Overwatch Halloween Terror 2018: Ranking Every Skin

No one does Halloween like Overwatch.

Mei Overwatch
Blizzard

Customisation and personalisation have always been right at the heart of Overwatch. Obviously, a huge part of that is playing as each character to figure out which playstyle suits you best. Unlike a lot of other games in this genre, support and medic characters have just as much value as the straight up offensive tanks.

But the customisation runs deeper. There are skins and victory poses for you to unlock as well to make your character truly your own. After overblown controversy about Tracer’s pose, these unlockables feel like a core part of Overwatch’s DNA.

The devs have been great with support in this regard, and with the game in general. Summer, Christmas and previous Halloweens have all seen special skins released for fans to dress their favourites up in. This year is no different, with nine characters getting the spooky treatment.

In that mix there’s some of the most beloved heroes, some under-appreciated characters and relative newcomers getting in on the action... but who looks the best?

9. Doomfist - Swamp Monster

Doomfist Overwatch
Blizzard

How did a Halloween costume make him less scary? It’s not that this is even a good idea badly executed; it’s a bad idea altogether.

Doomfish, as Overwatch fans quickly named this one, is a legendary costume but it’s pretty far below legendary par. It’s propping this list up beneath the three epic skins too. Would it work without the huge arm? Possibly, but then that’s a huge part of his character. They could have given him a gross, infected, boil ridden limb, or even gone the Big Daddy route. They’ve done a character tribute elsewhere in Halloween Terror, and it’s much better than this.

It isn’t his worst skin, not when you consider a lot of his rare ones are mere palette swaps. But looking at his back catalogue, other than his Formal (and maybe his Talon) skin, you see a distinct lack of personality.

Overwatch’s lack of story has never been a huge concern for the fanbase. Characters like Tracer, Mercy and Reaper have enough personality to carry what little story the game implies. With Doomfist though, you sometimes get the idea the game doesn’t know exactly what to make of him.


8. Widowmaker - Spider

Widowmaker Overwatch
Blizzard

Can’t imagine the design team took too long here. Giving the spider lady a spider costume? It’s Halloweeny, but that is a seriously low bar for a Halloween skin.

It’s above Doomfist purely by the virtue that despite its extreme laziness, it does look vaguely cool. Nowhere near as cool as Florida Mayhem, Nova or Côte d’Azur, but cool nonetheless. It’s just a shame that again, it’s wasted potential.

Widowmaker is one of the Overwatch characters most suited to Halloween; why they lowballed her with an epic skin instead of giving her a much more ambitious legendary is anyone’s guess.

She seems perfect for the femme fatale angle. Halloween is known for its spookiness, but there’s a fun vibrancy to it. Seeing a Widowmaker skin following this pathway might have been better received than just sticking spiderwebs on her legs. When your design for a skin on a globally popular shooter takes the same attitude as a burnt out teacher taping webs to classroom walls, you know you’re doing something wrong.

Any fans of Widowmaker will likely have a better skin than this in their roster anyway.


7. Pharah - Enchanted Armour

Pharah Overwatch
Blizzard

Pharah’s Halloween skin suffers from a similar problem to the two proceeding it. None of them feel particularly in tune with their characters, and as a result feel like downgrades, especially when compared to the best skins Pharah, Doomfist and Widowmaker have to offer. Last year’s Possessed wasn’t amazing either, but it was better.

Considering that they’ve pretty much removed Pharah from this skin altogether, there’s no real surprise it’s lacking personality. That’s a nice twist at least, but it’s a twist in the same way it’d be a twist if you booked tickets for Metallica and Taylor Swift came on stage. It isn’t bad, necessarily, but it certainly isn’t what you’ve paid for. It’s a Pharah skin with no Pharah, at the end of the day.

Strangely, as other skins indicate too, the armour seems to hold Pharah back from a creativity perspective. With it being such a huge part of her image, most skins are just palette changes. At least this one thinks outside the box in all fairness.

Climbs above Doomfist and Widowmaker because having it collapse as if empty when the player dies is a nifty little feature.


6. Moira - Banshee

Moira Overwatch
Blizzard

While it’s not mathematically in the centre, Moira’s Banshee skin marks middle ground between the three uninspiring ones and the five great ones.

On its own merit, the skin is well designed, being the right level of spooky and creepy for a Halloween event. It just feels like it perhaps misses the mark of her fabulous Eireannach skin.

Like Widowmaker, she feels like one of the characters most malleable to a Halloween event. But again, this skin plays it a little safe. There certainly was more thought poured into this skin than the spiderwebs stuck onto Widowmaker’s thighs, but Blizzard could’ve taken a bigger risk. Outside of the box thinking backfired on Doomfist, but it paid off handsomely for others on this list.

As one of the newer members of the Overwatch stable, in some ways it makes sense that they’ve given Moira a skin that stands out so much. The Banshee skin is memorable, but it doesn’t necessarily feel in line with her biotic powers the way something like a sorceress would be. Tapping into the character might have been less attention grabbing, but might have made more of a connection.


