10 Bands That Actually Got Better After Losing Members

The Art of Moving Forward.

FILE- Dave Grohl and the Foo Fighters performs during the 54th annual Grammy Awards in this file photo dated Sunday, Feb. 12, 2012, in Los Angeles. On Tuesday Aug. 28, 2012, music industry online magazine NME says the Foo Fighters have played their
Chris Pizzello/AP

Losing a band member can be an equivalent to losing a family member at the worst of times. After years of slogging it out on the road, life tends to catch up with some rock stars a bit quicker than others. Even if these artists didn't die per se, to see some of the greatest musical minds actually drift apart is more than many fans would be able to stomach.

However, the best of these acts know how to turn these circumstances into a positive. From losing a main songwriter or even the dreaded lead singer departure, these acts were able to thrive without the help of their foundational members. Instead of sinking like a stone, these artists managed to even get bigger and better after they signed the musical divorce papers.

Whether it was just due to being in the right place at the right time or getting rid of some of the excess baggage, the new looks for these acts turned them into bonafied stars rather than just another underground band. It may have left these artists' core audience a bit perturbed, but when has anyone ever gotten successful without pissing somebody off? Despite being in a bad spot from a musical perspective, there's no way these acts have any second thoughts about their rise to the top.

10. Green Day 

Green Day were one of the fresh faces the rock scene sorely needed in the mid '90s. After the best creative mind of the decade was destroyed by Kurt Cobain's hand, many gnarly rock fans found refuge in this little upstart act from the Bay who were making letter perfect pop punk. Despite getting the job done with only 3 core members, many people forget about the salad days of Al Sobrante.

Born John Kiffmeyer, Sobrante joined both Billie Joe Armstrong and Mike Dirnt in the late '80s when they were first starting to get their musical dreams off the ground. In lieu of the usual massive debut record, these guys took the DIY punk approach and worked off of a handful of EPs and a pretty decent full length effort 39/Smooth with Kiffmeyer behind the kit. Though there was nothing inherently wrong with Kiffmeyer's drumming, his style of being just a little bit behind the beat became all the more noticeable when Armstrong and Dirnt started to grow as players and songwriters.

Finally realizing his role as the third wheel, Sobrante left Green Day for college, leaving drummer extraordinaire Tre Cool to fill the spot on Kerplunk, which gave the band enough exposure to be signed with Reprise Records for their pop punk opus Dookie. While Sobrante may have had the best intentions when it comes to Green Day, not vacating that drum throne would have been one of the greatest cases of wasted potential in punk history.


9. Fleetwood Mac

In the late '60s, it seemed that Fleetwood Mac had a bit of a revolving door policy when it came to members. Having a system like that isn't totally out of question, so long as the people who are still in the group remain the center of attention. On the other hand, when the main songwriter and bandleader is the one you're having problems, you might want to consider an upgrade.

After years of having blues legend Peter Green up front, his departure led to the drafting of Bob Welch, whose jazz guitar background just didn't fit with their blues roots. As the rest of the group set up shop at Sound City Studios, drummer Mick Fleetwood found a potential replacement in one of the guitar players in an opposite studio. While Lindsey Buckingham initially agreed to be their new guitarist, he signed on as long as his girlfriend Stevie Nicks could join as well.

After a few years of flimflamming around for potential stars, these blues legends had finally found their calling with...folk rock. Yeah, rather than the blues they had prided themselves on over the years, Fleetwood Mac became known as one of the best emotional powerhouses of the '70s, with Nicks, Buckingham, and keyboardist Christine McVie each carrying equal weight as songwriters. As opposed to their tried and true formula in the early years, this dramatic shift in tone turned these bluesy rockers into one of the greatest rock acts in history.


8. Pink Floyd

It's no secret that Pink Floyd are pretty much musical gods at this point. Across the '70s, these British prog rock juggernauts created some of the most thoughtful rock and roll ever created, along with one of the most parodied and culturally significant album sleeves with Dark Side of the Moon. The legend of these guys looms so large that people tend to forget their far more trippy beginnings.

Long before David Gilmour entered the picture, the original incarnation of Floyd began with Syd Barrett, whose psychedelic songs fit like a glove in the age of flower power. However, things started to get a bit too trippy as time went along. Even though Floyd have always had a more surreal quality to their music, Barrett's struggles with hallucinogenics led to him suffering a near psychotic breakdown, which inevitably caused his departure after A Saucerful of Secrets.

