10 Bands Who Released Genre Defining Second Albums

When following up on a debut album resulted in a career perfect and inspirational masterpiece!

Marilyn Manson performing on the Main Stage at the Reading Festival.
Yui Mok/PA Archive

It’s not uncommon to find that a band’s best work often comes with the release of their second album. Largely the first record is conceived of music written over a period of a few years, prior to being signed; songs that have undoubtedly been honed and road-tested to death, but written and demoed with a certain raw inexperience.

There are of course exceptions to the rule, but often when a band finds success following the arrival of a hit debut, it is the increase in songwriting maturity, a greater budget and more time to develop the recording process with a more prestigious producer, that allows for true greatness.

And in some instances, bands have gone on to create genre-defining second albums that have absolutely rubberstamped their names in the history books, forever linking them to a certain style or movement and epitomising that sound in the minds of fans. The landscape of rock and metal has always evolved over the decades, and here are some of the finest examples of the second albums that have truly left their mark.

10. Slipknot - Iowa

Slipknot arrived in a gloriously individual fashion with their debut album in 1999, which was released on Roadrunner Records, the hottest heavy music label at the time. Nu-Metal had exploded by the end of the decade and Slipknot were banded in that genre, due in no small part to the fact that Ross Robinson, the legendary producer in the scene, had helped create the record. But Slipknot were undoubtedly in a different class of their own.

A band made up of nine mask and boiler suit-wearing alluring musicians, who collectively created music at the very heaviest end of the nu-metal spectrum, Expectations were high when they recorded their second album Iowa, and when it arrived in 2001 it was an absolute game changer. Slipknot having already tasted immediate commercial success went in the most extreme direction possible, which ended up elevating their reputation in the metal scene. Iowa is considered their masterpiece.

It is their heaviest album by far, with career defining songs in their catalogue such as Disaster Piece and Heretic Anthem. Iowa can be considered the record that brought extreme music to the mainstream, and unquestionably sits as the heaviest record ever to sell in excess of 1.75 million copies. It also rubber-stamped Slipknot’s place at the top of the metal tree, as they have gone on to become one of the most successful bands of their generation, selling out arena tours with every record cycle, and headlining festivals around the world.


9. System Of A Down - Toxicity

System of a Down are another band who arrived with the nu-metal explosion, but who also had an originality to their sound that saw them stand out from the crowd. Their debut album had been brought to fruition by super producer Rick Rubin in 1998. He had discovered System of a Down playing in the club scene of LA, and at the heart of the Armenian-American band were the extraordinary talents of vocalist Serj Tankian and guitarist Daron Malakian.

Following the success of their debut, the band built up to the highly anticipated release of Toxicity, their virtually perfect second album in 2001. By this time their unique sound was fully realised, and they dropped a record which from start to finish is one of the strongest of the era. Led by the massively successful MTV hit Chop Suey!, the album also featured the singles Toxicity and Aerials, and was a sublime blend of heavy and melodic music.

The album gained notoriety for System of a Down, who came under criticism for the lyrical content of Chop Suey!, which controversially for such a big hit appeared to be based around the theme of suicide. And famously, the album dropped in the same week that the 9/11 terrorist attacks took place, which had a huge impact on the band members around the release and promotion of the record. Toxicity has gone on to sell over 10 million units worldwide, and can be considered a perfect example of alternative metal from the turn of the millennium.


8. Isis - Oceanic

Isis were an underground band led by the talented Aaron Turner (vocals / guitar), who from their inception in 1997 through to their break up in 2010 built up a steady cult following. Their fine reputation extended quickly from their roots in the east coast hardcore scene, to worldwide acclaim as they hit the road on high profile tours, supporting the likes of Tool and Mogwai.

They also helped pioneer the sub-genre sound of post-metal, a term used to describe rock / metal songs with long sections of instrumental parts, repetition, and a structure that does not follow a classic path of verse-chorus-verse. Isis expanded on the blueprint laid down by other such bands as Neurosis and Godflesh, who themselves were a big inspiration for Aaron Turner. Isis’ first album Celestial was released in 2000 on Neurot Recordings, but it was with their sophomore release Oceanic in 2000 that Isis really left their mark on the world of rock.

The record is considered to be an absolute classic of the post-metal genre, featuring unusual elements of atmospheric and ambient soundscapes to compliment the aggression, which saw them cross over to reach a wider audience. Oceanic was a turning point in the career of the band, that would also end up being a hugely inspirational and ground-breaking release. Influencing not just a whole host of bands to experiment with their own interpretations of the style, but also a whole avant-garde music scene that has since developed worldwide throughout the 2000s.


