10 Horror Movie Villains Who Were Totally Right

These horror "villains" were actually pretty damn justified.

The Lodge
Sony Pictures Releasing

In the overwhelming majority of horror movies, there's little debate over who the "good" and "bad" characters are, because the lines tend to be drawn incredibly clearly. There are the hapless victims desperately fighting to survive, and then there's the thing trying to kill them. 

But not all horror movies are created equal, and sometimes filmmakers prefer to make things a little more soupy and ambiguous, to the extent that when we take a step back and really think about it, the supposed "villain" might actually be basically in the right.

Now, "right" is itself a relative concept that can mean many things to many people, but from everything that's presented in the following ten horror films, it's incredibly easy to conclude that the apparent bad guy didn't really do anything wrong. Or in the very least, they were pushed to murder by circumstances wildly out of their control, and they are, in fact, a bigger victim than just about anyone else in the movie.

As such, it's incredibly easy to look at their behaviours - most of them, anyway - and consider that they were largely correct on the balance of circumstances.

10. Johnny - In A Violent Nature

The Lodge
Shudder

Much like his obvious inspiration - Friday the 13th's Jason Voorhees - there's an innately sympathetic quality to In a Violent Nature's Johnny (Ry Barrett), considering all the guy wants to do is be left alone to rest.

Johnny's tragic backstory is that he was a developmentally delayed boy who fell to his death during a prank gone wrong, and when his father confronted one of the individuals responsible, he too was killed, with both deaths being subsequently covered up. And though Johnny returns as a vengeful, undead revenant, the key to keeping him napping in the dirt is to leave his prized locket - which was given to him by his mother - hanging on the remains of the fire tower where he died.

The film literally begins with the central characters picking up the locket, triggering Johnny's awakening and subsequent rampage.

Now, did those kids deserve to get brutally torn apart? Not really, as they weren't to know that taking some random locket would rouse Johnny from eternal slumber, but at the same time, maybe don't take things that aren't yours.

Johnny just wanted to keep his stuff and rest easy - not be bothered by young'uns messing with his wares.

Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.