarely do those games make much of a lasting impression...With the Switch, Nintendo is bucking that convention and harkening back to their Super Mario 64-driven Nintendo 64 launch by offering an unusually small launch lineup dominated by one spectacular game...This latest Zelda is an astonishing demonstration of what Nintendo’s best creative minds are capable of. At times I have had to consciously separate my adoration for the game from my more complicated feelings about the system on which I’m playing it...Breath of the Wild is a massive open-world adventure with numerous complicated simulations running on top of one another. It’s the most technically ambitious Nintendo game I’ve ever played." - Kotaku
"There is something remarkable about seeing The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild running in portable mode, followed by that 'wow' moment of docking the console and continuing on a television." - Polygon
There has been nothing short of universal praise for the new Zelda game, which arrives on a tidal wave of hype, and considering how rare it is for a console to launch with one great game let alone one being called a masterpiece by many publications, Nintendo clearly knew what they were doing here.
It's a bold strategy for Nintendo to release the Switch with such a minimalist launch lineup, but considering that practically every Switch owner will be picking up Zelda, it may well have worked out for the best.
3. There Are Lots Of Small Annoyances
"The kickstand on the back of the Switch is flimsy and seems destined to snap off...Both the Joy-Con grip and the Pro Controller lack a headphone output...The charging port is on the bottom of the Switch, which...means you can’t prop up the screen on a table while charging it...The release buttons you use to detach the Joy-Con are small and hard to press without accidentally pressing other buttons as well. The caps that slide over the Joy-Con when you’re using them separately are oddly tricky to get on and off. There’s no HDMI output on the tablet...There’s no support for bluetooth headsets...The included HDMI cable is a hair under 5’ long...The included Joy-Con grip doesn’t charge the controllers...Your only alternative is to buy a Pro Controller or shell out $30 for a nearly identical “charge grip” with a USB input. The console apparently drains some of its battery even when docked—I’ll put it in the dock at 100% charge, play for a while, and when I take it out, it’ll say it’s at 88% charge." - Kotaku
"It highlights the push and pull that typifies the system: it’s trying to be so many things at once that it can’t pull any of them off perfectly." - IGN
That's just a sampling of the avalanche of irritations Kotaku listed about the Switch, which in isolation wouldn't be so bad, but together can result in an unintuitive experience that's nowhere near as simple or user-friendly as it should be.
Naturally mileage is going to vary vastly in terms of how annoying these grievances actually are, but some of the design choices clearly come across as schizophrenic and counter to conventional logic. No doubt some of them will receive not-so-elegant fixes from frustrated consumers, while others may simply be whined about for the entirety of the Switch's lifespan.
2. There's Still A Lot We Don't Know
"The Switch’s entire online infrastructure is being patched into the system on the same day it reaches consumers. None of these features, or even a clear understanding of what they will be, were made available to reviewers. This…is not a good litmus test for Nintendo’s future success in this arena...A considerable amount of its functionality is tied to a major system update that isn’t live yet, and which Nintendo has not committed to delivering prior to the Switch’s general availability on March 3. Even more alarming, Nintendo all but refuses to answer questions about the system’s pending update, even while the review embargo precedes it by more than a day." - Polygon
"Nintendo says we can publish a review of [the Switch] right now, though I have no idea why Nintendo would want us to. The company’s new toy isn’t finished yet." - Wired
Critics have been put in something of an awkward position when it comes to reviewing the Switch: they've been able to toy with the units for 1-2 weeks, but haven't been given access to a number of key features that will be patched in on launch (apparently).
As such, there are many questions that the press have been unable to answer, such as: What is the e-shop like? Are purchases finally unified between Nintendo consoles? How exactly does the phone-based online multiplayer work? How will Virtual Console work, which platforms will it cover and when will it actually launch? When will video apps such as Netflix and YouTube be available? What will actually be contained in the day-1 patch?
It's frustrating how uncommunicative Nintendo famously are about matters such as this, and on the eve of a console launch even more so. Fingers crossed everything works out in the end, but best to avoid disappointment by expecting at least a few bumps in the road.
1. Technical Limitations Could Hurt It In The Long Run
"Breath of the Wild, which was developed simultaneously on the Wii U, seldom quite makes it all the way to 30 frames per second in TV mode, and it even dips far south of that when lots of particles or physics objects are on screen at once. That it suffers from these performance issues despite a lack of anti-aliasing does not bode well for the system’s long-term capabilities – or its prospects for landing ports of big-budget AAA games...Even the massive, sprawling world of Breath of the Wild is housed in a tiny 13.4GB file, and on a big, 1080p screen, it becomes fairly obvious that many of the textures have been heavily compressed." - IGN
"Breath of the Wild looks and performs noticeably worse when plugged into the dock than it does in handheld mode, a potentially worrying indicator of how the Switch’s graphics processing hardware will hold up over time...Any time I’m running in tree-shade on a sunny day in Hyrule, zooming in for a closer view, or moving quickly through the rain, it feels like things drop into at least the 20-25fps zone...It’s worrisome that Nintendo’s own developers have been unable to get their top-billed game running equally well on TV and in handheld mode...It’s not a reassuring start." - Kotaku
And finally, numerous outlets were surprised by how the hardware struggled to run Breath of the Wild at a consistent framerate, which given the hand-wringing over the poorly optimised Wii U footage of the game, just seems ridiculous on a brand-new console.
The point here is that the graphical ceiling for the console may be rather low and be unable to evolve much beyond what Zelda is capable of. Ultimately it's not a deal breaker as Nintendo consoles are rarely that fussed about top-tier graphics, but it's still rather worrisome that in 2 or 3 years' time the platform's games could look massively behind the curve.
Fingers crossed that developers find clever ways to make the most of the Switch's hardware and keep things running at a smooth 30 FPS.
--
What do you think of the Nintendo Switch reviews so far? Getting one on launch or waiting for a while? Shout it out in the comments!