5. McCree - Undead

McCree Overwatch
Blizzard

Turning this killer cowboy into a skeleton just in time for Red Dead Redemption 2 was a genius piece of marketing. Many people will have been replaying the brilliant first Red Dead Redemption game, including the essential DLC Undead Nightmare. With the cowboys and zombies crossover considered one of the greatest DLCs of all time, this skin will definitely have set some nostalgia alarms blaring.

McCree marks the start of a severe spike in quality. The top five are all, for various reasons, considerably better than those that came before. It might even seem a little harsh for McCree’s awesome skin to place just one above the very meh Moira, but with Sherlock, Scrooge and last Halloween’s Van Helsing to live up to, McCree’s set himself a high bar.

There’s a nice little metaphor in there too, if you’re prepared to work for it. McCree’s whole deal is that he’s atoning for past sins. Putting right what once went wrong, Quantum Leap style. Almost as if his old life is dead, but still following him around wherever he goes, like a zombie.


4. Sombra - Bride

Sombra Overwatch
Blizzard

Sombra’s legendary Halloween skin feels the most like an actual Halloween costume of the entire pack. The whole ‘ex-wife’ gag recalls the cult chick flick Mean Girls, while the slick new hairdo has shades of the Bride of Frankenstein or Bellatrix Lestrange.

Sombra has one of the best selection of skins in all of Overwatch. Is this her best? More than anything else on this list, that’s a matter of opinion. Each skin seems to suggest something new about her. With her being so secretive and hard to read, it’s up to your own interpretation to figure out what suits her sensibilities best.

However, it just misses out on the medal positions because of the diversity of Sombra’s characterisation. She’s had so many skins and is so elusive and mysterious, it’s hard to fully understand her personality. You feel like she’s the kind of woman who’d wear a plain t-shirt emblazoned with ‘Costume’ to an actual Halloween party.

Because of this, while the Bride skin is cool, it doesn’t strike at the heart of the character like the other three above her do.


3. Mei - Pumpkin

Mei Overwatch
Blizzard

It isn’t scary, but it fits her cutesy character perfectly. Halloween costumes don’t need to be terrifying, after all. Considering it’s only an epic, it’s way better than a lot of the legendaries on offer.

As it’s an epic, it is just adding colours to her usual fur hooded coat. It’s not as good as her Christmas skin Mei-rry, but just like that one it’s quintessentially Mei. If you don’t like her as a character you aren’t going to like this skin, but then you’ll have no real cause to buy it or wear it.

What it lacks in wow factor it more than makes up for in charm. Being such a cheerful soul, it really wouldn’t have made sense if Mei’s skin had been dripping with buckets of blood and gore. While it’s true that Sombra’s bride is the most costume-like, that’s only because Mei’s is a paint job on her usual coat. The general idea of dressing like a pumpkin is totally Mei.

If anyone still needed convincing, the adorable pumpkin key chain dangling from her hairpin surely sells this.


2. Soldier: 76 - Slasher: 76

Soldier 76 Overwatch
Blizzard

The stars just aligned for this costume this year. Jason Voorhees is an iconic horror character, but various Friday the 13th flops over the years prove he isn’t cast iron reliable. However, Soldier: 76 feels like the perfect character for this skin, while Michael Myers’ box office success with this year’s Halloween has set those slasher flick nostalgia glands tingling again.

There’s just the fact it’s incredibly cool too. It can’t be overstated how much Blizzard swung for the fences here. They could’ve had Reaper as Ghostface, but that wouldn’t have surprised the fans half as much. Soldier: 76 is usually quite cut and dried. Putting him in a larger than life skin like Jason could have easily backfired and wound up being goofy and disjointed. Instead, it fits like a crinkled yellow glove.

It’s not just a tribute to Jason either. They couldn’t really call the costume Slasher and not add in some slashing, after all. A la Gears Of War, Slasher: 76 equips Soldier: 76 with an ultra violent chainsaw add on to the rifle.

Stacks of people will be donning classic movie character costumes on Halloween. There’s no reason the Overwatch crew shouldn’t either.


1. Wrecking Ball - Jack-O-Lantern

Wrecking Ball Overwatch
Blizzard

This costume is just genius. It’s so inventive and so obviously Halloweeny, this has to be one of the most coveted event skins Overwatch have ever put out.

Wrecking Ball (or Hammond, technically) doesn’t always enjoy the popularity of say, Genji, with the fans. None of the characters are hated, but if Wrecking Ball gets another couple of skins like this, he’s going to swiftly climb in the popularity stakes.

With the nature of this character and his reliance on his mech, it’s not surprising that most - if not all - of Wrecking Ball’s skins to date have been a little bland. He’s similar to Pharah in that regard. This Halloween skin eschews this marvellously, giving him a huge, mechanical Jack-O-Lantern to ride around in. It’s like if Wild Wild West was made by goths. And Will Smith was a hamster. And it was actually good. Okay, maybe it’s not like Wild Wild West.

It fully uses every inch of the character too. While Widowmaker’s design team clearly broke for an early lunch, Wrecking Ball’s must have stayed late. It’s creativity like this that gives fans something to look forward to.


In this post: 
Overwatch
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

Self appointed queen of the SJWs. Find me on Twitter @FiveTacey (The 5 looks like an S. Do you get it? Do you get my joke about the 5?)