10 Albums That Turned Out Nothing Like You Expected

The unheralded classics! The unexpected genre shifts! That one Lou Reed record everyone hates!

Relapse Eminem
Aftermath

Some albums can never hope to live up to fan expectations.

Perhaps the record is years in the making, or the follow up of an unexpectedly huge hit. Regardless of the context, plenty of albums are doomed to be disappointing long before they are even unleashed on the world. After all, Yeezus could have literally led to the second coming of Jesus himself, and it still wouldn't have been My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy.

Other albums were always going to blow away fans and critics. Maybe it's because the artist never enjoyed much success with critics before and as such expectations are low for their new release, or maybe it's just because they'd had a while out of the limelight and the fact that they're back guaranteed anything passable would receive a fond reception.

But some albums, whether good or bad, signaled a huge shift in an artist’s sounds and aesthetic, and this fundamental change was one no one could have predicted. Some of the albums on this list were immediately adored whilst others were abhorred. Some have been vindicated by time, whilst others were well liked at the time and are now considered the beginning of the end.

But every one of these ten was an unexpected release that changed an artist's sound for good, turning out nothing like fans expected them they would.

10. Metal Machine Music—Lou Reed

Metal Machine Music Lou Reed
RCA

Okay, yes, you probably saw this one coming. But come on, when was the last time a popular musician brought out anything as strange, as jarring and grating, as downright insane as Lou Reed's Metal Machine Music?

The most infamously unexpected album here, this effort from the Velvet Underground mastermind is exactly what its title sounds like: grinding, clanking machinery.

For track, after track, after track.

If you've never really wondered what that sounds like, then congratulations! You're in good company, as few Reed fans, mainstream music critics, or even people in general had ever given much thought to the sounds industrial machinery could produce.

And this album didn't lead many people to give it much more thought, either.

Though Reed later claimed to have invented heavy metal in what was presumably just a diabolical pun, not many fans wanted to hear more random clanking from the man who brought you Satellite of Love, and whilst the album signalled Reed's shift into more experimental territory, it was the first and last truly outre record of his long career.


9. Kid A—Radiohead

Radiohead Kid A
Parlophone

It's hard to overstate how much Radiohead had the world of music in the palm of their hand during the late nineties, and how much was riding on their success.

The band's insanely catchy, clever sound made OK Computer a runaway success and left critics claiming that Thom Yorke's group were the sole hope for reviving mainstream rock. At the turn of the millennium BritPop was dying down and its best know artists were fading from stardom. Without Pulp, Blur, and Oasis, it was Radiohead or no one who would be turning rock into a massive genre for the foreseeable.

Then the band released Kid A.

This studio effort stripped away any lingering remnants of mainstream appeal from the band’s odd, uncompromising sound. Where OK Computer had radio-ready hits, this intense and raw album had snippets of endlessly repeated samples and layered arrangements of moody, dark riffs.

Where the band once seemed set for superstardom, Kid A cemented their status of the voice of a disaffected, disillusioned generation, with a sound as cold, unsparing, and uninviting as the genre could manage.


8. Be Here Now—Oasis

Oasis Be Here Now
Creation

Following the one-two punch of (What's the Story) Morning Glory and Definitely Maybe was never going to be an easy ask for Manchester BritPop icons Oasis.

The band was already facing all sorts of internal turmoil by the time their third studio album was being produced, with tensions between the Gallagher brothers reaching boiling point more than once.

But as long as they could keep producing snappy, witty rock hits, all would be alright.

Be Here Now, the third studio album from the band, was a sprawling, massive prog rock album, whilst their previous hits were tight, understated pop rock. Gone were the quick wit and sparsely arranged tracks in favour of seven minute dirges which made Champagne Supernova seem downright subdued.

The cheeky charm had been replaced by ambition, and arguably a bit more of it than the band's sound could handle. Though some critics have since defended Be Here Now, the album couldn't have been further from what fans expected, or what they wanted.


7. Girl Talk—Kate Nash

Girl Talk Kate Nash
Have 10p Records

An actor, singer, and songwriter, Kate Nash proved herself to be far more than the Lily Allen imitator many critics wrote her off as early in her career.

Yes, the two artists had a comparable aesthetic, pairing foul mouthed wit with a chirpy, poppy sound. But Allen's output tended to be more classic pop in its production, whereas Nash's critically well-liked first two albums had a more stripped back, acoustic feel to them.

The artist won over a legion of fans with her sharp lyrics and simple arrangements, with both albums providing memorably catchy indie singles. Then came 2013's Girl Talk, an album which it's fair to say turned out nothing like fans and critics expected...

For better or worse.

The singer’s third album saw her leave behind indie pop acoustics in favour of a loud, rockier sound. A messy lo-fi album, Girl Talk was influenced heavily by riot grrl music and split Nash's fans between those who felt this new music condensed and distilled her attitude, and those who found it a total tonal departure.


6. Congratulations—MGMT

MGMT Congratulations
Columbia

An odd band through and through since their inception, indie rockers MGMT seemed as blindsided by the success of their album Oracular Spectacular as the rest of the world were.

Glam rock had enjoyed a brief, ironic revival via The Darkness in the early noughties, but this was far from Justin Hawkins' winking falsettos. Hits like Electric Feel and Kids saw MGMT briefly revive the more lush and anthemic elements of psychedelia and fuse them with modern pop rock.

Equal parts glib and sincere, the album left the world waiting for its follow up.

