10 Classic Albums That People Originally Hated
From Reviled to Lovable.
There's a certain omnipresence that comes with some of the more celebrated albums in history. As opposed to just being good for its time or having some amazing songs, these records have been mulled over and dissected, as if moving one element out of place would have felt sacrilegious. You're saying that now...it wasn't that way at the time though.
For as much lip service as these artists might get for these albums, most of the records on this list only got that special treatment in hindsight. In fact, most of these initial masterpieces were met with either indifference or outright hatred by the fanbase at first, with people heralding them as some of the worst albums the music industry had to offer. Then again, sometimes genius isn't really appreciated unless it's in the rearview already. Looking back on them today, each of these records marked a new creative departure for these acts, proving that they were a lot more than just your average run of the mill act that you'd throw on in the background.
Not only have they held up well, but most of these would prove to be influential in the long run, giving birth to other acts and even new genres of music later down the line. Though the quality is certainly here, you would have gotten some strange looks if you thought these were good back in the day.
10. The Soft Parade - The Doors
From the start of their career, the Doors never seemed to fit neatly in one genre. Going from one song to the next, these psychedelic giants always toed the line of what constituted rock and roll, from hard rock to showtunes to even down and dirty blues jams. Once the classical musicians were brought in though, people started to get a bit skeptical.
Looking back on it today, The Soft Parade is a terrific album from the group's mid-period, with Jim Morrison balancing his trademark sleaze rocker with a more pop friendly sound. However, the initial reaction to something like Touch Me and Tell All the People was quite a shock coming from the same band that did Light My Fire. I mean, who wants to see the Lizard King go out on stage and perform a song that could have been a demented version of a Frank Sinatra tune?
On the other hand, that exact kind of weirdness held up in their favor, with each jazzy flourish of the album turning into solid gold over the years. It's not like the old Doors had gone anywhere either, with songs like Shaman's Blues and the title track having just as much darkness as you would expect from Morrison's poetry. This is by far the most adventurous album the Doors ever made, but don't let that dissuade you from thinking it's of any lesser quality.
9. Destroyer - KISS
After the success of Alive!, KISS had seemed to have done the impossible. Once they were down and out with pretty much no hope of ever conquering the mainstream, this double live record catapulted them into the stratosphere, with high energy updates on their classic brand of heavy rock and roll. Although things were just kicking into high gear, it was time for these shock rockers to move up to the big leagues in a different way.
Hooking up with producer Bob Ezrin for Destroyer, this record was initially scoffed at by the rock purists of the KISS army for being a step down compared to their normal sound. Since Ezrin would go on to work on high budget conceptual pieces like Pink Floyd's the Wall, the entire album amplifies each of KISS' characters to mammoth proportions. The brunt of the blame ended up coming at the expense of Beth, whose proto-power ballad sound was a bit grating for someone who wanted the makeup-clad warriors of the universe.
Then again, the actual muscle behind the songwriting hasn't gone anywhere, with Detroit Rock City remaining a rock classic and the larger scope of instrumentation making Gene Simmons's showcase God of Thunder a musical battering ram. For as much as it has held up over time, sometimes fans just can't get over the hurdle of something different coming down the pipeline.
8. Women and Children First - Van Halen
It feels somewhat strange putting a David Lee Roth-era Van Halen record as something worthy of being hated by the rock mainstream. Ever since their breakup in the late '80s, the entire rock scene has seemed to have put somewhat of a golden halo around this era of the group as one of the greatest runs in rock history. However, sometimes the hatred can come more from something you didn't hear as opposed to what you did.
When Women and Children First was initially released on the world, you could practically hear a pin drop when it came to the mainstream. Since these songs weren't the most single-ready at the time, most people seem to remember the tour for this album more than the album itself. What you're missing out on though might be the single most metallic release of the group's entire career.
