10 Blatantly Unfinished Albums (That Were Released Anyway)

What albums from classic artists needed a bit more work?

TLOP The Life Of Pablo Kanye West
GOOD Music

There's a lot of pressure on artists to release albums to strict deadlines, none the least because they have to book tours to support them months in advance. Although (as demonstrated by some artists on this list) streaming services mean that musicians now have the luxury to edit their records as and when they please - updating track lists, tinkering with mixes, and even adding entire new songs - there is still a high demand for physical copies of albums, meaning musicians still want to perfect their records before sending them out to the world.

This, of course, can lead to albums that feel rushed and incomplete, often sagging from a succession of weak tracks, sporadic running orders, bare mixes and underdeveloped ideas, as artists rush to release their records before they are fully complete.

A number of albums on this list were actually delayed -- sometimes for considerable periods of time - from their original release date, and yet somehow still managed to hit the market feeling unfinished or unrealised. There are few things fans find more frustrating than a scrapped album (as any My Chemical Romance fan will tell you), but a number of records on this list prove that sometimes artists should just scrap the ideas that don't work, rather than scrambling to release them anyway.

10. Kanye West - Jesus Is King

Initially intending to rapidly release a follow-up to his micro-album Ye in late 2018, it took numerous delays, a religious awakening, and an entire scrapped album for Kanye West to finally release his long-anticipated ninth studio record as a solo artist, in the form of 2019’s Jesus Is King.

Unfortunately, to say that this was not worth the wait is to put it mildly. With barely a memorable song on the album, Kanye’s second-shortest project (it only clocks in at two minutes longer than Ye) proves that even when writing religious records, Kanye can’t help but make music all about himself (“The greatest artist restin’ or alive” and “That’s why I charge the prices that I charge”, he offputtingly sings on “On God”).

While some of Kanye's forays into gospel are admirable (despite West's shaky vocals, "God Is" is a particular highlight), other songs feel like an attempt to recapture the lightning of his much earlier, and far superior, "Jesus Walks".

Thankfully, Yandhi - the almost-finished record Kanye scrapped for being too secular - was leaked online, with many fans seeming to prefer tracks from the axed project than those that made the final cut on Jesus Is King, and that's hardly surprising. Somehow feeling less developed than West's previous outing (despite having three more songs), the ten tracks on Kanye's first religious record feel, for the most part, bare bones and unrealised.


9. Coldplay - Everyday Life

Preceded by two of their most exciting singles in years (“Arabesque” stands alongside the best Coldplay songs of all time), Everyday Life seemed like a sure-fire hit, with the British giants promising a double album that, in terms of lyrical themes and visual style, harked back to their seminal 2008 outing Viva La Vida (indeed, some songs were conceieved during the recording sessions for that earlier record).

Unfortunately, the band’s commitment to release a double album seemed to be indicative of searching for style over substance, the album’s concept - two halves of a record, imaginatively titled “Sunrise” and “Sunset” - seeming like an arbitrary addition used to justify unnecessary excess, a tracklist so scattered that shuffling the record produces basically the same results as listening to it start to finish.

Inevitably, the fact that this record reaches a grand total of 16 songs means that there are a fair few duds here, with the most baffling decision being the inclusion of "WOTW / POTP", a literal studio demo, over the fully-realised and frankly fantastic Japanese bonus track "Flags".

While Coldplay's return to experimentation after the fairly basic pop of A Head Full Of Dreams is welcome, a few questionable inclusions (dodgy gospel, unnecessary interludes) bog down an album that would have benefited from more objective editing.


8. Fall Out Boy - MANIA

Yet another example of an album that suffered from numerous delays before its eventual release, Fall Out Boy’s seventh studio record still seemed incomplete when it hit the shelves, with the tracklist on streaming services even being edited after Mania’s release.

After fans’ divisive response to the dubstep-influenced lead single “Young and Menace” (which, frankly, is one of the most exciting songs on offer here), the band returned to the studio to re-work much of the record, leading to a Frankenstein’s monster of an album which seems unsure of what exactly it is, with classic emo pop-punk (“Wilson”) sitting uncomfortably alongside experimental electronic rock (“The Last Of The Real Ones”), soul (“Heaven’s Gate”) and eyebrow-raising reggae fusion (“Sunshine Riptide”).

