10 Classic Bands Who Only Had One Classic Album
Capturing the magic once.
There are countless artists whose names resonate with music itself. From the Beatles in the ‘60s to Nirvana’s surge in popularity in the ‘90s, some bands are so seminal that almost any record of theirs could be defined as great. On the other hand, some bands have made their way to the top with only one solid effort to their name.
Despite all that was going for them, these artists are the few outliers of the music industry who proceeded to fall back into obscurity after their one album. Whether it was due to a breakup or a severe drop in quality, these bands never were able to capture the power behind their first mainstream hit. For as hard hitting as a band’s breakthrough release is, it can also act like an albatross around their neck at the worst of times.
If you start at the top, people expect you to be able to equal it on every subsequent release, which often leads to loads of creative frustration. Even though some of these bands had modest hits after their first surge in popularity, they will always be living in the shadow of the record that got them their first big break.
10. Dire Straits
As the ‘80s started to get underway, your star power had to be larger than life if you wanted to be seen. Even if you could put together a bunch of great tunes into one package, it didn’t mean much if you had to compete with the neon-colored contemporaries dominating the charts. For all the more fabricated pop of the day though, Mark Knopfler from Dire Straits strapped on a headband and dominated the entire rock sphere.
Though the band had already had a hit with “Sultans of Swing” in the late ‘70s, it wasn’t until they made Brothers in Arms that people really started to pay attention. Pulling from the synth revolution taking place as well as resting on their laurels as mellow rockers, the band turned in some of the best feel-good tunes of the decade from “Walk of Life” to the unofficial anthem of MTV in “Money For Nothing.”
It was a great time to be Dire Straits, but the glory dissipated as the band went onto new projects. After a few more stabs at a full album, the band went their separate ways, with Mark Knopfler going on to be one of the most acclaimed guitarists in the world. Dire Straits have more than a few classic songs under their belt, but when talking about their recorded output, Brothers in Arms is the fullest album experience we ever got.
9. The Stone Roses
While most of the ‘80s sound needed to have a certain size to it, the entire rock scene was in for a shakeup by the end of the decade. Instead of the heavyhitters being hair metal bands or synth rock, bands were bubbling up from the underground that became known as alternative acts. Though grunge would get its time in the sun first, The Stone Roses laid the groundwork for what Britpop would be later down the road.
This self-titled debut from the band is an absolute treat, with every other song having a brilliant vocal melody along with the psychedelic instrumentation. Taking inspiration from everything from ‘60s rock to the shoegaze movement to electronic soundscapes, this album has a little something for everyone, with feel good tunes like “She Bangs the Drums” and “Waterfall.”
The band may have started their career off with a bang, but it quickly went south once the initial glory faded. After rubbing arms with other Britpop bands like Oasis, the band’s attempt at a second album with Second Coming ended up being a bit haphazard, with great tunes that weren’t grasped by the public. The band’s debut is definitely in the conversation of best alternative records of all time, but it’s a shame they couldn’t capitalize on their momentum.
8. Billy Idol
Billy Idol was an artist that seemed tailor-made for MTV. After winning the hearts of punk fans all over the world with Generation X, his more exaggerated take on the punk formula made him the darling of the early days of MTV. While his star was one of the brightest in the early days, it may have ended up burning him in the process.
While Idol’s debut record started his career off strong with songs like “White Wedding,” it wasn’t until his sophomore effort Rebel Yell that people really started to take notice. From the blistering title track to the more downtempo ballad “Eyes Without A Face,” this album catapulted Idol to the top of the rock heap, with his videos constantly getting played on MTV. Even the standalone singles from the era like “Dancing With Myself” ended up becoming classics, but even Idol didn’t realize that he was peaking way too fast.
Though Idol still kept his signature style throughout the rest of the decade, he quickly became a caricature of the punk attitude, with songs like “Cradle of Love” feeling like they were more novelties of the glam era than sincere rock. Idol did try to distance himself from his typical sound on albums like Cyberpunk, but by the time the alternative movement came in, people had stopped caring. It may be fine to throw on “Mony Mony” at parties, but don’t expect Idol to make a massive comeback any time soon.
7. Peter Frampton
Peter Frampton has built up quite the resume for a rocker in the ‘70s. Long before he became known as a solo act, his playing in Humble Pie helped influence an entire generation of rockers to pick up guitars of their own. With no studio doing him justice, Frampton struck out on his own with one of the greatest live albums of all time.
From track to track, Frampton Comes Alive has some of the greatest guitar breaks of the entire decade, with Frampton making exquisite use of the talk box while also finding time to play ballads on songs like “Baby I Love Your Way.” This entire record has everything you would need from a great classic rock album, but maybe it did its job a bit too well.
As Frampton’s career has gone on, his studio output has still not been able to compare to the massive amount of acclaim he got when he cut his songs live. Even when rubbing elbows with contemporaries like David Bowie and Ringo Starr, Frampton is typically considered a great guitar player, but not a great enough star presence to garner the massive adulation of his colleagues. For as much kickass is on Frampton Comes Alive, it ended up being a sad case of an artist pulling their trump card too early.
6. Steve Miller Band
Steve Miller has a rock and roll upbringing most musicians can only dream of. As he started coming up the ranks as a musician, his apprenticeship under Les Paul saw him learning from some of the greatest blues guitarists who ever lived. While Miller could have gotten by writing some of the most complex rock music ever made, his ability to write pop tunes wasn’t too shabby either.
Most people could hum a few bars of something like “The Joker,” but that was just the tip of the iceberg when it came to his star power. After embracing the large sound of the synthesizer, Miller locked himself away in a studio and wrote Fly Like An Eagle, which became one of the most essential records in the history of classic rock. From the title track to “Take the Money and Run” to “Rock’n Me,” almost every other track on here could have been a hit.
