The Best Nintendo Game Every Year 1983 - 2024

22. 2003 - Viewtiful Joe

Viewtiful Joe 1
Capcom

Nintendo have a long and checkered history when it comes to third-party support, partly in thanks to their choice of hardware. First cartridges and now proprietary miniature discs but, regardless, they managed to land a pretty sweet deal with Capcom to bolster their library in 2002.

This was a series of Gamecube-exclusive titles called the Capcom Five (of which four were released and only one remained exclusive. Hilarious).

The second of these was Viewtiful Joe. In an era that was embracing realism, 3D exploration and adult themes, Hideki Kamiya’s stylish action platformer went almost the opposite way every time: 3D environments that were merely a background for a classic 2D beat-em-up, visuals that were vibrantly cel-shaded and goofy writing that was full of referential humour.

Inspired by tokusatsu film in Japan, like Super Sentai and Kamen Rider, Viewtiful Joe’s full embrace of the love of movies also made for unique gameplay that utilised slow motion and after-images in both combat and puzzle solving. It was a game that was bursting with joy for its inspirations, and its own world.

A game with this kind of oddball character could only debut on the GameCube. It may not have sold well, but Viewtiful Joe made a believer of every player who picked it up in 2003 and beyond.


21. 2004 - Pikmin 2

Pikmin 2
Nintendo

Since Nintendo has a few core franchises they reliably lean on, it often falls to the new IP to truly define the generation. With the Lil’ Purple Lunchbox, the most noteworthy might be Pikmin, with the first game in 2001 and its stunning sequel three years later.

With every new franchise, the first entry is often about proving that it can work and the original Pikmin was a charming and cutesy facade on a deceptively tactical strategy adventure. Pikmin 2 took the formula and tweaked certain parts of it just enough to stand alone and, debatably, set itself as the apex of the franchise even to this day.

Commanding Pikmin with the GameCube controller was more satisfying than ever, and Pikmin 2 offered a much higher skill ceiling despite the loss of the first game’s strict campaign timer. In its stead, players battled competitively with friends, explored challenging dungeons and ran in fright of a terrifying semi-transparent man with bulldozers for hands and feet.

The series might not be for everyone but its incredibly unique vibe is what makes it such a delight, and Pikmin 2 is the most rewarding for those who really connect with that vibe.


20. 2005 - Resident Evil 4

Resident Evil 4
Capcom

At this point, Resident Evil 4 has been ported to so many systems that someone should check to see if it hasn’t gained sentience and is intent on spreading itself into the homes of as many people as possible as some kind of unexpected hostile takeover.

And whilst the PS2 version may be what brought the game its first big wave of sales, RE4 was originally part of the aforementioned Capcom Five and exclusively made the GameCube it’s home for ten months.

Resident Evil 4 is one of those games that has been written about so much that there might be nothing new left to say. And, for good reason. Heralded not just as one of the best games ever made, but as a title that revolutionised the third-person action game, RE4 still holds up twenty years and a remake later. 

Resident Evil 4 keeps players in its grasp with utterly addictive combat punctuated with fresh ideas and set pieces. There’s protecting the President’s Daughter, a battle on a moving boat, quick-time events, shooting galleries, the terror of the rattling Regenerator enemies and some frankly insane boss fights...

Games on Nintendo systems are often in the conversation for game of the year, but rarely is there a more universally agreed title than 2005’s Resident Evil 4. Even if most of those votes probably came from PS2 players…


19. 2006 - Wii Sports

wii sports
Nintendo

There’s something very funny about the year 2006. Xbox players were toiling in the war against the Locust in Gears of War, PlayStation were sneaking back through the forests of Metal Gear Solid 3 with the Subsistence rerelease… and Nintendo players? Waggling remotes around pretending to play tennis.

And somehow, despite the out-of-nowhere batpoo insanity of it all, the Nintendo Wii was an overnight sensation, becoming the company’s biggest launch and being in-demand for a lot of its first full year. 

