10 Albums That Fell Apart During Production
The Studio Death Sentence.
Everyone going into making an album is going to want to put their best foot forward. Even if some of the ideas might be shaky at the start, you’re normally able to iron out everything and make something that at least sounds decent. All of the building blocks to make something decent were here, but none of them were able to come together properly.
That’s not to say that all of these are terrible albums from back to front. In terms of raw ideas, some of these albums are pretty great, with the artists coming in with either a decent batch of songs or a different way to approach what they had already done before. It all came back to the production of the records though, with the producer not guiding them in the right direction and making for songs that were either boring to listen to or just not squeezing the most potential out of these acts.
That’s before you even get to how these albums sound as well. Some of these records may have a fine basis for a song, only for the actual sound quality to be terrible, either being too clean or sounding like it was coming out of a trash can. These are by no means career destroyers or anything like that, but it’s hard to see some of the best bands in the world clutching at straws to get something like this out.
10. Minutes to Midnight - Linkin Park
Just because an album falls apart during production doesn't mean that all of the songs are necessarily terrible. These are still legendary artists, and there's more that goes into a record than throwing together the best songs that you can and have them recorded one after the other. It's about taking your listeners on a journey, and Minutes to Midnight practically is a jarring mess to listen to from back to front.
Then again, it's not surprising why Linkin Park wanted to go in a different direction here, fresh off of the golden age of nu metal and wanting to take things in a much more alternative leaning direction. While there are germs of the savagery that came through on the early albums on songs like Given Up, what really kneecaps this record is the pacing, with every aggressive song being followed by a ballad. It might have been a choice to make sure the record stayed balanced all the way through, but every time the album feels like it's gaining momentum on something like No More Sorrow, Valentine's Day is right around the corner to snuff it out again.
Based on what we have though, you can still see the skeleton of what Linkin Park were trying to do, making a much smoother listening experience while also trying to call out some of the injustices happening in America on tracks like Hands Held High and the mammoth closer The Little Things Give You Away. Rock and roll is always about going against the grain though, and the fact that they split the record up like this gives you the impression that they were trying to play it safe.
9. Echo - Tom Petty and the Heartbreakers
As we reached the tail end of the '90s, Tom Petty felt like one of the last survivors of the classic rock scene that actually still had something to say. Coming off of his career renaissance on Wildflowers, he became almost an elder statesmen for the grunge community, loaning his guitars out to Eddie Vedder on occasion and even meeting some heroes of his own when working with Johnny Cash. Once he came up for air though, he found himself dealing with divorce papers, and it all unfolded on Echo.
While not every song on this album is necessarily about his breakup, the record's development was hellish for almost everyone involved, with Tom not taking care of himself, living in a chicken shack in California and being extremely disconnected from the songs he was writing. The rest of the Heartbreakers do their best job at holding everything together on this record, but Tom was the least of their problems when bassist Howie Epstein started to get out of control.
Being hooked on heroin, you can hear the last gasps of that Heartbreakers brotherhood on this record, as Howie does everything he can to hold it together, knowing that he was heading for a brick wall in the next few years. Each Heartbreakers record always tends to have a magical feeling to it, but the tone of these songs feels haunted by all the demons they were facing.
8. Death Magnetic - Metallica
When Metallica released Death Magnetic in 2008, metal fans across the world breathed a huge sigh of relief. The backlash behind St. Anger was still fresh in everyone's minds, and it was nice to see that the greatest thrash metal band in the world can still write headbangers when they wanted to. After a few years sitting with the record though, fans started to notice that those old production habits die hard.
Compared to the pristine sounds of the Black Album and even Load and ReLoad from the '90s, pairing Metallica up with Rick Rubin made for an awkward rub, with the live room feeling starting to grate on people. Though Rubin had many experiences bringing Slayer to prominence during thrash's prime, the loudness wars that were going on around this time made everything much too abrasive after a few listens, with the trash can snare of St. Anger being replaced with drum hits that sound like static whenever they hit.
