WWE 2K19: 10 Most Overrated Wrestlers

Go home, 2K, you're drunk...

Kurt Angle Stephanie McMahon
WWE.com

A lot of people believe Stephanie McMahon's on screen character is too powerful or overbearing, and she's a hard-to-stomach, ball-cutting machine who delights in getting the last word over everybody else sharing her segments. Just wait until those same detractors clap eyes on her WWE 2K19 rating.

Oooooooh boy, are they ever in for a treat when they compare it to some of the other women in-game. Brace yourselves, world, because the pitchforks are about to come out like never before. Amidst a women's revolution, a certain McMahon has even trumped her father's rating this year.

It's fair to say 2K's rating system needed an editor before the company released everyone's score. Some wrestlers are woefully underpowered compared to those of lesser standing in WWE, and a fair few have seemingly been handed ratings intended for someone else. That's the only way to explain some of the subjects burning under the microscope of disbelief here.

On the plus side, picking some of these guys and gals will ensure you win most matches in-game. Wait a minute. Actually winning some matches. That's an alien concept to some...


10. Curt Hawkins

WWE 2K19 Curt Hawkins
2K Games

Rating: 64

Why It's Too High: Wait, what? Curt freakin' Hawkins? The same guy who has lost pretty much every single match since the dawn of time, and a no-hoper who cannot buy a win on WWE TV. What is he doing here? Surely Hawkins, the subject teased in the last line of that intro, can't be overrated.

He is.

2K have missed a golden opportunity to make the man who has lost over 200 matches absolutely hopeless in the new game. We're not talking average or mediocre, we mean atrociously bad. As in, pick him and he'll fall over during Irish Whips or accidentally knock himself out with a steel chair kind of terrible.

64 might be the lowest rating in 2K19, but it's only four points worse off than Ariya Daivari. It should be in the 40s, just to keep the gag going.


9. Mustafa Ali

WWE 2K19 Mustafa Ali
2K Games

Rating: 81

Why It's Too High: Somehow, some way, 205 Live's Mustafa Ali is rated a full 17 points better than Curt Hawkins. Not only that, the Cruiserweight star is on equal footing with Adam Cole, Andrade Almas, Big Boss Man, Bobby Roode, The British Bulldog (!?) and more.

Yep. According to 2K, Ali's Mortal Kombat-style look means he could easily have headlined SummerSlam 1992 or worked main event steel cage matches against Hulk Hogan in the '80s. OK, maybe not, but it is a bit generous to give him that high a score.

Some of Ali's fellow 205 chums didn't fair so well. Noam Dar, for example, clocks in with a lowly 69 rating, and WWE's first Cruiser Champ TJP only has a 76. On top of that, Mustafa's 81 is only a point shy of Big Show, Sami Zayn and Elias, to name a few.


8. Cedric Alexander

WWE 2K19 Cedric Alexander
2K Games

Rating: 83

Why It's Too High: Speaking of way too generous, 2K decided to give reigning 205 Live king Cedric Alexander a rating that actually tops Big Show, Zayn, Elias and others. Seriously, that is not a joke.

No offence intended to Alexander (he's a fine performer) here. He has skills, though they shouldn't be anywhere near the mid-80s. Last year in 2K18, Cedric had a rating of 76, and that seems much more realistic. There's no way he should be running Jeff Hardy (84), Chris Jericho (85) and Kurt Angle's '01 character (86) close in this year's game.

Think about that for a second, then realise how ludicrous it is considering their presentation on TV. It appears being the current Cruiserweight Champion does a lot for one's standing in the eyes of 2K's developers. They clearly covet the belt more than WWE themselves do.


7. The Rock

WWE 2K19 The Rock
2K Games

Rating: 93

Why It's Too High: Sorry, Rocky, but all we smell is bullsh*t.

If this was The Rock from 2001, it'd be understandable. It's not though, it's part-time Dwayne Johnson, who last wrestled a six-second match against Erick Rowan at WrestleMania 32. Since then, Rocky hasn't worked a lick for WWE. He's been far too busy slaying Hollywood, and knocking out quality performances on the silver screen.

The fact he has a 93 overall in 2K19 is shocking. To put that into perspective, it makes him the joint-best wrestler in the entire game. He's level with Brock Lesnar, one point better off than poster boy Roman Reigns and a full two better than his own '01 model. How on earth did they work that one out?

Modern-day Rock is also superior to an in-his-prime Steve Austin (92), The Undertaker from 2002 (90) and the great Randy Savage (89). This is either sucking up to a Hollywood darling or someone in the 2K offices has a Brahma Bull tattoo from college.


6. Sting '99

WWE 2K19 Sting
2K Games

Rating: 91

Why It's Too High: 1999 was far from Sting's best year, and it wasn't even the peak of his 'Crow' character's powers. Anyone who watched longer than a few hours of Nitro would know that. Lord only knows then why Sting's '99 model is ranked three points higher than his '98 one, or a point more than '91.

That year ('91), he had epics against Ric Flair, teamed with Lex Luger to have a barn-burner against The Steiner Brothers at the first SuperBrawl, and even found time to tussle with a young Steve Austin.

