Silent Hills: 10 Big Rumours You Need To Know

With the P.T. demo being some people's Best Game of 2014, there's so much to talk about.

Kojima Production€™s P.T. is wildly successful for not only being genuinely frightening but also for bringing together Silent Hill€™s community, which hasn€™t been this active since Team Silent disbanded. While Kojima anticipated that it would take gamers a full week to discover P.T. was actually a playable teaser for the upcoming Silent Hills, the gaming community quickly overcame the language barrier (one would need to know seven languages to decipher all of P.T.€™s clues by themselves) and have not only solved the mystery but continue to develop their own theories based on the demo€™s many cryptic clues. That€™s why this article is here, to gather up the best of the best so far, the 10 big rumours about Silent Hills that you should know going into 2015. These rumours not only deal with its possible narrative but also what you can expect from its gameplay. Keep in mind that nothing has been confirmed and Kojima has said that most of the content for P.T. will not be carried over into Silent Hills. However, Silent Hill has always garnered bizarrely compelling (even convincing) theories that fans continue to discuss today. Regardless, if any of the listed fan theories are incorrect, they€™re worth considering and discussing up until the game€™s possible 2016 release date. By then, hopefully together fans will have figured out which are correct. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ay_RAkE7bUY


10. It Will Have An Open World

When you first step into Silent Hill, you might be under the impression that you€™re able to explore the entire city to your heart€™s content. Turns out that€™s not the case, as they€™ve always been linear albeit with enough exploration to discover important items. This might change with Silent Hills. In an interview with whatifgaming, the writer asked Kojima if the game would be open world. Kojima chose to be coy, of course, and he is probably waiting to reveal the answer at a later date; however, he did provide an interesting response: €œAll I can say is Fox Engine is meant for open world. I cannot discuss more on the game design itself in detail yet.€ Perhaps it€™s not an outright confirmation that the series will make the leap into open-world territory, but it certainly feels like Kojima is giving off a couple of winks and nudges. For some, this might raise two concerns: the final product might not look as good as P.T., and the narrative may become strained. Regardless of how receptive fans are to the idea, Hills could potentially change the way you explore the town.

9. Silent Hills Is Really Silent Hill 5

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QQcOdvcMgTE One of the more baffling reveals for Silent Hills is the extra "s" tacked on to the end of the title. It actually ties into a lot of the more convincing theories that will be covered later in this list, but for what it€™s worth, some speculate that the game is actually going to be considered as the true fifth entry in the series. Since Silent Hill 4: The Room, the series has abandoned numbered entries in exchange for subtitles. Silent Hill: Homecoming was initially teased as being Silent Hill V, but that was before before Konami officially revealed it. Coincidentally, Team Silent disbanded after Silent Hill 4, so some might feel that every entry that has come out since doesn€™t really count. It€™s no wonder then, that some, as pointed out (but discredited) by Youtuber dolikisse, might think that the s could just be a backwards five, making Silent Hills the first numbered entry since 2004. If this is the case, however, Konami would only confuse fans; therefore, the company would be wise to just leave it as is. If it's anything to longtime fans, Kojima has demonstrated in P.T. that he seems to have a deep understanding of the franchise. For instance, the series is partly inspired by Jacob€™s Ladder, and Lisa moves eerily similarly to the creatures in that film. Perhaps Silent Hills will be a return to form.

8. It Will Be About A Gamer

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_j2Sd12BmIw Kojima enjoys being meta with his titles - the most famous example being the Psycho Mantis boss fight in Metal Gear Solid. And based off a key detail in P.T., Kojima may up the ante in Silent Hills by making it about a gamer. At the end of the demo, the fetus complains about how his no good dad would sit around and play video games all day until he suddenly snapped and decided to kill everyone. While it€™s not confirmed, many suspect that Norman Reedus's character is the father who murdered his wife and her unborn child, and he could be the gamer since he's the star. Youtuber Dreamcastguy elaborates on this theory by discussing the fetus's remarks about how unimpressed he was by his father€™s lack of originality. Video games are repetitious by nature because gamers try to perform a certain task over and over again until they get it right, so considering how tedious exploring the same hallway is, gaming culture in general could be a major theme. What we don€™t know is if or how Kojima will take advantage of current-gen hardware to knock down the fourth wall to scare or make fun of gamers themselves. Being able to fast forward the PlayStation 2€™s clock to win a boss fight in Metal Gear Solid 3: Snake Eater was mind blowing enough; and based on the horrifying scenes in P.T., anything similar might be too much for fans of Silent Hill.

