10 Bands Who Were Justified In Changing Sounds
Because sometimes you need a new direction.
Finding the winning formula in any way of life is a tough ask. Finding all the right ingredients to blend together and get something going is the key to success, and is this has never been more true than in the creative world.
Bands are perhaps the best example of this in action, working tirelessly in an industry where all the talent in the world doesn't necessarily equal the success and recognition a group might deserve. The history books are littered with groups that never made the grade, however they're also lined with stories of how even the most famous of groups struggled to even a book a venue before making it to the big time.
So whether because of a lack of musical identity that either unleashes their potential or resonates with the audiences of the day, or the clashing of personalities from within the band itself that end up holding them back, there's many reasons why a group might look to take stock and find a new direction.
And sometimes, it works out for the best...
10. Muse
Matt Bellamy, Chris Wolstenholme and Dominic Howard have been jamming out as Muse since the mid 1990s and regularly dabble in experimental sounds and genres with each release they collaborate on.
Whilst songs such as Starlight and Knights of Cydonia have become some of the most mainstream sounding rocks songs in the British scene and synonyms with the band itself, Muse's origins were far from this sort of scene. Having been evolving during the heyday of underground grunge music courtesy of the likes of Radiohead, the band's early songs are far more aggressive-sounding than what most would expect to hear these days.
A sort of goth-glam group, it wasn't until the start of the 2000s that Muse really began embracing a more radio-friendly vibe, producing one of the most famous covers of the Broadway classic hit Feeling Good during the production of Origin of Symmetry in 2001.
Building on this, Muse would continue along this road with Absolution in 2003 and then again with Black Holes and Revelations, arguably their most iconic and easily their most successful release having topped the UK charts, in 2006.
9. Journey
For better or worse, Journey became one of the world's most listened to bands when their hit single Don't Stop Believin' broke the world in 2009. Becoming the most listened to tune in iTunes history, the sound of Journey in the early to mid 1980s was the absolute epitome of big, radio-friendly rock tunes that were everywhere across the decade.
However, this settled sound was very different to the types of tunes Journey were pumping out when they first started out. Formed in 1973 initially as a backup group for more established artists in the San Francisco Bay Area, Journey's initial sound had a far more blues/jazz vibe to it than the all-out rock sounds they would adopt later on.
The band released two albums in this style, Journey in 1975 and Look Into The Future in 1976, but sales and overall reception were somewhat on the flat side. Their record company, Columbia, requested that the group change their style and band members Neal Schon, Ross Valory and Aynsley Dunbar all began taking singing lessons in order to help harmonise their vocals and lay the foundations for their more commercial works.
8. Kings Of Leon
Brothers Caleb, Nathan, Jared, along with their cousin Matthew formed Kings of Leon back in 1999 and have gradually become one of the most well-known stadium rock bands in the world.
However, things didn't start out that way for the band from Nashville. With all the band members growing up regularly attending traditional Christian mass, elements of soul and preaching can be heard in the group's early direction, leading to a far more rhythm, bluesy sound.
Having released their first EP, Holy Roller Novocaine, in February and their first album, Youth and Young Manhood, in July 2003, Kings of Leon became a well respected group within the industry, albeit a still largely undiscovered one.
Having proven themselves as a skilled and passionate band, Kings of Leon began to broaden their style in their second album, Aha Shake Heartbreak, in October 2004 with the lead single from the release, The Bucket, rising to the top 20 in the UK.
The peak of Kings of Leon's success would come with their fourth album, Only By The Night, in 2008 however. Hit singles Sex on Fire and Use Somebody were the mainstream-sounding songs the group had ever produced, but it did bag them two BRIT Awards in 2009 alone.
7. The Cure
Having been formed all the way back in 1978, The Cure have become one of the most influential and recognisable gothic rock bands in the world. With his wild hair and red lipstick, frontman Robert Smith has evolved so much as an artist and taken the band through countless different styles and genres, all to great success it should be said.
The Cure were formed in the midst of the post-punk movement that was sweeping across the UK in the late 1970s. The gloomy, dreary sounding notes and tones were synonymous of the time and immediately established the group as one of the leading lights in the anti-establishment scene.
However, from the early 1980s onwards, the band became a lot more commercially mainstream and their audience began to grow more and more. From the middle of the decade in particular, upbeat, glossy songs such as Close To Me, Just Like Heaven, Inbetween Days and Friday I'm In Love were released and were instant hits.
Having been going for over forty years now, adapting and evolving is the key reason behind The Cure's longevity. It's also led to a hugely successful career, with the band scooping up a place in the Rock n Roll Hall of Fame for their 13 studio albums and 30 or so single releases.
6. Red Hot Chili Peppers
One of the most widely celebrated and successful alternative rock bands to have emerged from the infamous 1990s American scene, Red Hot Chili Peppers have amassed a collection of 25 top-ten songs, 13 number one hits and the record for the most weeks spent at number in the genre with 85.
However, their direction looked very different when they started out life in the industry in the early '80s. Founding members Anthony Kiedis, Hillel Slovak, Flea and Jack Irons had all gone to the same high school and were all immensely influenced by more funk and soul sounds, rather than traditional rock that would probably be expected.
Indeed, the band's debut album, The Red Hot Chili Peppers, is credited as being the first ever blend of funk and metal music. The early sound of Red Hot Chili Peppers often featured heavy groovy bass sounds and usually rolled around improvised tunes being strung together by Kiedis' rapping, a long way musically from their accomplished, radio-friendly tunes that they would eventually adopt and become far more famous for.