Despite being called a hair band for most of the '80s, this was where Van Halen really knuckled down, with songs that were as much indebted to punk and Black Sabbath as it was to the party rock that they lived and died on. Across every track, songs like Loss of Control and Romeo Delight take no prisoners, sounding like they could be played either in a stadium or inside a dirty nightclub in downtown LA. If you consider yourself a VH aficionado, you owe it to yourself to give this one just a little bit more consideration in terms of the all time greats.
7. 2112 - Rush
Ok...now it's just starting to get pushy. How in the hell is 2112, one of Rush's crowned jewels that has been heralded as a masterpiece in the prog rock genre, ever be considered something worthy of hatred? While this record is a virtual bombardment of musical perfection from cover to cover, most people forget that this was seen as career suicide back in the day.
Coming off of the prog rock epic Caress of Steel, these Canadian icons were under intense pressure from their label to come out with some more commercial material. Since the tour dates were drying up and the album sales were criminally low, Rush practically had their backs against the wall to come up with some more singles. Instead though, everyone hunkered down and vowed to make the record that they wanted to make, regardless of whether the label wanted it or not.
By the time the label received the finished album with a 20 minute epic piece to start, most were thinking that Rush would fade into obscurity and be dropped. What happened next proved to be the greatest way of sticking to your guns, as most prog rock fans managed to grasp the concept and started to spread the word about these rock legends from up North. Even though Fly By Night was the first real taste of success, this is when the prog greatness truly gets underway.
6. Hunky Dory - David Bowie
At the start of the '70s, there was almost a 50/50 chance that David Bowie was going to become known as a novelty act. Long before the glam rock alien took shape, Bowie was originally blackballed out of the serious rock scene and known more for his space-themed hit Space Oddity. Once Ziggy Stardust arrived on land though, people had to give Hunky Dory some serious reconsideration.
As opposed to just looking good in retrospect, Bowie's fourth proper outing is actually capable of rivaling Ziggy as one of the greatest records he's ever made. Inspired by a trip to America, this piano-driven affair has some of the greatest tunes that Bowie would ever write, including Changes and Life on Mars?, the latter of which first shows Bowie's ability to flesh out Ziggy. Along with the amazing single material, there's also a good look at the more eccentric sides of Bowie's mind, from the open-hearted hope present in Quicksand to the pastiche of the Velvet Underground unfolding on Queen B*tch.
While Hunky ended up selling poorly in its first run, the massive success of Ziggy Stardust made a lot of people backtrack, coming across this one a little later. For as much as the makings of something brilliant are on here, this is just a fun little jaunt before the Starman reached the full peak of his powers.
5. Kid A - Radiohead
The entire aura behind Kid A by Radiohead has almost been beaten to death by critics at this point. With pretty much unanimous praise being heaped upon it ever since its release 20 years ago, fans and critics see this one record as both an amazing feat unto itself as well as a turning point for the world of rock and roll in general. Then again, if you were there at the time, this was a bit of a rough sit at first.
By the time Radiohead had stopped touring behind OK Computer, fans were chomping at the bit to see where they were going next. Seeing how they pretty much made the perfect rock album, we were expecting nothing less than another shimmery take on rock and roll. Once the electronic bits came in, many fans were more than a little bit confused at what they heard, from the strange opening Everything in Its Right Place to the horn freakouts behind the National Anthem.
This wasn't the Radiohead we were looking for...it was something even better. Assembled from different fragments that the group were working on at the time, this record was the most artistic move they could have made, putting a stake through the heart of their rock period and launching them into the new millennium on all cylinders. While some people might have thought they had lost the plot, this really fulfills Thom Yorke's vision of getting a big eraser and starting again.
4. Core - Stone Temple Pilots
A lot of rock fans tend to forget just how insular the grunge community was when it started. Long before the media really got ahold of it, this kind of disaffected rock music was almost solely indebted to the Pacific Northwest, with most wannabes left by the wayside. In fact, the community was so close that you could sometimes pass by acts that were actually pretty amazing.
