Ranking Every Dynasty Warriors Game Worst To Best
With a new Hyrule Warriors game out soon, let's take a look at the series that started it all.
Since the release of Dynasty Warriors in 1997, this legendary hack and slash series has spanned nine mainline games, dozens of spinoffs, crossovers, and adaptions of the Warriors formula to storied franchises such as Gundam, One Piece, and Dragon Quest. It is the benchmark by which all other hack and slash, "1 vs. 1000" games are judged, and with recent successful collaborations with Nintendo (Fire Emblem Warriors and Hyrule Warriors) and Atlus (Persona 5 Strikers), this series shows no signs of stopping.
Even so, not all games are created equal. As with all long-lived, popular franchises, there's no doubt that Dynasty Warriors has experienced its own ups and downs over the course of its 23-year history. Looking back to the original, mainline series, with ancient Chinese warlords fighting it out on such famous battlefields as Hu Lao Gate, Wuzhang Plains, and Chi Bi, the debate rages on as fiercely as the wars upon which the games are based. Which games deserve to be recognized as True Heroes of the 3 Kingdoms, and which are better left in the past?
9. Dynasty Warriors
For those familiar with the sprawling battlefield combat that the Dynasty Warriors series is known for, returning to the original 1997 title may prove quite a shock. Rather than a war simulator, with hordes of nameless soldiers to mow down in your quest, the first Dynasty Warriors game is actually a weapons-based fighting game that has more in common with Soulcalibur and Samurai Shodown than its own sequels. A defensive game, Dynasty Warriors' mechanical selling point was its unique parry system; rather than an all-purpose block or guard button, an opponent's moves were countered by executing one's own attack at the same height, allowing a player to execute a devastating counterattack.
Even so, the lack of kick attacks hamstrung the game's offensive potential, making fights shallower and less dynamic than its contemporaries. With regards to its placement on this list, however, the simple fact is that Dynasty Warriors has so little to do with the Dynasty Warriors series. The characters and designs are similar, but in an entirely different genre. The original Dynasty Warriors is an interesting curiosity for diehard fans to revisit, but it does little to sate the appetites of fans hungry for the now-famous Dynasty Warriors gameplay.
8. Dynasty Warriors 6
First released in 2007, Dynasty Warriors 6 was intended to be a massive overhaul of the franchise, built from the ground up with a new combat system, new features, and new character designs, all designed to utilize the power of the new generations of consoles, the PlayStation 3 and the Xbox 360. How did it go so wrong?
Released to great fanfare that swiftly turned to disappointment, Dynasty Warriors 6 was a game that looked bad and played even worse. Riddled with bugs and glitches that would frustrate even the most forgiving gamer, it offered little to longtime fans of the series. Colors and textures were washed out, muddy browns and greys that did little to convey the beauty of iconic battlefields, and the branching attack strings (where strong and weak attacks could be alternated to execute unique moves) were removed in favor of even simpler combos that used only a single button each.
Even worse, the iconic designs and weapons of some of the game's most popular characters were removed. The transition from kingdom-based story modes to character-based story modes in Dynasty Warriors 5 had been an interesting change, but clearly it was too much for the Dynasty Warriors 6 team to handle. The only title to have fewer playable characters than its predecessor, Dynasty Warriors 6 further limited character diversity by cloning the movesets of over half its roster, stripping characters like Sun Ce, Zhang He, and Ling Tong of their famous instruments of war.
Attempting to bring Dynasty Warriors into the new generation, Dynasty Warriors 6 dug the franchise a hole so big that later games are still trying to claw their way out to this day.
7. Dynasty Warriors 9
Dynasty Warriors 9 is not a game that is interested in you understanding it. Dynasty Warriors 9 doesn't even understand itself. Originally heralded as an "open world Dynasty Warriors game", it seems less like it was developed with an open world focus in mind, and more like every single mechanic, trope, and innovation of the 2010s was dumped into a blender. Open world? Check. Crafting? Check. Grappling hooks? Check. Home decoration? Bafflingly, check.
Although a gorgeous-looking game, Dynasty Warriors 9 presents a beautiful world filled with meaninglessness. While there's no shortage of roving bandits or wild animals, delivery sidequests, NPCs to meet and build friendships with (by giving them gifts and doing tasks for them), there's so little here that draws one in. The story modes are long, but surprisingly flat, with weak voice acting and minimal animation. The rich world presents more of the same, with the same basic quest rotation available everywhere, and precious few secrets to discover for oneself.
