Red Dead Redemption 2 Review: 7 Ups & 3 Downs
An epic, flawed masterpiece.
There's a good chance that, like us, you spent a good portion of this past weekend shut inside playing Rockstar's latest open-world action extravaganza. After over eight years of waiting, Red Dead Redemption 2 is finally upon us, and thank heavens, it (mostly) lives up to the extraordinary hype.
Without question one of the most ambitious video games ever made, this western epic sets a new standard for the genre and for gaming as a whole, even if Rockstar's reach occasionally exceeds its grasp.
While there's already been early dissent from some players surprised by the game's slow pace, it's fair to say that most Rockstar fans will have one hell of a time with this.
As brilliant as God of War was, this is on a whole other level to pretty much anything else out there, and it's safe to say that we can probably call it the Game of the Year already.
Not all of Rockstar's choices work, but as an extremely artful and almost unimaginably detailed piece of entertainment, Red Dead Redemption 2 is a jaw-dropping testament to what the medium is capable of at its absolute best...
Downs...
3. The Clunky Controls & Movement
By far the worst thing about RDR2 overall is just how awkward and clumsy the controls are.
Making Arthur move around feels like wading through treacle, and interacting with objects can prove especially frustrating as he stumbles around in the environment before subjecting the player to a 5-second animation of opening a drawer or something equally rudimentary and boring.
This is obviously a design choice by Rockstar to evoke a more "realistic" vibe, but depressingly, it makes the game feel oddly reminiscent of Shenmue and its infamously trying controls and movement mechanics.
You can do yourself a favour by raising the Look/Aim acceleration and lowering the dead zone in the game's control settings, but even so, exploring this lush, vast world shouldn't feel like such an effort right off the bat.
2. Rockstar's Trademark Mediocre Combat
Combat has always been a weak point of Rockstar's games, and sadly RDR2 is no different.
Though gunplay is certainly not challenging due to the ultra-generous snap-aim and pornographic slow-mo that is Dead Eye, it nevertheless has a frustratingly floaty feel to it as has been the case with every game Rockstar has made for at least the last decade.
In addition to the wonky shooting itself, finding cover takes more effort than it probably should, with Arthur often getting turned around or flat-out not conforming to your requests.
Though fistfights aren't terribly frequent throughout the game, that's probably a good thing, because they don't boil down to much more than spamming the punch button, occasionally pressing block, and rinsing and repeating until your opponent finally stops moving. It's extremely rudimentary for a game that's so complex in so many areas.
While it probably won't happen, fingers are crossed that Rockstar finally fixes the shooting for GTA VI.
1. The Excessive Busywork
There's no denying that this is an absurdly detailed game, but there are certainly times where that meticulousness is to the game's detriment, at least as far as fun is concerned.
The prime culprit is the wildly unnecessary cores system which the player must maintain for Arthur's health, stamina and Dead Eye. Rather than simply have a single meter which can be upgraded over time and requires replenishing, there's that and also a core which must be refilled with separate consumables.
Though pickups are plentiful, it just adds a needless layer of bother and micro-management. That's not to forget the fact you need to also take care of your horse, which has its own health and stamina cores, and you'll also need to brush it frequently to keep it in tip-top shape.
One single bar for each of these elements is more than enough busy-work for one game, and while it never feels like a true nag on the level of, say, eating in GTA: San Andreas, it's the one aspect of the game that really feels too "game-y" for its own good.
And now that we've detailed why RDR2 isn't a flawless winner, here are the many, many things it gets so wonderfully right...
Ups...
7. It's The Most Immersive Open World Ever
If that title sounds like hyperbole, it really isn't: this is Rockstar we're talking about, of course.
Though you can argue that RDR2's storytelling is a bit of a step back ambition-wise from GTA V's brilliant multi-protagonist gimmick, the developer has undeniably created a more atmospheric, rich and fully lived-in open-world here than has ever been achieved in the medium before.
Riding through the hills and stumbling upon "random" scripted events that weren't on your map never ceases to amaze, and though it's clear this world has been carefully curated to the highest order, it really does feel like its components are "alive" whether you're watching them or not.
That this is all so masterfully executed while offering up few loading screens and never feeling like an overwhelming, Ubisoft-esque icon-fest, is absolutely staggering.
One can scarcely imagine how much thought must've gone into crafting the world and making it coalesce so seamlessly, and pulling it off on ageing current-gen hardware only makes it that much more incredible.
6. The Involving Story & Rich Characters
RDR2's story isn't as thematically rich or poignant as the first game's, but it's certainly a lot more ambitious, clocking in at around 30 hours on the lower end, and that's if you forego the side content entirely. Arthur Morgan, meanwhile, isn't quite the fan favourite charmer that John Marston was, but he's still an effortlessly classic Rockstar protagonist.