While St. Anger had the unholy pairing of bad songs and terrible production, Death Magnetic still feels like Metallica picking up where they left off back in the '80s, with songs like The Day That Never Comes and My Apocalypse taking that same nervy energy that you heard on Master of Puppets and bringing it into the modern age. The backlash of the past few years may have been unforgivable for some of the hardcore thrash fans, but Death Magnetic could easily serve as a reminder of why these guys were so respected back in 1986.
7. Neighborhoods - Blink-182
After fans started to learn about what happened during Blink-182's hiatus in the mid '00s, it felt like the pop punk bridges were burnt to a crisp. Tom DeLonge just didn't seem like he wanted to play that bratty pop punk anymore, and the next few years saw him disappearing into the world of space rock with Angels and Airwaves while Mark Hoppus and Travis Barker kept doing their usual schtick. Once Travis had a brush with death in a plane crash though, Neighborhoods felt like having a high school reunion with your friends all over again.
When you start to break down the ins and outs of this record's development, the reunion that we had envisioned almost felt like it was happening out of obligation, with songs that feel like they would make decent Angels and Airwaves songs but not retaining the same energy as tracks like the Rock Show or I Miss You. If the self titled record was already a bit of a mess to make, the tracks for these albums were practically being mailed in, as Tom insisted that the band play in separate studios to get the tracks, which makes a lot of sense when you realize MH 4 8 2011 is actually the name of a demo rather than an actual song title.
It might have made for some great singles on their own like After Midnight or Ghost on the Dance Floor, but this doesn't feel like the same band that got you bouncing around to All the Small Things. This is a reunion in name only, and it wasn't long after that Tom would disappear into the galaxy again.
6. Freaky Styley - Red Hot Chili Peppers
Whenever the Red Hot Chili Peppers have a bad record on their hands, it's usually down to them using the wrong producer. Even though their early years had some great potential, Rick Rubin could practically be called the fifth member of the band, always having their best interest in mind and pushing them to make the best kind of music they're capable of under the right circumstances. Long before they met their bearded shaman though, the Peppers may have been having too much fun on Freaky Styley.
Though the production credit from George Clinton makes perfect sense with the Peppers' funk rock style, the recording sessions quickly turned into a 24 hour a day party, with George being out of his mind on cocaine and the band indulging in a little too much as well, leading to songs that feel incredibly slipshot. While this is definitely an improvement from the demo sounds of their debut, you can tell that George is concerned with the low end more than anything, bringing up Flea's bass in the mix and Hillel Slovak's guitars taking a back seat most of the time.
Those drugs ended up coming back in other ways too, with the guest voice saying "look at that turtle go" coming courtesy of Clinton's drug dealer after not having enough money to pay him for his stash. Some bands can go through all of the drugs they want and still make a quality record, but Freaky Styley just sounds like a party that's one bad trip away from going completely off the rails.
5. Sonic Highways - Foo Fighters
For everyone who calls Foo Fighters by the numbers, you can't say that Dave Grohl isn't afraid to try some new things. Across every Foos record, Dave always wanted to challenge himself, and Sonic Highways may have been their biggest project yet, going to different cities across the USA and making a new song in a local studio native to the town. It was going to be eclectic and it was going to be ambitious, but no matter what we got though, it was going to be an absolute mess.
Although there are only 8 tracks on this record, Sonic Highways functions much more as a collection of decent singles than a proper album, going in a million different directions and never fully settling into a groove. As you go through the entire project, there's not much connective tissue between any of these songs, from Congregation sounding closer to a country song because of the band's time in Nashville to the more muted sounds of Subterranean from the band's experience in Seattle.
It would have been fine to throw this together as a decent compilation, but the appeal of Sonic Highways almost feels worse once they released the Saint Cecilia EP, having a much more coherent feel to it and blending a lot better than the proper album they released just a few months before. The concept may have been interesting at the time, but if you mixed both the EP and the proper album together and cherry picked the best songs, we would be in for one of the more unique records in the Foo Fighters' discography.
4. Let It Be - The Beatles
If you watch the Get Back documentary that's on Disney+, you can tell what the Beatles were originally going for for what would become the album Let It Be. Even with all of the bickering going on at the time, there's still an earnest attempt for them to go back to their roots as a bar band, sticking to live playing and making the ballads a bit more understated than the grand visions they were working with at the time. It made sense that they went with Abbey Road as their last album, then Phil Spector came in and dumped his schlock all over these sessions.