Meanwhile towards the end of the century, he had a tedious match with Rick Steiner, wrestled countless inconsequential matches on Nitro and tried on a failed heel turn on Hulk Hogan at Fall Brawl. There's zero reason why his 1999 character should be an improvement over either '98 or '01.

Hell, even his two matches for WWE in 2015 were better than WCW's nonsense that year.


5. Matt Hardy

WWE 2K19 Matt Hardy
2K Games

Rating: 84

Why It's Too High: Matt Hardy will always be regarded as one of the most exciting tag-team experts in WWE history, and he should be applauded for reinventing himself as the wacky 'Broken/Woken' gimmick fans last saw before he announced retirement.

That doesn't mean he merits the high 84 rating 2K have handed him for 2K19.

Matt in 2018 has not been a better worker than Daniel Bryan was in 2012, and that particular Bryan variant has an 83 overall. Then, there's the curious case of Mr. Perfect; Curt Hennig's character can only brag about an 83 himself, meaning 'Woken' Hardy is deemed more powerful than one of WWE's most heralded super workers.

If 2K were being honest with themselves and not looking through a Vanguard 1-tinted lens, they'd see that Matt belonged between the 78-80 region this year.


4. Baron Corbin

WWE 2K19 Baron Corbin
2K Games

Rating: 84

Why It's Too High: Baron Corbin has moved on from playing the deceptively agile big biker with the sad tummy and rapidly-diminishing hairline. His new 'Constable' look isn't for everybody, but it's a vast improvement, and he arguably looks bigger in-ring than ever before. Haters will always hate, so deciding a suitable rating for Corbin must have been a nightmare.

84, though? Well, it's a bit over-the-top.

2K have put Baron on level footing with Cesaro, Sheamus, Dolph Ziggler, Jeff Hardy, Rick Rude and others. Raw's stand-in authority man also has the same rating as The Miz's '10 model, and he won the WWE Title that year. Hmm, we're not sure it's accurate to say Corbin is on that same pedestal of quality.

He wouldn't have to drop too much to be in a more suitable place. 2K could've given Baron a rating of 81-82 and nobody would've blinked an eye. Corbin is deserving of that, just not punching above his weight a point behind the likes of Chris Jericho or Dusty Rhodes.


3. Paige

WWE 2K19 Paige
2K Games

Rating: 83

Why It's Too High: It's been said before, and yet it's worth repeating. 2K's approach to determining ratings for everyone on the roster is hard to work out. Sometimes, older wrestlers are judged on their peak run. Then, others are (rather bizarrely) not, and the result is an inconsistent mess of scores.

Paige is an example of that in the female ranks.

Her character model will be based on her current run as SmackDown GM sans fancy clothes, and so the 83 overall ranking seems a tad excessive. It's even more strange when seeing that the brand's current champ Becky Lynch has the same rating, or that Paige sits a mere two points behind WWE female worker extraordinaire Charlotte Flair (85).

Similarly, Paige is one point shy of matching Asuka (84), and sits level on points with Natalya. Meanwhile on the male side of things, her SmackDown superior and Commissioner Shane McMahon is way down at 81. It's all very illogical.


2. Stephanie McMahon

WWE 2K19 Stephanie McMahon
2K Games

Rating: 77

Why It's Too High: Yes, that does indeed read seventy seven. Here's a quick list of women in WWE 2K19 that Stephanie McMahon's character could probably demolish...

Alicia Fox (71), Lana (70), Bianca Belair (77), Dana Brooke (69), Brie Bella (76), Mandy Rose (70), Sonya Deville (74), Maryse (73), Sarah Logan (70), Liv Morgan (71) and Tamina (74). The most notable ones there are Bella, Tamina and Belair, who has the same rating as Steph.

Now, don't get us wrong, McMahon isn't bad in-ring. In fact, she excelled in her role at WrestleMania 34 and has previously done the same solid work in years gone past. Still, it's a little rich to claim she's competitive with most of the current female roster not named Ronda Rousey, Charlotte Flair, Asuka, Sasha Banks and the like.

Then, there's the baffling news that Vince McMahon's rating is 73. 2K believe Stephanie is worthy of four more points overall than her father.


1. Ric Flair

WWE 2K19 Ric Flair
2K Games

Rating: 91

Why It's Too High: This is not a diss on the legendary Ric Flair. Allow, if you will, an explanation as to why the iconic 'Nature Boy' tops this list.

In total, Flair has three different character models in 2K19. Both his '88 and '90 versions are rated at 90, and that's fine. Trouble starts when analysing his more modern character though. That one, presumably the guy who retired at WrestleMania XXIV and not the one starring in rap videos today, comes armed with a massive 91 overall.

This suggests that Flair in 2008 was better than Ric as NWA Champion 20 years prior. As great a match as he had with Shawn Michaels in Orlando, that cannot be true. Flair was a tour de force of a wrestler in the 80s, and he knocked out top-notch performances for breakfast in the early 90s too.

Surely it would have been more realistic to do what 2K did with Daniel Bryan's models by showing a natural rise then decline in Flair's abilities as the years rolled on.

Wooooo-oops.

-

Which other WWE 2K19 characters do you think are overpowered and overrated? Let us know down in the comments section below!


Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.