7. It€™s About Multiple Universes

Yes, considering that the title is plural, Silent Hills will probably be about multiple versions of the town. This isn't a new concept, as the recent Silent Hill games have placed a lot of emphasis on switching between the normal and other worlds; however, Kojima might reveal there are even more layers than just the two of which we know. In the demo, the lines €œWatch out. The gap in the door...it€™s a separate reality,€ and €œThe only me is me. Are you sure the only you is you?€ appear several times throughout. By themselves, these words already suggest that there are multiple universes; however, DreamcastGuy pointed out more mind-blowing clues in the same video where he discussed his gamer theory. Essentially, the main character exists in multiple realities, but the dead characters exist in one. Although trapped in this separate dimension, these ghostly figures are able to haunt the protagonist, but they can only occupy one hallway at a time. Then there€™s the line in which the main character sees a version of himself who wasn't really him, further grounding the theory about multiple universes. While nothing has been confirmed, this theory is highly compelling and easily one of the most plausible. Interestingly enough, the idea of multiple universes is not exclusive to Silent Hills; for instance, in Silent Hill 2, players can find the dead body of James Sunderland, the main character, in the Woodside Apartments. Perhaps Kojima is focusing on one aspect of the franchise that has simply remained unaddressed until (possibly) now?

6. It Will Be Episodic

Silent Hill games are traditionally full-length titles that can be completed between ten to twelve hours. Hideo Kojima, however, is thinking about changing the format by releasing Silent Hills in episodes, creating yet another possible explanation for the plural title. Kojima has actually been considering episodic content for some time now, thinking that the game industry could learn something from television. According to a 2013 article by Metal Gear Informer, Kojima envisions creating a €œpilot episode€ to test the waters, and then adjust the remaining episodes based off player feedback. In 2014, according to a Gamespot article, Kojima admitted that P.T. was an experiment for Silent Hills. Considering Kojima's statements from the 2013 article, it's possible that P.T. is the pilot episode for the upcoming game. As with the open-world gameplay, fans might have concerns regarding the pricing and length of each episode, as well as how the format will affect the overall narrative. However, Kojima could easily use the format for his advantage; if he paces each episode correctly, then he could end each one with a mind blowing cliffhanger to keep everyone thinking until the next.

5. It Might Be Exclusive To Project Morpheus

So, it€™s not a rumor that Kojima is being vague about the final gameplay for Silent Hills; all we know is that he wants to incorporate first-person perspective, even if it€™s not used all of the time. However, some speculate that there might be another reason that Kojima is toying around with first-person gameplay: Silent Hills could be exclusive to Sony's Project Morpheus. During the fetus€™s lengthy monologue about his father being a drag, he warns players that he will return and bring his new toys with him. While the fetus could be referring to the ingredients needed to create the protagonist's personalized hell, redditor Meddle111 suggested that new toys might refer to Project Morpheus, which could explain why P.T. is exclusive to the PlayStation 4. Konami has been silent regarding the target platforms for Silent Hills, but many speculate that the company is waiting for the release date of Project Morpheus before they reveal their own. After all, Sony could use a high-profile game to sell their VR technology, and Kojima, del Toro, and Reedus might be the perfect team to do it. However, considering that Silent Hill has been mostly multiplatform since Silent Hill 2, it might be unwise to abandon the Xbox One fanbase. Not to mention the game is in the earliest of stages; even Reedus himself hinted that they haven€™t filmed the major scenes yet. Regardless, considering how he enjoys using technology to mess with his fans, Kojima would have an easier time meeting his pants-filling quota with anything Project Morpheus-related.

4. Kojima Might Recruit Akira Yamaoka

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hUIZpcAnqik Team Silent disbanded after releasing Silent Hill 4: The Room, and since then the series has never quite felt the same. Admittedly, this one might seem slightly farfetched, but the thought of Kojima collaborating with the original developers is still captivating, even if it is just with one member. Thanks to Twitter, we can see developers converse with one another, often brainstorming ideas for video games or expressing casual interest in collaborating. Such is the case with series' well known composer, Akira Yamaoka. Upon confirmation of Silent Hills€™ existence, fans have bombarded Yamaoka with Tweets concerning his possible involvement. While he obviously has to play coy, he did provide one interesting response to My Silent Hill: €œIt's still undecided about it. Sure, be happy to!" Keep in mind that Yamaoka has worked with the series up until Silent Hill: Downpour. Not even he was able to save the series from being tarnished, and he now works for Lollipop Chainsaw-chaps Grasshopper Manufacturer. Still, considering he seems to have some passion left for the series, Kojima might be wise to at least hire him as a consultant.

