The Best Nintendo Game Every Year 1983 - 2024

32. 1993 - Star Fox

Star fox snes
Nintendo

Whereas in certain generations the next major milestone of gaming isn’t necessarily obvious (and might simply boil down to “more power”), the advent of 3D gaming was a clear horizon that the industry was moving towards. For a time, many franchises implemented tricks to use 2D elements in a way that appeared to give them more depth.

Star Fox was not one of these games. Famously the first game to feature Argonaut’s Super FX chip built into the cartridge, the 1993 sci-fi rail shooter was the first home console game to feature 3D polygonal graphics.

It was simply stunning that a machine that hadn’t been natively designed to produce such effects did so this flawlessly. Star Fox was fast and frantic, with a thumping soundtrack to match and - like the sharp points of the game’s polygonal Arwing - was cutting edge.

The game was a breath of fresh air; a worthy contribution to any SNES owner’s collection; and revolutionised gaming.


31. 1994 - Super Metroid

Super Metroid Crocomire
Nintendo

There are a handful of games out there that can claim they shook gaming at its core, but very few have entire genres named after them. Whilst Super wasn’t the first Metroid game, it was absolutely the one that perfected the formula.

Samus Aran’s third outing, even more than the previous two, ingeniously presented something that filled a niche; an adventure with a tight yet winding, inter-connected and constantly unfolding map that spoke to players who were tired of running from left to right to finish individual stages but also weren’t fans of full-on RPGs. It also almost wordlessly communicated a beautiful tale that really flipped the perspective of the parasitic Metroid creatures.

It may not be one of the console’s best sellers but, even twenty years later, Super Metroid is still beloved and heralded as not just one of the best games in its series but of the genre it helped create. Players all over the world are still enjoying it pure or otherwise breaking it with speedruns and randomisers. 

This level of devotion doesn’t happen without Super Metroid being a deeply satisfying game to play, with tight controls, luscious 16-bit locations to explore and a uniquely moody soundtrack.


30. 1995 - Chrono Trigger

Chrono Trigger
Square Enix

Every now and then in life, the stars come together to create something truly special. In the case of 1995, the stars were Final Fantasy creator Hironobu Sakaguchi, Dragon Quest creator Yuji Horii and famed designer Akira Toriyama and the “something special” was RPG genre giant Chrono Trigger.

Chrono Trigger innovated by introducing New Game Plus to the world, which worked wonderfully for a game that had so many missable events and alternative outcomes (such as some pretty major differences to the composition of your final party). It also, more obviously, set its turn-based battles in the overworld, taking advantage of a 32-megabit cartridge to smoothly transition from exploration to blasting poor Boundillos into oblivion with some incredible-looking combo attacks.

Every part of Chrono Trigger was a shining example of how far gaming had come. The game contained some of the most gorgeous sprite work and animation ever seen, which helped bring to life a story that moved effortlessly from tragic and emotional to goofy and slapstick. Said story, which dealt with time travel, had an incredibly rewarding pace - always setting up the next event before the last closed up, drawing players onwards to the next time period.

Chrono Trigger was the perfect way to say goodbye to the Super Nintendo and might well be the best the system has to offer, period.


29. 1996 - Pokémon Red, Green and Blue

Pokémon Red And Blue pokemon select
Nintendo

The Game Boy was released in 1989 and became the Nintendo console with the longest lifespan before being replaced by its successor. However, its not appeared thus far simply because Nintendo’s home consoles were always producing the biggest games year-on-year. That’s not to say that wasn’t the case with 1996, as this year the Nintendo 64 arrived and brought with it the likes of Wave Race 64, Mario Kart 64 and 3D platforming revolution Super Mario 64.

None of these were quite on the same level as GameFreak’s Pocket Monsters, however.

Despite the unstoppable wave of marketing and merchandising, and the fact that creator Satoshi Tajiri made two versions of the same game, the heart of the first generation of Pokémon was undeniably pure. Born from a love of bug collecting and RPG games, Pokémon Red and Blue’s easy-to-understand battle system, which paired up creatures that ranged from adorable to kickass, was not just a stroke of genius but something that truly had a lot of heart.

