WWE 2K16: 10 Superstars That Are Criminally Under-Rated

Brock Lesnar only 94/100?!?!

Getting a WWE Superstar's rating right is an unenviable task for 2K in their video games. This is because WWE is a machine that never stands still, it's a machine that is constantly moving and requires different cogs to get from one point to another. These cogs - the Superstars - are constantly changing in importance through the process of creative and storylines. As Piers Morgan's Twitter bio reads, "One day you're the cock of the walk, the next a feather duster." Never has a truer word been said in terms of WWE and how their product works. One minute you could be on top, the next you're down in the dumps with the rotting corpses on Superstars. Just look at Jack Swagger as an example of this in action... From World Heavyweight Champion to nothingness in a few short years. The former All-American, American has found himself rated as high as 89 in WWE games, but even though he's still up there in this year's game with a rating of 85, even he would have to concede he lucky to have that due to the way he's been booked in recent times. What I'm trying to say here is that the ratings in wrestling games in general aren't based on skill or prowess in the ring, they're based on how a Superstar is being booked at the time of development. If you're being pushed around WrestleMania season, you're in for a very pretty looking year in the virtual WWE Universe of their video games. Here's 10 Superstars who are criminally under-rated in WWE 2K16.

10. Brock Lesnar - 94

John Cena: 95 (PS4) Brock Lesnar: 94 (PS4) Work that one out for me... The Beast Incarnate has been unstoppable over the last two years, conquering everything in his path. He would be WWE World Heavyweight Champion now if it wasn't for The Undertaker interfering in the main event of Battleground in the summer. Even though The Phenom cost him the championship against Seth Rollins, Brock brushed aside the challenge of The Deadman in two stellar bouts which culminated in a throwback Hell in a Cell. But in feuding with Rollins and Taker, WWE seem to have wiped another rivalry from their minds. Coming off the back of the Streak ending victory at WrestleMania XXX, Lesnar challenged John Cena for the WWE World Heavyweight Championship. The Beast demolished Cena without breaking sweat at SummerSlam 2014 - using around 5678 German Suplexes on the road to a comprehensive victory. Mr Money in the Bank Rollins would then become involved in the rivalry, but Lesnar still came out on top. He should be the highest rated Superstar in the game off the back of this run alone. I understand that John Cena is the franchise player in WWE, but the company's leading game should really mirror what is going on in the real life product. And even though WWE won't want you to remember this, Brock Lesnar wiped the floor with the leader of the Cenation on more than one occasion.

9. Kalisto - 83

Look at that Salida Del Sol through a ladder from TLC and tell me that was done by a man who should be rated 83... WWE have their next Rey Mysterio with Kalisto and should be looking to push him like the two-time WWE World Champion Mexican great in the coming year. Kalisto is a victim of timing here. He and Sin Cara as the Lucha Dragons were introduced to the world on the RAW after WrestleMania XXXI, meaning that 2K couldn't give him anything too high - despite his obvious prowess. 2K and WWE would have been well into the development of their new game and would have only had The Lucha Dragons' work from NXT and sporadic Superstars appearances to work off. Given what the team has done over the last nine months they should be higher, with Kalisto receiving the bigger increase in rating of the two. Don't be surprised if he is THE breakout star of 2016 in WWE.

8. Paul Wight - 85

Paul Wight was a freak of nature. He was the size of Andre The Giant with all the agility and athleticism of a Brock Lesnar. He had all the tools to be the top guy in WWE. However, for one reason or another - including what mentor The Undertaker has gone on record as describing as a lack of motivation - he didn't really fulfill his potential back in the Attitude Era. He arrived from WCW with a huge reputation but failed to deliver. This has to be why his rating is so low in WWE 2K16. Over the last decade The Big Show's work has gotten progressively worse. Being that size and having all those miles under your belt can't be good for your health. This has affected Wight's work and has led a large proportion of the WWE Universe to call for his retirement. Why then is 2015's Big Show rated as a 91 compared to Wight's 85 in 2K16? No offence to Show at the grand old age of 43, but the man he arrived in WWE as is twice the athlete he is now. It should really be the other way round...

7. Kofi Kingston - 84

With Big E at 85 and Xavier Woods at 83 - bearing in mind that the bulk of the developmental work for WWE 2K16 was done in the early part of the year - you would have to admit that 2K had nailed the New Day. That is until you get to Kofi Kingston. Despite being a mainstay on the main roster for close to a decade now, Kingston's rating sees him fall short of the likes of Jack Swagger, Darren Young and Eric Rowan - all Superstars he is far superior than. You would have to put this down to a period of stagnation - and rocky start to the New Day's run - in Kofi's career. He played the role of a mid card babyface well without tearing up any trees. He would bag a couple of notable wins over the likes of Randy Orton, and bring something special out of his locker when the Royal Rumble came round, but that was about it for a long while. Then of course we had the confusion of what the New Day actually were at their inception before they came into their own as heels. We all knew how great Kofi was in the ring heading into this year, but I don't think any of us knew how great he was on the mic, "SUURRN." He, and the rest of the New Day for that matter, should be in for a huge increase in time for WWE 2K17.

