10 Best Progressive Rock Bands Of All Time
When Rock Got Technical.
Rock and roll has never been known as the most complicated of genres. When things first started back in the early '50s, all you needed was a basic understanding of the 12 bar blues to get by in any decent rock band. Once the '60s started to spread out, it was about time that bands started to mess with the structure of what rock and roll was about.
Rather than just get by with your traditional foundations of rock, these were the artists that bucked the trends and went for much more complex songs that no one had ever heard before. That meant songs that stretched out to much longer lengths, some blistering solos from everyone involved, and a whole mess of different time signatures to work with. As technical as some of these songs might seem though, prog doesn't really get enough credit for how much it opened the floodgates for the rest of us.
Sure, not all of us are planning to make another 9 part suite and make an album that would make a pleb's head explode. Then again, the seeds that were planted by these bands gave the rest of the rock scene free reign to try whatever they wanted to when the time called for it. It might be a little bit tough to figure out at first, but this is the kind of music where it pays to do your homework as a musician.
10. Yes
Any band that even thinks of going the progressive route has to have some level of faith in their instrument. As much as it might be fun to string together a few song ideas and call it a suite, you still have to be pretty proficient behind your instrument to make the whole thing move forward. And as the prog rock revolution got underway, Yes were practically the rock and roll answer to classical music.
In the era of the vinyl record, going through albums like Going for the One or Close to the Edge feel more like experiences listening to a classical piece, complete with vast sections that would sometimes go on past the 10 minute mark. It takes a lot to make a track of that length interesting though, and Steve Howe found a way by putting together some of the most off kilter guitar parts and making them fit under one roof.
That's not to downplay the rest of the band either, with Chris Squire's amazing bass playing driving songs like Roundabout and Jon Anderson's searing vocals sitting like a sonic bed on top of everything. Yes also don't get nearly the credit they deserve for bridging the gap to the next generation, going for the '80s update to their sound on tracks like Owner of a Lonely Heart. When other bands tried to chase trends, the most technical bands never really go out of style.
9. Dream Theater
Towards the end of the '80s, the world had really gotten used to virtuoso set of musicians in rock. Ever since Eddie Van Halen changed the game in the late '70s, there were a countless number of guitar players trying to outshred one another by just writing entire songs' worth of scale exercises. Along the way though, bands like Dream Theater found a way to put all of those shredfests into legitimate songs.
Across every single record that the band have made, you can see them practically refining their sound into something a lot more ambitious than before. Though songs like Pull Me Under already had a flair for the dramatic, the songs that come off of later records like Octavarium are still unmatched in the rock world, with each respective player coming up with parts that would normally make everyone else's hands fall off.
That doesn't account for taste though, and the guys definitely know when to go for something a little bit softer, like the amazing bends of John Petrucci or the laid back grooves that pop up in between the 20 minute exercises from Mike Portnoy. Even though it might be fun to just put together a song with tons of lead riffing in it, the only way to get the people to pay attention is to have a good song at the center of it. You'd better be taking notes, Yngwie.
8. The Mars Volta
The rock community at large was dealt a heavy blow in the early '00s when At the Drive In decided to call it quits. This post hardcore outfit had all the lightning in a bottle charisma that you would expect out of a great band, so why would they pick now to take a step away from each other? While you can tell that the band splintered, two of the masterminds had some other plans with the Mars Volta.
From their first record onward, every Mars Volta release has been a trip from start to finish, feeling like it's between the sounds of psychedelia, rock, and absolute insanity depending on where in the track you're listening to. Although Omar Rodriguez Lopez was already a guitar hero in the ATDI days, this is where he really flexes his chops, making layers of atmospheric noise in between some searing solo runs on albums like Deloused in the Comatorium or everything on the back half of Frances the Mute.
Combine that with the shrill voice of Cedric Bixler Zavala and you've got a band that puts together all the off the wall zaniness of someone like Frank Zappa, the atmospheric sounds of post rock, and just a little bit of rocket fuel to tie everything together with. For prog newcomers, this is probably not the best place to start, but once you've gotten used to everything, you're in for a damn gold mine once you get here.
7. Porcupine Tree
Granted, it's hard to really get any of the casual rock fans into something like prog overnight. After all, seeing the sheer song lengths on some of these records might have the AC/DC stripe of rock fan a little bit intimidated. And yes, this genre can be a little bit of a lot to take in, but that doesn't mean there aren't some kickass gateway bands along the way.
Around the time that prog rock was starting to make a resurgence in the '90s, we got Porcupine Tree coming up with some of the more radio friendly prog rock that was hard to come by at the time. From the way that he constructs melodies to how he puts together arrangements for songs, Steven Wilson seems to be just as inspired by bands like Pink Floyd and Dream Theater as he does with acts like the Beatles, never letting the song get in the way of a great hook.
That's not to say that this is the lightweight version of prog rock by any stretch. Listening to records like In Absentia will really keep you on your toes, going from catchy songs to riffs that feel like they're about to rip your head off. Because prog rock isn't always about pushing the limits of the listener. There's nothing wrong with kicking back with a good tune every once in a while.
6. Electric Light Orchestra
For as long as prog rock has been a thing, many bands have stretched the limits of what constitutes progressive rock. While there may have been bands in the genre that are known for some fairly simple songs, they get their progressive pedigree with how they choose to build their songs or the way they present themselves to the public. So when you look at a band called Electric Light Orchestra, keep in mind that that last word of their name isn't a joke.
Ever since their beginnings in the '70s, Jeff Lynne had a band in mind that was as informed by the sounds of classical instrumentation as they were with rock and roll, and when you listen to their work you can see why. Although the string sections might seem like a bit of an odd choice, these are the kind of lines that Jimi Hendrix would have played if he chose the viola over the guitar.