Obviously, Wii Sports is the best-selling game for the console as it was the pack-in during the Wii’s boom period. But this was very much the right call to make as it perfectly demonstrated what the console was all about. A simple compilation of five sporting events that were recognisable and easily adaptable to the system’s motion controls; Wii Sports was something that most able-bodied people could pick up and enjoy almost right away.

It doesn’t have the depth or necessarily the artistic merit of Gears of War or Metal Gear Solid, but Nintendo’s Wagglelympics helped many create memories with all kinds of people in their lives and, for that, we salute you Wii Sports.


18. 2007 - Super Mario Galaxy

super mario galaxy petey
Nintendo

And so a new Nintendo console arrives, so too does the Moustachioed Inevitability. Whilst both narrowly missing inclusion on this list, both Mario 64 and Super Mario Sunshine were huge hits for respective onsoles landing in the top and third sales slot respectively.

Thankfully, whilst Mario Galaxy did use what the Wii could uniquely offer, it was at its core a traditional 3D Mario platformer.

More than anything else, Mario Galaxy’s biggest strength was in its wild sight-seeing tour of Rosalina’s wacky universe, with its constantly shifting gravity and its endless planetoid each with different shapes, gimmicks and objectives. The game kept players engaged (or addicted) by retaining the most basic Mario gameplay but offering a continuous stream of something new to see.

And hear too, since Galaxy’s lushly-textured score was the first time Mario had an adventure to the sounds of a real orchestra.

Perhaps the most consistently good 3D outing that Mario has ever been on, Galaxy would remain one of the best examples of what the Wii could achieve in terms of its graphics as well as how innate motion controls could feel if done subtly.


17. 2008 - Mario Kart Wii

Mario Kart Wii Donkey Kong
Nintendo

It’s not surprising that when looking into which Mario Kart games frequently top the franchise in terms of fan favourites, the Wii edition is a regular #1 spot. After all, it sold like hot cakes with even better hot cakes inside of them.

And this is despite the fact that Mario Kart Wii is an infamously broken game, with speedrunners beating tracks in literal seconds by reversing and leaping over the finish line, and the game turning Funky Kong into a superstar by virtue of him being blatantly faster than every other racer. 

But in a sense, that’s what made the game so fun. It had something for everyone - from the diehard competitive racers with Gamecube or Pro controllers to your parents who wanted to try out the surprisingly enjoyable Wii Wheel. Mario Kart Wii appealed to the console’s mix of demographics with chaotic casual race and, for the first time ever, online play.

Each sequel is a must-have for its respective Nintendo system, but rarely has an instalment defined a console like Mario Kart Wii did.


16. 2009 - Grand Theft Auto: Chinatown Wars

grand theft auto chinatown wars ds
Rockstar

And the award for most surprising appearance from a franchise on a Nintendo list…

It’s not like Grand Theft Auto hadn’t been on Nintendo platforms before but Chinatown Wars was a brand new instalment that, more than anything else, made full use of what the DS was capable of… almost to an uncomfortable degree. 

There was something hilariously icky about selling and moving drugs using a DS touch-screen like you were getting away with something Nintendo shouldn’t know about. The game had lots of unique moments all throughout its campaign that used the console’s gimmick, and they had plenty of variety, from filling Molotov bottles and arming explosives to setting up a sniper rifle and burning documents.

The core gameplay was more akin to GTA’s original top-down feel but with the ability to move protagonist Lee around Liberty City on foot. It was a refreshing reminder of, and an update on, what came before GTA went full 3D.

So whilst there were plenty of concessions that didn’t put Chinatown Wars on the same scale as the PS2 games, it instead made something great out of what it could do. This is to say that, whilst DS fans may be dismayed that the first appearance from the console here is a GTA game of all things, it turns out that Chinatown Wars is the highest-rated title on the system. 

Wild.