The combat is a bit more dynamic than 6's, but not by much. Many unique attacks branch off from the game's new Flow mechanic, but they're finicky and unreliable, making them almost always worse than the basic attacks. Framerate issues and glitches further incentivize playing as simply as possible.
Lastly, and most unforgivingly for many players, the game has given into predatory DLC tactics. Though DLC has been a part of the franchise for a while in the form of unique costumes or weapons, Dynasty Warriors 9 offers additional playable characters whose data already exists on the base game. It's a shameless low for a franchise whose fans have given it so much.
6. Dynasty Warriors 7
Dynasty Warriors 7 has the unenviable fate of following one of the poorest critical receptions in the series' history. With the changes brought by 6 soundly rejected by fans and critics alike, the team behind Dynasty Warriors 7 went back to the drawing board to try and bring the classic spirit of Dynasty Warriors back to their game. The result was... mediocre.
Dynasty Warriors 7 is uninspired. In its attempt to take players "back to basics," it does little to break new ground in the series. The old combat system returned, with old designs, and old weapons. The focus returns to engaging story modes that breathe new life into these ancient historical figures. The world looks better than in Dynasty Warriors 6, with fewer glitches and bugs that slow down the experience. At its best, it's an average Dynasty Warriors experience, just more of the same. That's not an entirely bad thing.
Where it does try to experiment, though, Dynasty Warriors 7 falters. Free Mode and the co-op story modes have been removed, in favor of a new mode called Conquest Mode. Players fight across China in a tile structure, like a board game, periodically engaging in low-stakes, low-difficult battles divorced of any context. Many of the game's secrets, such as unlockable weapons, are found in this mode, making tediously completing the entire map a necessity for those who want to unlock their favorite character's ultimate weapon. It's a bland experience tacked onto an otherwise average game.
5. Dynasty Warriors 2
First released in 2000, Dynasty Warriors 2 is the game that defined what Dynasty Warriors would be for the following two decades. Rather than a fighting game like its predecessor, Dynasty Warriors 2 brought battlefield gameplay to the series, and forever altered what large-scale combat games would look like. With double the cast size of the original game, Dynasty Warriors 2 started strong with inventive, unique character designs, and surprisingly polished graphics for a PlayStation 2 launch title.
The game has its strange hiccups, artifacts of an older era. Certain characters look or play more similarly to each other than they would today, harkening back to fighting game standards like Mortal Kombat's ninjas, or Tekken's Jin and Devil Jin. The base weapon combat is surprisingly reactive and weighty, but the supplementary combat additions like mounted combat and archery are clunky and ineffective. There's effectively no post-game, no secret weapons or achievements that boost replayability.
Still, Dynasty Warriors 2's impact upon the series cannot be understated. Without Dynasty Warriors 2, there would be no Dynasty Warriors as we know it. It dazzled an audience and nearly created its own genre wholesale, building a diehard fanbase that would stay with the series for decades to come. Though in hindsight, it may not measure up to some of its successors, Dynasty Warriors 2 is a worthy and respectable entry in the series.
4. Dynasty Warriors 5
There's a lot to like about Dynasty Warriors 5, especially when compared to some of the games that followed it. Unlike Dynasty Warriors 4, it had individual story modes for each character, like in Dynasty Warriors 3. This shortened the individual stories, making them more digestible, and helped cement the unique heroics and personalities of each and every member of Dynasty Warriors 5's large cast. Even characters whose stories would have been short, due to untimely deaths, receive "what-if" stories that present new and exciting alternative histories to the semi-historical tales presented by the games thus far. Though many fans prefer the kingdom-driven stories, this is how to do the individual stories right.
In terms of aesthetics, Dynasty Warriors 5 isn't flashy or particularly exciting. By 2005, the PlayStation 2 and Xbox were showing their age, leading to a somewhat muddy graphical experience. Despite this, the game still holds up, if one can look past the visuals. Bases were a welcome addition to the mainline series (adapted from the Empire spinoffs), in which players could capture bases en route to their final assaults on the enemy, allowing them to halt enemy reinforcements, receive items, and summon their own allies for one coordinated push. At its core, it's not a substantial deviation from the gameplay of Dynasty Warriors 3 or 4, but in its defense, it's hard to improve on perfection. Dynasty Warriors 5 may not quite hit the peaks of its predecessors, but for fans, it's still an incredibly rewarding entry.