Over time, Lynne also knew how to refine his sound in the studio, starting with daring space rock songs to eventually landing on a happy medium between accessible and progressive on songs like Telephone Line and Strange Magic. That's before you even get to his production pedigree, being behind the board for his own band along with classic rockers like Tom Petty and Paul McCartney. Though the idea of 'making it' in a prog band is kind of up in the air, you've done pretty well for yourself if the surviving Beatles (the original progressive band) are asking to work with you.
5. Tool
Of all the bands that we've seen thus far, most of them still belong firmly in the rock category. That's not to say that all progressive music has to stick exclusively to the soothing sounds of modern rock. Any progressive player would be itching for something more, and Tool gave us something mind melting with their brand of progressive metal.
If you were there at Tool's inception though, you wouldn't have guessed that they would eventually go on to make something like Schism, being more of an off the wall metal act. With each passing release though, the band seemed to grow up exponentially, bringing in more complex time signatures and managing to even get psychedelic on some of their later records like Lateralus and 10,000 Days. From the sounds of these songs, you almost get lulled into a bit of a trance when you're listening to them, almost like Maynard James Keenan is giving you a false sense of security before hitting you over the head.
And believe me, that's no easy feat to make a progressive song feel hypnotic, especially when you're tossing around time signatures left and right like on Lateralus, which is so mathematically thought out that it's practically its own Fibonacci sequence. Even if you fancy yourself more of a straight prog rock person, you haven't lived until you've heard a Danny Carey drum solo.
4. Genesis
In prog rock circles, Genesis is either one of the kings of the genre or the reason why prog gets a bad reputation. Although they may have started out as one of the most exciting bands going at the time, the Phil Collins years have made for some songs that fall on the wrong side of cringy from time to time. For all of the more embarrassing moments though, that doesn't take away from the many innovations that happened in their heyday.
After going from the sounds of flower power into something a little more real, the Peter Gabriel era of Genesis was a sight to behold in the early days...quite literally. Aside from the amazing performances on songs like Supper's Ready, it was even more extravagant to see them live, with Gabriel making his stage getup more and more insane, from dressing like a flower to an STD depending on what song you were listening to.
As much as the shows could feel like a distraction, the music always kicked major ass, from Tony Banks flirting with different time signatures behind his keyboard on Firth of Fifth to Steve Hackett practically inventing techniques like tapping on Dancing with the Moonlit Knight. And before he went for softer rock, Phil Collins was still a powerhouse of a drummer, able to stand leagues above most of the session musicians that were making the rounds at the time. Genesis might not be the most consistent band in terms of prog rock, but if you swear them off, you're leaving some amazing music on the table.
3. King Crimson
At the end of the '60s, rock was definitely beginning to transition into something a little heavier than what had come before. With the arrival of bands like Cream and Led Zeppelin paving the way for genres like metal later down the line, you also had groups like the Doors stretching things out to unheard of lengths for the usual pop single. King Crimson were never concerned with pop stardom though, and their early work felt like the sound of synthesized doom.
Honestly, this band could have etched their name into prog rock history on the strength of In the Court of the Crimson King alone, making something a lot more brutal than anything else on the radio at the time. As the years went on though, Robert Fripp and co. created some of the most spellbinding music that would take some serious homework for anyone to master, like the many iterations of Larks' Tongues in Aspic or the sections of Frame by Frame where the guitars go out of sync with each other only to resync up later in the song.
The members of Crimson also knew how to spread the wealth of prog rock music as well, with Robert Fripp going on to work with bands like the Talking Heads and David Bowie and Adrian Belew contributing guitar parts to Nine Inch Nails songs later on in his career. Even after half a century as a band, King Crimson never forgot the cardinal rule of prog rock: never stop exploring.
2. Rush
The cheap shot that most music fans throw at prog rock is that it's a genre for nerds. For the people who think of themselves as too good for a genre like this, it would make sense why they wouldn't want to try to learn about odd time signatures or be willing to go on a long journey throughout a record. As anyone who's seen Revenge of the Nerds will tell you though, you should never count the nerds out any time soon.
Although Rush have been known as the nerdiest of the progressive bands, they still packed one hell of a punch on every single record. Across each iteration of the band, they were never afraid to dip their toes into any genre they saw fit, going from elongated album journeys in the '70s to going full fledged synth pop in the '80s and finding their rock chops again later in life.
Somewhere in the middle though, they managed to hit the sweet spot of their writing where they condensed the prog experience into an accessible package, with the mainstream coming to them rather than having to actually dumb down their sound in any way. Even though they called it quits years ago and Neil Peart is no longer with us, Rush are one of the few bands that tried practically everything they could during the time they were together.
1. Pink Floyd
One of the biggest challenges when it comes to prog rock is trying to fit into the sounds of the times. As much as writing different suites into your music might seem cool to you, it's always up in the air as to whether the rest of the world is going to like it. In a rock scene where writing these long songs feels anti commercial, Pink Floyd has always been the main exception to the rule.
While the band were already a bit wacky during the days of Syd Barrett in the band, the loss of their friend due to mental health issues helped inform everything that came afterwards. From Meddle onward, Floyd never compromised their vision for new sounds, and somehow got the rest of the rock community to go along for the ride, like on the complete album experience of Dark Side of the Moon or the rock opera juggernaut that came with the Wall.
Along the way, you also had a handful of decent singles that haven't dulled in the slightest over the years, with Money still being one of the most famous rock songs in the world that's in an odd time signature. Throughout rock and roll, fans can never grasp the complexity of this stripe of band. They do recognize heart though, and Pink Floyd managed to build their legions of fans by always keeping their prog spectacles close to the chest.