On the surface though, it's not like the grunge community didn't have a point when it came to Core by Stone Temple Pilots. Across its runtime, it's clear that Scott Weiland is taking more than a few cues from Eddie Vedder's singing style, as well as the deliberately dirty licks from the DeLeo Brothers. Once you separate it from its time period though, this is a good slice of what would become known as alternative rock later down the line, toeing the line between the heaviness of grunge and the regular rock and roll of days gone by.
Though you could argue the boy-bandification of grunge happening on the power ballad Creep, there's not a single cynical bone in Weiland's body when he sings this or any other song for that matter. At the end of the day, it just comes down to the rockers' version of alternative, which is still pretty kickass once you give it a chance.
3. Warning - Green Day
Going into the '00s, it seemed like the entire pop punk community had left Green Day in the dust. Ever since blowing up off of the strength of Dookie in '94, these punk brats had found it harder and harder to regain their momentum across albums like Insomniac and Nimrod. However, the rock world was about to be shaken by great tunes that are among the best Green Day ever wrote....and no, they're not from American Idiot.
Before Billie Joe Armstrong got the idea for the pop punk rock opera, this experimental shift into folk punk on Warning was one of the most wild left turns fans could have imagined. Instead of the usual frenzy in Green Day circles, most fans were downright spiteful to this thing, openly criticizing it for being too different than what these guys stood for in the first place. While the fanboys were complaining though, Green Day were hitting on some of the most creative ventures of their career.
Across every track on this album, nothing sounds the same, with the acoustic driven title track, the swinging boogie rhythm of Blood Sex and Booze, and even the weird macabre story on Misery. The back half is where it really shines though, with songs like Waiting and Minority stretching into more complex lyrical topics that you wouldn't find in your normal punk rock. Say what you want to about Warning...if this proof of concept didn't exist, we probably wouldn't have gotten American Idiot just a few years later.
2. White Light/White Heat - The Velvet Underground
The Velvet Underground always seem to get the title of that one band that everyone got later. As opposed to other art rock acts in the late '60s, the Velvets didn't see nearly as much time on the charts, what with their odes to being strung out on heroin and waiting to score some drugs from a dealer on the mean streets of New York City. If you thought the first record was bad though, people were lining up to take shots at White Light/White Heat.
Then again, this album almost seems designed to annoy the more fairweather rock fans, with an aptly titled fiery production and some of the most scattered song fragments coming from Lou Reed and John Cale. While this album can be a bit of a tough listen just starting out, the Velvets were actually onto something brilliant on here.
Across the title track and Lady Godiva's Operation, Reed and co. had created something that was very ahead of its time, combining chaotic guitars and artistic vocals to create the beginnings of punk, metal, and noise rock later down the line. This all comes to a head on Sister Ray, a 17-minute journey where Reed practically has a personal battle with his own instrument. Like all Velvet Underground albums though, White Light/White Heat was practically buried until we saw its offspring emerge in the decades that followed.
1. Pinkerton - Weezer
The arrival of Weezer on the alternative rock scene could not have come at a better time for rock fans. After the devastating blow of losing Kurt Cobain in 1994, Rivers Cuomo's open-hearted dorky love songs were exactly the kind of lighthearted music that we needed to hear. Once they started to make actual sad songs though, you better believe some people were p*ssed off.
For a good few years after its release, Weezer's sophomore effort Pinkerton was known as the pariah of these nerd rockers' catalog, worthy to be put into the shadows of the rock scene. It's not hard to see why either, given that most people weren't ready for Rivers to drone on about his sex life, inner feelings, and overall uncomfortable personal life across these infectious melodies. However, things started to take a bit of a different course after the '00s.
Looking back on it now, this is probably the 2nd best record Weezer has ever made, as it tells the tragic story of Rivers losing his will to carry on being a rock star and resorting to whatever he can find to soothe his pain. The hate was that bad too, with Weezer breaking up for a good few years before re-emerging in the '00s with the Green Album. For as much as people may have liked to deny this one back in the day, this is the kind of raw beauty that you get once every career.