10 Albums That Killed Artists' Careers

Nothing would be the same again.

Pinkerton weezer
DGC Records

For many artists, all it takes is one album to put them on top of the world. Whether it's your first time up to the plate or the result of years of hard work, bands have fought tooth and nail to make their work better than the rest. Then again, it also takes just one album to see it come crashing down.

Arriving at the low point in these artists' discography, these are the albums that mark the beginning of the end for any more good music. It could come from a drastic change in sound or just a lackluster delivery, but these artists have not been able to recover from the performances that they turned in on these albums.

The kicker is that some of these albums aren't even really bad. In fact, some of them stand up as some of the best work of the band's career, but these records may have had a hand in the band's downfall by setting the bar a little too high.

A lot of these acts have done phenomenal work, but these are the records where you knew things weren't going to be the same. It was fun while it lasted, but here's where everything starts to run out of gas.

10. Maybe You've Been Brainwashed Too - New Radicals

If you wanted any credibility as a pop star in the late '90s, most of your songs had to be laced with alternative tendencies. Even though the sound of grunge had long since fallen by the wayside, the angsty attitude and youthful lyrics still had a firm hold on the pop scene. Just before the age of boy bands, the New Radicals came out with one of the brightest pop gems of the decade.

Maybe You've Been Brainwashed is an absolute joy to listen to, with care-free songs like "You Get What You Give" being juxtaposed with more heady tracks like "I Hope I Didn't Just Give Away the Ending." So if a record is this good, how did it end up costing the band its life? Well, this was a case of a band calling it quits before they reached their full potential.

Given the sudden rush of fame, frontman Gregg Alexander began to loathe his new life as a superstar, often performing with his hat pulled down so as to not see the crowds he was performing to. Shortly after wrapping up a leg of the tour, Alexander cut ties with the rest of the band and began a successful life as a songwriter outside the spotlight. He might be in a better emotional place now, but it's a shame we'll never see how great this band could have been.


9. The Endless River - Pink Floyd

Pink Floyd are one of those rare bands in rock history whose sound is much bigger than any individual person. Even when the band lost their founding member Syd Barrett, they soldiered on and created some of the greatest prog rock ever made on albums like Dark Side of the Moon and The Wall. Once you start taking more key members out of the equation though, things tend to get a little spotty.

After songwriter Roger Waters' departure in the late '80s, the band put out a few more records before moving on to solo projects. It feels like that's where Floyd should have ended, but the Endless River was one of the most unnecessary albums to come from one of rock's greatest bands. Standing at about an hour, never has an album title felt more apt, with songs that drag on for what feels like eternity.

With most of the album being instrumental and Roger Waters still out of the picture, this collection of tracks ends up feeling less like a sonic statement and more like a contractual obligation that needs to be fulfilled. Pink Floyd has gifted the rock world with some of the greatest soundscapes in music, but when it comes to their final statement, this river has drowned many listeners in its day.


8. Two Against Nature - Steely Dan

Steely Dan deserves all the respect in the world for the innovations they brought to the music industry. Sure, some of their records seem like they should be played on a chartered yacht, but they also featured some of the greatest performances in pop history as well as some of the most well-produced songs of the era. The band were essential to the golden age of the '70s, but it was a much different story when stepping into the next millennium.

After years of being apart, dual masterminds Walter Becker and Donald Fagen finally met up again and started working on tunes for Two Against Nature. With fans waiting with baited breath, the result was some of the most lifeless songs of the band's career, combined with performances that made the band look like the boring yacht rockers they had been accused of being.

This record also stands as a colossal screw-up for the Grammy Awards, who awarded this bland piece of yacht rock Album of the Year over giants like Eminem and Radiohead's Kid A. Becker and Fagen may have thought they were working against the grain at the time, but Two Against Nature will probably be remembered for its undeserved accolades than the actual music inside.


7. Other Voices - The Doors

The lead singer role tends to be looked at as the essential sonic force in the band. Even if the person in question can't play a note on any instrument, the way they bring their point across to the audience can often be what makes or breaks bands in the spotlight. Not every band has to rely on the strength of their frontman's presence, but the Doors are definitely a band that fits that category.

Throughout the band's chaotic history, Jim Morrison was the lifesblood of the band, whose eccentric personality and poetic musings onstage excited fans around the world. Once Morrison was found dead after the band's comeback album LA Woman, many people rightfully thought that it would be the end of the Doors' career as well. As fate would have it though, the other band members started getting very bad ideas.

Just a few years after Morrison's passing, the band tried to bounce back with the album Other Voices, with organist Ray Manzarak taking over for Morrison on vocals. The band doesn't play poorly all things considered, but you can tell from listening to it that the magic of the band had faded along with Morrison. Other Voices is not an offensive album by any stretch, but after this boring collection of songs, one of the most interesting acts of the '60s seemed to have officially run out of gas.


6. Calling All Stations - Genesis

It's not easy when the frontman decides to leave the group. With he or she being the main spokesperson of the band both onstage and off, the loss of the band's voice can leave the rest of the group scrambling to find someone else. This kind of blow often kills most bands, but Genesis managed to pull it off effortlessly once drummer Phil Collins stepped up to replace Peter Gabriel in the '70s.

Everything seemed to be right with the world, with Collins steering the band into a poppier style of prog while also juggling a successful solo career. As time went on though, the solo allure seemed to be much more promising than Collins sticking it out with Genesis. After the band's album We Can't Dace, Collins announced his departure with no ill will towards anyone in the band, leading to Tony Banks and Mike Rutherford drafting Ray Wilson for Calling All Stations.