Of course, the band’s second album Congratulations was a massive departure from their debut’s glittery rock. A more muted prog rock effort, this 2010 release saw the band abandon the synth-y sound of their first hit for a darker, more guitar-led psychedelic rock album which was bereft of any radio-ready mainstream hits.

Since then, fans have come to expect all manner of weirdness from the band, but there was a time when the artists behind Brian Eno were almost mainstream hitmakers.


5. Electra Heart—Marina and the Diamonds

Electra Heart Marina
679

There are few things stranger than an artist managing to move from Kate Bush comparisons to Kesha comparisons in the space of a single record.

Yet that's exactly what Welsh singer songwriter Marina managed with her second studio effort Electra Heart. The artist's debut album, The Family Jewels, was critically acclaimed for its odd fusion of singer-songwriter indie idiosyncrasy with more mainstream, if dark and ironic, pop elements.

Even the album's suggestive title hinted at its tone, a smirking middle finger to the mainstream.

Cut to the release of follow up Electra Heart, which saw her abandon the stripped back singer songwriter elements of her earlier work for some catchier, more pure and unadulterated pop. The wit was still there, it was just now sledgehammer subtle, as were the lush pop song arrangements and unabashedly mainstream radio hits.

The album won over a legion of fans for the artist now known as Marina, but many critics never returned to their former love of her music despite her lyrics remaining as sharp as ever beneath the catchier instrumentals.


4. Graceland—Paul Simon

Graceland Simon
Warner Bros.

Released when former Garfunkel collaborator/ moody folk icon Paul Simon was in a deep dark funk, the iconic album Graceland is probably the biggest sonic departure from form on this list.

Simon's long career before this 1986 hit had been defined by often playful, occasionally sombre lyrics backed by sparse folk instrumentals. Whether it was solo or with frequent partner Art Garfunkel, Simon's output was a low-key and stripped down affair with simple arrangements usually driven by guitar and piano.

Graceland, in contrast, brought entirely unexpected African music influence into his previously folk oriented sound. The exuberant and vibrant record won over countless new fans, although Simon was deservedly criticised for working in South Africa during the country's period of apartheid.

Nonetheless the seventh solo album from the singer was a revitalising smash success, one which took the pain and uncertainty of his twin break ups with collaborator Garfunkel and ex-girlfriend Carrie Fisher and married them with the busy instrumentation of South African township music to revolutionise pop rock.


3. Lasers—Lupe Fiasco

Lupe Fiasco Lasers
1st & 15th/Atlantic

Released in 2010, Lasers was the long-awaited, much-vaunted third studio album from Lupe Fiasco.

The rapper had by this point impressed with a string of standout features on tracks by the likes of Kanye West as well as his own breakout pop rap hit, Superstar. But it was the more introspective likes of Kick, Push, a moody skateboarding anthem, that led this indie kid to standout amongst a crowded line up of indie rappers.

Something of an outcast, Lupe eschewed the hard edged rhymes of gangsta rap and glam rap alike, favouring a more honest and sensitive brand of lyricism based in his suburban alienation.

But after the subdued independent success of its predecessors Food and Liquor and The Cool, Lasers saw the rapper abandon his low fi sound from hyper produced slick pop songs. Starting as he meant to go on with a glitzy, bombastic Modest Mouse-sampling lead single, the album left listeners unimpressed as Lupe leave behind the subtle charm which made him stand out in favour of a more aggressively mainstream sound.


2. Rebirth—Lil Wayne

Lil Wayne Rebirth
Cash Money Records

Released shortly after a string of all-time great mixtapes and one instant classic album, Rebirth was... well, it certainly provided New Orleans native Lil Wayne with a rebirth of sorts.

In that, as well as killing off his chance of massive mainstream success, the album also saw him reborn as a corny rock rap cartoon character instead of his zany, wordplay-crazed former self.

This disastrous 2010 rock album is not what anyone expected from the creator of Tha Carter III, a lyrical genius whose surreal and bizarre free associative writing had seen him stand out amongst a crowded field of mainstream rappers. The wild wit and constant verbal invention of his features, freestyles, and singles was replaced by a surreally misjudged mash up of various rock trends.

The rapper returned to form as a lyricist with his later mixtapes, but never won back the crowd with a feature length project after what was widely viewed as a wholesale departure from his sound.


1. Relapse—Eminem

Relapse Eminem
Aftermath

Much like the earlier example of Lil Wayne's Rebirth (though nowhere near as misjudged), Eminem’s return to the mainstream Relapse was far from what prospective listeners were expecting when it was released in 2009.

The rapper had all but retired from the mainstream after the subdued response to Encore, his fifth studio effort. Veering wildly in tone between clumsy, would-be heartfelt ballads and puerile comedy tracks, the album lacked not only Em's typically sharp wit, but both his vicious mean streak and his more mature, darker moments were gone too. The self empowerment anthems were cheesy and the comedy toothless, disappointing fans of all stripes.

Listeners as such presumed that Relapse would be a string of poppy hits with both the fist-pumping inspirational anthem appeal of Lose Yourself and the hilarious freewheeling wit of earlier hits like Without Me

Instead, the album was an intense, gritty slice of horrorcore that didn’t even touch on the crowdpleasing sound of his more recent, poppy albums. Filled with some of the rapper's darkest and most disturbing tracks of his career, this brutal and unrelenting horrorshow may have given way to the far poppier and more mainstream Recovery. But for a minute there, the rapper's dark heart was front and centre, and fans were nowhere near ready for its bleak depths.


In this post: 
Eminem
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

Cathal Gunning hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.