7. Alice In Chains - Dirt

Alice In Chains announced themselves on the world stage when their debut album Facelift landed in 1990, and its lead single Man In The Box became a huge MTV hit. In the following year all eyes were on their hometown of Seattle as a number of bands - including Pearl Jam, Nirvana and Soundgarden - all released critically acclaimed albums that sold by the bucketload, helping to create the ‘grunge’ label bestowed by the music press as a way to catagorise the alternative rock sound that was coming from the area.

And it was with their follow-up album, Dirt in 1992, that Alice In Chains created the record that would define them as a band, becoming a pivotal record in the genre also. Considered a pure rock masterpiece, Dirt is a dark and melancholic collection of songs that took Alice In Chains in a bleaker direction that also imprinted on the hearts of millions. Dirt has sold over 5 million copies worldwide and is considered to be the band's true magnum opus.

Dirt is immortalised in part due to the fact that singer Layne Staley completely stopped making music just 4 years later and saw out his days living as a recluse, having succumbed to the drug addiction that was largely responsible for inspiring the lyrical content of this amazing record. His vocal melodies with guitarist Jerry Cantrell are legendary, with the two perfectly executing their song writing on classics such as Them Bones, Would? and Down in a Hole.


6. Marilyn Manson - Antichrist Superstar

Marilyn Manson, the band led by the notorious singer of the same name, released their debut album Portrait of an American Family in 1994. They had previously been grafting away, gigging in their native Florida as Marilyn Manson and the Spooky Kids, before being discovered by Trent Reznor who signed them to his Nothing record label. A tour with Nine Inch Nails and then Korn followed, and Marilyn Manson started to make a serious name for themselves.

They kept the momentum going with the release of Smells Like Children in 1995, a collection of remixes and B-sides that also provided them with a hit single, their cover version of The Eurythmics’ Sweet Dreams (Are Made Of These). This set them up perfectly for what came next, the second proper studio album which would turn them, and specifically the singer himself, into a worldwide phenomenon. The aptly titled Antichrist Superstar arrived in 1996, and lifted Marilyn Manson to an unprecedented level of commercial success.

Antichrist Superstar took their image into a far darker direction, elevating the shock-rock style of Alice Cooper to the next level, whilst making the singer one of the most recognisable faces in pop culture. With tracks such as The Beautiful People and Tourniquet, Marilyn Manson firmly put their own spin on the industrial rock/metal sound which had been made popular with NIN and Ministry. There were solid songs with darkly artistic music videos to match, combing to make them the true icons of a new generation in goth culture.


5. Tool - Aenima

When Tool burst onto the LA scene at the beginning of the nineties, they instantly offered something new in the alternative music world, with a diversely individual sound of their own. Led by their enigmatic vocalist Maynard James Keenan, Tool’s debut album Undertow (1993) delivered some sublimely unique songs such as Sober and Prison Sex, which were also some of the most leftfield and bizarre MTV hits of the time - due in part to the quirky stop motion animated videos created by guitarist Adam Jones, who also worked in Hollywood as an FX technician.

Tool's second album Aenema arrived in 1995 and completely took what they had started on Undertow, and raised the bar ten-fold. Adam Jones’ videos for the song Stinkfist and the title track received heavy air play on MTV, and their profile was significantly boosted in the US, while also launching them onto the worldwide stage. But it was the development of their style on Aenema that really stood out, as Tool explored a traditionally ‘un-cool’ progressive sound, blended with alternative rock that was executed with a complex virtuosity and considered truly ground-breaking at the time.

The direction taken on Aenema pushed the band well onto the way of their own musical path, which was explored further on their subsequent records - while Aenema also inspired a whole host of bands that would arrive in the following years, and who were clearly influenced by the innovative Tool style.


4. Nine Inch Nails - The Downward Spiral

After spending some years as a session musician during the height of the late eighties synth-wave scene, Trent Reznor spent any spare studio time he could find for himself to knuckle down and record his first album as Nine Inch Nails, Pretty Hate Machine, which was released in 1989. The album took the eighties synth-pop sound into a darker place, mixed with heavy distorted guitars in places, and was one of the influential albums in what would become the industrial-rock scene of the nineties.