Rather than bouncing back like they normally do, this album is almost like a novelty item, with songs that felt more like generic rock than the more experimental material they were known. The push back from fans ended up being so bad that the band cancelled their tour and broke up a short time after. Genesis deserve a lot of kudos for getting an equally strong singer, but Calling All Stations proved that trying to make lightning strike twice was a pipe dream.


5. Cut the Crap - The Police

In the early days of punk, The Clash were one of the bands that everyone was paying attention to. Whether it was the ratty punks in the underground scene of London or the rock luminaries checking out the newcomers, this quartet had some of the most soul-stirring music of the entire genre, where they combined politically charged lyrics with the tuneful sensibilities of pop music.

Though Joe Strummer tends to get a lot of credit for the band's fantastic sound, co frontman Mick Jones was the one able to turn those political ideologies into songs. Take Jones out of the equation and you get something like Cut the Crap, which is probably the most generic punk album ever released. Completely reassembling the band from scratch, this entire album is Strummer's vision of a career reinvention, which ended causing the downfall of the entire group.

Instead of songs that hit you right in the face with their intensity, these songs tend to be tepid at best, with songs that fluctuate between sloganeering and milquetoast punk jams. Even the one good song on the album "This is England" feels more like a lament at the band's current foundation rather than a war cry. For a genre that is all about wearing your aggression on your sleeve, Cut the Crap is the one album that managed to reduce the Only Band That Matters to rubble.


4. Results May Vary - Limp Bizkit

Ever since the beginning, Limp Bizkit were never really that good of a band. Though the band showed promise with the more aggressive cuts on their early albums, they threw almost all of their potential out the window once the royalty checks came in for songs like "Nookie." The band may have been at the right place at the right time, but Results May Vary is when everyone realized the bile they were listening to.

Even though frontman Fred Durst had already been in hot water at this point for inciting a riot at Woodstock 1999, people were still willing to hear if he had changed at all on this latest record. Instead of hearing something more thoughtful or introspective, most of these songs feel like the same old whining you would hear from a 16 year old kid, with lyrics that dealt with being picked on in middle school.

The exit of guitarist Wes Borland doesn't do the album any favors either, with most of the songs having to be carried by Durst's tough-guy facade. The album even gets really uncomfortable in places, with lyrics that range from wanting to smell undergarments of the opposite sex to making light of the school shootings that took place at Columbine in the late '90s. It's never fun to see a band fall from grace, but considering what we were given with this album, it's not like Limp Bizkit's irrelevance was unwarranted.


3. Just Push Play - Aerosmith

Aerosmith have gone through plenty of changes ever since they came on the scene in the '70s. Originally being pegged as copycats of the British Invasion, the band found their edge on albums like Rocks but quickly faded from view due to drug problems. Though it was awesome to seem them rise again in the '80s, things started to take a more stylized direction.

As the band went on to make albums like Get a Grip, you could hear them going more towards pop music than rock and roll, which culminated in the #1 single "I Don't Want to Miss a Thing." These songs usually just felt like something the guys needed to get out of their system, but Just Push Play was where they reached the point of no return.

Instead of having a handful of pop tunes amid the rockers, this album was the band diving head first into pop music, with songs that had a certain polish that drove fans up the wall. The album was far from bad, but when you place a song like "Jaded" next to "Sweet Emotion," it's almost impossible to believe the songs are from the same band. Just Push Play has its fair share of high points, but this is where Aerosmith lost all their goodwill in the minds of their rock fanbase.


2. Be Here Now - Oasis

If you were into any kind of rock music in the late '90s, Oasis probably showed up somewhere in your record collection. The band's solid one-two punch Definitely Maybe and What's the Story Morning Glory weren't just great albums, but put the band at the top of rock heap with some of the biggest shows in rock history. However, you never think of going down when you're at the top of the world.

When the band ventured into the studio again, the end result Be Here Now ended up being one of the more spotty releases ever to come from a mainstream band. Rather than the tight songs that evoked both the Sex Pistols and the Beatles, these lengthy cuts dragged the listener on for 7 to 9 minutes at a time, all leading to nothing in the end.

Though the album is far from Oasis' crowning achievement, the band initially received rave reviews for their 3rd effort, with many critics lauding it as their creative pinnacle. As time went on though, people began to understand just what they were hearing, with even Noel Gallagher not being pleased with the final product. With the original lineup of the band fracturing at this point, Be Here Now is the sound of the Gallagher Brothers with stars in their eyes, waiting for a miracle that isn't going to come.


1. Pinkerton - Weezer

It almost feels wrong to put the best album on this list at the top of the heap as a career killer. On the surface, Pinkerton is not only one of the greatest albums Weezer has ever produced, but may very well be one of the greatest albums of the '90s as a whole.

On the other hand, this stroke of genius ended up backfiring on the band spectacularly.

Coming off of the high of their pop punk debut, Rivers Cuomo used Pinkerton as a way for the band to get raw, with a blemished production and more introspective lyrics about Cuomo's love life and disarray with being a rockstar. While these tend to be seen as the album's greatest strengths nowadays, people were having none of it at the time. With Weezer supposed to be the antithesis of bands like Nirvana and Soundgarden, the last thing they wanted from these nerd rockers were downtrodden songs about despair.

The entire rock fanbase ended up coming around on Pinkerton over the years, but the damage had already been done.

Given the intense backlash, Weezer broke up for 5 years, only to re-emerge in the early '00s, with Cuomo changing his writing style to appease his audience. Weezer have released some solid albums since Pinkerton, but as a whole, this initial flop ended up changing Cuomo's songwriting... and not for the better.


In this post: 
Weezer
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

I'm just a junkie for all things media. Whether it's music, movies, TV, or just other reviews, I absolutely adore this stuff. But music was my first love, and I love having the opportunity to share it with you good people. Follow Me On Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/timcoffman97