What really elevates the game however, as is usual for the developers' work, is the marvellous supporting cast of characters.
Especially engaging are gang leader Dutch van der Linde, Lenny Summers - who, in one of the game's best missions, has a drunken night out with Arthur - violent reprobate Micah Bell, vengeance-craving outlaw Sadie Adler and, of course, John Marston, who is cleverly re-contextualised within this new prequel story.
Even when the story has its heavy-handed or slack moments, the wonderfully memorable characters keep it on the right side of engaging.
5. The INSANE Visuals
It goes without saying that this is one hell of a handsome game, and while there are certainly shinier AAA offerings out there, there are probably none that manage to be this visually stunning while boasting this level of detail on this scale.
Rockstar has sensibly created an incredibly geographically diverse world map, and while the most impressive locations are certainly best left unspoiled, they vary wildly in terms of topography, climate and technology. It gives the developers a ripe opportunity to demonstrate what the RAGE engine is truly capable of.
There are so many visual moments in this game that'll just force you to stop riding, take a breath and soak in the artistry before you, and again, that such a robust project can look so impressive on five-year-old consoles is a masterstroke of engineering and design.
There are certainly a few aesthetic concessions if you want to nitpick - hair looks surprisingly awful almost universally and HDR support is disappointingly washed-out - but the fact that the game's visual majesty doesn't lose its lustre after 30+ hours is pretty mind-boggling.
4. The Meaningful & Addictive Side Content
In an era where so many open-world games just vomit out repetitive copy-and-paste mission types - looking at you, Ubisoft - it's enormously refreshing how meaningful and singular almost all of the peripheral missions and events here feel.
Whether you're simply hanging out around your camp, partaking in one of the many outrageous Strangers missions or heading off the beaten path to engage with a random encounter, it rarely ever feels like a chore. Even the most inessential side-quest seems like it was placed in the game with real thought and care.
And without getting into spoilery specifics, RDR2 does indeed have a post-game much like its predecessor, though a far more substantial one which can take a surprising amount of time to play through.
That you get all this alongside an extremely lengthy and rich main story instantly makes RDR2 one of the most value-filled games on the market.
3. The Ambitious, Laid-Back Pacing
As is evident from its divisive, arguably lumbering opening two hours, Rockstar is in no rush at all to tell this tale, and the result is perhaps the most slow-moving AAA game ever made.
You'll ultimately spend more time riding around and talking with your gang than you will shooting people, and in addition to the game's almost fetishistic approach to animating every last, mundane character movement, fast travel options are also rather limited.
As such, you'll probably find yourself riding to most missions, and though it's fair to say that Rockstar probably should've included a more comprehensive fast travel option, it's clear they're trying to immerse players in a very particular, deliberate atmosphere and tone.
For many players it'll simply be too low-energy, but if you can appreciate a slow-bleed approach in-between all the bloodshed, then RDR2's uniquely relaxed pacing is a major breath of fresh air.
Think of it as the Blade Runner 2049 of video games: a magnificent technical achievement that polarises the mainstream due to its methodical clip.
2. The World-Class Voice Acting, Music & Sound Effects
And what would those gorgeous visuals be without an incredible sound package to boot? Characteristically, RDR2 is an absolute banger across-the-board in this area, from the voice acting to the musical score and sound effects.
If Roger Clark does a remarkable job making Arthur a complex and nuanced protagonist, he's only outdone by Benjamin Byron Davis, whose velvet-voiced Dutch once again steals the show, while Rob Wiethoff's reprisal of John Marston is an utter delight.
Original composer Woody Jackson also returns for the sequel, and from the sweeping operatic overtures to the incidental music, he does a fantastic job boosting the game's atmosphere immeasurably.
And of course, there's the actual sound effects themselves, which from the meaty, crunchy gunfire to the most ridiculously subtle environment effects, are absolutely at the top of their field.
1. It's One Of The Best Games Of The Generation (If Not Ever)
And in case you hadn't guessed yet, 7 ups and 3 downs doesn't mean we're rating this game a 7/10. Far from it, in fact.
Rockstar hasn't just made a fantastic game and indeed one of their very best efforts to date, but also delivered a landmark title that stands among the very best of the generation and probably of all time.
While its slow pace and sometimes frustrating mechanics won't be for everyone, the overall package is so ingenious in its construction that it's hard to care too much about them.
No, it's not a flawless game and its issues are certainly worth discussing, but RDR2 is ultimately further proof of Rockstar's singular talents, and how nobody else in the industry is making games on quite this level of polish and intelligence.
So, what do you make of Red Dead Redemption 2 so far? Shout it out in the comments!