10 Best Wilco Songs
After last month's surprise new album Star Wars, what are the Chicago band's best ever songs?
Wilco are often called America’s Radiohead, and they’ve been critically-acclaimed since they formed back in 1994. Their magnum opus came in 2002 with Yankee Hotel Foxtrot, which got a perfect 10 from Pitchfork, but also nearly ripped the band apart.
Don’t be fooled by the fact that was 13 years ago, though. They’ve consistently made interesting and compelling music throughout their career, and newly-released ninth record Star Wars is no exception.
It arrived in July 2015 with little warning, and took just about everyone by surprise. The band posted short messages on Facebook and Twitter announcing its availability, and that was that. The very next day they performed it live, in full, at Pitchfork Festival in their hometown of Chicago. In keeping with its low-key introduction, frontman Jeff Tweedy described the album simply as “having a cat on the cover”.
A trim 11 tracks and just 33 minutes long, Star Wars is definitely the band’s most fun release, full of fuzz guitars and understated pop melodies. For a band who of late have become famed for virtuoso guitar solos, it’s also surprisingly focused - there’s not much widdling to be found here.
In short, it’s very good indeed, and testament to the fact that in their third decade of existence and onto their ninth line-up, they’re still producing visionary music and evolving their sound.
But with a back catalogue of well over 120 album tracks, plus countless rarities, outtakes and alternative versions, just what counts as definitive Wilco?
10. You Satellite
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=p9SlP81uG20As this post is inspired by Star Wars’ surprise release, it seems apt to start there. While tracks such as Random Name Generator, Where Do I Begin and The Joke Explained are some of Wilco’s best songs in years, its standout is You Satellite.
Lots of the album is upbeat, fuzzy and - whisper it - fun, but this is a slow burner, and could easily drop onto one of their classic albums. Pitched somewhere between Yankee Hotel Foxtrot’s sparsity and A Ghost Is Born’s experimentalism, it features a repeating two chord guitar pattern that underpins everything, while eerie background noises give it depth.
Its most fascinating aspect is its descending guitar line, that seems to never pick one time-signature and stick with it, which gives an ever-changing feel to things despite the simplicity of it all.
9. Misunderstood
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3NRr2QrXn7sFrom one of Wilco’s most recent songs, let’s now turn to one of their oldest.
Misunderstood is the opening track on the band’s second record, the sprawling 19 track double album Being There (it also serves as the opener to their live album, Kicking Television, which is where anyone completely new to Wilco should start).
Thunderous drums and feedback kick things off before Jeff Tweedy’s acoustic guitar and Jay Bennett’s piano take things back several notches. Another slow-burner, it finally dials things up to 10 towards the end as the song starts to fall apart, and Tweedy sneers his thanks for “nothing at all” towards unnamed antagonists.
It borrows a verse from little-known singer-songwriter Peter Laughner but it’s the original line “Do you still love rock and roll?” that has become one of Wilco’s most enduring, and is still greeted with huge cheers whenever it’s played live.
8. California Stars
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gxzMbAMO73kIn 1992, Woody Guthrie’s daughter Nora contacted Billy Bragg and asked him to put some of her father’s unused lyrics to music. Bragg in turn asked Wilco to join the project, and six years later the result was two albums, Mermaid Avenue volumes 1 and 2, with songs roughly split 50/50 between Wilco and Bragg.
California Stars was one of the ones Wilco tackled and, just pipping Bragg’s Way Over Yonder In The Minor Key, it’s the best thing on either volume.
Deliberately not an attempt to emulate Guthrie’s music, it instead sets his lyrics atop one of Wilco’s most straightforward musical compositions. The gentle acoustic rocker uses a lap steel guitar to great effect, but trims away any excess fat, giving Guthrie’s lyrics top billing and allowing them to really shine.
7. Hummingbird (Alternative Version)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=J9oWVWd1ysEThis is an alternative version of the A Ghost Is Born track of the same name. It originally featured on The Wilco Book, an “exploration of the artistic statement presented by the band” according to Wikipedia, which was released in 2004.
The book, which features photos, artwork and commentary from the band about their craft, also included a 12 track CD of unreleased material, including this. More recently it got a more widespread release on last year’s four CD rarities collection, Alpha Mike Foxtrot.
This take of Hummingbird strips away most of the album version’s instrumentation - but keeps its strongest aspect, the melody, intact - replacing it with a nagging strummed guitar, an insistent kick drum and a hammered dulcimer. The latter two are courtesy of drummer Glenn Kotche, and it almost seems as if this reworking of the song is designed solely to show off his exceptional percussion skills.
6. A Magazine Called Sunset
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5MSYgSSS-LgAnother song which you can find on rarities album Alpha Mike Foxtrot, this was actually an outtake from the Yankee Hotel Foxtrot sessions.
