Red Dead Redemption 2: What Happened To Every Character

15. Leopold Strauss

red dead redemption 2 strauss
Rockstar

Status: Deceased

A criminal so revolting that even his fellow outlaws resent him, Leopold Strauss is a special type of evil. Instead of gunning down his victims or raising hell across towns, Strauss is in the business of lending money to desperate people he knows either can't or won't pay it back, then calling in someone like Arthur to forcefully take whatever they have left as repayment.

After completing a bunch of these "debt collector" missions for Strauss, Arthur eventually gets sick of the destruction he's caused to relatively innocent people, and forcefully kicks the money lender out the gang.

Charles reveals to John in the epilogue that Strauss was eventually tracked down by the Pinkertons and interrogated, where he died in custody. However, despite being kicked out, he stayed loyal to the end, leaving this mortal coil without confessing anything about his former companions.


14. Hosea Matthews

Red dead redemption 2 hosea
Rockstar

Status: Deceased

There was no way Hosea was going to have a happy ending.

Despite being the moral compass of the entire gang and the "wise old sage" archetype, this particular outlaw knew he didn't belong in a world where the Wild West was only a fairytale.

Even then, he deserved more than being gunned down in the street during a failed robbery. Thankfully, Charles points out that he buried both Hosea and Lenny in Bluewater Marsh, so at least Hosea wasn't left in Saint Denis.


13. Lenny Summers

Red Dead Redemption Lenny
Rockstar

Status: Deceased

Lenny was tragically killed during the botched heist in Saint Denis, shot after wrangling with a policeman. He's one of the many casualties in the city, and absolutely did not deserve to go out so needlessly.

Still, the sheer shock of seeing what is one of Arthur's closest friends (and immaculate drinking buddies) get unceremoniously gunned down brings the reality of the situation crashing down on the player.

Red Dead 2 is all about the death of the wild west; the creation of law, societies and order. Having the loveable Lenny be taken away only hammers home how much danger Dutch is continually putting the gang in.


12. Susan Grimshaw

red dead redemption 2 susan
Rockstar

Status: Deceased

The low-key pillar of the gang next to Dutch, Susan is the battle-hardened "mother" of the group, looking after the likes of Mary-Beth and Tilley, while maintaining food supplies and a strong backbone for the group overall.

Sadly, Miss Grimshaw meets her maker thanks to Micah, who takes her out during the commotion of the Pinkertons arriving at camp, right at the end of the game.

This isn't before Susan shoots Molly for supposedly giving Dutch and co. up to the feds - a notion she rationalises by saying O'Shea, ”knew the rules”.


11. Micah Bell

Red Dead Redemption 2 Micah
Rockstar

Status: Deceased

A ludicrously detestable fleck of excrement and one of the best villains in gaming history, even when Micah is still on "your side" in the earlygoing, he's a psychopathic liability.

Come the point later on when it's time to turn the tables and point guns his way, many of us delighted in blasting Bell's brains all over the mountainside.

Regardless of your actions with Arthur, it's always John that finally enacts revenge - though the kill is somewhat cheapened by Dutch firing the first shot.

Either way, I've never been so glad to see the end of a character since Joffrey on Game of Thrones.


10. Uncle

Red Dead Redemption 2 Uncle
Rockstar

Status: Alive

Loveable oaf and chronic alcoholic, we always knew Uncle was going to survive RDR 2, because he's working on John's stable in the original game.

Still, that didn't stop Rockstar having him be kidnapped, or putting him slap-bang in the middle of many arguments surrounding "pulling your weight" for the camp.

Metaphorically, Uncle represents that part of us that just wants to lay about - the freeloading easy-goer who benefits from everyone else getting their hands dirty, just so he can wait for a handout.

Still... he's so brilliantly written, you're glad to have him around.


9. Sadie Adler

red dead redemption 2 sadie
Rockstar

Status: Alive

Possibly the most ferocious character Rockstar have ever written, Sadie's transformation from everyday housewife to blood-soaked, deranged killer is genuinely terrifying.

From ruining best-laid plans because she could take a shot at those who killed her family, to running out into open fire and surviving whilst racking up a body count, Adler is the manifestation of "what the old west did to people", shown first hand.

Sadie's final scene involves attending John and Abigail's wedding before taking off. It's worth noting that when discussing a place to finally retire, Sadie cites South America, so she could very much still be alive.


8. John Marston

red dead redemption 2 john marston
Rockstar

Status: Alive

Main character of the first Red Dead Redemption, Rockstar's work fleshing out John's past is brilliant.

We find out that not only was he involved in any number of crimes alongside the gang, but that he actively ran out on Abigail and young Jack Marston, only to be rescued when it happened again, by Arthur Morgan.

Following this, John mostly stays in the background, only intersecting with Arthur as the pair plan a life away from Dutch. Everything culminates in a mountainside duel at Ambarino where John makes a break for it as Arthur takes on Dutch, Micah and scores of law enforcement.


7. Javier Escuella

red dead redemption 2 javier
Rockstar

Status: Alive

Another character who's very status as being alive in the first game meant they'd survive no matter what, Javier still plays a key role in the gang, and even joins up with Arthur against Dutch at the close of the game.

I say "even", because he ultimately sides with Van Der Linde, walking a thin line between what's "right" in the moment, and what his morals are clearly telling him.

This somewhat carries into the original game, as an older Javier is much more jovial about the circumstances of his leaving, clashing with John over the decision he made in the moment.


6. Molly O'Shea

red dead redemption 2 molly
Rockstar

Status: Deceased

A character I wish we'd seen far more of, Molly is cast aside as "Dutch's woman". This is almost by design, as we as players get about as much look into her motivations and morals as Dutch does - the message being that Dutch just wants followers; wants people to be in love with him, but is never going to reciprocate it.

This climaxes with Molly staggering into the camp, proclaiming to have sold Dutch and everyone else out, only to be gunned down by Susan Grimshaw.

The reality though? She was just saying these things to lash out at a prideful Dutch, as we find out the real rat was Micah all along.


Contributor

Josh has over 11 years of experience as a published writer, having worked nine of those years as a full-time content producer at WhatCulture. In that period he has created hundreds of articles, videos and podcast episodes for multiple WhatCulture channels, specialising in gaming, horror and film & TV. He now primarily works as a senior content producer and presenter on WhatCulture Gaming where he co-hosts the WhatCulture Gaming Podcast, a top 3 UK most listened to gaming podcast that he co-created in 2018. Over the years he has reviewed several high-profile gaming releases, covered industry events with on-site reporting, opined on breaking news, and even kicked off his interviewing career by chatting to childhood hero, Tommy Wiseau.

Gaming Editor
Gaming Editor

WhatCulture's Head of Gaming.