The second Fall Out Boy album to not have produced a Billboard 100 single, Mania is a case-study of what happens when a band doubles back on its original vision. Frontman Patrick Stump confirmed Mania had been delayed as it felt "rushed", but the final product doesn't fair much better.

For every song promising a much-needed shake-up to the Fall Out Boy formula, there's another which feels paint-by-numbers FOB (the forgettable "Champion"); and with the rousing "Young and Menace" - which fared much better as an opening statement, as per streaming sites' original tracklisting - being nonsensically relegated to the tail end of the record, it's a wonder it was included on the final cut at all.


7. The 1975 - Notes On A Conditional Form

Like Blur before them, the 1975 opted to go for style over substance with the follow up to their seminal 2018 release, A Brief Inquiry Into Online Relationships. That record hopped between genres with ease, sometimes integrating several musical styles into one song, the strength of its vision ensuring the project somehow managed to sound like a cohesive album despite the differences between individual tracks.

Attempting to capture lightning in a bottle twice, Notes On A Conditional Form - which adds even more genres into the mix - feels like a less successful band trying to rip off A Brief Inquiry rather than being its true follow-up by the same group.

And despite its release date being pushed back numerous times, Notes On A Conditional Form still feels unfinished, the (many) musical interludes - a 1975 staple - feeling more like they're here to fill up space rather than on their own merit, bloating the album to 22 tracks spread over one and a half tedious hours without adding anything valuable to the mix.

Forgettable album tracks transformed what should have been a stellar record (its singles, especially "People" and "Me & You Together Song", are amongst the band's best) into one that's memorable for all the wrong reasons. Their longest record yet (and hopefully ever), Notes somehow ends up having the least amount of songs, and even some fully-realised ideas ("Roadkill", "Nothing Revealed / Everything Denied") fall flat against the 1975's previously high standards.


6. U2 - Pop

A strange mis-step for the band that gave us classics like The Joshua Tree, U2 took The Edge's idea that "U2 albums never get finished, they just get released" a little too far here, unleashing this unfiltered and misguided experimental pop mess into the world with next to no spit and polish.

A lot of the electronic elements here feels downright jarring (especially, and most vitally, on the opening tracks "Discotheque" and "Do You Feel Loved"), leading to an album that has aged poorly, even when compared to its contemporary records that also dabbled in synth experimentation.

Clearly, U2 were also dissatisfied with the final product, with the few songs from the record that did make it onto the band's Best Of 1990-2000 compilation only appearing as highly edited versions, the removal of unnecessary walls of sound leading to far superior mixes that highlight the musicality of the songs, proving that Pop would have benefited hugely from the removal of unnecessary instrumentation alone.

Despite its faults, Pop has become an unlikely fan favourite for some, with defenders praising Bono's lyrics and U2's attempts to embrace an entirely new sound.


5. Kanye West - The Life Of Pablo

While there are some undeniably excellent songs on Kanye's most ambitious project since My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy ("30 Hours", "No More Parties in LA"), others feel incomplete, with "Freestyle 4" feeling like a first draft slapped onto the track listing for the hell of it, and ""Siiiiiiiiilver Surffffeeeeer Intermission" being as unnecessary as its extraneous stylistic spelling suggests, a misplaced callback to the skits on West's early albums on a record which seems to be all about experimentation and leaving Kanye's musical past behind.

A number of songs here went through many different iterations before the album's eventual release, with the original version of "Facts" somehow feeling more fleshed out than the Charlie Heat cut that made it onto The Life Of Pablo.

Even Kanye must have realised that The Life Of Pablo was unfinished, as the artist continued to tweak the record after its release, declaring it a "living breathing changing creative expression". As well as some lyrical changes and minor changes to mixing, the most notable modification was the addition of another unnecessary interlude, "Frank's Track" (which first appeared at the tale end of "Wolves" and really should have been cut entirely) and a whole new song, "Saint Pablo".


4. Oasis - Be Here Now

Not so much undercooked as overdone, Be Here Now suffers from Oasis' inability to cut back the excess that bog down this album.

In fact, there are a tonne of decent songs here, with arguably more tunes than both Definitely Maybe and (What's The Story) Morning Glory? put together, that Be Here Now could have been a perfect record - if Noel Gallagher and co. hadn't decided to try their best to stretch almost every track to the seven minute mark, leading to unnecessarily elongated introductions, diversions and repetitions that might have been well executed with better musicians at the helm.