Nine Inch Nails followed this release with the Broken and Fixed EPs, before recording the true defining release of their career, The Downward Spiral (1994). The album was unlike anything heard before, a complete experimentation in what was possible with industrial rock music, and a strange eclectic journey from start to finish. Trent Reznor and his band of hired musicians produced the controversial hit Closer, the aggressively abrasive Mr Self Destruct and March Of The Pigs, and the stripped back sounds of Piggy and Hurt.

These were in addition to whole number of further intriguing deeper cuts, which blended electronica, rock and metal like never before. Lyrically the album is incredibly dark, dealing with the deep subject matter of Reznor’s addictions and mental health, and The Downward Spiral would ultimately go on to see Nine Inch Nails become one of the highest grossing, and most in demand touring bands in the world.


3. Deftones - Around The Fur

In the early nineties, the emerging grunge music scene in Seattle hit a nail into the coffin for the popularity of traditional hard rock. But it was the next big musical trend of nu-metal that would see a new generation of bands - this time largely from the LA scene - take alternative music into a heavier direction. The style would blend a myriad of different influences, from rock to metal to hip-hop together with a lyrical style that would shift from screaming to clean singing and back again.

Korn were the first notable band of the genre who took the rap-metal style from the likes of Rage Against The Machine, dropped the tunings on their instruments and created something new on their 1994 debut album. Deftones arrived soon after with their debut album Adrenaline (1995), but it was with their second record, Around The Fur, released two years later in 1997, that they showed the world a completely individual style of their own, transcending their reputation above their peers.

The Deftones sound is personified by the extraordinary vocal style of Chino Moreno, who when singing melodic parts channels an influence of an eighties Depeche Mode style, before unleashing blood-curdling screams in a heavier groove-metal style. Tracks such as My Own Summer (Shove It) and Be Quiet (Drive Far Away) showed a finesse in the songwriting of Deftones, while the album also features a notable guest appearance from Max Cavalera (Sepultura / Soulfly) on the song Head Up.


2. Metallica - Ride The Lightning

In 1983, Metallica released their debut album Kill Em All, which was a rough around the edges prototype for the fresh emerging metal style that was being born on the west coast of America; a sound heavily influenced by the New Wave of British Heavy Metal style from the likes of Iron Maiden, but with added speed and aggression.

But it would be with their follow-up record Ride The Lightning, released just one year later in 1984, that Metallica would create one of the all time classic examples of what would become known as thrash metal, and which still holds up today as one of the finest records in the genre. This was when Metallica shook off the teenage rust they had on Kill Em All, and where their songwriting significantly matured. Tracks such as For Whom The Bell Tolls and Creeping Death are still staples of the mammoth metal band’s live sets, and Fight Fire With Fire may just be the most intense opening on any metal record from the era.

They also showed another side of their songwriting evolution with the acoustically written Fade To Black, which progresses to be one of their deepest and most emotional songs. Ride The Lightening has sold over 5 million copies and was the penultimate Metallica record to feature key songwriter and bassist Cliff Burton, before he tragically died in a tour bus crash during the cycle of their following album, Master of Puppets.


1. Nirvana - Nevermind

Nirvana had made a name for themselves gigging in and around their native Seattle scene and with the release of their debut album Bleach (1989) on the local independent record label, Sub Pop. Then, with the release of Nevermind in 1991 on the major label Geffen, they completely changed the trajectory of their career. Having recently installed Scream drummer Dave Grohl into their lineup, Nevermind was recorded with producer Butch Vig, and the band recorded a video for the track Smells Like Teen Spirit to launch their new music.

The video would go on to be a monumental success on MTV, with Nirvana soon becoming the biggest buzz band in the world as Nevermind became a musical phenomenon. The album showed Kurt Cobain’s creativity as a masterfully complete songwriter, as he moved beyond the largely distorted punky collection of songs on their first album, writing with a pop melody on tracks such as Come As you Are and Lithium, and with a haunting melancholy on Something In The Way.

Nevermind has gone on to sell over 30 million copies, but the success it brought for Cobain was not the success he wanted. He struggled with the fame and adulation that was thrust upon him and, as we know, Kurt took his own life just three years later- a tortured artist who just couldn’t find peace with living under the spot light, as one of the biggest rock stars in the world.


Contributor
Contributor

Connoisseur of Alternative Music & Cult Movies. Freelance writer covering the Rock & Metal music scenes, and the Horror, Sci-Fi and Fantasy Film & Tv genres.