Xbox One Vs PS4: Head To Head In 10 Key Areas

nd I spent an ample amount of time exploring the features and software of the Playstation 4, and vice versa on the Xbox One throughout the week of November 22nd leading up until today. And while I have various game reviews live €“ including Killzone: Shadow Fall and Dead Rising 3 - today we will be stepping away from critiquing software primarily, but rather pitting the capabilities of these next generation behemoths against each other, across various topics. This will not be an article that holds back on criticism and renders every point of discussion a tie either; I have very vocal, both positive and negative things to say about each console. Ultimately however, I hope you come away with a greater knowledge and understanding of which next generation console you want to bite the bullet on first. Click Next to begin...


10. User Interface

Ps4 Interface 600x300 It€™s often taken for granted and overlooked due to how little time is actually spent at a console€™s dashboard, but it€™s a very aesthetically important aspect to get right. The first thing you will see upon firing up any console for the first time nowadays is a home center; these are your first impressions of a machine you just dropped some heavy dollars on, and first impressions go a long way. Both consoles have made vast improvements to their console too. For one, Microsoft hasn€™t littered the Xbox One with a slew of in your face advertisements courting you to check out nonsense you don€™t care about. You can also fully operate the entire dashboard along with multiple sub menus via using the Kinect 2.0 (which comes bundled with the console). Even more surprisingly, searching for games, movies, and more through Bing is actually responsive and correct. So long as you€™re saying recognizable things with a degree of clarity. Microsoft also has taken steps backward though unfortunately. The Windows 8 reminiscent layout with gigantic boxes everywhere is aesthetically hideous. It€™s nice being able to fully customize your own personal screen with apps that you€™ll probably seize the most entertainment out of, but the sheer ugliness of it all sours the gesture. There€™s also no way to check your HDD storage which frustrates me, because I play a wide variety of games and install files are now larger than ever on both consoles. The Playstation 4 however once again has a sleek and familiar interface, where once again your various console sections are laid out horizontally with multiple sub menus trailing down vertically. Games also now have their own separate line which initially felt counter-intuitive to selecting apps, but with the standard bundled microphone you can simply say the title and begin playing instantly. I have very little, if any at all complaints with this dashboard and I haven€™t even mentioned the vibrant blue background and calming music that overlay the hub, which are wonderful little touches. Both consoles also have an activity feed for your friends, but again because the Playstation 4 simply looks sleeker, its What€™s New hub comes across more spiffy. Admittedly, both consoles will take some time to completely navigate on muscle memory reflexes, but the Playstation 4 wins this round for its aesthetics and ease of use.

9. Friends And Social Media Integration

Skype Xbox You also have more in-depth notification options for how friend requests, messages, and simply viewing your friends list operates across both consoles. Name requests however are a neat feature exclusively to the Playstation 4, allowing you to display your real identity and Facebook profile picture alongside your online handle. The Friends hub on Playstation 4 is essentially Facebook, but stripped of all the annoying clutter and nonsense. You can also now have up to 2,000 friends across any individual Playstation Network account, which is fantastic news. Personally speaking, I€™m already at 118 and still trucking along friending fellow gamers. If you enjoy reading my content then shoot me a friend request at Solid_Fantasy, I certainly would be grateful to accept considering it€™s so robust and simple. Microsoft however didn€™t really expand on anything, which is completely baffling because legions of gamers have been vocal about both console€™s original 100 person limit they were confined to on both Playstation 3 and Xbox 360. The Xbox One just has a new Followers tab which essentially imitates Twitter in hackneyed fashion. They did implement Skype though which works well enough. Sony definitely wins this round overall though.