These wall of sound "experiments" might be exciting on paper, but ultimately have no placed on a record by the straightforward Britpop band who included a song about eating lasagne on their debut record.

Convinced that bigger means better, there's just too much noise and not enough substance here, with a bunch of perfectly passable songs ("D'You Know What I Mean?", "The Girl in the Dirty Shirt", the stellar "All Around the World") being rendered almost unlistenable due to their excruciatingly elongated lengths.

Unlike other records on this list, Be Here Now wasn't unfinished due to underdeveloped ideas - there are plenty here - but rather because it seemed rushed out of the studio without adequate care taken in trimming down the tracks.


3. You Me At Six - Night People

Night People is far from a bad album, but recently You Me At Six frontman Josh Franceschi announced on social media that if he could tweak any YMAS album, he'd go for the Surrey outfit's fifth outing.

In fact, You Me At Six began expressing dissatisfaction with the follow up to their chart-topping fourth album Cavalier Youth almost immediately after release, stating that they felt they weren't able "to deliver what [they] wanted to", as they had focused more on creating a unified body of music than the quality of the individual songs.

Listening to Night People, this shows. "Take On The World", which sounds like You Me At Six's take on the Coldplay and Snow Patrol ballads, a watered-down "Fix You", received an updated "New Version" only two months after the release of the record, with more background instrumentation more emphasised in the mix, and an entire minute chopped of the track's length.

The ballad - which has since become a fan favourite and set-list staple, despite its imperfections - is not the only song on Night People which sounds half-baked or incomplete. "Brand New", which shifts from minimalist introspective verses into a danceable bop of a chorus with a transition as smooth as sandpaper, feels like a ghostly draft of a song rather than a finished product, much of the song feeling sparse and incomplete.


2. Suede - A New Morning

A record that reeks of unfulfilled potential, Suede's fifth studio album is stuffed with stripped back bare songs that sounded as though they were coming from a completely different band than the pioneers of Britpop, at times feeling more like an acoustic singer's parody of Suede's themes (loneliness, alienation) than the genuine article.

Some of the songs here are admittedly pretty nice run of the mill mid-tempo pop tracks, but even the record's best bits were a huge mis-step away from what fans had come to expect from Suede. Suffering from both a lacking overall vision and a dodgy track list, fan favourite B-sides ("Simon") and other songs recorded around the same time ("Attitude", "Golden Gun") were bafflingly left off the album, despite being largely better than the unfinished-sounding songs that made the final cut.

A stark foil to its overinflated predecessor Head Music, A New Morning was so poorly received that the band broke up shortly after, reuniting in 2010 and releasing the mighty return to form that was Bloodsports a few short years later. Now three records into the second phase of the band, Suede thankfully hasn't released another dud since, seeming to have learned from their mistakes. Indeed, even lead singer Bret Anderson noted that the band's fifth output doesn't seem to fit with the rest of the band's discography.


1. Blur - 13

Supposedly Blur's Blood On The Tracks, being Damon Albarn's introspective exploration into his break-up with Elastica frontwoman and long term partner Justine Frischmann, 13 is a record that promises some gorgeous moments of emotional clarity ("Tender", "Coffee and TV", the harrowing "No Distance Left to Run"), all of which are overshadowed by the sheer wall of noise, unnecessary bites of experimentation which seem to serve as a segue away from sincerity, an excuse for Albarn and friends to do just about anything other than open up.

While some of these heavily-stylised electronic-reliant pieces are more memorable than others (some, like "Bugman", are even good songs), 13 sounds a bit too much like just over an hour of static and half-baked jam sessions interspersed with a couple of tracks that are more typical of your quintessential breakup record.

In attempting to push the experimentation and raw sound that helped elevate the band's 1997 self-titled Blur into the American market while simultaneously shedding the bells and whistles of Britpop even more than their previous record, 13 seems way too concerned with shocking listeners who were expecting more tunes like "Parklife", "Country House" or even "Song 2", with the band spending so much time on crafting strange lo-fi electronic noise that they apparently forgot to write some actual tunes. Oops.


Watch Next


In this post: 
Kanye West
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

When Matteo isn't cashing in on a lifetime of devotion to his favourite pop culture franchises and indie bands, he's writing and publishing poems and short stories under the name Teo Eve. Talk about range.