10 Artists That Changed With One Song

Changing on a Dime.

Moves Like Jagger
A&M Octone

Most bands know how to change over time. You can’t keep mining the same three chord schlock forever, and artists want to start exploring different avenues of their sound that no one has heard before. Sometimes those happen over time, but you can also get it within the span of one song.

The minute that these songs hit the airwaves, fans knew that it was never going to be the same again. Either bringing in new production techniques or diving headfirst into a new sound, there was no build up for these changes at all. While it might have been brave for these artists to stick their neck out on the line, not every one of these songs went over well in the beginning. Fans were vocal about detesting these songs at first, only to come around on them years later and praising their favorite bands for completely reinventing themselves.

For the unlucky few though, these were the songs that sunk their reputation and made sure they would be relegated to the bargain bins of music history. Change should be a good thing, but if you don’t know how to handle it well, you’ll become yesterday’s news in no time.

10. Under the Bridge - Red Hot Chili Peppers

At the start of the ‘90s, most of the Chili Peppers had lived enough for any rock star’s lifetime. Although they might not have been the most high profile band to come out of California, their legendary knack for partying and creating a cool funky time onstage was unrivaled by any of their peers. There was a darker side of them though, and Under the Bridge was something that no one was expecting.

While the Peppers had always intended to work with Rick Rubin, Rubin was floored when he found a piece of poetry by Anthony Kiedis that he thought would make a great song. Kiedis was initially lenient to be this vulnerable with his song lyrics, but when John Frusciante came up with the central guitar figure, nothing was off the table, bringing in a choir and hardly any percussion to tell the story of Kiedis feigning for heroin back in the day. While Kiedis singing about his demons was nothing new at this point, what was new was his perspective on it, looking more as a survivor of his demons and doing his best to look to the positive side of life instead of giving in to his hedonistic tendencies.

ven though Kiedis had a few relapses after this, the rest of the Peppers’ catalog is informed by him trying his best to recover on songs like Otherside. Since this was the Peppers’ first major exposure in the public eye in 1991, this song deserves a place next to Nirvana for ushering in the next phase of rock and roll.


9. When You Were Young - The Killers

The entire appeal of the Killers’ first record seemed like it was ripped straight out of the ‘80s. From the minute that you heard songs like Mr. Brightside or Somebody Told Me, these guys felt like the logical extension of acts like Tears for Fears or Duran Duran, utilizing those splashy keyboard sounds and making them new again. Brandon Flowers wasn’t looking to be a nostalgia act though, and he found his way back into rock and roll in the heartland.

While Sam’s Town had a lot in common with their debut, the turning point for the entire band was When You Were Young, which has a far more reflective tone than what their initial lyrics were about. After spending time falling in love with Bruce Springsteen’s music, this song feels like it was ripped straight out of the Boss’ playbook, down to the walk down of different instruments just like in Born to Run. Flowers is practicing what he preaches here, taking the sound of Springsteen and painting pictures of people who are looking for some kind of salvation, either through the love they find in each other or the rest of the world that awaits them outside of their nothing town.

They’ve never looked back from this song either, creating albums mining the same heartland rock that they love. Although Mr. Brightside is still their most celebrated song, When You Were Young is a more accurate picture of what the Killers are these days.


8. I Don't Want to Miss a Thing - Aerosmith

For as long as Aerosmith had been in the game, they never had a #1 during their prime. From Dream On to Walk This Way to Rag Doll, none of the band’s big hit singles ever got the top spot, until Diane Warren came in with a knockout song for the movie Armageddon. After finally tasting that success though, Steven Tyler got a bad idea planted in his head.

Ever since I Don’t Want To Miss a Thing, Aerosmith have been trying their best to go pop, either making songs with too glossy production values or trying to collaborate with pop stars in an attempt to get on the radio. Although the band have returned to their roots in blues a couple of times like the covers album Honkin on Bobo, that seems to be the furthest thing on their mind on Just Push Play, which tries to copy the formula of I Don’t Want to Miss a Thing over half of its runtime.

While the initial hit they had still sounds great today and might be a touch cheesy, these new songs feel like they’re designed to be movie soundtrack songs…except there’s no movie to pair them with. Even the band started to have problems with it, not even appearing in the video for Girls of Summer and Joe Perry getting frustrated about how Steven just wants to write pop songs. Every band has the right to evolve, but you can’t really hold up the mantle of the Bad Boys From Boston with a song like Jaded.