Whilst the group might have been initially disappointed with the studio's meddling and bemoaned the polished sound they were first pushed towards, their eventual success with this formula has probably helped ease those initial concerns.
5. U2
Love 'em, or hate 'em, U2 possess a record within the music industry that any group would be proud of. Having burst onto the scene as Ireland's most exciting rock band in the late 1970s, U2's popularity reached astronomical heights following their Band Aid performance in 1985 and the release of the Joshua Tree, with the singles I Still Haven't Found What I'm Looking For' and With or Without You, in 1987.
After another strong release with Achtung Baby in 1991, U2 hit a string of poor releases as the decade rolled on. Hoping to capture the emerging popularity of the LSD-fuelled disco days of the '90s, Zooropa and Pop were albums that could have been the death of any band, U2 were in desperate need of a new identity for the incoming 2000s.
Thankfully for them they hit back with a return-to-basics, stripped back approach with All That You Can't Leave Behind in 2000, featuring the singles Beautiful Day, Walk On and Stuck In A Moment You Can't Get Out Of. Not only did this reunite the band with its core following once again, it opened up the doors to a whole new generation of music lovers from out of the cold.
4. Fleetwood Mac
Another group with a staggeringly long history within the industry, Fleetwood Mac have amassed together over 120 million record sales and a place in the Rock N Roll Hall of Fame since their formation in London in 1967.
Having been assembled together from a group of artists heavily active in the genre beforehand, Fleetwood Mac's debut album, also named Fleetwood Mac, was actually a collection of original and covers of classic rhythm and blues-sounding songs.
Whilst the album helped launch the band's career with a no.4 place on the UK charts, it didn't contain any singles and barely scraped into the top 200 in the United States. The bluesy tunes would continue with the band's second album, Mr. Wonderful, in 1968, going a little bit further in fact with the addition of horns, keyboards and a live sound.
The unearthing of partners Lindsey Buckingham and Stevie Nicks in 1974 completely changed things for Fleetwood Mac however. The duo combined their immense songwriting abilities throughout their time in the band, but arguably brought the biggest shift in tone with Rumours in 1977. A far more soft-rock release featuring elements of pop, the album features some of the group's best ever songs, including Go Your Own Way, The Chain and Dreams and eventually went onto sell 40 million copies.
3. Bee Gees
Arguably the disco world's most successful and celebrated group, Barry, Robin and Maurice Gibb formed the Bee Gees all the way back in 1958 and have become known for their three-part tight harmonies and groovy looks.
However things were very different for the group when they first started out in the late '50s and early '60s. Having formed another group, The Rattlesnakes, prior to the Bee Gees, Barry, Robin, Maurice and friends Vince Melouney and Colin Peterson began their journey in the music industry heavily dabbling in skiffle, rock and rolling sounds.
The first three albums released by the group contained very little of the disco direction they would eventually become famous for, with Spicks and Specs in 1966 containing Rock n' Roll elements, and Bee Gees' 1st in 1967 and Horizontal in 1968 representing the way of psychedelic rock that was sweeping across the industry at the time.
By the end of the 1960s, it was clear that the industry was evolving and that the Bee Gees' style of folk rock was on its way out. Cucumber Castle was the last album of theirs to chart until the release of Spirits Having Flown in ten years later, coinciding with their embrace of the emerging world of disco.
2. Genesis
Having been founded in 1967 by Charterhouse pupils Tony Banks, Mike Rutherford, Anthony Phillips and Peter Gabriel, Genesis were one of the most influential progressive rock bands of their day. Throughout the early to mid 1970s, the band became more and more centred around their increasingly glamorous and outlandish live performances, with Peter Gabriel's extravagance on-stage a particular talking point.
With Gabriel becoming more and more distracted by his increasing popularity, tensions among the group continued to rise and culminated in him leaving the band and going solo in 1975.
Finding a replacement for an individual such as Gabriel would be a tough ask for any group, however Genesis made the bold decision to keep things in-house and promote drummer Phil Collins to being the band's frontman.
Coinciding with the start of the '80s, Genesis evolved into one of the UK's most commercially successful groups. Follow Me Follow You became the band's first top 10 hit in 1978 and led to the release of Duke, Abacab and Genesis as studio albums in 1980, 1981 and 1983 respectively. This change of style led to a far more harmonious group, and the trio of Rutherford, Collins and Banks continue to tour as Genesis to this day.
1. The Beatles
John, Paul, George and Ringo started out life as the Beatles by dressing smart and appearing as respectable young men of the time. As the 1960s rolled on however, The Beatles were right at the heart of the changing norms and values within society.
The initial sound The Beatles produced in the early 1960s combined elements of traditional Rock 'n Roll first heard in the decade prior with the pop elements that were proving popular with the '60's younger generations.
Following their invasion of the United States in 1964, The Beatles came more and more innovative. With enlightening trips to India and the increasing use of psychedelic drugs providing them with inspiration aplenty, the four boys from Liverpool would begin flexing their creative genius in the years that followed.
As they began pushing society's expectations of them more and more, The Beatles would often split off on their own and bring their own identities back with them into the recording studio. From 1965 onwards, The Beatles would produce the iconic albums of Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band in 1967, The White Album in 1968 and Yellow Submarine and Abbey Road in 1969.