Its approachability set legions of non-gamers off on an epic journey in which they had total control. Planning and constructing a party, swapping stories and even Pokémon themselves with friends, in order to track down and collect all 150 (or 151, if you believed the playground rumours) and become the ultimate master trainer.

Pokémania was a phenomenon the likes of which gaming wouldn’t see again until Fortnite Battle Royale.


28. 1997 - GoldenEye 007

Goldeneye 007 Klobb
Rare

When Sony released the PlayStation in 1994 they did so knowing that Nintendo’s hold on all-ages gaming was firm and, therefore, they could aim for a more mature audience. 

But 1997 saw the release of the game that had PlayStation consumers visiting their N64-owning friends and family members and getting to grips with an awkwardly shaped three-pronged controller to play the FPS game that was setting the world on fire.

GoldenEye 007 was a landmark moment in the shooter genre, being the most approachable and feature-heavy FPS to land on a console. It allowed players to more precisely aim around the screen, and rewarded them with different hit reactions depending on where their shots landed. There was stealth, there was dual wielding and there were a host of mad cheats to offer variety to the experience.

Best of all it supported four-player multiplayer for split-screen carnage. Finally, the joys felt by PC shooter players could be realised on a wider scale. And it worked wonders for Nintendo and Rare, as every player who got to try GoldenEye at a friend's house was inspired to purchase it, making it the best-selling game for the system without the word “Mario” in the title.


27. 1998 - The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time

legend of Ocarina Of Time
Nintendo

As previously noted in the PlayStation list of the same type, 1998 was one of gaming’s best. No matter what console you were on, you were spoilt for choice. In fact, the N64 had several great titles but if there was ever a “nailed-on” entry for this entire article, it was surely Ocarina of Time.

If you know anything at all about video games, you know how important and beloved this game is. Ocarina is a title that entered the Video Game Hall of Fame on its first nomination, has been given endless retrospective rewards and is the single highest-rated game on MetaCritic with a near-perfect score of 99. Whilst time may not have been kind to its visuals, and the franchise has arguably iterated Ocarina into redundancy, there is still a beautiful spark in Link’s first 3D outing.

And that is the spirit of adventure, a wonderment clearly felt by the artists and developers who produced it that they were breaking new ground. The world of Hyrule felt diverse, huge and full of secrets that - whilst recognisable to what came before - required the player to think in new ways. It’s truly astounding how much the team got right on the first published attempt, as Zelda would use Ocarina as a blueprint - heck, so would a lot of other adventure games - for the next two decades. 

With both of Nintendo’s mascots translating over so well, the era of 3D had truly arrived.


26. 1999 - Mario Party 2

NINTENDO 64  Mario Party 2
Nintendo

Whilst ‘99 saw many memorable titles land for the N64, Mario Party 2 should be recognised as the sequel that set up one of Nintendo’s most prolific franchises. Making the original game look more like a proof of concept in retrospect, Mario Party 2 put into place so many series staples.

More than just better boards and better minigames, the title introduced Dual and Battle minigame mechanics to add more direct competitive experiences. It’s strange now to think that the first game didn’t even have items and that it was something that the sequel introduced.

It also finally gave players a chance to practice before playing each game, meaning everyone finally had a chance to understand what was going on beforehand. You were no longer exclaiming “oh I think I’m getting this now” just as your friend completes every single minigame. 

One of the N64’s biggest strengths over its competitors was native four-player support; a shrewd decision that Nintendo made the best of time and time again. The Mario Party series was a big part of the console’s multiplayer line-up, with the second game in particular still held aloft as the superstar of the series.


25. 2000 - Paper Mario

paper mario
Nintendo

On the other hand, one thing that the N64 had an almost total lack of were classic roleplaying games. The restrictions of cartridges over the PlayStation and Saturn’s disc drives were such a difference-maker that Square left Nintendo in the lurch to craft Final Fantasy VII for PS1, leaving the Big N without a developer for the follow-up to SNES cult classic Super Mario RPG.