3. Dynasty Warriors 8
Much like Dynasty Warriors 7, Dynasty Warriors 8 takes the formula of the older games and attempts to modernize it. It works. The story mode is further deepened, with optional challenges in each battle providing extra incentives for players to push themselves. The voice acting, dialogue, and character animations may be the best the series has ever seen, making each character feel rich and vibrant, bursting with nuance and pathos.
Free Mode returns, as does co-op story mode, with Dynasty Warriors 7's Conquest Mode replaced with a much-improved Ambition Mode. As you fight battles of your choice to gain influence or favor, money, items, or build alliances, you steadily build up your small settlement with the aim of eventually attracting the Emperor's attention. While Conquest Mode felt lazy and aimless, Ambition Mode feels almost like a Dynasty Warriors Empires spin-off on its own.
The standard modes don't skimp on features either. Each character comes with their own unique weapon, while still being able to equip other weapons types, allowing the player to customize their favorites as they like. Furthermore, a rock-paper-scissors mechanic has been added to the weapons, necessitating changing weapons in smaller skirmishes against individual officers. This helps the player become more acquainted with different movesets and fighting styles before jumping headfirst into a character who uses that moveset or style as their base.
While Dynasty Warriors 7 was weighed down by the failures of Dynasty Warriors 6, Dynasty Warriors 8 was free to experiment and modernize the series in its own way. No modern Dynasty Warriors game has better captured the heart and soul of the franchise than Dynasty Warriors 8.
2. Dynasty Warriors 3
While Dynasty Warriors 2 created the blueprint for what Dynasty Warriors would become, it was Dynasty Warriors 3 that truly established how great this series could be. With co-op, better AI, and over a dozen new characters, Dynasty Warriors 3 set the standard for a great Dynasty Warriors game. Across the board, it simply had so much more depth than its predecessor. Standardized weapons were replaced with weapon tiers, each character beginning with low quality weapons with limited combos and progressing to more powerful, unique weapons throughout the game. There was even post-game content, with each character having access to a secret, fourth tier weapon if certain challenges were completed.
Stat drops further create a sense of progression. Throughout the game, items will drop from defeating officers or finding secrets, raising a character's attack, defense, health, or other stats. Though not originating in Dynasty Warriors 3, it contributes to the game's RPG stylings, making the player feel like they're growing alongside their character as they progress through the story. It helps that Dynasty Warriors 3 is one of the hardest games in the franchise as well, requiring good play and many stat boosts to complete on the harder difficulties.
It's hard to talk about Dynasty Warriors 3 without addressing the... unique voice acting. Dynasty Warriors has often suffered from questionable voice acting, with stilted dialogue and mispronounced names the norm for the series' earlier entries. It's particularly noticeable in Dynasty Warriors 3, with some lines so bad as to stick in players' minds for years later ("Feel the power of my MAGIC!" comes to mind). Ultimately, though, the rest of the game is so likable and innovating that it's easy to forgive. Besides, at its worst, it's truly so bad it's good.
1. Dynasty Warriors 4
When it comes to the best Dynasty Warriors game, it's hard to choose anything other than Dynasty Warriors 4. It leaves nothing on the table. It brought new characters, new modes, new epic stories, and new features that fans had been clamoring for since Dynasty Warriors 2. Duels were added, lending a cinematic air to one-on-one confrontations with important enemy officers. Versus Mode and Challenge Mode were both beefed up with a variety of exciting features. Finally, players could create and play as their own unique character, adding themselves to the rich kingdom-focused story mode.
In nearly every way, the gameplay is streamlined and made more user-friendly, without dumbing down the core aspects. Bodyguards can be given orders on-the-fly, while bow and mounted combat become far more usable. Siege weapons are introduced, capable of frying your allied soldiers with flames in an instant if you don't take them down first. Parries return from the series' first game, helping the player reverse momentum when pushed up against the wall by their opponents. The RPG elements from Dynasty Warriors 3 are retained, and strengthened, with weapons having their own EXP system to help them improve incrementally.
Most importantly, the story was truly epic. While some prefer kingdom-based story modes and others prefer individual-based ones, there's no denying how well Dynasty Warriors 4 pulled its story off. Playing through over fifty years of history, Dynasty Warriors 4 truly feels like living through a war, watching allies and enemies alike perish, only to be replaced by new faces as the war machine grinds ever onward. There's an emotional core to Dynasty Warriors 4, something that keeps so many fans coming back to it even after so many other games.
Dynasty Warriors is a great series with so many excellent games, but Dynasty Warriors 4 will always be the greatest.