Pokémon Sun And Moon Review: 6 Ups And 3 Downs

The best since Red and Blue?

Pokemon Sun And Moon
The Pokémon Company

Rating: ★★★★☆

The Year of our Lord Two Thousand and Sixteen will, it's fair to say, not be remembered all that fondly. From every single person who wrote a good song in the 80s dropping down dead, to politics as a concept simply curling up in a ball to die, this particular rotation around the sun isn't going to be looked back on with much fondness at all. Except of course, if you like Pokémon.

You see, if there's been one tiny flower that's grown out of this 365 day long casket of dung, it's been Pokémon. Cast your minds back to the hazy heat of the summer, and the only memory that nearly salvages 2016 is traipsing around cities and parks with your friends excitedly catching things in Pokémon Go.

The mobile phenomenon might have faded away due to a combination of developmental mishandling and everyone reeling from their data bills, but the franchise has just returned to its spiritual home of the Nintendo handheld. Sun and Moon, possibly the most anticipated Pokémon games since Red and Blue themselves has arrived and, by and large, it hasn't disappointed.

Game Freak promised the best Pokémon experience since the original release of Red and Blue


Ups:

9. The Nostalgia Factor

pokemon go tracking
Nintendo

There's a very good reason why Pokémon Go was at the forefront of my mind when I opened this article, and that's because it seems to have been at the forefront of Nintendo's as well. After spending the better part of 20 years producing these games for the same core audience, they all of a sudden found themselves with a huge potential market this year.

From a business perspective, look at it this way. Pokémon Alpha and Omega sold just over 3 million units in two years, Pokémon GO had 45 million playing every single day. That's an extra 42 million people who you know have at least a passing interest in your product - appealing to them must understandably have been priority number 1 during development.

The result hasn't been drastic, but right from the off there's an overwhelming amount of the original 150 kicking about to be caught. Without going out of your way to find them, players can have a Pikachu, Growlithe, Caterpie, Mankey, Eevee, Abra, Drowzee, Spearow and Jigglypuff within the first few hours of playing. Vastly outnumbering the other 650+ species in the game.

A cynical ploy to make the game as familiar to new players as possible this might be, but given how well-loved the original game's creatures are it really does improve the opening stages of Sun and Moon.


8. The Overall Environment

pokemon sun and moon
Nintendo

Given how much of a fuss Pokémon games make about the regions in which they're set, there's never really been too much to separate one from another. Johto, Kanto, Hoenn, Sinnoh, Unova and Kalos have all been pretty much of a muchness - large cities broken up by grass-laden roads and a few extreme weather environments. Alola feels completely different.

It's easy to pin that all on the fact it's in a more tropical setting, but even the very layout of paths and towns feels completely different to previous installment. Where other titles have felt like 2D games rendered in 3D, Sun and Moon feels as close to an open world setting as we've seen with the franchise. Paths wind around every-which-way and you're even presented with more than one route to take.

The island set up also gives a real sense of exploration and size to the overall game as well, with each individual land mass presented as its own entity with different areas and no linear path through it. Yes, certain areas won't open up until you've achieved certain things, but Sun and Moon lets you feel like you can explore.


7. Revamping Gyms

Wishiwashi Totem Pokemon Sun And Moon
Game Freak

Here at WhatCulture, some genius wrote all the way back in May that the classic Pokémon Gym system was in desperate need of some overhaul. You go to a town, you find the gym, the person inside has a team of the same type of Pokémon, which you rush through using whatever you've got that's strong against it. Collect you badge, and on your merry way.

In Sun and Moon, the model's not quite been torn up, but it's still worlds away from what players have seen previously. Each island effectively doubles as one long gym challenge, with puzzles, sub-leaders and overpowered (and oversized) Totem Pokémon. All of these offer a great variety to the challenge, and require strategies more complex than simply 'have type advantage'.

Ultimately your fate comes down to the battling the island's Kahuna, who is a gym leader in all but name, but earning the right to battle is considerably more fun than it has been in any generation prior.


6. Getting To Interact With Your Pokémon

Pokemon Sun Moon Amie
Nintendo

This is corny, I'll grant you, but introducing a feature where by you actually have to pay your Pokémon attention outside of battle is a really, really nice touch. Using the touchscreen, players can tend to and clean their Pokemon after battles (literally toweling them down if they're dirty, blowdrying them if they've been hit with water attacks etc), feed them special beans to keep their energy up, and pat them to let them know they're doing a good job.

After investing so much in your teams in years gone by, it always feels a little flat that the most you'll ever interact with them is issuing one of four commands in a battle. Having one follow you around in the Gold/Silver remakes was nice, as were the pageants, but you never quite felt a sense of interaction with them. Knowing that your starter particularly likes a rub under its chin adds an unquantifiable personal touch to things.

What's most impressive here though is that this isn't merely a cosmetic feature. Having a team who are well fed and happy will positively impact their ability in battle; healing themselves of status ailments, scoring critical hits more frequently and, best of all, stopping themselves from going to 0HP. After 20 years of experimentation the game has finally captured that anime quality of the strongest Pokémon being those with the strongest bond to their trainers.


5. Alolan Variants

Alolan Pokemon
Game Freak

It's a bit strange putting this in as an Up as, technically, it's made me furious, but having redesigned classic Pokémon as the core of the new additions was brilliant. So brilliant, in fact, that I feel genuinely victimised that this idea took 20 years to occur to them.

