10 Bad Debut Albums From Great Bands

Red Hot Chili Peppers did NOT start well...

red hot chili peppers
EMI

The best bands of the rock genre seem to have a certain omnipresence to them. The sounds coming from the groups' amplifiers are so essential to the genre that they almost feel like they existed since the dawn of time. However, the actual beginnings of these bands may not be up to their usual standard.

While each of the bands on this list are some of the greatest musicians in their field, their debuts ended up leaving a lot to be desired. The same musicians may be at the table, but their initial idea for their sound was not necessarily setting the world on fire. Looking back, it may even be a good thing that these records didn't blow up, otherwise we may not have gotten the more adventurous music these groups made later down the line.

Are each of these records some of the worst in the genre? No, not really. Given the track records of these bands later in their career though, the quality between these starts and their classic material feel like night and day. These records definitely show the musical magic lying underneath the surface, but the actual execution behind the songs are a bit rough around the edges.

10. Bob Dylan - Bob Dylan

Rock and Roll as we know it would look a lot different were it not for Bob Dylan. Originally immersed in the American folk scene, his decision to combine rock instrumentation with his biting lyrics led to something much deeper than just the three chord rave-ups. With each passing album, Dylan seemed to be on a hot streak, but his first step up to the plate felt a bit shaky.

As opposed to the scathing indictments of American society, Dylan's first outing is a straightforward folk affair, with Dylan accompanied mainly by his acoustic guitar. Given the man's fantastic tunes, it's a bit disconcerting that most of these tunes are covers rather than originals, like his run through the traditional "House of the Rising Sun" and the blues song "See That My Grave is Kept Clean."

This is the album where Dylan wears all of his folk influences on his sleeve, even to the point of having one original being written to his hero Woody Guthrie. At the same time, songs like "Talkin New York" show the wit of Dylan's later work peeking through. It may have been just another folk record at the time, but no one could have predicted this humble singer would go on to shape the entire music world as we knew it.


9. Pablo Honey - Radiohead

There has been no band more interesting to watch in recent years than Radiohead. Whether it's their experimental work in the 90's or their glitchy experiments in the 2000s, each release from this group seems to push the boundaries of the rock band formula further. It's almost habitual how much they switch things up, but their debut saw them being followers rather than leaders.

Compared to other rock bands, Pablo Honey is far from a disappointment, with crunchy guitars, brash rock attitude, and even a No. 1 hit single in "Creep." For Radiohead though, this record feels like a sore thumb amid their spotless track record. As great as it may have sounded at the time, this album reeks of the early 90's, with guitar tones that sound like they're ripped straight out of a lesser grunge band's catalog. Though songs like "Anyone Can Play Guitar" can still hit hard, the difference between this and the band's more adventurous outings like Ok Computer feel like night and day.

Even the band themselves have bashed some of these songs, with Jonny Greenwood loathing their hit "Creep" and hardly ever performing it live in recent years. Radiohead's music always feels evergreen, but this album's luster has definitely faded over time.


8. From Genesis to Revelation - Genesis

Of all the prog bands of the 70's, Genesis always had an unbridled tenacity. Whether it was losing band members or getting pushback from their label, the band were able to survive lead singer changes and even managed to put prog on the pop charts with Phil Collins behind the mic.

While the band's first delve into progressive material came on Trespass, the band's real first outing is something the members would probably want to keep under wraps. Recorded while many of them were still in high school, the album has a sound that feels closer to baroque pop than prog epics. It makes total sense for the band to make something that sounds like Kate Bush, but the production of the record comes off more amateurish than intentionally raw.

Vocalist Peter Gabriel also sounds like he hasn't quite found his voice yet on this outing, with his trademark wail replaced with a lilting mix of breathy vocal passages and posh pop phrasing. Upon release, the album was met with widespread apathy from the record industry, leaving the band to make a big course correction on their later works. Most of the band consider this album a demo rather than a proper record, but this is the actual first steps of the prog rock giants before their gradual ascent.


7. Pretties For You - Alice Cooper

Throughout his entire career, you can't really say anything Alice Cooper has done has been "normal." From his maniacal stage show to his off-the-wall song topics, the man (and band) were one of the most shocking acts ever to emerge during the birth of hard rock.

Once the band got into the studio for the first time, their experimental outings ended up biting them in the ass. Signed to Frank Zappa's label, the band's debut Pretties For You was an absolute commercial bomb, with most of the songs being too unhinged to be commercially viable. Aside from the spotty song construction, the actual production of the record is a bit lackluster, with most of it feeling too noisy to latch onto any coherent melodies.

There are some shining lights to be found here like "Reflected," which would later be reworked and retitled "Elected" for the band's later period masterpiece Billion Dollar Babies. Given the band's raucous stage behavior, it seems like they were trying to recapture the energy of their live shows but ended up making an album that was a mess rather than controlled chaos. Alice Cooper's loveability comes from his weirdness, but this was the one instance where he may have been too weird for his own good.


6. Rocka Rolla - Judas Priest

Out of all the bands to emerge as hard rock bands, Judas Priest were the first major group to fly the flag for heavy metal music. The band's insane headbangers from British Steel to Hell Bent For Leather gave them a congregation of metal fans that have stood by them through thick and thin.

Long before the band became known as the metal gods, their first album was much more psychedelic than metallic. With many of the songs being written by original singer Al Atkins, this first offering from Priest feels closer to a British band than one of the heaviest acts in the world. Just before Rocka Rolla was recorded, Atkins left the group, leaving screamer Rob Halford to take over. Halford's scream is definitely in full effect, but the songs just make Halford feel like a placeholder singer rather than a fully-fledged member of the group.