8. Installing Games

Mark Cerny Ps4 It€™s already been mentioned in this article but this generation has some incredibly meaty games in terms of data size. Across both consoles, Ryse, Killzone, NBA 2K14, and more have gargantuan mandatory install sizes surpassing the 40GB mark. Prior to both console launches, we really had no idea how this would function, other than that you would only have to install a fraction of the game before being able to jump in. As someone who has played multiple games across both consoles, I can tell you that there is a massive difference between how each OS multi-tasks. PS4 games require practically no waiting time before playing. You can pop Killzone in and begin playing within 2 minutes. Xbox One games however are a crapshoot; Ryse took around 5 minutes while Dead Rising 3 took roughly 15 minutes! The bottom line is that every time I have inserted or downloaded a Playstation 4 game, I was into the game swiftly afterwards.

7. Streaming And Sharing

Twitch Tv Xbox One 600x300 This is a peculiar situation because the Xbox One may have actually lucked out and benefited from not being able to broadcast gameplay through services like Twitch TV at this time, although it is an advertised upcoming feature. And I say that because there have been quite the shenanigans going on with Twitch users broadcasting from the Playstation 4 with a free camera game titled The Play Room, that in a nutshell uses your living room or gaming space as the video feed. Not all people have creatively abusing this feature €“ one couple actually created a shockingly successful talk show with it- but unfortunately once one imbecile does something stupid, they subsequently ruin it for everyone. Twitch TV administrators have banned feeds that are broadcast with The Play Room. What was done that caused this uproar? There€™s a laundry list of sordid acts including one person high as a kite rubbing pizza on his crotch, but the straw that broke the camel€™s back involved a drunken male completely stripping his unconscious and drunken wife nude for the entire world to witness. Naturally, neither Sony nor Twitch wants to be associated with sexual assault, so this is perhaps for the best. Arguably the most crucial aspect here is that you can already stream your gameplay from the Playstation 4 while Microsoft is still ironing out its kinks in advance. If anything though, I imagine that this problem will get escalated with the Xbox One considering that one of their most promoted peripherals is a camera that is being heavily pushed for both casual usage and legitimate gaming features. On a smaller scale however, both consoles can already capture footage that can be uploaded to various avenues. Well, the Playstation 4 can, all of the Xbox One footage either goes to your activity feed or something called Sky Drive, which is as irrelevant as it sounds. Both consoles definitely succeed at seamlessly sharing content with your gaming buddies through the actual system though.

6. Networking

Downloads 600x300 Setting up networks for both consoles is as easy as eating Thanksgiving pie; it€™s actually embedded into the initial system set-up. All you do is enter your account information or set everything up if you€™re new to either PSN or XBL. The Xbox One and Playstation 4 both have wholly unnecessary features that use their respective camera devices to lock an account to your face, but it€™s technologically neat nonetheless. What really separates these two apart is just how drastically different the download speeds seemingly are. On my Playstation 4, I downloaded the initial 600MB update so ridiculously fast that I was unable to comprehend what the heck was even transpiring. I even downloaded retail games from the Playstation Store within 30 minutes, and these are 30-50GB sized games we€™re talking about here. It seriously felt like I had been teleported into the future where download and upload speeds are meaningless terms. The Xbox One doesn€™t have terrible download speeds, but they are essentially no different than what I was getting with my 360. It€™s an odd situation that I can€™t technically explain, but that€™s my honest to God experience so far.

5. Hardware

Consoles I have heard tales from the internet over Playstation 4 consoles wobbling, bricking, crashing games, HDMI cables breaking, and I€™ve heard even more Xbox One stories regarding disc drives breaking, accounts being banned, and more. I cannot squash the credibility of these stories, but I can tell you that both of my consoles are still kicking like their brand new, even after expending serious hours into them. Aesthetically the Xbox One is one of the ugliest and bulkiest devices I have ever owned. People will come over to your house and mistake this black hunk of plastic as a VCR; it€™s that much of beefcake and barely fits into my entertainment center. On the contrary, the Playstation 4 is smaller, sleeker, and more aesthetically intriguing with its overlapping double rectangular shape.