15. 2010 - Kirby's Epic Yarn

kirbys epic yarn
Nintendo

2010 was a pretty strong year for Nintendo seeing the likes of Donkey Kong Country Returns, the West finally getting Professor Layton and the Unwound Future, and Super Mario Galaxy 2 arriving which we’re giving silver this year for the sake of variety.

The gold - and every other colour of the rainbow - goes to the joy in video game form that was Kirby’s Epic Yarn, one of the year’s most pleasant surprises. Turning the Kirby series into something totally fresh, it’s funny to look back at Epic Yarn winning Best Graphics awards for the year but it truly deserved it as few games had attempted such a handcrafted feel before.

With the Wii in the home of plenty of families, the game was a no-brainer buy for those with young children but there was still enough flair for people of all ages to enjoy.

It was the attention to detail, and the breadth of that detail, that made Epic Yarn such a wonderful experience. Even though the game presented next to no challenge (players couldn’t die), there was always a reason to keep going. Each new stage presented new gimmicks, transformations or just fun visual ideas that kept the game captivating.


14. 2011 - Pokémon Black & White

pokemon black white
Nintendo

Returning to the DS, and we’re back to the world of stuffing cute critters into spheres and then forcing them to take on cults, criminals and that next door neighbour you have weird feelings about.

And there were more of those cute critters than ever by 2010’s Black & White versions, which added a stonking 156 designs. With the series perpetually trying to find the right place to draw the line between new and nostalgic, the fifth generation of games outright did away with the latter, populating the gorgeous United States-inspired Unova with all-new Pokémon. This, in itself was a bold and controversial move.

But whilst the quality of the Pokémon will always be up for debate, Black & White received universal praise for its story that actually posed questions about the morality of stuffing cute critters into spheres. Its characters asked its players shockingly poignant philosophical questions, which built up to one of the best final acts in the series.

Every Pokémon fan will have a different ranking of the games, and Black & White to many were already a step-down from the previous year’s HeartGold & SoulSilver remakes, but they should be commended for what they did right.


13. 2012 - ZombiU

zombiu u
Ubisoft

The Wii U’s launch line-up consisted of a selection of lesser-versions of 3rd party games like Mass Effect 3, Batman Arkham City and Assassin’s Creed III. In terms of exclusives, the console didn’t have a strong start.

The best of the bunch though, unexpectedly, was a Ubisoft title. Far from a perfect game, with review scores ranging from “good” to “good enough”, ZombiU was still an excellent addition to the Nintendo line-up for a few reasons. 

First of all, coming off the Wii, it represented hope that the company was more open-minded about signing off on more mature titles. Secondly, it was one of the more ingenious uses of the gamepad that the console ever saw in it’s lifespan.

Set in London during a zombie apocalypse, players used the GamePad screen as a map and inventory. There was nothing like the tension of looking between the TV and the controller, expecting a monster to come looking for lunch whilst you rifled through your backpack. End up eaten, and you’d reload as another hopeful survivor, able to find your former zombified self (or even your friends, with online functions enabled).

ZombiU was a rare breath of fresh air in an otherwise mouldy, rotting zombie genre, and its ports to other consoles come with the caveat of “it was better on Wii U” - which nobody says about really any other game.


 
Posted On: 
Contributor

Coming from a content creation background that now spans over two decades, Psy cut her teeth on personal video production and community radio. Originally joining the team as a writer and presenter, she added video editing duties to her responsibilities over time and became the longest-standing editor of the irreverent gaming show Tues Your Own Adventure. Psy has worked on many previews and reviews, long-form editorials (either her own, or supporting as an editor), as a frequent quizmaster and more. Praised for the two-pronged attack of her hard work ethic and light-hearted editing style, Psy is otherwise known as a font of retro video game knowledge which has caused her to rack up many gaming quiz wins. Outside of WhatCulture, Psy runs First Aid Spray Podcast - a long-running channel that focuses on Resident Evil in all of it's forms. You can follow her on BlueSky at http://psywhite.bsky.social and Instagram at http://instagram.com/therealpsywhite