6. Enzo Amore - 80

Bada boom, most underrated guy in the room... I get that Amore is supposed to be the perennial underdog in NXT at the moment - his size and in-ring style tells you that pretty blatantly - but having him so low is a bit of an insult. The Certified G and A Bona-Fide Stud has proved that he can go in the ring, showing technical prowess and seemingly endless energy. He compliments his giant of a partner Big Cass very well and never fails to set up the hottest of hot tags by the way of great selling. Then we have his mic work. Enzo should be a mind 80s Superstar in WWE 2K16 thanks to his promos alone. He's arguably the best on the mic in the entire WWE let alone NXT, and if you don't believe me just head on to Youtube to check out a plethora of his highlights. You can't teach what he does on the stick. You really can't. He's certainly one of a kind and destined for the main roster in 2016. This, hopefully, will see his rating increase to something closer to what his displays have shown us to date.

5. Baron Corbin - 81

You all hate this entry, don't you? But you can't get away from the fact that Baron Corbin is one of the most improved Superstars in all of WWE this year and could be set for a breakthrough year in WWE if he can master his work on the microphone. Once more, this one has to be down to timing. In the early part of the year, the powers that be in NXT booked Corbin as a monster who defeated anyone and everyone in next-to-no-time. It looked as if Triple H et al knew he wasn't capable of doing anything other than a 20 second squash match and seemingly played to his strengths. Now, with rivalries against the likes of Bull Dempsey and Apollo Crews under his belt, Baron has proved he can put on longer matches and hang with the best of them. He starting to become someone you hate for all the right reasons, rather than having an X Pac type heat on his shoulders. He's by no means the finished article but if far better than an 81 on WWE 2K16 suggests.

4. Edge - 88

Don't get me wrong, 88 is a very respectable score indeed - after all Edge was the Ultimate Opportunist and never billed as THE guy in WWE - but for me at least it just comes up a little short for someone who has the Rated R Superstar's achievements. 4-time WWE Champion 7-time World Heavyweight Champion 5-time WWF/E Intercontinental Champion 1-time WCW United States Champion 12-time World Tag Team Champion 2-time WWE Tag Team Championship King of the Ring (2001) Money in the Bank (2005) Royal Rumble winner (2010) Bragging Rights Trophy (2010) Fourteenth Triple Crown Champion Seventh Grand Slam Champion WWE Hall of Fame (Class of 2012) 2 Slammy Awards That deserves to be in the low 90s at least, right? Edge's abilities in the ring and on the mic deserve a little more than he's been given. He's one of those fluid competitors who never seemed to miss a beat, while the improvement in his promos from his Brood days to the end of his career was unparalleled. Then again, 2K could have simply played up to the gimmick and marked him low on purpose. The marks!

3. Kane (2001) - 87

The Brothers of Destruction Kane. The everyone is scared of him Kane. The record breaking eliminations from a Royal Rumble Kane. The Kane that we all knew and loved from our childhoods. The no selling. The ridiculous feats of strength. The popularity of the BoD team. A score of 87 doesn't even come close, especially when you see that the glorified jobber that is Corporate Kane is rated an 86 - 2001 Kane blew him out of the water! Have I made my case? Surely he needs to be pushing a 91 or 92? Or am I being too biased in my role as an Attitude Era masked Kane mark?

2. Tyler Breeze - 83

Once more, timing is making 2K look pretty foolish in their judgement. For a long while before his ascension to the main roster in WWE, Tyler Breeze was one of the most over and respected in-ring competitors in NXT. I mean, WWE doesn't pick you to be Jushin Thunder Liger's opponent for what looks like could be his only WWE match if you aren't good at what you do. Why then is Breeze a mere 83 on the game? My guess is timing and the amount of exposure the Sultan of Selfies had around Mania season when the game was in its development phase. We haven't seen much in the ring from Prince Pretty since his promotion but it's clear that he know his way round a wrestling ring, while his gimmick and mic skills are certainly there. The more we see from Breeze the better. He's certainly one to keep your eye on over the coming years.

1. Cesaro - 88

An Andre The Giant Memorial Battle Royal win and a frustratingly failed run with Paul Heyman... WWE 2K15: 93 (PS4) A fantastic run of tag team performances with Tyson Kidd and a solid few months of five star singles matches where he was allowed to showcase his prowess in the ring... WWE 2K16: 88 (PS4) Work that one out for me?

Content Producer
Content Producer

Video & written Content Producer for WhatCulture Wrestling. NCTJ trained journalist. BA Hons, Sports Journalism.