7. The Catalyst - Linkin Park

Every Linkin Park album tends to sound like the future. Even though some of the digital effects may sound a bit cheap on Hybrid Theory these days, the initial listeners were treated to something that felt very robotic, like you were stepping into some dystopian future. It was still rock though, but The Catalyst took all of the guitars and threw them out the window.

As our first taste of their album A Thousand Suns, Linkin Park gave us a track that was coated in electronics, with Joe Hahn having a much bigger role in the song than any other member of the band. While the initial reaction was mixed, the rest of the album didn’t fare much better either, relying on interludes in between songs that were focused on creating cinematic sounds instead of hard rock stomper tracks. Although nu metal fans might have felt betrayed, this was the turning point for Linkin Park’s career going forward, taking the digital sounds and gradually incorporating the sounds of rock back into everything, like the digital smokescreen behind Burn it Down or turning the sounds of rock and roll inside out on Lies Greed Misery.

Even when the band wasn’t up to snuff, this was the sound that helped them remain relevant, still finding time on the radio well into the 2010’s and leaving most of their peers in the dust. Fans might have called it a mixed bag and metalheads might have considered it sacrilege, but the Catalyst remains a gamechanger in the world of Linkin Park.


6. Nothing Else Matters - Metallica

The biggest hurdle that metal fans have to clear with Metallica are the ballads. As much as some diehard fans might want to lose their minds to Whiplash and Creeping Death, songs like Fade to Black and Welcome Home Sanitarium gave us a different side than we were used to seeing from the thrash legends. While those were still metal songs, Nothing Else Matters was the first time they merged into easy listening territory.

Starting as a guitar figure that James Hetfield fiddled around with when he was bored, this was almost close to hair metal territory, being a road dog song about missing the one you love back home. Despite Hetfield not wanting to show it to the band, the song turned up on one of their demos and became a contender on The Black Album. Adding in an orchestra and beautiful clean guitar, this was the song that no one could have expected from a thrash metal band, leading to some metalheads dismissing it in disgust.

Throughout the Black Album though, this was the sound of change, turning Metallica from one of the best underground bands to an act that might be able to take the entire genre mainstream. As much as Metallica may have lived and died on playing some of the most ferocious metal imaginable, no one can touch you once you let yourself be this vulnerable.


5. Moves Like Jagger - Maroon 5

Maroon 5 were never known as the most authentic rock band in the world. Even when they were releasing some of their more celebrated material in the ‘00s, they were the kind of pop rock band that used ‘rock’ very loosely, spending most of their time making pop music with guitars. Right after their third album Hands All Over though, things started to change when Adam Levine channeled his inner Rolling Stone.

While Moves Like Jagger is far from the worst song ever made, this was the sound of Maroon 5 starting to cater to the shallow pop fans of the world, with lyrics that don’t make too much sense and looking to find something that gets you moving without thinking too hard. Although the song still has the funk leanings that they were getting into on their last few records, the raw numbers of this song gave the band incentive to go even poppier on their next handful of albums, going for the sounds of stadium pop on Overexposed and taking pages out of the Coldplay playbook.

The rest of their career hasn’t fared much better either, with Adam Levine taking charge and the rest of the band falling into the background on albums like Red Pill Blues, most of which is the sound of 30-somethings trying to blend in with the teenagers of the world. While Maroon 5 might be the cash cow name these days, Moves Like Jagger may as well have been the first single for the Adam Levine Experience.


4. Everything In Its Right Place - Radiohead

Radiohead were never supposed to be one of the biggest bands in the world. Although they may have been designed to be alternatives from the mainstream, no one expected OK Computer to blow up like it did, painting a grim picture of what could happen should humanity lose itself to technology. When it came time to make a follow up though, Britain’s latest kings of rock decided to throw everything remotely rock and roll out the window.

Leaning on the sounds of jazz and electronica, Radiohead unpacked their synthesizer and went crazy on Kid A, with Everything In Its Right Place kicking things off. Compared to the smooth sounds of Airbag from the last projection, the difference is night and day here, as Thom Yorke plays an icy keyboard part and delivers an awkward riff that feels like it could have been computer generated. While his voice may have still been intact, the mission statement was clear: this was not going to be OK Computer part 2.