3. The Aliens Might Play Their Biggest Role Yet

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Sh-eZsjcwwE In our 10 Times Silent Hill Was Absolutely Terrifying article, we discussed how Kojima is admirably continuing some of the series€™ traditions such as chilling bathroom scenes. Based on one of P.T.'s radio broadcasts from Hell, it looks like Kojima is also bringing back the aliens, except this time he might not be doing it for a joke ending. The theory was set in motion when Youtuber SirDaidv filmed a loop containing the chilling Swedish broadcast. He called upon his fans to post a translation, which they happily obliged to do (in order to view the translation, you'll need to setup the captions in the above video). One of the more interesting passages suggests a fictional story is real in Silent Hill's lore: €œAs the radio drama from 75 years ago was the truth.€ Keep in mind that the broadcaster is referring to the year 1938 when War of the Worlds, the famous story by Orson Welles, was broadcast to the public. The rest of the broadcast also suggests that the aliens have taken control of everything and will soon open a portal to a new dimension. Perhaps the aliens set in motion the events leading up to the first Silent Hill game, and, despite the humorous endings, have been responsible for everything that's happened in the series? By including the War of the Worlds reference, Kojima might be trying to turnthe series€™ UFO jokes as part of the series€™ reality. Whether or not the aliens have been behind the town this whole time remains to be seen, but at the very least we can expect their presence in some form.

2. The Town Might Be Breaking Into Our World Via The Game's Developers

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dsr2QBDIpwc This next theory ties in nicely with the one about the main character being a gamer. While that much is clear in P.T., we still don€™t know how meta Kojima is planning to be in Silent Hills. However, DreamcastGuy has another interesting theory in which not only will Silent Hills be in the real world, but it will also be about the game's developers - not just gamers. DreamcastGuy thinks that Silent Hill only exists by possessing the game€™s developers: Hideo Kojima and Guillermo del Toro. Both artists are known for exploring alternate universes, and Kojima has a track record of putting himself in his own games, referring to himself as God in Metal Gear Solid: Peace Walker and as a hostage in Ground Zeroes. Interestingly enough, DreamcastGuy also believes that Silent Hills will acknowledge the fact that the series has declined since Silent Hill 4: The Room. He even refers to fetus€™s criticism regarding how unoriginal his father, a gamer, was when he murdered the family; if you reread the lines except replacing the father with the series€™ developers, it€™s easy to see why the fetus is unimpressed. By bringing his new toys, the fetus, as well as the game€™s developers, hopes to inject a fresh dose of fear into the declining franchise. It€™s also worth mentioning that the name of the fictional studio Kojima created, 7780 studios, is based off the square meter of a prefecture called Shizuoka, which when translated sounds similar to Silent Hill. While it€™s most likely a joke, it could also give DreamcastGuy's theory a bit more credence.

1. There€™s Another Silent Hill In The Midwest

For this next theory, speculators focused on both the number 204863 as well as the image above to determine one of the many possible settings for Silent Hills. According to some Redditors, the town has has apparently moved across the country. While fans are still developing theories about the aforementioned number (the common theory is that it's actually Hideo Kojima€™s birthday), someone dug a little deeper and discovered that it refers to the genome model number of Populus Trichocarpa (which could also be connected to the demo€™s title), aka The Black Cottonwood. Keep in mind that Silent Hill traditionally takes place in the Northeastern part of the United States, and the movie is based on an abandoned mining town called Centralia, Pennsylvania. The Black Cottonwoods, on the other hand, can be found in the Northwestern part of the country. Tying in with the multiple Silent Hill theories, this could be a metaphor for the town branching out into new territory. Interestingly, another Redditor pointed out that Heather Mason of Silent Hill 3 grew up in Portland, where The Black Cottonwood is present. This could lead back to the idea that Kojima is attempting to focus on old plot points that Team Silent only hinted at like multiple dimensions. Have you heard of any other creepy theories about Silent Hills that you feel are worth mentioning? Feel free to let us know in the comments section!

Contributor
Contributor

Garrett is a technical writer by day and a freelance writer by night. When he's not thinking about popular culture he is either...no wait, he's always thinking about popular culture.