After a record like that, there also comes the unenviable task of topping it, which Miller stepped up to face. Though Book of Dreams did have a few classics on it, the afterglow of Eagle was too thick in the air for people to pay too much attention. Fly Like An Eagle has enough hooks for any other band’s career, but its star power ended up stifling the man who birthed it.
5. Beach Boys
From the moment that they started their lush vocal harmonies, the Beach Boys always seemed to be destined for a singles act. While their odes to cars, girls, and surfing were definitely fun in the early part of the ‘60s, there was no real reason to think that the band would be treated as anything more than a novelty act. Then Brian Wilson got the idea of a lifetime…
Aiming to compete with the Beatles’ album-centric productions, Wilson went into the studio and crafted Pet Sounds, which ended up becoming one of the most celebrated albums in rock history. Though the sound was still what you’d expect from these California surfers, the added touch of instrumentation made everything blossom out even more. Even the single from the sessions, “Good Vibrations,” is known as one of the greatest songs in the entire rock canon.
This is one of the best albums in rock, but it did take its toll on its creator, with Wilson going into a depression and suffering a mental breakdown as a result. The band would eventually try to venture further into psychedelic territory, but the results ended up being much more lackluster than people wanted to hear. The Beach Boys may still be able to deliver their big hits when summer comes around, but when it comes to their true artistry, Pet Sounds stands alone.
4. Sex Pistols
If you’re talking about a band that embodies everything great about the punk aesthetic, The Sex Pistols have to be your prime candidate. With a loose energy in their playing and some of the most venomous lyrics in the rock world, these guys were the crude answer to the more manufactured rock that had been the order of the day. When you have a foundation centered around chaos though, you can’t necessarily blame anyone if it ends poorly.
Though the band were already off the rails at the best of times, they did keep it together long enough to create Nevermind the !*$%, which has become a staple of the rock genre. With songs like “Anarchy in the UK” and “God Save the Queen,” the band captured the spirit of every disenfranchised youth of England who wanted to speak out against authority.
Things were off to a good start, but it was a different story once they decided to tour. Under the disastrous eye of Malcolm McLaren, the band made their way to the US, but found themselves in absolute shambles, with Sid Vicious on a road to self-destruction and the band suffering from personality differences. After a layover of a few days, the band returned to England and quickly folded, leaving Johnny Rotten to move on to Public Image Ltd. and Sic Vicious to fall apart due to his drug addiction. We may only have Nevermind the !*$%, but that was all the rock world needed to spark the new wave of punk music.
3. MC5
The MC5 were by far the most raucous band of the ‘60s Revolution. Coming from the mean streets of Detroit, the band combined everything off-the-wall about the Summer of Love movement and blew it up to gigantic proportions, with songs that sounded like Little Richard being filtered through a city punk.
Given their more chaotic approach to their craft, it made sense that the one album that broke them could only be captured live. From front to back, Kick Out the Jams is one of the greatest hard rock albums ever created, with riffs that sound like they’re about to fall apart but end up leaping through your speakers like rabid dogs. Though the sound was just focused on hard rock, the band found fans in everyone from Jerry Cantrell of Alice in Chains to Slash from Guns N Roses.
With the world waiting for what would come next, their studio followup Back in the USA ended up being somewhat underwhelming. From the more slick production to the different covers they performed, the record left fans begging to hear the songs live rather than being cleaned up in the studio. The MC5 may have folded shortly thereafter, but Kick Out the Jams is responsible for exposing rock and roll at its garage roots.
2. Boston
For as much great material was emerging from the rock world in the ‘70s, the overall sound of the production started to feel a little stale. Sure, bands like Blue Oyster Cult may have written some badass tunes, but the actual staying power got muddied by the sound of their records. Out of all the more extravagant acts of the day, Boston’s debut still sounds fresh even by today’s standards.
Being almost entirely the brainchild of guitarist Tom Scholz, the record has one hit after another, from the arena anthem “More Than a Feeling” to the bluesy groove of “Smokin.” In addition to just being great songs, Scholz’s use of keyboards, guitars, and homemade gear had a huge impression on the rock world going forward. Any record this seminal should set up a band for a career of awesomeness, but it ended up inadvertently killing their groove.
By the time they got to making the record Don’t Look Back, Boston had quickly gone from being sonic innovators to somewhat of a one trick pony. The songs ended up sounding so similar that the band actually called it Don’t Look Back in the hopes that fans would ignore the power of their debut. Boston’s debut is a big reason for rock’s growth, but it did end up costing the band any further ambitions.
1. Derek and the Dominos
Coming off of Cream, Eric Clapton was quickly being looked at as one of the first guitar gods. With a sound all his own and some of the tastiest solos in rock history, Slowhand had enough fame to retire his name from rock altogether. While he seemed to have everything, Clapton’s unrequited love led to one of his finest short-lived groups.
Writing songs in tribute to George Harrison’s wife Patti Boyd, Clapton got a band together called Derek and the Dominos to record the tunes. Not only did these end up being some of the most celebrated songs of Clapton’s career, but also showed him trading lead lines with the great Duane Allman on songs like “Layla.” This entire project could have been on to something huge, but it was not to be.
Shortly after going their separate ways, Duane Allman was killed in a motorcycle accident, taking a little bit of the magic with him. Deciding to retire the name, Clapton moved on to his solo career, where he would still see a good helping of hit songs. A guitar duet of this caliber is something we didn’t know we needed, but the rock world should be thankful that we at least got it once.