4. Controllers

Ea 56070 The Xbox 360 set a new industry standard with their wonderfully ergonomic button layout. For many it was simply the go-to controller of last generation and is held in high regard as one of the best controllers of all time. Personally, I was one of those rare individually that actually preferred the PS3 controller, but I absolutely understood the praise for what Microsoft created. It€™s a new generation though which means both Sony and Microsoft have taken some gamer feedback and refined their design. Both controllers have made drastic modifications to their triggers; Sony tweaked theirs into actual triggers over the pedals that plagued the Dualshock 3. Seriously, who hasn€™t gently put that thing down only to accidentally activate the triggers, which resulted in rewinding or fast-forwarding a substantial chunk of whatever it was you were watching? That assuredly won€™t ever happen again. Meanwhile, Microsoft took their already comfortable triggers and went one step further by improving upon their feedback. The real changes, aside from Sony playing catch up, come from the touch pad that replaces the traditional Start and Select buttons. After using the touch pad in Killzone: Shadow Fall to switch function modes on your drone companion, I am impressed and feel that more development studios will make stronger use for it than Microsoft€™s Kinect voice commands gimmick. Guerilla Games actually made damn good use of the Dualshock 4 with Killzone all around, using the controller€™s speaker to output audio logs and the traditional light to indicate your health status. Both are exceptional controllers though no matter how you slice it.

3. Launch Titles

It€™s safe to say that both consoles launched with a strong lineup of games thanks to fan favorite franchise such as Assassin€™s Creed and NBA 2K, but in the long run most people buy consoles with exclusive titles that appeal to their personal interest. I have no doubts that Sony€™s strong first party support presence will carry over into this new generation, but launch titles are impressionable and influential in pushing early adopters over the edge. Realistically though, both consoles have a disappointing exclusive launch lineup, ripe with games that failed to deliver or were delayed altogether. The only next generation exclusive titles that have wowed me on a large scale are the vibrant and colorful SHMUP Resogun for the Playstation 4, and Dead Rising 3 for the Xbox One. Everything else does an admirable job at showcasing just how powerful these machines are graphically, but left much to be desired in more important areas of game design. I suppose this isn€™t anything groundbreaking though when you look back at past console launches.

2. Graphics

B2ea1d53df2468afadacfe523f7c7399 This is probably the most pertinent point of contention for anyone interested in entering a new generation of gaming, and rightfully so. Coming in, the Playstation 4 had the upper hand considering that it was confirmed that only one Xbox One game- Forza 5- would achieve the technical marvel of 60 frames per second and 1080P resolution. Even multiplatform games factually run better on the Playstation 4, which is a complete 180 in landscape from last generation, where the Xbox 360 generally got superior versions of most titles. Despite that, I have to admit that the game that visually blew me away most was Ryse: Son of Rome for the Xbox One. A game like Killzone: Shadow Fall isn€™t necessarily far behind, but there is extreme detail and nearly photorealistic animations and facial expressions all throughout Ryse. So while Sony may technically have the upper hand, I urge you all not to count Microsoft out here, or to at the very least see Ryse in action with your own two eyes.

1. Which To Buy

If your interests lie predominantly with gaming then I definitely recommend a Playstation 4. The Xbox One isn€™t the terrible gaming machine most had expected it to be, but it is a rather disjointed machine that seems to be attempting too much and far too early. If you are interested in the more non-gaming related aspects like synching your console to your television receiver, creating a glorified DVR to supplement your gaming desires then Xbox One potentially may be for you. The war being waged ultimately has to break down to that question, because from corporate conferences and now having telling hands on experience, it€™s painstakingly clear that the Playstation 4 is exactly what it is marketed as; a gaming console for the players. Which next generation console are you more interested in? Do you agree with my assessment? Comment below!

In this post: 
PS4 XBox One
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

I write for WhatCulture (duh) and MammothCinema. Born with Muscular Dystrophy Type 2; lover of film, games, wrestling, and TV.