Instead, the jilted ex-lover Nintendo began crafting the follow-up themselves.

Inspired by the so-called ultra-realism of 3D graphics of the time, Nintendo wanted Paper Mario to be a cuter and more charming affair than something like Super Mario 64. This birthed the unique paper-craft aesthetic, stage-play-set battle arena, and a Mario who had never shown so much personality before.

Paper Mario’s “all ages” vibe might not seem like the deepest role-player but it had plenty going for it, Timed button presses and flicks of the stick, depending on the kinds of attacks Mario and his allies were utilising, caused more damage. There was the badge system, for giving characters passive buffs. Outside of battle, each of Mario’s allies’ unique abilities could be used to navigate the world or find secrets.

It might not be the first Mario RPG game but it’s absolutely the most important, as it created a franchise in its own right and inspired the separate Mario + Luigi series.


24. 2001 - Super Smash Bros. Melee

super smash bros melee
Nintendo

Whilst the GameCube era might not have been Nintendo’s strongest financially, it produced plenty of solid gold classics. One of the best came in just the first few months of the console’s time on the market.

Super Smash Bros. Melee was the wine squeezed from the grapes of its predecessor but its true strength was the perfect balance of its content. The character roster felt massive but not intimidating and the various modes - Classic, Adventure, All Star, that one where you take your middle school angst out on a sandbag - kept players entertained whilst helping them to get better at the fundamentals.

Or you could just turn all the items on “very high” and let chaos reign.

It made for a deeply replayable package, assisted by its superb engine that far outlived the GameCube itself. Even with multiple sequels in later generations, Melee’s swift, heavy and exploitable engine set the groundwork for Nintendo’s first eSport - accidental or otherwise.

More than anything, Melee took the concept of the Nintendo party fighter to a level that made it gaming’s premiere crossover event. Just the opening video weaving through the likes of Zelda, Kirby, Star Fox and surprising choices (to Westerners, at least) like Ness. That first 90 seconds was Nintendo hype like we never had before, and it became the console’s killer multiplayer app for a long time.


23. 2002 - Metroid Prime

Metroid Prime Meta Ridley
Nintendo

Despite clearly wanting to do more, Metroid is one of the franchises that Nintendo has struggled most with. Historically, the games have always sold better internationally than in Japan so, in a way, it made sense to boldly hand off development of the franchise to a Western team.

Retro Studio’s shift to a first-person perspective sent fans into a terrified frenzy on its first reveal, but when Metroid Prime landed (first in America, a rare occurrence) the talk went flat. It was a refreshing reboot for a series that had been dormant for nearly a decade.

Still, a lot connected the new Metroid style to its forebearers. The precision-based shooting in its exploration and boss fights was more evident than ever, and there was the same thick, lonely atmosphere that players expected, with each locale stuffed with secrets to find and mysteries to unravel.

Couple this with brilliant immersive touches that made players feel like they were inhabiting Samus’ powersuit, and the game connected with Nintendo’s older audience hungry for games that pushed the envelope.

Samus had finally proven she could viably walk both the 2D and the 3D paths and offer something different. To this day, both Super Metroid and Metroid Prime are the golden stars of the franchise, with the #1 podium purely down to personal preference.


 
Posted On: 
Contributor

Coming from a content creation background that now spans over two decades, Psy cut her teeth on personal video production and community radio. Originally joining the team as a writer and presenter, she added video editing duties to her responsibilities over time and became the longest-standing editor of the irreverent gaming show Tues Your Own Adventure. Psy has worked on many previews and reviews, long-form editorials (either her own, or supporting as an editor), as a frequent quizmaster and more. Praised for the two-pronged attack of her hard work ethic and light-hearted editing style, Psy is otherwise known as a font of retro video game knowledge which has caused her to rack up many gaming quiz wins. Outside of WhatCulture, Psy runs First Aid Spray Podcast - a long-running channel that focuses on Resident Evil in all of it's forms. You can follow her on BlueSky at http://psywhite.bsky.social and Instagram at http://instagram.com/therealpsywhite