Why have we been inflicted with Garbadors, Vanniluxes and Binacles when revamping both the look and the type of classics designs was apparently an option. Alolan Ninetails combines Ice and Fairy types, Marowak melds Fire and Ghost, Raichu learns Psychic attacks, Dugtrio has... long... blonde hair? Ok, so it's not all perfect, but overall it's a great idea and it's been executed tremendously.

With a Pokédex now creeping over the 800 mark, if Nintendo had rolled this policy out from the beginning the game's greatest criticism (namely, the new creature designs largely suck) would have been solved. Add a handful of new additions every generation, and make the rest of the new releases altered versions of established classics.


4. All The Little Things

Pokemon Sun Moon Sharpedo Mount
Nintendo

What really makes Sun and Moon a triumph though isn't the huge changes or the grandiose new features, but the minutia of the game. The smaller ideas that have been subtly added in to gradually improve the overall composition and experience of the game. Individually, none of these would really make any odds but, together, they combine for a really complete game.

When you catch a Pokémon in the wild now, it's not automatically transferred to a box at some distant centre, instead you're asked what you'd like to do with it - add it to your party, or transfer to a specific box. You're now afforded a special place to grow berries and beans, to save traipsing to the same spawning locations for them every few hours.

Best of all, HMs are now a thing of the past, with you instead given the ability to summon Pokemon to do the job instead. A Charizard swoops in to fly you around, a Lapras happily sails you across waters, a Tauros smashes through rocks, and none of them take up a needless "HM Slave" slot in your team.

Better character customisation, little objective markers on the map, even the barely-reported QR Code Pokedex scanner (to let you find where to catch specific monsters) are great. All in all, there's a ton of tiny little features that meld together beautifully.


Downs

3. Z-Moves

Pokemon Sun Moon Synchro Evolution
Nintendo

I got a bit of flack for saying in my preview article this year that they needed to dump Mega Evolutions. Essentially a cheap gimmick designed to make battles needlessly easy and give the promotion team a cool feature to hang the marketing on. Thankfully, there's been no sign of these in my experience of Sun and Moon (although I'm sure it'll crop up eventually), but it's been replaced by something even worse.

Z-Moves, which are type specific, once-per-battle super-attacks that require a crystal to power up, come complete with ridiculous OTT animations, and do nothing but guarantee a cheap KO. They add nothing from an attacking perspective, and when your opponent has one it merely means you have to factor in losing one of your team straight out of the gate.

I can't quite find the words to describe to you just how stupid the names and animations of these attacks are. Each have a name that wouldn't look out of place as a copyright-free wrestling finisher, and an animation that should signal the end of the world. Supersonic Skystrike, Continental Crush, Black Hole Eclipse; if I rolled my eyes any harder at these I'd faint.

Just watch this. From the name, to the animation, to the dance the trainer does, to the fact that it's NOT A MOONSAULT this is one of the most jarring things to be seen in a Pokemon game...


2. The New Pokémon

Sandyghast Pokemon
Game Freak

This train's never late.

Sometime between Generation III and IV (depending on how hard to please you are) the cry from Pokémon fans became a rather unanimous "these new creatures are a bit rubbish". Where Gen I was so well rounded and imaginative that it secured the franchise for 2 decades, and Gen II added 100 monsters that only increased the overall standard, ever since it's been the same pattern of bizarre and soulless designs that appeared to be based on just whatever happened to by lying around the developers office.

The quality of the three starters gave cause for optimism, as all three looked far more in keeping with the simplicity of the earlier generations, but even they evolve in frankly ridiculous ways. As for the rest, there's nothing to really get fans excited or that will capture the imagination whilst playing. And yes, we now have a sandcastle Pokemon to add to the ice cream cone, pile of garbage, and set of keys in the big Please Try Harder file of designs. The less said about Gumshoos resemblance to Donald Trump the better.

It's not all negative though. Rockruff and Salandit wouldn't have looked out of place in previous generations, and the Alolan forms of classic Pokémon mean that, by and large, Sun and Moon has plenty of great monsters to choose from. However it's just a shame that, yet again, the original magic of earlier games hasn't been captured.


1. Team Skull

Team Skull
Game Freak

Look up "the absolute worst" in the dictionary and what do you see? Well, nothing, as three word phrases aren't listed in there. But if they were you'd get a definition of Team Skull.

While Sun and Moon has eschewed the traditional model of trainer and rival set off on an adventure, fight Team [Intimidating Word] along the way, and challenge the Elite 4, there's still room for the band of Poké-thugs to pop up causing trouble. This time it's Team Skull, a bumbling, dancing, rapping collection of idiots whose schemes seldom extend further than messing up bus timetables (no, seriously).

They're not the game's main antagonists thankfully, but seem to be a direct pastiche of modern gang culture - specifically a combination of European urbanity and Japanese street life. Even their soundtrack, a bass-heavy indecipherable rap of "yo's" and "damn's" seems like an unsubtle dig at this sort of crowd. Is it deliberate? Is it's meant to be some sort of critique on the yoof of today? Is it lazy villain design? I don't know, but I hate them regardless.

All that said though, gimmicky moves, uninspiring creature design, and some baddies I can't get away with should not detract from what is, ultimately, an outstanding game. Can I go so far as to say that, in fact, this is the best Pokémon game since Red and Blue, and it's probably even worth you picking up a 2DS on the cheap just so you can play it? Yes. Yes I can. I can and I will. Do that. Thanks. Bye.


Managing Editor
Managing Editor

WhatCulture's Managing Editor and Chief Reporter | Previously seen in Vice, Esquire, FourFourTwo, Sabotage Times, Loaded, The Set Pieces, and Mundial Magazine