While Spector's rap sheet working with both George Harrison and John Lennon on their solo albums was great, hearing what he did to these back to basics songs was the exact opposite of what the band was going for. As opposed to leaving the rawness in, you can hear Spector tinkering these songs into their own pop symphonies, with Paul McCartney especially being pissed that The Long and Winding Road was given the full orchestral treatment without his permission.
By the time it came out, the rest of the Beatles had already moved on to other projects, but Paul was frustrated enough with their final album to make a revised version called Let It Be...Naked, taking away all of the fluff and hearing the album as the band intended it to be heard in the first place. The golden age of the Beatles was the stuff of music legend though, and you can see why people would have a few issues with this mess being their last real swan song.
3. Be Here Now - Oasis
Everything about Oasis' rise to fame in the '90s was all about building up the momentum of them both on stage and in the studio. From the minute that Definitely Maybe hit the airwaves, the band were on a mission to become one of the greatest bands in the world, and it looked like What's the Story Morning Glory lived up to all of those promises, with tracks like Champagne Supernova and Wonderwall becoming modern classics in the world of rock. Now that you've reached the top of the mountain, what the hell do you do afterward?
While the original teasers for Be Here Now sounded like it was aiming even bigger than its predecessor, the songs that actually turn up on here were almost too sanitized by Oasis' standards. Since most of the sessions were being fueled by the band and their producer out of their minds on cocaine, the songs tend to stretch out way too long than they have any right to, with potentially good tracks like All Around the World and D'You Know What I Mean going on for 7-9 minutes at a time.
Oasis may have got what they wanted in the short term with this being one of the biggest albums of their career, but things started to unravel almost immediately after touring wrapped up, with the band taking a hiatus and coming back a shell of themselves on Standing on the Shoulder of Giants just a few years later. The Gallaghers always had a strong belief in being the biggest band in the world, but this is what happens when you start to believe your own hype a little too much.
2. All Hope is Gone - Slipknot
Every great Slipknot album is usually born out of a strong sense of pain. Though the songs speak for themselves as some of the most brutal tracks ever put to tape, it always has to be the right occasion to get something this feral, whether that's working themselves down to the bone on Iowa or paying tribute to their brother on .5 The Gray Chapter. Slipknot didn't have too many things to worry about in the mid '00s though, and All Hope is Gone was the one time where they may have been playing things too safe.
While this is the album that gave them some of their biggest hits on radio like Psychosocial and Snuff, the band's decision to make the record at home ended up being a big mistake, with everyone being a little too comfortable at the studio. When asked about the sessions, most of the band don't really remember how the sessions even went down, saying that their producer could never get all of them together in the same room to jam during the recording and Joey Jordison having to record almost all of the drum tracks completely by himself.
There's definitely that blistering energy on songs like Gematria and the title track, but this feels less like a proper Slipknot album and closer to a knockoff version of what Slipknot is supposed to be. The classics are still here in some capacity...you just might have to dig a little deeper to get to the really good stuff.
1. Vapor Trails - Rush
It was going to take a miracle for Rush to do anymore recording past the late '90s. After the Test For Echo tour, Neil Peart practically took a giant hiatus from music, losing both his wife and daughter within the span of a year and becoming truly lost, getting on his motorcycle and driving all around the country. Once he finally had time to stop though, the next Rush record was bound to be the grand return we were waiting for...and the headache that we didn't want.
Released right around the turn of the century, Vapor Trails is the Rush record that most fans had been clamoring for for a long time, getting rid of almost all the synthesizers and going back to the band's real power trio roots. The music itself is classic Rush, but the actual mix of the project is some of the worst of its time, being a major victim of the loudness wars and every song having the potential to give you a migraine if you aren't careful.
For all of the technical glitches added to the album though, fans had to just live with a little bit of head throbbing to listen to songs like One Little Victory for a few years, with a remix coming out almost a decade later that sounds more like a band and not the sound of every instrument clipping the mics. If anything though, the quality of this record just feels that much better though. You know you have something special on your hands if your fans want to risk their hearing in order to listen to it.