With Barrett only there in spirit, Gilmour was drafted as the new guitar player, as Roger Waters started to take the reins of the group's conceptual direction. The shadow of Barrett's unresolved mental state even led to the creation of one of Floyd's greatest musical triumphs in Wish You Were Here, which was dedicated to his musical influence. While Pink Floyd is the soundtrack of the '70s for many people, their career trajectory could have turned out a lot different if Barrett were able to hold on to his sanity.


7. Nirvana

There's pretty much no way to undersell how important Nirvana were to the rock mainstream in the '90s. Instead of just signaling a change in musical style, the video for Smells Like Teen Spirit sparked a new movement for adolescents who were sick and tired of hearing the same hair metal schlock being shoved down their throats by MTV...ironically enough by yet another video on MTV. Even though there's a lot of that alternative magic surrounding Kurt Cobain, it took a while before all the proper parts were in place.

As Cobain started to get the ball rolling with Krist Novoselic, they had an incredible problem when it came time to find a drummer. Originally having Aaron Burckhard behind the kit (and a brief stint with another guitar player), Nirvana thought they had found their guy with Chad Channing. Though Channing showed his stuff on the group's debut on Sub Pop Bleach, the lackluster drumming style led Cobain to search for a new man behind the skins, going so far as to draft Dale Crover from the Melvins for some show dates.

After years of trying to get the right guy, it didn't gel until Dave Grohl from Washington DC came along, whose songwriting mindset allowed him to give the songs just what they needed to breath, from the opening fill of Teen Spirit to the relentless power of Stay Away. Many bands might tend to focus on the songs first, but when it comes to rock and roll of any kind, you need to have a good backbeat if you really want things to explode.


6. Def Leppard

Contrary to popular belief, Def Leppard were never really in the trenches with the hair metal scene. Despite being the darlings of MTV in its golden age, the group's original incarnation as a borderline metal band was a bit strange for fans who saw Photograph and tried to play catchup. However, in order to actually get to where they were, they needed to lose a bit of dead weight.

During their hard rock years, the main supplier of riffs was Pete Willis, whose fantastic lead and rhythm lines can be heard on On Through the Night and High N Dry, which even resulted in their first big hit with Bringin on the Heartbreak. On the other hand, Willis's drinking problem could no longer be ignored when it came time to cut the tracks for their breakthrough album Pyromania.

Often stumbling into the control room, Willis would fumble over his guitar and get into spats with producer Mutt Lange. After giving him a few weeks to clean up, the rest of the guys ended up drafting in Phil Collen, who was just the right kind of guitar technician they needed to really wow the crowds. Though Willis did end up contributing rhythm tracks to Pyromania, the moment belongs to Collen, as Def Leppard had finally solidified the lineup that would take them to the top of the glam rock food chain.


5. Foo Fighters

It's safe to say that the Foo Fighters are basically a glorified solo outfit for Dave Grohl. While that's not to discount any of the contributions from the other members of the group, the actual drive behind this band has always been Dave Grohl trying to pick up the pieces of his post-Nirvana music career. Even though the first Foos record was practically Dave by himself, it took a little while to settle into the definitive lineup.

Going with drummer William Goldsmith as the original touring drummer, Grohl found himself increasingly dissatisfied with his drumming style. Instead of telling him about the way the drums should be played, the Foos' sophomore effort The Colour and the Shape resulted in Grohl rerecording all of Goldsmith's drum parts himself, which led him to abruptly quit the project soon afterward.

Left to go out on tour without a permanent drummer, Grohl ended up finding his kindred spirit in Taylor Hawkins, who was drumming in Alanis Morrissette's touring band when he got the call to join the Foos. Fitting like a glove, Hawkins' swing and style was just the right feel for Grohl to play off of, complete with both restraint and aggression in equal measure. Despite being a bit of a percussion perfectionist, it was almost like Dave didn't need to worry about the drums anymore once Hawkins took over.


4. Rush

It's hard to think of Rush without the amazing drum stylings of Neil Peart. Ever since the prog rock sounds of this Canadian trio graced the airwaves, every aspiring drummer had found a new god to study in Peart, as he reinvented the prog rock sound left and right. However, there was a dark time before Peart was even in the picture.