Less than three minutes long, A Magazine Called Sunset is a sixties-inflected warm pop gem. With its upbeat feel you can see why it never made the final album cut, and in fact it would probably have been more at home on previous record Summerteeth.
It also has possibly Wilco’s most ridiculous intro. Like a cross between a circus clown act theme tune and a cheesy 70s lounge act, it has no relationship whatsoever with the rest of the song.
While it’s only ever been a recorded footnote, the band have never shied away from playing it in the live arena. It’s been performed over 60 times in recent years, not bad for a band with such a vast back catalogue.
5. Radio Cure
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gm-MpLGfogAThe first of two tracks on this list from Wilco’s artistic pinnacle, 2002’s Yankee Hotel Foxtrot.
Radio Cure features one of Jeff Tweedy’s most confessional lyrics. “Cheer up honey, I hope you can” he sings to a lover he doesn’t understand, before announcing “there is something wrong with me”.
It’s all very grim, and musically it’s just as bleak. The drums are pushed right to the back of the mix, leaving Tweedy’s guitar and voice to stand out front and centre, vulnerable and painful. Despite how uncomfortable it can be to listen to, it has an odd beauty. As the song comes to an end, and Tweedy’s voice verges on breaking as he sings “distance has no way of making love understandable”, it’s very hard not to start to admire the brutal honesty, warts and all.
4. Spiders (Kidsmoke)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Iu6f4dAaXpcAfter he was drafted in to remix, pare down, and generally mess up Yankee Hotel Foxtrot, Wilco enlisted fellow Chicagoan Jim O’Rourke as producer for the follow-up, 2004’s A Ghost Is Born. Nowhere is his influence felt more than on the 11-minute robotic Spiders (Kidsmoke).
At its time of release it was by far Wilco’s most experimental song, which is saying something as they’d become known as a band not shy of trying the weird or the different.
With more in common with Krautrock than the band’s alt-country roots, the first “chorus” doesn’t even come in until the track is four minutes old, and on its first outing, it’s completely instrumental. We finally get a chorus with words after almost eight minutes, which ends with the line “There's no blood on my hands, I just do as I am told”.
For all its sinister repetitiveness and avant garde flourishes, it’s brilliantly hypnotic.
3. Venus Stop The Train
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7S-p8ff0wB4This slight yet achingly gorgeous track has never been officially released, though can easily be found online as part of the Yankee Hotel Foxtrot Demos.
Those demos provide a fascinating glimpse into the genesis and growth of what would become Wilco’s most revered and beloved record. And unlike A Magazine Called Sunset, you can easily envisage how Venus Stop The Train could have fitted onto Yankee Hotel Foxtrot had the band included it.
Late multi-instrumentalist Jay Bennett provides the song’s only musical accompaniment, a mournful piano, as well sharing lead vocal duties with Jeff Tweedy. It’s a poignant reminder that, despite Bennett and Tweedy’s very public falling out and the former’s acrimonious sacking, when working together they could produce music of a rare, timeless beauty.
2. I Am Trying To Break Your Heart
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zlxH9-TYseYDuring the fractious sessions for Yankee Hotel Foxtrot, Jay Bennett attempted several mixes and sequences of the album, none of which pleased Jeff Tweedy. Exasperated with how things were going, he invited Jim O’Rourke to have a go at mixing this song, and the members were so impressed with the results that they handed over all mixing duties to him.
But this was not the first transformation it had undergone. The band had also sacked drummer Ken Coomer halfway through recording, replacing him with Glenn Kotche, who added a whole array of non-conventional drum sounds. It’s these that truly give I Am Trying To Break Your Heart its weird, disconnected quality.
As piano melodies are played slightly out of tune and instruments seem to be hit at random in the background, one of the band’s greatest ever songs is almost buried under a wall of wilful experimentation. Almost, but not quite. They leave just enough there to make this a truly majestic album opener.
1. Impossible Germany
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7I79m7_kAnAThis is all about the guitars.
When Wilco released 2007’s Sky Blue Sky, some fans were initially disappointed at the album’s dad-rock leanings. Probably the band’s least immediate collection, its delights took their time to really show. But once fans realised that the album is designed to showcase the guitar work of the recently-added Nels Cline, the songs took on added meaning.
Cline may have contributed some exceptional solos over the years, but nothing even comes close to the majesty of the second half of Impossible Germany. What starts off as fairly uniform album track slowly transforms into a fist-in-the-air full-on stomper as Cline’s guitar work gets ever more frantic.
Of their myriad tracks, this one would be right at the top of a dream Wilco setlist for most fans, so included here is a live version, taken from the Ashes Of American Flags DVD. The craft and guile on display from a band at the top of the game really is something to behold.