With the music being much more in line with the late 60's blues rock movement, the band were itching for a change once they delivered the roaring followup Sad Wings of Destiny, which was their first flirtation with the heavy metal sound. The Priest may have been born on this record, but they were a long way from preaching the Gospel of Metal.


5. The Red Hot Chili Peppers - The Red Hot Chili Peppers

The Red Hot Chili Peppers are one of the most eclectic bands to come from the alternative side of the spectrum. The group's fusion of rock, funk, and hip hop was something completely unique in the era of grunge bands like Nirvana and Pearl Jam. They may reached their culture zenith in the 90's, but the band's debut from 1984 feels much more incoherent by comparison.

There are still some trademarks to be found on this record, like the irreplaceable low ending from bassist Flea, who annihilates the four-string on every track. On the other hand, the Chilis are much more than just their star bass player. Vocalist Anthony Kiedis' vocal flow is a lot more rough around the edges on this outing, with most of the lyrics going for impact rather than settling you into a groove. Though Hillel Slovak was known as the beating heart of the band in the early years, this album's guitars are actually played by Jack Sherman, who isn't bad by any stretch but also doesn't bring much to the table.

The band would later hone their funk chops on Freaky Styley and eventually acquire guitar god John Frusciante, but this album feels like the one moment where the Chilis' relentless energy wasn't in full effect just yet.


4. Shades of Deep Purple - Deep Purple

Deep Purple are known in many circles as one of the greatest hard rock acts to come from Britain in the late 60's. Taking elements of jazz, classical, and rock, the group's songs felt like long journeys that tested the limits of what hard rock could be in its infancy. That is, once the classic lineup was secure...

For the band's first few releases, the band's initial lineup consisted of bassist Nick Simper and vocalist Rod Evans, whose skills seemed a bit too artificial given the band's raw musicianship. On most of these cuts, the musicianship between Jon Lord and Ritchie Blackmore shine through, but the actual composed sections are pretty slapdash given the band's later output. Much of the songs are actually covers of old rock standards from the Beatles' "Help" to Jimi Hendrix's "Hey Joe," which are perfectly fine but nowhere near the classic sound of Purple.

Drummer Ian Paice even went so far as to say that the band identity at this juncture was not solid, with most of the songs sounding like lesser B-sides from jam band Vanilla Fudge. Though the band did pull out one great song in their cover of "Hush," they were poised for much greater things once Ian Gillan and Roger Glover joined their ranks.


3. 39 Smooth - Green Day

There's probably not one rock fan in the world who hasn't had Green Day as an inherent part of their life. The band have created some of the most indelible tracks in pop punk, from their landmark smash Dookie to their career renaissance in the 2000's with American Idiot.

The band may have been destined for superstardom, but their debut 39 Smooth is a much rougher affair than many fans would probably be accustomed to. Recorded on a shoestring budget in their indie punk stomping grounds, the band sounds like they're struggling to find their identity on this release. Songs like "Don't Leave Me" feel like punk-infused ripoffs of Husker Du, while oddities like "Rest" feel like a misguided attempt at psychedelic rock.

On the other hand, this album also has some highlights like "Going to Pasalacqua," which shows the band's more tuneful pop-punk sound coming into clearer view. However, the band is not even secure at this point, with original drummer John Kiffmeyer's fills not packing quite the same punch as Tre Cool a few years later. This is a solid enough pop-punk release, but the more crusty punk execution makes it feel more lopsided than exciting. There are some decent tracks to be found here, but this is only a must-own for the hardcore Green Day fanatics.


2. David Bowie - David Bowie

David Bowie has been known as rock and roll's most inventive chameleons. Throughout most of his career, Bowie created a myriad of different identities and went down many different sonic avenues from space rock to glam to experimental to industrial. Many may consider the man's first hit "Space Oddity" as the world's introduction to Bowie, but his initial first release would leave die hard fans shellshocked.

Recorded just before the Summer of Love, Bowie's self-titled debut was far removed from his more adventurous later recordings, with songs that dealt with more infantile topics like on "Rubber Band" and "Sell Me a Coat." Whereas Bowie's later work opened your mind up to different musical possibilities, these tracks are so cheesy they sound more like a late 60's vaudeville show than a rock and roll album.

Unsurprisingly, Bowie ended up feeling the same way about the album and even released his second album eponymously to try to differentiate his new identity from what he considered an embarrassing beginning. Even in interviews, Bowie has said how he wishes "Space Oddity" was his first artistic statement rather than this off-kilter pop sound. With a string of great albums to his name afterward, Bowie didn't have to live in the shadow of this record for much longer.


1. Metal Magic - Pantera

From the first time most metalheads heard Pantera, they knew they were going to be in for a wild ride. Even to this day, the band's albums like Cowboys From Hell and Vulgar Display of Power hold up as some of the heaviest albums ever to come out of the metal scene. On the other hand, these grizzly offerings are a far cry from where the band got their start in the early 80's.

Before they acquired frontman Phil Anselmo, the band cut their teeth in the Texas club circuit as a glam metal outfit in the vein of Van Halen. Given their determination to become stars, the band's first offering Metal Magic feels like the result of a bunch of kids trying to imitate their heroes. Though guitarist Dimebag Darrell was already showing his chops as one of the greatest guitarists in the metal world, the actual songs and vocals from Terry Glaze seem like lackluster first drafts rather than fleshed-out compositions.

Just a few years down the road, the band would discover acts like Slayer and Metallica and take their music in a much heavier direction. For now though, Metal Magic is the sound of a band trying their hardest to ride the coattails of the glam metal scene.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

I'm just a junkie for all things media. Whether it's music, movies, TV, or just other reviews, I absolutely adore this stuff. But music was my first love, and I love having the opportunity to share it with you good people. Follow Me On Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/timcoffman97