When Rush originally formed in the mid '70s with Geddy Lee and Alex Lifeson, the original man behind the drum stool was John Rutsey, whose style was much more about the standard rock and roll style. While Rutsey did perform well on their eponymous debut record, you can tell that his taste catered more towards more commercial acts like Bad Company or Cream rather than the outlandish stylings of King Crimson or Yes. What made matters worse was when Rutsey went on the road, which showed him living an unhealthy lifestyle for a man with juvenile diabetes.

Deciding to part ways shortly after a mini tour, Lee and Lifeson scoured the scene for drummers before finally arriving at what might be the greatest drummer in the world. More than just a typical timekeeper, Peart's vast knowledge of different time signatures as well as his literate background turned him into the group's lyricist and creative visionary. Rush could have carried on playing their own brand of bluesy rock and roll, and yet the entire prog rock world would have probably been worse off for it.


3. Pantera

Pantera probably hold the distinction as the one metal act that has scared the most parents in their day. Instead of using the pure visual horror of something like Marilyn Manson or Alice Cooper, this demonic music coming out of Texas struck fear in the hearts of elders and excitement in every adolescent's mind. Though these guys could have readily delivered thrash metal cocktails at the drop of a hat, they had to make a crucial decision before going forward.

Long before the Cowboys From Hell became what we know them as today, their first handful of albums were far different, with Dimebag Darrell leading the group as a glam rock act. Very much in the style of Van Halen, albums like Projects in the Jungle and Metal Magic are a far cry from what these guys would become, with Terry Glaze out front trying on his best impression of a hair metal vocalist.

However, things started to turn a corner once Dime and his brother Vinnie Paul started to sink their teeth into Metallica and Slayer. Quickly dropping Glaze, the Abbott Brothers eventually landed on Phil Anselmo, whose definitive growl and muscly delivery fit right in when playing off of Dime's heavier riffs. Though Glaze might have been able to take Pantera far in the early days, it only took one singer out of New Orleans to make this band the face of '90s metal.


2. Genesis

Many prog rock aficionados tend to worship at the alter of Genesis. Forming in the late '60s when these young men met in charter schools, the melodic sensibilities of Tony Banks and Mike Rutherford working off of Peter Gabriel's outlandish stories made for some of the most adventurous music to have 'rock' associated with it. Just when it seemed that Genesis were becoming living legends, something changed when the Angel Gabriel departed them.

This wasn't a subtle loss either, with Gabriel's songwriting and wild stage antics playing a pivotal role in almost every one of the group's records and live shows up to this point. It wouldn't have been surprising for most fans if Genesis just gave up, but the rest of the guys found out that Gabriel's replacement was already in the band. Emerging from behind his drum stool, Phil Collins' singing voice gave the group a second wind, as they went into the '80s and dominated the charts with albums like Invisible Touch and their self-titled record.

Despite many people calling out Collins for 'destroying Genesis,' many of their songs in this period do a great job at balancing the more accessible material with the prog rock stylings they had become known for. Sure, there might have been a new face up front, but when you have music this good, what's there to really complain about?


1. The Beatles

Most of the Beatles' journey to the top of the rock world has gone down in legend at this point. After working in the club circuit in their hometown of Liverpool, people still tell the tale of the Fab Four gracefully stepping into rock history on The Ed Sullivan Show, with one pop-flavored hit after another. Though it seemed like the entire group had remarkable synergy, it didn't really work out that way when they first started.

Formed as the result of schoolboys, the main lineup of John Lennon, Paul McCartney, and George Harrison was originally a five piece, with Stu Sutcliffe behind the bass and Pete Best on drums. While Sutcliffe looked every bit the part with his James Dean persona, his total incompetence on the bass and focus on art led to him abandoning rock and roll altogether.

Though McCartney graciously switched over to the four-string, the real magic still wasn't secure until producer George Martin pointed out Best's off-kilter drumming style when it came time to record. Despite some major pushback from fans, the band quickly drafted in Ringo Starr from rival band Rory Storm and the Hurricanes, who ended up being just the kind of song-centric drummer who knew just when to pull back and hit hard at every turn. While the Fabs could have gone on with Best behind the kit, the entire history of rock and roll may have turned out a whole lot different.


In this post: 
Foo Fighters
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

I'm just a junkie for all things media. Whether it's music, movies, TV, or just other reviews, I absolutely adore this stuff. But music was my first love, and I love having the opportunity to share it with you good people. Follow Me On Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/timcoffman97