Across the rest of the album, Radiohead were making songs that catered more to the sounds of trip hop and the electronic scene, like building an entire track around a looped sample on Idioteque and using guitars as a dramatic soundscape on Treefingers. While this might not have been the Radiohead most wanted, it’s responsible for buying the band their freedom to do what they wanted. Kid A may have been a divisive album at first, but without it we never would have made it to the weird worlds to come like In Rainbows.


3. Helena - My Chemical Romance

Every mall goth kid who ever got a fringe haircut in the mid ‘00s has My Chemical Romance to thank for their aesthetic. While MCR were far from the first band to pile on the white makeup and sing about spooky things, they were the ones to bring it to the mainstream, with Gerard Way becoming one of the kings of all things emo. Aside from all the fashion though, they were still a rock band, and Helena was their first taste of something a lot more caustic.

Though the band’s debut I Brought You Your Bullets was beautifully rough around the edges, they seemed to grow up incredibly quickly on the next album, making a song that would put any other arena rock band to shame. Though the tone was still pitch black by talking about a couple being broken up by death, the rest of the song is almost influenced by punk in its delivery, from Frank Iero’s harsh guitar stabs to having the whole thing come crashing in on the chorus.

These weren’t just some kids fumbling their way into a hit either, with Ray Toro blossoming out as a guitar player on this record as well, tapping into the bombastic sounds of rock and roll that most of us hadn’t heard on the charts since Queen had split up. Little did we know that MCR hadn’t begun to reach their potential, with each subsequent record getting more conceptual and trying out more sonic soundscapes on records like The Black Parade. My Chemical Romance might have started as a more ramshackle rock band, but Helena is ground zero for their sound.


2. Space Oddity - David Bowie

In the early ‘60s, David Bowie was still grappling with what he wanted to be. Although he was looking to cut his teeth as a songwriter, his first foray into pop music was far from perfect, being a folk rock star with a taste for vaudeville on his true debut. Since his taste for theatrics fell on deaf ears, Bowie needed something that was stronger than any Earthly rock and roll.

Almost as a reintroduction to the world, Space Oddity became the song that launched Bowie into superstardom. First being thought of as a novelty record about the space race happening at the same time, Bowie takes us on a journey in these few minutes, making you feel like you’re about to take flight along with Major Tom as he goes off in search of new lands. This wasn’t just a character piece either. Just like his creation, Bowie was on the start of his voyage into new sonic territories as well, going on to create Ziggy Stardust in the image of an alien crashing down to Earth to save humanity.

The sounds of alien glam wasn’t big enough to hold him though, and Bowie would spend the rest of his career picking away at the different pieces of his art, from diving into krautrock during his Berlin period to flirting with everything from pop to drum n bass to soul to jazz. The Starman’s career was always defined by changes, and Space Oddity was the first major voyage that Bowie would never return home from.


1. Strawberry Fields Forever - The Beatles

As the ‘60s wore on, no one was sure whether rock and roll was going to be another passing fad. The genre was barely a decade old yet, and The Beatles had become one of the biggest acts in the world, only to leave the road after being too overwhelmed by screaming female fans. Though that should logically be where the story ends for them, John Lennon came into Abbey Road Studios with one of the greatest songs of his career.

While Strawberry Fields Forever was originally conceived as a folksy song, the band saw this as an opportunity to experiment with the ramifications of rock. Being students of the avant garde, the band took different pieces of different takes of the song and stuck them together, speeding up and slowing down different parts of the song to make sure the whole thing blended well. With some of the most graphic imagery Lennon would write in a song, this would serve as the first taste of psychedelia, as the Summer of Love began not long after the song came out.

This was also the first time we got to see the Fab Four as studio creations, using the recording format as its own instrument, from toying around with different tape loops and wild sounds on Sgt. Peppers to incorporating synthesizers towards the end of their run on Abbey Road. Just because the Beatles left the road didn’t mean they were dead by any means. The decade had only just begun, and the Fab Four were just as curious where their music could go as their audience.


In this post: 
Maroon 5
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

I'm just a junkie for all things media. Whether it's music, movies, TV, or just other reviews, I absolutely adore this stuff. But music was my first love, and I love having the opportunity to share it with you good people. Follow Me On Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/timcoffman97